Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I've made a massive error in career choice?

42 replies

maybeyesterday · 07/09/2023 19:27

I'm doing my post grad in social work. Worked hard for 5 years to get my degree in something more general. This is my final year and final placement.

Last placement was with a voluntary agency and was more like support work I was doing. Intensive contact with service users, helping them manage day to day life, attending court and appointments, doing risk assessments and care plans. I loved every second of it. It was such a positive experience and my confidence just grew.

However, I'm now on my second week of a statutory placement. And I just don't think I can do it. I feel like they're speaking a different language (although getting to grips with the acronyms now), I find it so intense and just feel like it's so much responsibility. I know I am protected as a student but I am worrying about when I qualify and whether I'm up for the job. I have been flung in the deep end, have been allocated cases and have had to do visits alone. I haven't even shadowed a visit on this placement, just done visits myself. Is this usual because it's my last one?

Also in the office the social workers were talking today about how they're working 60 plus hours a week to get everything done and are only getting paid for 37.

I honestly don't know if I can do this. It would be a shame to quit now though. Is this usual nerves for just starting somewhere? Or a sign it's all been a waste of time?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Birch101 · 12/09/2023 08:16

And in respect to you doing visits alone I would flag this immediately

Birch101 · 12/09/2023 08:14

I think you are right be concerned you are going into an area which is severely understaffed, under funded and under appreciated/respected. Whilst your role could actually benefit and help people I would say get your qualification and when looking for jobs be seriously looking at management style and what measures are in place to protect staff and retain them.
And for God sake don't do extra hours without claiming for them.
It appears that most public sector jobs run on the kindness and extra time of staff. No wonder sectors are pissed off.
Hopefully you find an area of social work you can enjoy and a team you can respect

User63847439572 · 12/09/2023 08:08

Honestly? Yes it’s basically a pretty horrible job. I just left after 17 years and I should’ve done it earlier.
but one of the pluses is that there are lots of different settings you can work in so it’s fine if that type of statutory team isn’t for you. Find something where it’s more old fashioned therapeutic social work, probably employed in the voluntary sector.
a hospice for example, or even mental health ward where your caseload is clearly defined by those staying on the ward.

hylian · 12/09/2023 08:05

OP, I really think you should carry on and get your qualification.

It's one placement at the end of the day, you can grit your teeth and get through it, and if it puts you off working for the local authority that's OK. LA social work is infamously stressful and busy and definitely not for everyone.

But there are so many other jobs that ask for a social work qualification which won't be like that placement. You don't even have to be a social worker but the qualification is really useful. Believe me - I'm in a related field and it will take you far to have that piece of paper!

Wherly · 12/09/2023 07:56

Are you in adults or children's?

Justdontforgethelegofrog · 12/09/2023 07:53

How's it going this week OP?

Aquamarine1O29 · 08/09/2023 20:32

CherryCokeFanatic · 08/09/2023 19:36

Maybe a job on the tills at Tesco would have been easier

The OP is due to complete a MASTERS degree. Why would she want a job on the tills at Tesco? Far too qualified for that.

flowertoday · 08/09/2023 20:29

Social work is tough, but in a good team survivable . The rewards can be huge, but that isn't a day to day reality / experience. The economic climate and political climate is making it very difficult across health and social care.

My advice would be not to go for child protection when you qualify. Of everything it is the toughest job and in my experience where practitioners are working the longest hours and burning out the fastest. There are pressures everywhere of course , but it is my child protection colleagues who I really worry for as they are under so much pressure .

Don't give up. You are needed and will be valued. The last placement of the course is tough but you will be OK.

Turmerictolly · 08/09/2023 20:19

Not helpful but I'd switch to an OT career if I were you. Same pay scales, managed, planned workloads, variety, travel opportunities, private or public practice, far less stress.

Careerconfused · 08/09/2023 20:07

I agree that student SWs should be given a small caseload, but not in week two and not without any introduction to the job. Presumably won't have ever worked in an adults team before, how are they supposed to know what to do on a visit? It's one thing to have developed the people skills to knock on the door and talk to someone, but they'd need to shadow visits to know the role, eg if it's an assessment role what is covered, what support is available to offer etc.

I work in an authority that is struggling, and even our fully qualified/experienced social workers can't be allocated cases until the end of week 2, the system actually blocks it - to allow them to complete the mandatory training that is expected before they can have allocations (eg GDPR, our practice model intro and a refresher on how to use the database/workflow)

Gahhhhereheisagain · 08/09/2023 20:05

@Jellycatspyjamas I get that. But I think we offer more in the way of external solutions, be that help with housing, care, family work etc, rather than spending hours talking.

Jellycatspyjamas · 08/09/2023 20:01

I feel that the job the social workers are doing is more akin to psychology or talking therapy. I wanted to go into social work as I like concrete solutions.

Social work is as far removed from talking therapy as night is from day - there are no concrete solutions though, the work is complex and relationship based, with a whole range of ethical and practice dilemmas, and very few concrete answers.

Jellycatspyjamas · 08/09/2023 19:58

I don't think you should just be given a caseload, that's totally overwhelming.

You so realise that in a few short months final placement students will in qualified jobs and will be carrying many many more than 3 cases, most of which will be worked as a solo or lead worker?

Of course the OP should have a proper induction and be supported on more complex cases but final placement students should be able to manage a small caseload. Better to feel, and manage, that sense of overwhelm in a supported student placement than find themselves feeling that for the first time on the job when they are professionally accountable for their practice.

Gahhhhereheisagain · 08/09/2023 19:42

I don't think you should just be given a caseload, that's totally overwhelming. I have be given three people and I share them with another person who can advise me.

Gahhhhereheisagain · 08/09/2023 19:40

Are you on a graduate scheme like think ahead?
I think it's normal to realise that it's going to be tough and that you worry about how stressed everyone is. Are you in NHS or local authority?
I'm on placement and I feel equally overwhelmed although less so with the acronyms. I feel that the job the social workers are doing is more akin to psychology or talking therapy. I wanted to go into social work as I like concrete solutions. It's just made me realise that I really want to go back to inpatient units rather than community. When is your placement over?
You could always ask to switch to something you feel more comfortable with.

CherryCokeFanatic · 08/09/2023 19:36

Maybe a job on the tills at Tesco would have been easier

Mydustymonstera · 08/09/2023 19:35

Also - off topic slightly @Cheeseandlobster same! It’s a real surprise feeling so much more supported and valued in the stat sector compared to 3rd sector - not what I expected when I first qualified.

Mydustymonstera · 08/09/2023 19:33

If it’s really going pear shaped with your PE you need to speak with your course tutor. It should be challenging with a lot to learn and changes you will make to your practice e, but you also should feel very supported in that. (Another Sw and link worker). How does your experience compare with rest of your cohort?

chocolateshortcake · 08/09/2023 19:23

I am a SW and a PE and even on your final placement you should have a proper induction with shadowing and familiarisation with the setting. You should also be having weekly supervision so I would speak to your PE and explain how you are feeling. Even when our team was completely short staffed and overwhelmed I would try my hardest to buffer my student from that experience as ultimately we want you to come back and work with us. It can be hard to challenge your PE but they should know this needs to happen. Where I am there is a PLA meeting 2-3 weeks in and the induction is supposed to be completed by then, do you have this coming up and could you use this as a way to ask for an induction plan?

Andylippy1 · 08/09/2023 13:44

I would ask your PE about an induction to the placement and a plan of shadowing colleagues. You will need to undertake in house essential training as well. Have you been offered training? I would advice you to talk with your uni of college tutor about this lack of an induction programme. Are you able to link up with colleagues and ask them directly if you can shadow them on any interesting visits?

It is highly unusual to not have an induction as a student on placement. Very poor practice in my view.

Jellycatspyjamas · 07/09/2023 22:33

I was so nervous meeting the service users though

What was making you nervous? I’d expect a student on final placement to be ok meeting service users, to be able to prepare for visits and ask about anything that worried them beforehand.

It’s common practice where I am that you have a practice educator, they’d only have a link worker if the practice educator wasn’t based in their team. Her being busy is neither here nor there, it’s not your responsibility - you need to be able to ask for what you need. Social workers need to be assertive with their service users but also with fellow professionals, if you need an induction plan, or to be shadowing visits etc you need to speak up.

What preparation did you do for your practice placement - what feedback did you have from first placement and what came up in your pre-placement meeting. You need to consider that the next job you go to you’ll be a fully qualified social worker and while your first year will be protected, you’ll be expected to find your feet and carry an allocated case load.

Your first placement sounds lovely, and your first placement should be quite sheltered but it doesn’t always prepare you for the pace of statutory social work. It sounds like you’ve got a hill to climb in this placement but you’ll get there.

Halsi · 07/09/2023 21:59

Definately finish your degree so you have it, you can use it for lots of different types of work,maybe work for a charity? Or a hospice is a good pace and well resourced for social work. It is a very hard job in some areas but you'll find something you like. Good luck in your career!

maybeyesterday · 07/09/2023 21:55

Catopia · 07/09/2023 20:52

Raise the acronyms with your manager. The profession is full of them (and sometimes different LAs/teams use different ones, or have the same abbreviation to mean different things in different contexts). If it's not clear, write a list of what you come across that needs clarifying, ask what they mean, and then at the end of the placement give them the list to pass to the next student. We did this as an exercise in a previous team and came up with about 5 pages of acronyms or terms; it really must have been like a foreign language for those joining straight out of uni.

Yes I have a notepad dedicated to acronyms. I am asking constantly, 'what is this, what is that' and then I am writing down the words and then going home and researching what they all mean. This is helping. Good idea to pass on to students.

OP posts:
maybeyesterday · 07/09/2023 21:53

Andylippy1 · 07/09/2023 20:48

I am a SW and a PE. Are you on your 2 week induction? You need to shadow visits as part of your induction. If this isn't being arranged flag it up with your practice educator. You need to do visits with different social workers to learn about them and develop your own style. The stat placements are very different to voluntary ones but you will adapt if you want to do it. The second placement is more in depth than the first ones and you need a lot more practice evidence to pass it.

Keep going is my advice. The SW's in the team probably work long hours but they need to talk with the manager if they are doing such long hours to get the work done. It isn't realistic or sustainable going forward to do these long hours. LA's don't pay overtime so yes your colleagues will only get paid for 37 hours which is the contracted full time week hours.

Hope this helps clarify as few things. Good luck I'm sure you can get through your stat placement.

I haven't been given or spoken to about an induction. My link worker is also my practice teacher and is totally busy and overwhelmed. I wasn't offered the chance to shadow any visits etc. Was just allocated my case load. I asked if someone would be coming with me to visit but they said that I was fine as it was in a hospital setting most of my visits. So I just got on with it. I was so nervous meeting the service users though.

OP posts:
Intersmellar · 07/09/2023 21:51

I am sure I felt the same during the first few months in statutory work but honestly it gets better and easier the more experienced you become and you can use your social work degree in lots of different areas- youth work, yot, voluntary sector.