Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we aren’t “super lucky” about this?

245 replies

ValentinaLouise · 07/09/2023 17:35

Talking to a friend today about how I may potentially switch jobs at some point after maternity leave. She has said I’m a fool to do that and right now me and DH are “super lucky”. I’m not so sure but it’s certainly made me think! And although obviously we have to decide this, it would be interesting to see what others though.

me and DH work at the same place on alternative shifts, switching weekly. So we currently bring DS to work with us and the other goes home with him again, if that makes sense. So yes, we are lucky that there is always one of us available and we don’t need childcare, but this does mean we don’t see each other apart from a quick kiss until 8:30pm every day, it feels like we are solo parents for half a day until the weekend (obviously not I’m aware it’s definitely not even close to having to do it on your own) but not sure how to explain it. It’s good because we split everything 50/50, when I’m on lates I do what he does on earlies, etc. regarding cleaning/cooking/child stuff. Means DS is just as close to both of us, etc. and I do see the perks but it feels like we just never do anything as a family until the weekend. We obviously see each other for about an hour in the evenings too but then the one on earlies needs to go to bed, etc. it’s nice we do get to spend the weekend together of course though but I’m not sure this is such a “super lucky” situation? We obviously get double income and no childcare costs and again, we can split things equally but I do feel we are missing out on a lot as a family and have to do everything solo, but kind of just tag teaming it. Not sure.

would it be silly to change jobs in this situation? Is this a situation you would be glad to have?

OP posts:
inloveandmarried · 08/09/2023 16:40

That sounds like a pretty amazing set up given the extortion costs of childcare. Plus your little one gets equal time with both parents.

I think your friend might be right.

Iwasafool · 08/09/2023 16:34

I think you can look at not needing paid childcare and that's lucky. Your little one always has mum or dad of both of you so I think that's lucky for baby (I know not everyone will agree with that.) On the otherhand you get very little time as a family which isn't lucky at all (unless you dislike each other which doesn't sound like the case.)

So I'm on the fence as I can see both sides.

Notamum12345577 · 08/09/2023 16:32

I would say you are luckily financially (as you can both work full time without paying for childcare) but not luckily time spent together wise.

Doone21 · 08/09/2023 16:13

No you are super lucky. Loads of people don't get family time together in the week some don't even get weekends.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 08/09/2023 16:12

Realistically how much do you actually do in the week ?? Because other than boring stuff we do absolutely nothing.......your friends right, id be sticking it out at least until your child starts school. You could start having some late evening walks or drive outs if you're that bothered but having entire weekends as a family sounds like a set up most people can only dream of.

Turfwars · 08/09/2023 16:12

Hold onto it until the school years, it's only a few years which will fly by.

We paid thousands and thousands in childcare and we only had one DC, and we live in a country where there's decent enough subsidies and even had family helping us. It could have probably funded the extension we really want to get.

Now, more than ever is a time to be really clever about where your hard earned money goes.

Pleaseme · 08/09/2023 16:08

I think you really need to investigate the costs of childcare it could easily be £1k + a month. I’m unsure how much you’d really get together. Would you change to a 9-5? If he did permanent earlies you could possibly get half nursery days. Then you have to decide whose off for illness, stress of getting dc up and out the door. Whereas now I’m assuming you can have fairly relaxed mornings.

saffy2 · 08/09/2023 16:05

ValentinaLouise · 07/09/2023 20:00

yes exactly we do a full day at work and then look after our son for the rest and soon to be 2 under 3! It will be tiring :)

So do all working parents though?

saffy2 · 08/09/2023 16:03

Also as an example, this will entirely depend on where you live. But assuming you got a 9-5 job and therefore childcare would be needed 8.30-5.30 5 days a week for 2 children (as a previous poster said, you would need to pay for all the hours needed as I can’t fill an alternate half a day space every other week). With me (in the southeast so expensive) that would cost £630 PER WEEK.
find out hourly rates of Childminders near you and find out what your cost would be, but if you lived near me it would be absolute insanity to give up the situation you currently have.

Blanketpolicy · 08/09/2023 15:59

I think there are some cons to your set up, but there are some very big pros to way over compensate for them.

jays · 08/09/2023 15:56

Some of the answers on here are hilarious. All the ‘most people do this’ and ‘most people don’t have that’ and the even more dramatic ‘nobody gets to do that! Unless you know’ most people’ or ‘everyone’ you’re actually not in a position to say what most people and everyone else does.

MyShmoo · 08/09/2023 15:55

I think personally it does sound like you already have the ideal set up for now. I think it's a case of you thinking the grass is greener maybe? Definitely the cost of childcare for 2 kiddies is huge! It's also so lovely for DC to have at least one parent there for the majority. I think if you swapped jobs you would REALLY regret it.

In our current situation we dont even get weekends together as a family or evenings, we'd have to take annual leave to have the weekend to do things together with the kids.

itsallnewnow · 08/09/2023 15:51

Dh and I work different times and we're still like ships passing in the night because that's the reality of working and having kids I think. We also pay £££ in childcare so no I wouldn't give up what you have until you're through the preschool years

saffy2 · 08/09/2023 15:50

But so do other working parents?

saffy2 · 08/09/2023 15:48

Yes I think no childcare costs is very very beneficial, especially for two.
we don’t eat as a family, because the kids eat earlier and my partner isnt home until 6pm earliest. Actually most nights I eat alone. He also has a hobby outside of the home, so 2 weeknights of the week he comes home around 7.30pm instead, the other weeknights he comes home at 6pm and then leaves at 8pm to do the hobby returning when I’m in bed. He does bedtime when he is at home, I do it when he is not. He leaves the house at 7.15am, we are often not even downstairs yet. So 90% of parenting through the week is down to me. I am a childminder and wouldn’t consider doing anything else due to the aforementioned not having to pay for childcare.
weekends he often takes them out for the day on one of the days so I can get a break. We do something together the second day, or both days if he hasn’t taken them out. We don’t get much if any time doing anything of quality all four of us during the week. I think that’s pretty normal to be honest and I think you’d find the same if you changed your situation.

GirlOfTudor · 08/09/2023 15:46

You've got it very cushy! Both spending one on one time with your child, no childcare costs and managers who are happy for you both to presumably start a few minutes late/finish a few minutes earlier to exchange your child.

Research other people's situations and childcare costs around you and see how you'd make it work.

DistantSkye · 08/09/2023 15:44

I'd look at childcare costs, potential working patterns and commuting time and decide what's best for you as a family - everyone is different in terms of what works for them.
I don't think many families have much quality family time during the week - especially as kids get older your evenings can get eaten up by their activities/friends coming over/going out.
I suppose you're fortunate in saving childcare costs and having a choice of working patterns but I can see how it would get tiring doing either the morning routine or bedtime alone all week.

PinkRoses1245 · 08/09/2023 15:43

I wouldn't say lucky, I'd say fortunate in that you don't pay childcare. You say " but it feels like we just never do anything as a family until the weekend" - this is most families where both parents work, surely? Weekdays would just be breakfast and out the door, and home for dinner and bed. it sounds nice and balanced between you and DH. Can you reconsider once DS starts school?

Fink · 08/09/2023 15:40

I would think being together from 8.30pm nearly every evening and the whole weekend is at least as much, if not more, than most families with two working adults get. I'd count myself very lucky to get that. Even if one of you has always been on earlies and so is tired early, it's not the same as a proper night shift, so you can see a bit of one another.

The lack of childcare costs is obviously a huge additional benefit, and the fact that there is always someone home to prep the evening meal and do the child's bedtime. In most families with two fulltime jobs, the dinner has to be got ready in a hurry after work, or constantly you live off things that are prepped the day before (once you've got the kids in bed, i.e. you're tired already!).

You would be absolutely mad to give this up for a 9-5 type job, unless it were for some other reason (you hated the current job, career progression etc.).

2023forme · 08/09/2023 15:29

BIossomtoes · 07/09/2023 17:46

Don’t most people only do things as a family at weekends?

I was going to say similar. Obviously lots of people work over weekends - DH and I both worked days/nights/weekends when DC were young. But even when we were both on days at the same time, we did very little 'as a family' in the weeknights as we were shattered/dealing with DC/trying to get a little bit of 'me' time each.

I think your current situation is really good, especially as you are expecting DC2. Save having family time until weekends and holidays - if you didn't have the current arrangement and used childcare, you'll be too skint/knackered/stressed out to enjoy weeknights anyway!

Dotgat · 08/09/2023 15:23

When our DC were pre school we both worked office hours with a commute so juggling nursery drop off and work we pretty much only had time once kids were in bed at 7.30. Then tidy up, make tea, TV, bed by 9.30/10pm. Not much difference to you except it cost us £900 a month for childcare!

Now they're primary aged we work from home but alternate who starts early, shutting themselves away in another room, the other parent takes on the morning breakfast and drop off routine, then after school it's wrap around care, or driving them around to activities and playdates while the other parent has 121 time with the child who isn't out that night, or. . . . we tidy up! We do sometimes eat together as a family during the week but the timings often don't work unless we want to eat our tea at 4.30pm before rushing out to swimming lessons!

Weekends are family time as even in school holidays kids are either in holiday club, or we tag team our annual leave. But now they sleep though the night we are happy to get up early with them at weekends and make the most of our time together so it feels like quality time. Having said that, our children enjoy 121 time with me or DH now they're older, plus we pursue our own hobbies and socialising, or I do something together with DH around the house like gardening or cooking, so we still aren't together all the time.

To have more family time you need to either:

  1. Have a stay at home parent who looks after house and life admin
  2. Buy time by outsourcing house and life admin, eat out/take away
  3. Limit the number of kids extra curricular activities and your own socialising and hobbies.

Everything is a balance so only you know what to prioritise.

TooOldForASugarDaddy · 08/09/2023 15:23

Honestly, it is not the set up standard but both of you are having much more valuable hours with your child than you would ever had if both worked the same shift.

There is not much you can do as a family when you both finish work in the evening, the kids haber been at the nursery the whole day and EVERYONE is exhausted to do much with the 1 or 2 hours you have before the kids go to bed.

runrabbit77 · 08/09/2023 15:03

DH and I both work full time.
DH leaves for the office just before 7am so we dont see him in the morning. I get DD3 up and ready and take her to nursery before going to work to start at 10. DH then leaves work at 4 to collect DD and is home by 6 where he sorts and does dinner etc. I get home at 7 and put DD to bed. So we get about two hours together in the evening. All our family time is at the weekend.
You are lucky that you are not paying for childcare, and tbh most homes with two working adults have various degrees of 'ships in the night' during the week.

Libra24 · 08/09/2023 15:02

I think you probably have a great thing going and childcare is not only expensive but exhausting for children so much so that even having dinner with them is usually touch and go for meltdowns. Childcare for full time hours is about £1000 a month, per child. And it's hard to find ad hoc or shift pattern child care too.

I fully appreciate that feeling of not having the time together that maybe you would like or that you had on mat leave but I wouldn't rush into anything yet. Enjoy your mat leave and assess things again. There are big promises in the political manifestos for childcare. You might be in a different position in 12-18 months.

Wolfinthehouse · 08/09/2023 14:41

This is basically our situation except we don't work in the same place. We have opposite shifts, works really well. I do a double on his days off though to make up for the fact I have less hours the rest of the time. We don't see a huge amount of each other but I'll probably change jobs once the kids are teens/self sufficient. Until then we just enjoy A/L together as a family and the kids do activities with us separately 🤷‍♀️
it's the most cosy effective way of raising small kids and means summer holidays are covered by us!