Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop feeding DD’s boyfriend

363 replies

tobatz0220 · 07/09/2023 11:13

I know I'm probably BU

DD and her bf are 18, and they were in an on and off ‘relationship’ since they were 12, but have been together without breaking up for 2 years. For many reasons, he lives with us. Not sure if they're relevant.

DD finished sixth form this year and she's due to start uni in a few weeks. Boyfriend however hasn't done anything since he finished sixth form. He didn't go most of his last year and as a result, failed his A levels. He told DD he wasn't enjoying what he chose and is due to go and do a course at college, I'm not sure if he will stick to it. DD’s room is a mess and I know it isn't DD as she's very tidy but she (rightly) refuses to tidy up after him. In his defence, he is helpful around the house.

My reason for posting is he doesn't eat meals, he constantly snacks. He eats chocolate, sweets, cakes, yoghurts, fruit, cereal etc. I buy the chocolate and sweets as a treat for my DCs and the other things for their lunchboxes, if he eats all of it he goes and buys his own. He used to be underweight and has gained weight but I don't think the constant snacking is good for him. He doesn't eat dinner even though he would previously eat it so I know he likes what I make. DD asked him why and he doesn't really give a reason, just that he isn't hungry.

A few cupcakes were left over from DD’s birthday and he ate all of them yesterday, which led to the DC’s being upset as there would've been enough for all of them to have one each.

WIBU to hide all of the snacks from him and not feed him?

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 08/09/2023 11:00

I think you meant well but this isn't going to end well for him or your daughter. Step up and put in some boundaries. Let him know where he stands now and give him some warning of what you expect of him when your daughter leaves to go to university.

CheshireCat1 · 08/09/2023 10:48

It sounds as though he is struggling, maybe depression.

Zimunya · 08/09/2023 10:47

@tobatz0220 - not sure why you've come in for such a load of criticism on this thread. I think what you are doing with your DD's BF - giving him a home and family support - is wonderful, and all credit to you for that.

As to the actual question - it's absolutely fine to keep school snacks separately and for everyone to be told that they are not available. Your house, your rules.

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/09/2023 10:44

@BetterWithPockets

how have you worked out that the two have a “really good relationship”?

can you really not see how it’s backed the daughter into a corner? How hard it would be for her to extricate herself from the relationship when he lives with her in her family home and knowing that would make him homeless.

she is 18 ffs, she deserves better from those around her

user1492757084 · 08/09/2023 10:39

Tell the boyfriend that you will provide breakfast and an evening meal if he is at home but that he has to buy and make his own lunch and snacks.

You are enabling him to stay a child.
Also ask him to pay rent and allocate him regular chores .. like cleaning one bathroom and vaccuming.

BetterWithPockets · 08/09/2023 10:38

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/09/2023 08:04

@BetterWithPockets

its not kind on her daughter though is it?

I don’t see why that’s the case. It sounds to me as though the OP’s daughter is very level-headed and the two have a very good relationship, so I’m assuming if the OP’s DD does ever want to split up with her boyfriend, she’ll be able to talk to her mum about it — as the OP has said.

porridgeisbae · 08/09/2023 10:36

It's not an ideal setup all round though OP.

TheGoddessFrigg · 08/09/2023 10:36

You are teaching your daughter to put her own needs second to that of a deadbeat male. If she doesn't end up with this one, there will be many more to take his place.
This reminds me so much of my parents, and it makes me sad that they, and you, could not tell your daughters that they are worth SO MUCH MORE.

porridgeisbae · 08/09/2023 10:34

There's a large locked box at my friend's where he can keep his snacks when I come over. Smile

I imagine he's a bit down about failing his A-levels.

LadyBird1973 · 08/09/2023 10:19

I can really relate to how this has happened. DS had a girlfriend who moved on when her stepdad threw her out. It was meant to be temporary until uni but then neither of them went. Covid happened and they were both here for a few years. The house wasn't really big enough for an extra person, the bedroom got messy due to lack of space and they started to behave as if they are equal paying tenants in a flat share. I think she and DS thought they did loads to be helpful but I was constantly coming home to mess. It came to a bit of a head and they have moved out now. But relations have been impacted - you start off doing a good thing to help and in the end it bites you in the arse!

He needs to move out now. You have been helpful and supportive but I truly don't think this is working out for you. And it does potentially trap your daughter. He's not respecting your home and because he isn't yours, you are in that awkward place of not knowing how (or if you should) parent him. He and dd are living in the no man's land between adult relationship and teenagers at home. She needs some space to grow.
I wish I'd done things differently.

Koalasparkles · 08/09/2023 10:00

Not unreasonable at all. He's now a "grown up", can get a job and buy his own food. I don't think it's unreasonable at all to tell him that the snacks are just for you, your partner and the kids. You can't plan meals etc if he's eating things. You've been v generous letting him live with you (whatever the reasons are), but he could go get a job and get his own place now. Whether he does or not, that's up to him. If he studies and cracks down, fine, but that should come with rules in my opinion. One of those should be to stop being a CF and eating everyone's snacks you already provide a meal, if he doesn't want to eat it then he's an idiot.

Smittenkitchen · 08/09/2023 09:59

I think the neighbour did him absolutely no favours by giving him odd jobs when he should have been at school. I understand why you felt in a difficult position and wanted him to take responsibility for his own attendance etc. but perhaps going to school could have been a condition to living at yours? Anyway that ship has sailed. I think you need to be a bit stricter with him, he's living in your house and eating your food. It's good you're going to have a word with him. He sounds like he needs some clear boundaries. Agree with PP that he sounds depressed.

weirdoboelady · 08/09/2023 09:58

I think your relationship with him is a strange one. You took him in when he was still a child (under 18) and he is even now only just 18. Obviously out of the goodness of your heart - I do have concerns about your daughter living with him at such a young age but you don't want to discuss that, so I won't. I'm just going to give you a different way of looking at this.

I'm going to forget all the 'relationship with your daughter' stuff and just focus on everyone's health. Here you have a young person who you are enabling to live on junk food only and reject real food. If it was your daughter, would you be continuing to buy snacks and not feed her real meals? I suspect the answer to this is no, so why are you enabling this young man, that you obviously care about, to do this?

(Also, in a sub thread going on in my mind, I will put small amounts of money on the hypothesis that he is leaving snack wrappers all around the bedroom and that you will eventually get a mouse infestation.)

I think I would be having a conversation with BOTH of them about this, saying how concerned you are, how you realise that you are enabling a dangerously unhealthly lifestyle, and this is going to change. I'm sure all the other MN will jump down my throat, but yes I would be hiding ALL snacks and only issuing them or access to them if proper meals have been eaten. Hopefully eating some proper food will at least lift his mood a bit and start to set him on the right road. Also talk about the mouse thing - no more eating in bedrooms. This is horribly restrictive, I know, but you will need to be rather heavy handed to change things, and it does sound as if you want to make some changes. (I think you need to, but there's no reason you should care about my view. Your OP sounds as if you want to.)

You sound like a lovely caring person - can you be an effective caring person by doing this?

Eskimal · 08/09/2023 09:53

CindersMum · 08/09/2023 09:31

His family is dysfunctional?? How can you possibly comment on that?? It could easily be that the lad comes from a household where boundaries are enforced and he sees the gf's mother's boundaries as a softer option.

I am sorry you are unable to understand the meaning of the words “I suspect”. It does mean your comment above is pointless.

Riverlee · 08/09/2023 09:48

horseyhorsey17 · 08/09/2023 09:41

It's shocking that his parents have abandoned him - without any money - and good for you for stepping up. It's no wonder he's depressed and failed his A-levels and is experiencing disordered eating. He needs proper professional help for this, to see a doctor and a mental health councillor. He's also most likely entitled to benefits to support him living alone/pay you some rent so you should speak to Citizen's Advice about this.

It's great he's got you to help him but - and I say this with kindness and no judgment - he isn't your priority, your daughter is. Him living with her and putting all his emotional problems on her is going to make her life a lot harder than it needs to be. Yes it's fine for her to support him, but actually living together means that's going to be insanely intense for her. That just isn't fair on her. She might not see that if she's in love, but she will realise it when she gets a bit older. It's your job to support HER now.

Good summary of the situation.

horseyhorsey17 · 08/09/2023 09:41

tobatz0220 · 07/09/2023 19:24

He wasn't living here from 16, it's been 8 months. He was 17 and DD was 18.

His parents aren't paying for him, I don't think he's had contact with his mum for a while and he doesn't talk to his dad as he moved abroad and he's still annoyed about it.

@Aserena the issue isn't me not cooking big enough meals, he doesn't eat them anyway.

It's shocking that his parents have abandoned him - without any money - and good for you for stepping up. It's no wonder he's depressed and failed his A-levels and is experiencing disordered eating. He needs proper professional help for this, to see a doctor and a mental health councillor. He's also most likely entitled to benefits to support him living alone/pay you some rent so you should speak to Citizen's Advice about this.

It's great he's got you to help him but - and I say this with kindness and no judgment - he isn't your priority, your daughter is. Him living with her and putting all his emotional problems on her is going to make her life a lot harder than it needs to be. Yes it's fine for her to support him, but actually living together means that's going to be insanely intense for her. That just isn't fair on her. She might not see that if she's in love, but she will realise it when she gets a bit older. It's your job to support HER now.

StillWantingADog · 08/09/2023 09:39

you're very kind to have taken him in.
I think you need to speak to him about not eating the family snacks, but in a similar way to if your DH or DD were eating them. Nobody in the house has the right to eat more than their fair share of snacks, its irrelevant if they are part of the family or not.
Make it clear that you're more than willing to feed him meals (assuming you are).
Sounds like the poor lad has issues, if he can admit he has some kind off sugar addiction I'd encourage a GP trip but easier said than done.

I'd let your daughter handle the mess in the room issue, as long as it doesn't spread outside their room.

tobatz0220 · 08/09/2023 09:35

This will be my last post on this thread, thanks everyone who actually answered my question and I will talk to him and only have the snacks out that aren't for lunchboxes.

Not sure why people are making assumptions, I do have saving, a mortgage and I don't have a low paying job. And no, I don't just want a man around the house. I have a DP that doesn't live with us but if that was the reason, he would be living with us.

I'm not sure how it's “creepy” that I want to help him.

OP posts:
fearfuloffluff · 08/09/2023 09:34

Firstly - none of you need a constant flow of sweet processed snacks, stop buying them. They increase your risk of all sorts of diseases, whether you're a healthy weight or not. Have fruit, nuts, other healthy stuff instead and keep the processed crap for high days and holidays, if you must.

Secondly - the proportion of school sweetheart couples that get through uni together is tiny. I'd imagine the proportion where one is a student and the other is doing nothing with their lives is even smaller. Right now they're on a fairly equal footing but uni will change your daughter and he'll still be in the same place, but feeling worse because of how your daughter is changing.

Your daughter will want to break up with him (which is very hard) but will have the extra difficulty of him potentially being homeless if she does. That's very bad.

You've basically taken on responsibility for him by letting him move in, if I were you I would concentrate on doing all you can to get him to a point where when/if they break up, he's in the best possible place for it as that will hit him hard if it also means moving out and living on benefits somewhere.

Now is the time to get any help you can to get him on a track to sort his life out, improve his confidence, have a sense of what he can do in his future. It's probably also his best chance of staying in a relationship with your daughter and not dragging her down, tbh.

I'd be having conversations (whether all together or separately) about what would happen if they broke up and how that would impact the domestic situation.

CindersMum · 08/09/2023 09:31

Eskimal · 08/09/2023 09:15

There’s a lot more going on here that just a question about hiding snacks.
He sounds very much like my husband who has severe ADHD. My husband can wash up but he can’t work out a system for his own belongings. He eats things without thinking about the consequences. He can’t hold down a job or finish school course etc. A lot of ADHDers do fine at school until they get to the part with less teacher discipline and more reliance of self-motivation (6th form, uni, college).
ADHDers really struggle with mid and long term vision. If a consequence is not right under their nose in the very immediate future they struggle to assess the impact of their actions.
You need to set some boundaries in your home. I suspect he lives with you because his own parents are struggling with undiagnosed ADHD and they run a dysfunctional household.

His family is dysfunctional?? How can you possibly comment on that?? It could easily be that the lad comes from a household where boundaries are enforced and he sees the gf's mother's boundaries as a softer option.

Switcher · 08/09/2023 09:17

I feel quite sorry for him. I'd be a bit worried , I think you are too. The snacks aren't really the issue, it seems more like he is struggling in general and comfort eating sweet treats in an unhealthy way (don't have to be overweight to be unhealthy). I don't think I'd mention the food, I'd just talk to him about whether he's ok.

Eskimal · 08/09/2023 09:15

There’s a lot more going on here that just a question about hiding snacks.
He sounds very much like my husband who has severe ADHD. My husband can wash up but he can’t work out a system for his own belongings. He eats things without thinking about the consequences. He can’t hold down a job or finish school course etc. A lot of ADHDers do fine at school until they get to the part with less teacher discipline and more reliance of self-motivation (6th form, uni, college).
ADHDers really struggle with mid and long term vision. If a consequence is not right under their nose in the very immediate future they struggle to assess the impact of their actions.
You need to set some boundaries in your home. I suspect he lives with you because his own parents are struggling with undiagnosed ADHD and they run a dysfunctional household.

Nanny0gg · 08/09/2023 09:07

tobatz0220 · 07/09/2023 19:24

He wasn't living here from 16, it's been 8 months. He was 17 and DD was 18.

His parents aren't paying for him, I don't think he's had contact with his mum for a while and he doesn't talk to his dad as he moved abroad and he's still annoyed about it.

@Aserena the issue isn't me not cooking big enough meals, he doesn't eat them anyway.

I assume his mother still claimed child benefit?

He needs a proper plan. He can't stay with you forever and if they do break up he's stuffed,

IncreasinglyGrumpy · 08/09/2023 09:04

Sounds like there were food issues in his childhood growing up - I'd have a sit down conversation and perhaps agree a purchase of his own supply but it has to last a week - that way he can learn food is available and it doesn't have to be grabbed all the time

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 08/09/2023 08:58

A lot of people have told you that you are not acting in the best interests of your daughter, OP. They’re right. I am mid-30s now but remember being an 18 year old with a boyfriend SO clearly. If my mother had facilitated him moving into my house I would have been so dragged down and missed out of some of the best years of my life, some of the most wonderful experiences which led to my ambitions and expectations of my life growing significantly. You’re clipping your daughters wings massively - she might not have the perspective to know it yet because she’s 18 (I know you said you asked her). This is shit parenting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread