Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will nursery find this a strange request?

152 replies

Amilp · 07/09/2023 11:31

DS recently started nursery. He’s 11 months. I’ve realised that he is given a desert after his lunch and after his dinner. This is chocolate cake, sponge cake, etc. AIBU to ask them to just give him fruit instead? I don’t want to kick up a fuss but I wasn’t planning on introducing chocolate etc until he was 3 or 4??

OP posts:
itsmyp4rty · 07/09/2023 18:36

TBH at that age I wouldn't have wanted ds eating a bunch of processed anything, whether it contained sugar or not. The meals will be as cheap as anything to maximise profit and what they call 'beetroot cake' might still have a ton of sugar in it - the catering company will want it to sound good for parents but will also want the kids to actually eat it.
The school dinners at ds's school are appalling - they got a lot worse after covid. It's all a lot of cheap processed crap.

Amilp · 07/09/2023 18:35

Didimum · 07/09/2023 17:49

They don’t think it’s ‘impossible not to’, they just have differing ideas on food to you.

My kids are out of nursery now, but similar to what a poster above said, our nursery used to serve main meal and pudding altogether - it taught the kids that ‘pudding’ is not a treat or a reward, but it’s a balanced moderation and that food is just food. The children did not plump for the ‘pudding’ first and disregard their main meal, they just enjoyed the food and ate a bit of everything. I don’t always do this at home, but when I do, my kids still will just eat a bit of everything in whatever order they want, which is fine with me.

You aren’t required to agree with that, but you don’t need to be shocked at how other people treat food and eating.

Edited

@Didimum i’d say possibly the problem with obesity in this country is the fact that few people are shocked at giving an 11 month old cake twice a week after a meal… so yes I am a bit shocked by it! I am a big chocolate lover myself and eat far too much so I am by no means perfect, but my son has no idea what day it is let alone what a balanced diet is, so there’s really no need for him to be eating that yet.

OP posts:
IDoughnutKnow · 07/09/2023 18:34

It's easier to avoid this stuff with your PFB. Impossible with subsequent children.

If you want to be certain that they're eating only the things you want them to eat, nursery isn't a great choice.

Bringbackniles · 07/09/2023 18:34

I would ask the nursery what is actually in the puddings first. Did they give you menus before your son started?

If its full on chocolate cake for puddings then no, not many people would be happy with that for an 11 month old.

Having a no chocolate approach until 3 or 4 may backfire. A little bit of cake or chocolate in a child's diet is not a bad thing, if their diet is balanced in general.

My sister was very strict about a healthy diet for her children. They are all obsessed with getting their hands on every treat and 'naughty food' available, at any opportunity. (I don't agree with labelling food as a treat but this is her approach)

Other kids (Inc my own) who are allowed chocolate/cake/biscuits/crisps as part of a balanced diet seem much less bothered by it all.

Cowlover89 · 07/09/2023 18:33

Wouldn't bother me.

MariaVT65 · 07/09/2023 18:33

Clefable · 07/09/2023 18:23

While I agree generally about it being bad to use food as a bribe, I'd be lying if I didn't lure DD1 into doing something with mini marshmallows from time to time. Christ knows sometimes it's fine to be lazy. Sometimes I think we should be more lazy actually.

I agree with you. In my example that my friends have told me about, ‘helping the child through a tantrum’ isn’t practical in the middle of a car park and when you have somewhere to be. Sometimes you’ve got to what you’ve got to do. We all try our best and there are no ‘perfect parent’ medals.

Dramatic · 07/09/2023 18:29

MariaVT65 · 07/09/2023 18:18

Bollocks. I can assure you there are no problems with my friends’ children now, as a result of being bribed with a bit of chocolate to get in the car. No lasting effects. Stop hating on other mums.

I genuinely don't think we'd have ever been on time for anything if I hadn't bribed my toddler to get her shoes on and get in the car.

menopausalmare · 07/09/2023 18:27

I imagine it'll be a piece of bland traybake sponge (sorry if any nursery cooks are reading). I wouldn't worry too much.

Sunrise33 · 07/09/2023 18:26

I am quite relaxed about cakes and sweets but I find the culture around this strange sometimes. It’s also not impossible to keep a child away from certain foods and it’s okay to be different.

Stopthatknocking · 07/09/2023 18:25

OP, I've not rtft, because much of it seems to be a debate about your choice of diet.
However, at the nursery I work, this request would easily be honoured.

But I suggest you ask first what they are actually getting.

We provide 'chocolate cake' but it is actually vegan beetroot cake with little sugar.

Those children who have fruit for pudding at lunch and tea, as well as with the other children at 2 snack times, get so much sugar from the fruit.
Some of these children over the years have had problems with thier teeth because they ate too much fruit.

Ask, and when you have the facts make your choice. The nursery should easily be able to accommodation this request

AnnaBegins · 07/09/2023 18:25

We asked our nursery to do exactly the same. When DD started at 12 months old, they'd only just started taking children under 2, so the menu was very much geared towards over 2s - chocolate cake or chocolate ice cream every day, and definitely not low sugar versions!
They were absolutely fine with the request and gave her fruit or yoghurt as available.
It's a perfectly reasonable request so that you can decide when you're happy to introduce each thing.

Clefable · 07/09/2023 18:23

While I agree generally about it being bad to use food as a bribe, I'd be lying if I didn't lure DD1 into doing something with mini marshmallows from time to time. Christ knows sometimes it's fine to be lazy. Sometimes I think we should be more lazy actually.

Soontobe60 · 07/09/2023 18:23

Amilp · 07/09/2023 17:39

@MariaVT65 no it doesn’t really matter. I just genuinely find it astonishing that my 11 month old baby has had chocolate cake twice this week when he could have had a piece of fruit.

The chocolate cake they serve at nursery / school is most likely as ‘healthy’ as a piece of fruit! It will likely have less sugar, and the chocolate elect will be cocoa powder.
My granddaughter loves nursery chocolate pud and custard - she wont eat my full fat chocolate brownies though!

Thementalloadisreal · 07/09/2023 18:22

Meh, food is food, if you make something forbidden they’re more likely to go overboard on it one day. Personally they’re better off offering it all at once with lunch and not specifically as dessert.

Cake isn’t even that bad, compared to other sugary treats. Small children need lots of calories and with the eggs, butter and flour (and sugar!) it will be providing that. Yes it contains sugar but so does fruit , yoghurt, milk, etc. Do nurserys encourage teeth brushing after lunch? Ours used to.

I can’t see why you couldn’t ask them not to, or at least in the first instance enquire as to the ingredients? But when he gets older he might notice he’s missing something.

lilyblue5 · 07/09/2023 18:22

The cake will be tiny, low sugar, baby friendly. I’d let him have it

MariaVT65 · 07/09/2023 18:20

whatsappdoc · 07/09/2023 18:14

What's with the 'lazy' barb I keep seeing on here. This thread - 'lazy' parenting, 'lazy' nursery. So fucking what? Being lazy isn't a crime. If bribing children gets you through the day, crack on. If you think serving chocolate cake is lazy, vote with your feet. I think 'lazy' is another stick to beat women with. If a dad looks after his kids and actually manages to stick the washing machine on as well he gets a medal for multi-tasking.

End of off-topic rant.

THANK YOU

MariaVT65 · 07/09/2023 18:18

TheBarbieEffect · 07/09/2023 18:16

Of course I’m judgemental. There’s no need for bribery - it’s lazy and sends an awful message that the kids are in charge. They’re not.

Taking the “easy” way out now makes it harder later on. That’s why your friends end up dealing with this for months - because they’re not parenting effectively.

Some things aren’t a choice. They have to get in the car seat/pram etc. It’s also okay for children to tantrum, and it isn’t our job to fix it. It’s our job to help them through it.

I have a toddler and a baby. A toddler who has woken every two hours for over two years. I understand exhausted. I do not understand sending terrible messages and making life harder for yourself later.

Bollocks. I can assure you there are no problems with my friends’ children now, as a result of being bribed with a bit of chocolate to get in the car. No lasting effects. Stop hating on other mums.

FoodFann · 07/09/2023 18:17

They shouldn’t be offering cake and chocolate. I’m a teacher at a primary and I looked up the law on food standards when I was appalled at the quality of school dinners. I’m shocked that they’re getting away with cake and chocolate for toddlers! Disgraceful

TheBarbieEffect · 07/09/2023 18:16

MariaVT65 · 07/09/2023 17:58

Stop being so fucking judgemental.

I’ve had quite a few friends who told me they went through long periods of their toddlers refusing to get into car seats, screaming etc, so they had to resort to bribery. Sometimes as an exhausted parent you just have to get things done and it’s not forever.

Of course I’m judgemental. There’s no need for bribery - it’s lazy and sends an awful message that the kids are in charge. They’re not.

Taking the “easy” way out now makes it harder later on. That’s why your friends end up dealing with this for months - because they’re not parenting effectively.

Some things aren’t a choice. They have to get in the car seat/pram etc. It’s also okay for children to tantrum, and it isn’t our job to fix it. It’s our job to help them through it.

I have a toddler and a baby. A toddler who has woken every two hours for over two years. I understand exhausted. I do not understand sending terrible messages and making life harder for yourself later.

whatsappdoc · 07/09/2023 18:14

What's with the 'lazy' barb I keep seeing on here. This thread - 'lazy' parenting, 'lazy' nursery. So fucking what? Being lazy isn't a crime. If bribing children gets you through the day, crack on. If you think serving chocolate cake is lazy, vote with your feet. I think 'lazy' is another stick to beat women with. If a dad looks after his kids and actually manages to stick the washing machine on as well he gets a medal for multi-tasking.

End of off-topic rant.

Lavender14 · 07/09/2023 18:14

Yanbu I'd ask for further info on what they're given and I'd provide a yoghurt or fruit he lives to be given to him instead. No need for that every day and even if it's sugar free etc it's still building the expectation of a daily dessert which most people don't have.

jamorchocolatedoughnut · 07/09/2023 18:13

Not unusual request at all, in every nursery I worked at the under 2s only had fruit or yogurt. It was common for parents to ask this is be continued on after two. Just ask them todo it and it will be fine.

ColleenDonaghy · 07/09/2023 18:12

Twice a week doesn't seem so crazy when it's probably a tiny slice of a no sugar recipe. Ask them.

As others have said you won't succeed in avoiding chocolate until 3 or 4. Having them watch while other children get excited about a tasty treat that they can't have will only increase the forbidden fruit aspect.

MariaVT65 · 07/09/2023 18:11

dottiedodah · 07/09/2023 17:55

Hi there ,as an ex Nursery Nurse I would say this isnt usual.At the Nursery I worked at ,Bananas and Custard were usual desserts .Usually fruit or yoghurt. At Birthdays A plastic "Cake" which could be separated and rejoined with velcro was presented .Any parents bringing a real cake in would be asked if they wanted some to take home . Maybe have a word in their ear

Yes, from my friends whose kids attend other nurseries, bananas and custard is the example i’ve heard, not cake!

Nevermind31 · 07/09/2023 18:11

It will be “chocolate” cake. If you try some you’ll realise that nursery desserts have very little on common with proper ones. Very little sugar and other things that would make it indulgent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread