Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That it's not my responsibility to be chasing ExH to pay school dinner money?

189 replies

DietCokeAddict19 · 07/09/2023 21:30

ExH and I split up 6 years ago, we have 2 DC who are at secondary school.

ExH is a high earner - approx £100k to my £20k.

Up until last year ExH paid child maintenance (£500 per month) but that stopped as the kids are with us each 50% of the time. It was agreed that we would each pay half of the costs associated with the children (uniform, school trips, school dinners etc) but it almost always falls to me to either buy these things, or I end up having to ask/remind him to pay for them.

Last year over the year I have just totted it up and I paid £700 for school dinners (!!!), he didn't pay anything.

He has the same school app as me so he can see when their balance is running low, but he seemingly doesn't look at it or ignores the reminders to pay. So I end up paying because I don't want the kids to go without lunch. I sent him a message before the term started to highlight that I paid for all school lunches last year and could he top up their balances, to which I got a shirty reply of "I'm sure I put money in last year" and a promise he would top up. He hasn't. So I have because DS1 has 65p in his account and couldn't buy lunch tomorrow otherwise.

Despite ExH having the kids half the time he still seems to be fucking Disney dad and I end up having to be the responsible one and sort everything out. Part of me wonders if he does it on purpose and likes me having to come to him and ask him for money, but I'm fucking tired of it. I hate asking for money and part of me wishes I could pay it all myself so I don't have to ask, but he earns so much more than me and I can't afford it all now that my monthly child maintenance has stopped.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DietCokeAddict19 · 20/09/2023 10:59

catherinecooksondog · 20/09/2023 10:20

This is a brilliant solution?!

??

OP posts:
catherinecooksondog · 20/09/2023 10:20

This is a brilliant solution?!

Bature · 19/09/2023 23:34

DietCokeAddict19 · 19/09/2023 20:15

We never managed it through CMS, it was just done between us.

Have you now contacted them?

DietCokeAddict19 · 19/09/2023 20:15

catherinecooksondog · 19/09/2023 17:20

Have you checked with CMS if they’ve closed your old claim? Or was it just managed directly before/not logged with them?

We never managed it through CMS, it was just done between us.

OP posts:
catherinecooksondog · 19/09/2023 17:20

Have you checked with CMS if they’ve closed your old claim? Or was it just managed directly before/not logged with them?

pphammer · 19/09/2023 14:15

I can understand your line of thought.
In your case, child maintenance is due , just a smaller amount than if your kids were more or full time with you.

Have a look at the government child maintenance calculator website.

That said, the amount will be a minimum amount your ex must send you. Try to negociate with him a higher amount or that he pays for other specific needs.

I believe many loving dads do that even if in conflict with ex's

All the best

DietCokeAddict19 · 19/09/2023 08:58

pphammer · 18/09/2023 21:42

With such difference in salaries, why did you agree interrupting child maintenance?

I didn’t think I was entitled to it. I thought that once it was 50/50 then it wasn’t payable.

OP posts:
catherinecooksondog · 19/09/2023 08:15

50/50 overnights doesn’t mean EVERYTHING has to be 50/50 split… Another tactic could be to embrace the Disney Dad he loves to be. School trips are optional, right? So just say, I’m sorry kids, I just can’t afford it with the cost of living increases, we’re on a tight budget. Maybe your Dad would be able to afford the whole lot? Otherwise I’m sorry you won’t be able to go. Same with clubs, and non-essential items. Push it all back on him. They will NOT remember as adults their Dad being the greatest because of buying thing. All that matters is love, security, warmth, affection, supporting them, being kind and being RELIABLE. Which you are. X

catherinecooksondog · 19/09/2023 08:03

Just catching up on your woes which are basically my partners woes with his ex… (with her being the baddie, very unusual I realise).

I think it doesn’t matter about his other properties… The beneficial interest thing is TOLATA law (property). There is a potential for him to claim. But the solicitors cost SO MUCH, and that he owns other properties and is in a hugely better financial position than you, they would probably advise him not to bother.

But who knows! I’d be looking at a cohabitation agreement to cover myself!!! If you’re in a happy relationship, it could be possible to arrange?

Though honestly, you sound like such a nice person and I think the current partner is taking the piss even more than your kids Dad?!?!?!?! He should be paying ALL the outgoings seeing as in total they are LESS than he makes from renting out his place? He’s essentially living with you for free and still could be even if he paid everything…….

Regarding that school trip money…. I can’t fathom how half of the trip is £400 that’s insane! Email the school reception and copy ex in and address it to them and say it’s his half and he owes them and not you? We had to do this with everything. It’s a bit embarrassing but who cares, it worked. She has to pay her half of football and trips and everything to the clubs etc directly now.

Also there are these great apps nowadays, things like Splid, you can just track what each of you pays for exactly… If he will get on board? She won’t, but the paying things direct and getting my step son to ask her for things himself worked for us.

pphammer · 18/09/2023 21:42

With such difference in salaries, why did you agree interrupting child maintenance?

DietCokeAddict19 · 12/09/2023 21:47

MeAgainPeeps · 12/09/2023 12:34

What did child maintenance say?

I haven't managed to contact them yet. On the to do list for this week.

OP posts:
MeAgainPeeps · 12/09/2023 12:34

What did child maintenance say?

RandomMess · 12/09/2023 11:03

Hurrah

Carry on in that vein.

"I paid £x last year for lunches and you only paid in £y. I've loaded £y this year so you need to do the rest from now. If you go over £x let me know and I'll give you half.

Another time - you that trip last year, you still owe me £a for your half of it.

DietCokeAddict19 · 12/09/2023 10:10

Shock announcement!!

ExH has paid some money into the lunch money account on Scopay. Without further input from me.

(might have been because when I had to drop off sports kits on the weekend I discussed it with him in front of DC - “I had to pay in some further money yesterday as DC1 only had 65p left and wouldn’t have been able to buy lunch” - don’t think he liked his behaviour being shown up in front of the children)

Anyway, result!

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 11/09/2023 23:06

Stop feeling stupid. It’s so unproductive. Instead, work out what you want and what you need to do so you can have it. You won’t change your ex or your current bloke, focus on yourself. You are worth being happy and feeling good about yourself. Don’t send flagellate in a new thread. Ask for help in ditching him and starting a new better phase of your life, if that’s what’ll make you happy.

DietCokeAddict19 · 11/09/2023 22:52

SurprisedWithAH0RSE · 11/09/2023 13:36

Of course Your ex is already bad mouthing you to the kids! Why would you think he’s not !! There’s nothing you can do to control what he says and does, you can only control what YOU do.

Of course you are scared - that’s how these abusive men managed to control us for years. We know that if we speak out of turn or do anything that don’t like, there will be hell to pay. And even once we’ve left them, they still control us by fear. We are like a huge elephants tied to a small stick.

So go ahead and apply for CMS today. If you don’t get anything you’ve wasted the tenner it costs to apply.

And you know what you need to do about your current partner . Why don’t you start a new thread in relationships ( just about him, not the money for the kids stuff ) and ask for support to leave him ?

Thank you @SurprisedWithAH0RSE Yes ExH gaslit me for years and had me convinced that he was right and I was wrong. It’s taken years to even manage to stand up to him a bit. He knows exactly how to press my buttons and just keeps going and going and going until my mind goes completely blank and I can’t think straight. It’s been a while since he has managed to do that, but the memory of it is still there and it is scary to think that his anger would be directed in that way towards me again if I were to rock the boat. Thanks for helping me see that.

And I will post on relationships about my current partner. I think it will be a fairly unanimous “LTB” and I feel stupid for the things I’ve put up with. I am not even worried about being single, I’m not bothered about that at all. I am worried about the impact on the kids - we have been together for 5 years, which is almost half of DC2’s life. Partner is close to DC2 so I think DC will find it really difficult (and he was the child who also found me and his dad splitting up the hardest too). So I’ve got mega guilt over that. And I know what MN thinks of women bringing new partners into their kids’ lives so will have to prepare myself for a hard time. Probably deservedly so, if I could have shielded them from more hurt.

OP posts:
SurprisedWithAH0RSE · 11/09/2023 13:36

DietCokeAddict19 · 11/09/2023 09:57

I don't know what would happen re CMS. Yes I paid for all school lunches last year, and all the DofE costs, and the majority of a school trip cost (over £1000), and I take the DC to the dentist (and now have to pay as they won't offer NHS provision any more), but he takes them to the optician, takes them to their clubs on his weekends etc. So I wonder if I would be eligible for anything.

I'm sitting here wondering why I am reluctant to even try. I genuinely feel scared/worried that rocking the boat will make things worse. That by even trying to make a claim with CMS that he will be furious and somehow make life worse for me. I don't know how he could do that, other than bad mouthing me to the kids I suppose, but it's fear that is causing this inaction. Same fear that makes me not stand up to my current partner probably, who has just fucked off on a 2 week work trip and left me to sort out doggy day care for his dog.

So when I earlier said that it's me that's the fool, I really think it is. I don't understand why I can't stand up for myself and say that how I'm being treated isn't ok. I'm already in therapy but it's clearly not helping!

Of course Your ex is already bad mouthing you to the kids! Why would you think he’s not !! There’s nothing you can do to control what he says and does, you can only control what YOU do.

Of course you are scared - that’s how these abusive men managed to control us for years. We know that if we speak out of turn or do anything that don’t like, there will be hell to pay. And even once we’ve left them, they still control us by fear. We are like a huge elephants tied to a small stick.

So go ahead and apply for CMS today. If you don’t get anything you’ve wasted the tenner it costs to apply.

And you know what you need to do about your current partner . Why don’t you start a new thread in relationships ( just about him, not the money for the kids stuff ) and ask for support to leave him ?

Barney60 · 11/09/2023 13:00

Can you just stop chasing him , its stressing you out, kids will pick up on this, send him one final message saying sick of chasing him now applying via courts.
Then do it, show them the messages keep a tally get proof hes not paying his way.
If you do it legally not on broken promises the courts will chase him.
Good luck, we mums have enough stress without adding to it.

MeAgainPeeps · 11/09/2023 12:31

Ask CM and go from there. If ex is a dick then hes a dick who is choosing to stiff his own kids. Ultimately, it's your child's entitlement.

Your current partner needs to be your next ex. Its better to be single than subjected to these dickheads. Honestly, @DietCokeAddict19 being alone might be scary but surely it's less scary than a future with these wasters.

catherinecooksondog · 11/09/2023 12:08

*visable

catherinecooksondog · 11/09/2023 12:07

I think you’re thinking about what’s best for your kids emotional well-being over your own financial position and good on you - having an ok relationship with your ex is worth it’s weight in gold. Going to CSM might damage it. You need to preserve what you have because even if he’s being a prick about money, compared to a lot of exes he’s doing a lot of the grunt work at least? Routine medical appointments and clubs etc are so exhausting when it’s all on one parent.

Can you approach him gently and say you’ve double checked and you put £X into their lunch money last year versus his £X amount. And you’d really appreciate it if he could pay more this year to balance it out? And that you’re not trying to be difficult as you really value your relationship, you just want to make sure things are balanced?

The alternative is to keep tabs and then refuse to pay for winter coats etc as he “owes” you lunch money. Gutted for Disney Dad to get to buy the big, viable things whilst you plod at the lunch money but maybe just see it as an investment in your kids mental health by maintaining good relations. Good luck x

DietCokeAddict19 · 11/09/2023 10:37

On a related subject - if I don't have a current claim for tax credits, can you open a new claim for this or do you have to do onto universal credit?

Just checked the tax credits calculator and seen that I would still be eligible for tax credits if I wasn't together with my partner.

OP posts:
DietCokeAddict19 · 11/09/2023 10:16

And yes I am the one in receipt of Child Benefit

OP posts:
DietCokeAddict19 · 11/09/2023 10:16

Belle001982 · 10/09/2023 04:04

He should pay and be reasonable about sharing costs, but personally I think it sounds like he’s using non payment on the school dinner app as a little power trip.
I would definitely put a claim in for CMS just do it, at least you’ll know and have an outside eye cast on the financial arrangements and give some formality to the issue. If you’re still getting lumbered with most of the costs how is this truly 50/50 I found a useful piece of info about calculating maintenance when there is 50/50 care and it’s not just how many nights you have them that makes the difference apparently.
https://watson-thomas.co.uk/help-and-advice/31-help-and-advice-children/182-child-maintenance-when-you-have-an-equal-share-in-parenting

Thank you, that's a really helpful article

OP posts:
DietCokeAddict19 · 11/09/2023 09:57

I don't know what would happen re CMS. Yes I paid for all school lunches last year, and all the DofE costs, and the majority of a school trip cost (over £1000), and I take the DC to the dentist (and now have to pay as they won't offer NHS provision any more), but he takes them to the optician, takes them to their clubs on his weekends etc. So I wonder if I would be eligible for anything.

I'm sitting here wondering why I am reluctant to even try. I genuinely feel scared/worried that rocking the boat will make things worse. That by even trying to make a claim with CMS that he will be furious and somehow make life worse for me. I don't know how he could do that, other than bad mouthing me to the kids I suppose, but it's fear that is causing this inaction. Same fear that makes me not stand up to my current partner probably, who has just fucked off on a 2 week work trip and left me to sort out doggy day care for his dog.

So when I earlier said that it's me that's the fool, I really think it is. I don't understand why I can't stand up for myself and say that how I'm being treated isn't ok. I'm already in therapy but it's clearly not helping!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread