Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we aren’t “super lucky” about this?

245 replies

ValentinaLouise · 07/09/2023 17:35

Talking to a friend today about how I may potentially switch jobs at some point after maternity leave. She has said I’m a fool to do that and right now me and DH are “super lucky”. I’m not so sure but it’s certainly made me think! And although obviously we have to decide this, it would be interesting to see what others though.

me and DH work at the same place on alternative shifts, switching weekly. So we currently bring DS to work with us and the other goes home with him again, if that makes sense. So yes, we are lucky that there is always one of us available and we don’t need childcare, but this does mean we don’t see each other apart from a quick kiss until 8:30pm every day, it feels like we are solo parents for half a day until the weekend (obviously not I’m aware it’s definitely not even close to having to do it on your own) but not sure how to explain it. It’s good because we split everything 50/50, when I’m on lates I do what he does on earlies, etc. regarding cleaning/cooking/child stuff. Means DS is just as close to both of us, etc. and I do see the perks but it feels like we just never do anything as a family until the weekend. We obviously see each other for about an hour in the evenings too but then the one on earlies needs to go to bed, etc. it’s nice we do get to spend the weekend together of course though but I’m not sure this is such a “super lucky” situation? We obviously get double income and no childcare costs and again, we can split things equally but I do feel we are missing out on a lot as a family and have to do everything solo, but kind of just tag teaming it. Not sure.

would it be silly to change jobs in this situation? Is this a situation you would be glad to have?

OP posts:
ValentinaLouise · 07/09/2023 19:52

Maybe we don’t realise just how helpful we have got it then! Definitely a lot to think about. The shifts are 5am-12:30 and 12:30-8 so the swap over is helpful for school aged/nursery age too. It just feels hard sometimes because I don’t feel I see him all week but seems that can easily be the reality if we did it differently, with a whole load more negatives!

OP posts:
Watchthedoormat · 07/09/2023 19:47

I think you have a great set up.
Very fortunate to have whole weekends off together too to spend as a family unit.
Many don't have that luxury.

SurprisedWithAH0RSE · 07/09/2023 19:42

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 07/09/2023 18:57

You'd be mad to put your children in nursery when you don't need to. This 'family time' that you're idealising doesn't exist for any working families during the week. It's one mad juggle of pick ups and drop offs from one end of the week to the other.

Why on earth would you want to switch from what you've got to paying thousands per month for chaos?

You're so lucky to be able to do what you do. Your children are cared for by you and their dad. You have no extortionate childcare bills and your family time is at the weekend. Just like everyone else.

This.

Ducksurprise · 07/09/2023 19:40

Very fortunate.

My youngest is 12, eldest nearly 30, we still don't have every weekend together and have never had more than one hour a night. I don't feel unlucky, it is the bed we made, but yours sounds better

confusedmum2023 · 07/09/2023 19:38

First off my opinion doesn’t include childcare as we luckily have two sets of grandparents who help out.
I think what you describe sounds pretty decent! My dh works in hospitality so his 2 days off are weekdays and i’m off the weekend. I’d give up seeing him all week if it meant we had weekends as a family. He is home at 10pm earliest on his working days so it’s me and dd alone for bedtime routine and dinner. I suppose it depends on what u really want from the extra time together and if you can afford the childcare. We always have nice dinners at the table when he is home and do like a family games night or movie night. We sometimes go out for dinner and during school holidays we always do something fun like go to the beach on his days off. Suppose it’s about making the most with the time you do have together.

Folklore9074 · 07/09/2023 19:38

Nothing comes for free in a way, you 'pay' if you like, for your set up of no childcare fees with not seeing each other until the weekend.

And I think you have a point about family time OP. We're a dual income household, one dc in nursery full time. We both wfh for the most part so can do pick up, drop off, etc. and have bit of time all together in the evenings. As for any parents, dual income, one working, one staying at home etc. its full on. That is family life to certain extent I think. One thing to note though about our set up, while nice most days, it is very expensive to have a child in nursery full time - worth it and necessary for us but it costs a lot.

CurlewKate · 07/09/2023 19:38

Yep. Super lucky. Hang onto those jobs like grim death.

SmallestInTheClass · 07/09/2023 19:32

We have always done family dinners. Both of us work in fairly 9-5 office jobs but tend to early start so more like 8-4pm. But we have paid childcare (was a private nursery then a before and after school childminder who also did the holidays). We paid for care from 7:30am to 17:30/18:00pm to allow for commuting time. If we have extra work, we can do it later in the evenings, or some nights one of us works later. We don't have dinner all together every night, but average about 3 week nights. I think we are lucky with our jobs but also have gone without other things to afford the childcare which is a huge portion of our income. I think it's worth it for the family time, if you can afford it. I appreciate many just can't, especially with more than one child.

JammyDodgersandPeas · 07/09/2023 19:30

It's very rare in our house. I work in a school so I'm around all the time that the kids are at home, but DH normally works 9-8 ish, so I do all the dinner, bed, bath routine. He sees the children in the mornings. I alternate eating with the kids and eating with him (and occasionally eat by myself once they're asleep if he's working past 10pm).

Your set up is definitely very lucky.

momtoboys · 07/09/2023 19:24

I don't know many parents of young children that see much of their spouse during the week. It seems like an ideal situation to me unless your pay will increase a great deal to afford child minding for two children.

Canonlythinkofthisone · 07/09/2023 19:24

You are super lucky yes. My DH has his days off in the week whilst I have weekends off. The only days together we get off are booked annual leave.
It means our DD only has to go to nursery 3 days a week and it's still a grand a month. A thousand pounds. Every month. Even with 2 decent salaries, it's crippling.
She spends her mornings and 2 days a week with her Dad and the evenings and weekends with me. We essentially tag team. I sometimes don't see him for 3 days at a time as he works late shifts and I work early days. We make it work because we don't want to spend even more on childcare. It means we are careful with our plans for time together as a family. Sometimes it breaks my heart that we don't all sit down together to eat ever, but at least we can afford food for us all. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Prettyrainbowcolours · 07/09/2023 19:20

Yabu. We only have Sundays as a family, as I work Saturdays. Dh works Monday to Friday. It saves on childcare costs and as much as I don’t like it, needs must.

CaptainSeven · 07/09/2023 19:17

Even the fact you don't have to stress about one person getting home late (because DS commutes with you) is serendipitous!

You've get a really perfect set up right now. Hold on to it because childcare costs a fortune (we paid for childcare in one form or another for 15 years and I stopped adding up the cost at £75,000)

TiaraBoo · 07/09/2023 19:17

My ex DH used to come home between 7:30 and 9:30 pm so no I don’t think you’re missing out on much.
And you are lucky to have a choice of paying /not paying for childcare!

TiredRetired · 07/09/2023 19:17

Working with dependent children is hard going tbh, whatever the arrangement. Just relish the weekends and holidays. This time will pass too quickly.

WaltzingWaters · 07/09/2023 19:16

I understand what you’re saying about evening family time, but few families actually get that unless maybe one parent is a stay at home parent or works part time.
We have the opposite in that I work the two days that my partner doesn’t work. We see each other in the evenings (though still only from 6:30/7pm) but veeeeery rarely get an actual day off together.
I would say you’ve got a good thing going, especially if you calculate what 2 childcare spaces would be costing you. But if you have really good wages and would prefer to go for childcare and have a similar schedules then of course, change it.

RidingMyBike · 07/09/2023 19:13

ValentinaLouise · 07/09/2023 17:53

Do you not eat dinner as a family? Do bath/bed with the kids together etc?

Not whilst using childcare - got in from work and nursery about 6.30pm so then it was straight into bedtime routine.

Have never done bath and bed together after the first few months - easier to take it in turns so the other one can get on with clearing up after the meal or have some downtime.

Imissthe00s · 07/09/2023 19:12

If you’re only going to gain a few hours in the evening I think you’d be silly to change. If you get family time of a weekend like most people then I don’t see the issue

monotonousmum · 07/09/2023 19:11

While I understand this seems hard right now, two kids is going to be hard no matter what!
The amount you save on childcare is enormous, and like others have said you'd be unlikely to find childcare that would all you to do alternate weeks, so paying for 50% of time you don't need. You'd also only spend more time together every other week, assuming you'll be looking for a job that matches one of his shifts. So all of that, and you're still in the same situation half the time anyway.

Not to mention resentment. Maybe your OH is great - but there will be many others on here that would kill for an OH doing 50/50. That could slip if the circumstances change.

FMLWTF · 07/09/2023 19:10

I barely see DH in the week. I don’t think it’s uncommon.

determinedtomakethiswork · 07/09/2023 19:08

I think you have the perfect arrangement. As long as your job isn't absolutely awful, I would put up with that until the children are a bit older.

Caterina99 · 07/09/2023 19:08

I don’t think I’d love the set up, but I’d definitely suck it up for 2 full time incomes and zero childcare when they’re small. Plus 50/50 with your partner is awesome as I feel so many women do childcare all day and then do an evening work shift which must be exhausting!

Lots of families don’t see each other much in the week. Or one of them has to work weekends. And they’re shelling out a lot in nursery fees too.

I can’t quite work out what time your shift change is. Will that be an issue for school timings?

latetothefisting · 07/09/2023 19:04

I think you are over estimating how much time the average family or even just couple with 2 kids spend together in the week. Lots of people are single parents or have at least one parent who either works unsociable hours/much more changeable shifts or just very long hours due to high pressure job/long commute, so it would be normal for them not to see the kids at all in the evenings. Lots of kids are in some form of childcare both before and after school, or do activities several times a week, which, with parents ferrying multiple kids to different places, means they are like ships in the night . Some people go to bed by 9 even if they don't work shifts. I don't think there are many families where both parents and children are all home by 5:30pm, have tea together and then spend the evening together, every night.

I've found that some people hear 'lucky' and interpret it as 'easy' and think it discounts everything else they've done, the hard work they put in, the other issues people might be affected by, etc. But it's just a word, and everything is relative - someone could be 'lucky' they have childcare they trust with their kids and is reliable, doesn't mean they can't simultaneously resent that it costs them a fortune. We could all be considered 'lucky' we even have jobs to go to, doesn't mean we're not exhausted from them or didn't work hard to get them. People with fertility issues might think anyone who has kids is lucky.

I think all your friends mean is that you're lucky to have this option, which lots of people don't. It doesn't mean it makes your life easy, and if doesn't work for you then by all means change it. But don't get resentful just because of a word choice.

Lovingitallnow · 07/09/2023 19:03

I think this set up means the mental load is assuredly reasonably distributed. Which is priceless. P

Bunnycat101 · 07/09/2023 19:03

I’d think very carefully before switching. Two in nursery could easily be more than £2k a month.

Do you not eat dinner as a family? Do bath/bed with the kids together etc?

Nope- never have really been able to do that. Because of our commutes one person does mornings and one evenings. We generally don’t get to sit down together until 8 at the earliest. You really are in danger of swapping to something that won’t be that much better but will come with a big bill.

Swipe left for the next trending thread