Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Questions about his ex... *Trigger warning*

93 replies

ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 21:26

So first off, I am a woman who feels the past is in the past. Don't judge someone on their history etc. Don't pry about someone's ex's or previous sexual history.

However, I need to know if IBU in this instance?

A girl has recently stalked my Instagram Story and Facebook that I don't know - she popped up on viewing Stories and then today liked and unliked an old FB pic on my profile. I click on her profile, curious, and see she lives in the same town as my boyfriend. A small specific place not local to me.

I send him a screenshot and ask if he knows her, genuinely curious why I'm being stalked by a random. He replies they have history and she was a bit mental. I ask how long ago and he said before us. He then rang me very angry, saying I was interrogating him and asking why I was starting a fight.

This reaction has then caused me to ask why he was overreacting. If it was someone in the past it's cool and he can calm down, but could he tell me what happened between them. I wouldn't normally care or want to know, but the combination of her stalking me and his big reaction triggered my spider senses.

He eventually let on that he had been with her a few months, got her pregnant, then she has had an abortion and they went their separate ways.

This had made me feel quite insecure in that he has never shared this with me - not that he had to - but that in looking more at her profile I can see he liked a selfie she took last year while we've been together, and also a picture of her son at school this year.

Im now worried he has unresolved feelings for her hence the big reaction and also liking her pictures. He's only liked two, but why would he be liking them otherwise?

Am I being overanxious now? Should I just trust his version of things as he's told me?

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 07/09/2023 23:52

Tbh I don't think it matters if he still likes his ex/she is stalking him/it's his kid etc...the point is he's flew off the handle and you're left feeling shitty and insecure. You're asking what you should do to make it right. You sound needy. Take control and let him know you won't be spoken to in that tone....and remove yourself.

Haretest · 07/09/2023 23:33

Is the son from the school pictures the right age to be his?

WinterDeWinter · 07/09/2023 23:30

Op, having had a previous abusive relationship is famously not a defence against another - quite the opposite.

Tantaijin · 07/09/2023 23:24

So, just looking at the facts you’ve presented.

You have been in a ‘worse’ relationship before (I’d be willing to bet it was emotionally abusive at the very least). I’m also guessing that you haven’t done anything like the freedom program to stop you falling into the same old trap again…no offence, but you are displaying the classic ‘fingers in ears’ behaviour about this new and ‘better’ relationship. Despite it being clear to everyone else that it is a disaster and a complete waste of your precious remaining years.

This new relationship has more red flags than carnival bunting.

He lies to you, repeatedly. And I think we all know he is not going to stop.

Despite your attempts to downplay it, it’s clear you are modifying your behaviour to avoid his sulks/anger/disproportionate annoyance to normal everyday questions and conversations.

You’re focusing on this woman because it’s easier than looking at the cracks you are desperately trying to ignore.

It’s obvious to anyone with eyes that this won’t end well, but as you’ve said you don’t want any honest LTB comments…at the very least do the freedom program. You will remain vulnerable and stay in this cycle, every ‘perfect’ new relationship rapidly turning to shit until you do.

Densol57 · 07/09/2023 23:21

Maybe he was finally free of her stalking then bang she is back stalking you and his anger is misplaced anger at her popping up again.

HowAmYa · 07/09/2023 23:20

ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 23:18

@HowAmYa thank you. I won't be apologizing tomorrow. I'm meant to be going to stay with him for the weekend..but I'm thinking I just pull back right now unless he can turn it around, acknowledge he's handled this sh** and work through this with me like a partner.

May need to keep checking in to keep my resolve to not back down. If you girls can keep me strong.

Youve got this! There's a shed load of us who have had/have partners like this.
We got your back!

ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 23:18

@HowAmYa thank you. I won't be apologizing tomorrow. I'm meant to be going to stay with him for the weekend..but I'm thinking I just pull back right now unless he can turn it around, acknowledge he's handled this sh** and work through this with me like a partner.

May need to keep checking in to keep my resolve to not back down. If you girls can keep me strong.

OP posts:
HowAmYa · 07/09/2023 23:15

ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 23:03

@HowAmYa wow. This hit home. I just rang him and said can we talk calmly as I want to know the truth if there was any crossover and need some reassurance and finding the whole thing overwhelming. He flew off the handle saying I had RUINED HIS DAY and cut me off.

He then sent me a message saying I clearly don't trust him and ruined his day. I haven't responded and so he called back and sent a passive aggressive message when I didn't answer.

Think I need to just go to bed and sleep on this. Like you say, any normal person would just be able to laugh comfortably about this with their partner which is what I was hoping/expecting.

Edited

I'm so sorry you're having to go through this.
I remember these same scenarios. You'll be the one apologising the next day because they won't. My exh used to also be an absolute bastard after having a drink. I thought all men were like that. They really are not!
It shouldn't be like this. But you have us here to tell you, that this isn't normal behaviour OP.
You become so accustomed that you forget what a truly healthy relationship is.
Relationships are great when you talk about everything. But realistically it's more about not necessarily telling each other absolutely every minute detail of everything ever, but the fact that if you wanted to, you comfortably could (without judgement)

JanglyBeads · 07/09/2023 23:10

ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 22:20

And I've just realized he's lied to me. He once told me I was the youngest person he'd ever been with (I'm quite a bit younger than him.)

She's three years younger than me!

So in fact he sought to conceal that whole relationship from you.

And reading your most recent post... I think you need to end this relationship. If you feel like that might be in any way a scary thing to tell him, make sure you have family or friends around for support.

Has he ever made you feel scared at any other time OP?

JanglyBeads · 07/09/2023 23:06

I'd want to know why he hadn't told me he'd fathered an embryo and been through its abortion, why he got angry when you were asking normal questions about a Fb stalker, why she might feel the need to check your profile out, why he's always defensive rather than open, if he could possibly be a repeat of your previous "bad boy", why it's made you feel so insecure...

I don't think I'd like the answers though.

ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 23:03

@HowAmYa wow. This hit home. I just rang him and said can we talk calmly as I want to know the truth if there was any crossover and need some reassurance and finding the whole thing overwhelming. He flew off the handle saying I had RUINED HIS DAY and cut me off.

He then sent me a message saying I clearly don't trust him and ruined his day. I haven't responded and so he called back and sent a passive aggressive message when I didn't answer.

Think I need to just go to bed and sleep on this. Like you say, any normal person would just be able to laugh comfortably about this with their partner which is what I was hoping/expecting.

OP posts:
Daffidale · 07/09/2023 22:54

I’d obsess a bit less about the exact details of who didn’t follow who and when on Instagram and Facebook 3 years ago.

Him liking 2 of her posts in a year? That’s hardly any interaction. What does a like mean anyway. It’s like the barest acknowledgment you’ve seen something. No red flags there.

If you’re concerned about HER stalking YOU (which I would personally be uncomfortable with) then block her on Insta and Facebook so she can’t see your stuff.

Him lying to you and losing his rag when challenged. Whole other issue that’s def a red flag.

HowAmYa · 07/09/2023 22:54

The issues with his anger won't go away.
I'm not saying you're walking on eggshells but I bet you're aware that you approach him tentatively because you know he will blow up or get defensive.
Any normal person would be much easier to broach these things with.
I've been there. I told myself I had the greatest relationship in the world with my now exh but in truth I pussyfooted around asking anything like this because I didn't want him to get angry or annoyed or ruin his day.
But I have a DP now where now and again something or another will come up about a previous relationship and we can have a laugh about it.

The big problem you have is that you don't even know if his reaction is a red flag because you say his reaction is like this with pretty much everything.

I get you feel you have a solid relationship. And you probably can go on and have a great future together. But you have to at some point ask if you're ever going to be able to just be YOU and be able to talk to him the way you want without having to change your behaviour to accommodate his. I was happy with my exh. Because I told myself I was. In reality, though he wasn't the worst human being in the world or anything, we just were not made for each other. We are so different. From experience, this kind of behaviour, doesn't ever change.

Looking at your last update, you're already finding holes you never knew were there.

ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 22:20

And I've just realized he's lied to me. He once told me I was the youngest person he'd ever been with (I'm quite a bit younger than him.)

She's three years younger than me!

OP posts:
ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 22:08

UPDATE

So, yes, because I'm being anxious I've just been stalking.

He said he wasn't friends with her on Insta and never had been. I've just looked through all his pictures on Instagram however and she has previously been on his and began liking his pictures from May 2020 and stopped in November 2020. He met me and started sleeping with me in July 2020.

I don't want to jump to conclusions, however the fact is if by his account 'they saw each other for a few months then fell pregnant and had an abortion'.. there could be a crossover with when he was with me.

We were casual in the beginning so I can't hold him to account in this. But I'm now freaking that he made her get an abortion because he met me 😨he was the one pursuing a relationship etc and chasing me for ages.

She's obviously taken him off her Instagram at some point as they are not friends now.

OP posts:
Missingmyusername · 07/09/2023 22:05

ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 21:37

For the 'dump him' brigade as much as I love and appreciate your self-respect-clad enthusiasm, it's really not something I'm contemplating at all. I love him a lot, I'm just anxious about this situation and wondering AIBU or how to proceed.

Proceed with what? You love him, you trust him so it’s all good then, isn’t it? Just forget about it and stop giving it head space.

Gremlins101 · 07/09/2023 22:00

I would believe him. I find my exes Facebook presence fascinating and I'm very happily married with kids. I do a fair bit of "wow thank god I dodged that" or "aww look he seems happy" and it's all very innocent.

There's no way if they were a good match, they would have gone their separate ways after he got her pregnant. They'd have had a baby together, surely.

I think you can let him off the hook after a good chat about the whole thing to clear the air.

SmileyClare · 07/09/2023 22:00

Yeah you need to be aware that you’re trying to alter your behaviour to avoid triggering his anger.

You don’t say how long you’ve been together but it’s not something to ignore.

Youve done nothing wrong in asking about an ex who has popped up on your SM

ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 21:57

@lto2019 thank you. You sound really balanced and reasonable which is what I need right now 🙏

OP posts:
lto2019 · 07/09/2023 21:56

Do you never have a nosy at exes profiles? She has probably had a nosy to see what you're like. He has liked 2 pics of her - so?
I don't see any red flags - I wouldn't be arsed in the slightest. As for the termination - it happened to them - not sure why he would need to tell you? The only thing I would be concerned about is him saying she is mental - but who knows she might be.

ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 21:56

@HectorSalamanca I've been with the guy three years, were pretty deep in 😝 if it was three months yes this situation would make me think differently, as I would assume the worst and run.

OP posts:
ConfiderWren · 07/09/2023 21:54

@SmileyClare well this is the thing, do I ask more? I feel like I would feel much better if he would talk to me openly about what happened, why they separated..

But then the posters highlighting my insecurity as unreasonable would indicate this is the wrong thing to do, so should I just assume trust and let it go, and work on myself?

I feel like in a healthy situation I would have been safe to ask and have a calm, open conversation. It's his anger that I don't know how to react to and that has made me feel insecure.

OP posts:
HectorSalamanca · 07/09/2023 21:53

gwenneh · 07/09/2023 21:29

Yeah it’s always that “they’re mental!”

That, coupled with the defensive response, would be an enormous red flag.

Yep. He has a 'crazy ex'

Same old trope.

There is more to this than meets the eye.

Dump. You're not that deep in yet

beastlyslumber · 07/09/2023 21:49

Janieforever · 07/09/2023 21:44

I don’t agree, I’d be furious if a partner wanted the detail on my ex’s. Apparently on here it’s ok for a woman to ask but if a man asks it’s heinous?

I said nothing about OP asking about his past. That seems reasonable in the context but ymmv.

The red flags here are his anger and her anxiety and insecurity.

SmileyClare · 07/09/2023 21:48

Whether you’re “working on “ his temper or not, his angry defensive reaction is the red flag. Plus calling her “mental”.
This is the line always trotted out by men who can’t take responsibility for issues in a relationship.

Youre in essence now treading on egg shells and feel you can’t ask anything about his past in case he reacts “”badly”and accuses you of starting a fight.

A bit of online snooping from an ex is really nothing to be concerned about. Presumably he had some sort of relationship with her son so I can understand him looking at his first day at school pic.