Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School bans ALL physical contact

262 replies

DataColour · 07/09/2023 09:48

The parents haven't been informed by the school of this rule, but the kids have been told they will get a warning for the first transgression and then a detention is it happens again. No physical contact at all permitted. How are they going to enforce it and is this the case is any other school (from a quick Google I found that a school in Essex has done this) and AIBU to think it's ridiculous? I have 2 DCs in this school so it will affect them.

OP posts:
AmIAutumnalNow · 07/09/2023 11:11

sezzer87 · 07/09/2023 10:46

Secondary schools are like prisons these days.
My daughters school has removed toilet entrance doors, made them gender neutral. Painted the colourful walls grey, added extra high fencing with extra gates everywhere. Cctv in the bathrooms too. There's also a one way system and they've taken 15 minutes off lunchtime and removed one of the canteens so now when my daughter wants to eat lunch from school she has to run to the canteen and fight for the last bits of food. So much more I could add to this as well.

Do you ever wonder why.

Have you ever worked in a secondary school?

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 07/09/2023 11:10

So many people seem to miss the point when on about work by mentioned "inappropriate" and "unwanted" and "consensual"

Of course unwanted contact is banned.

But consensual hugs and touches are allowed

Here they've banned it all.

That's extreme and too far the other way. It teaches that any touch is some how evil and wicked. That physical contact is wrong no matter what

Children spend much more like half their time at school. Building healthy relationships is important and consensual touch is part of that.

Covid showed us that without human touch things were horrible and depressing. I remember hugging one friend very quickly because we hadn't for ages and we needed it but the "rules" didn't allow it. It felt so good even for that brief second. Human contact is, for most people, incredibly important

ElEmEnOhPee · 07/09/2023 11:09

Thinking about a family member who lost their mum at 13 to cancer. How her frineds supported her in the 5 years her mum was battling it and when she died. How their friendship and hugs helped soothe her through the most difficult time in her life. Her home life was traumatic in other ways too, so no, she couldn't have got that same comfort at home. Her dad wasn't in the picture and she was being raised by a grandfather who was also grieving.

There are MANY similar things that teenagers will be going through and different circumstances why they might need to seek comfort from friends. It actually sickens me that people can be okay with depriving them of that.

Tandora · 07/09/2023 11:08

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:06

It is part of school culture, it is very very easy to regulate, no issues at all

I’m sure whipping children was easy to regulate; and very much a part of school culture at one time.

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I don't really understand why people think this is "the way the world is going" - this has been a bog standard school rule in many schools, forever. Nothing new about it

Tandora · 07/09/2023 11:07

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:00

no, you have a strong opinion that is "affected by or driving irrational and wildly uncontrolled emotion" the definition of hysterical

You honestly think that going 7 hours without physical contact is "degrading" "dehumanising" going to damage someone's physical and mental health?

That is hysterical

And the overwhelming majority of people on this thread thankfully agree with me.

CalistoNoSolo · 07/09/2023 11:07

VeridicalVagabond · 07/09/2023 10:31

If banning sexual assault was enough to stop it happening no one would ever get sexually assaulted as it is, in fact, illegal.

Stopping kids from high fiving or hugging their friends is not going to stop sexual assaults from happening.

If children can't touch each other, they can't physically/sexually assault each other. If there is inappropriate touching its much easier to penalise the perpetrator if there is a blanket ban on all touching. As UK schools seem to be hotbed of sexual and physical assault I would say a no touching rule seems to be a sensible starting point.

ZadocPDederick · 07/09/2023 11:07

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 10:51

It is not wrong. If you have any contact at all with children and cant see that this is a perfectly reasonable, and common school rule, then THAT is very worrying

It isn't a common school rule. The fact that you have encountered it doesn't make it common.

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:06

Dilapidateddilapidate · 07/09/2023 11:05

@BorrowedThyme it just seems so clunky as to be unworkable anyway. Kids bump into each other, pass things to each other touching hands, brush fluff or whatever off each other, nudge each other, pat each others shoulders to get attention in a noisy room, lean close to whisper etc, who has the time to police all that?!

The assaults that happen would still be against the rules if this particular rule didn’t exist- if there weren’t rules against it it wouldn’t be called assault- yet it still happens. A clunky, hard to police and implement ban on touching will not stop assault or physical bullying, or for that matter fighting, from happening.

It is part of school culture, it is very very easy to regulate, no issues at all

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 07/09/2023 11:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CharlotteBog · 07/09/2023 11:06

Viviennemary · 07/09/2023 11:03

No need for hugging or holding hands in school.

That's so sad to read.
Hugging and holding hands is such a normal thing for children/humans to do.

IsItThough · 07/09/2023 11:06

Viviennemary · 07/09/2023 11:03

No need for hugging or holding hands in school.

But neither is it inappropriate

Dilapidateddilapidate · 07/09/2023 11:05

@BorrowedThyme it just seems so clunky as to be unworkable anyway. Kids bump into each other, pass things to each other touching hands, brush fluff or whatever off each other, nudge each other, pat each others shoulders to get attention in a noisy room, lean close to whisper etc, who has the time to police all that?!

The assaults that happen would still be against the rules if this particular rule didn’t exist- if there weren’t rules against it it wouldn’t be called assault- yet it still happens. A clunky, hard to police and implement ban on touching will not stop assault or physical bullying, or for that matter fighting, from happening.

Tandora · 07/09/2023 11:05

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:00

no, you have a strong opinion that is "affected by or driving irrational and wildly uncontrolled emotion" the definition of hysterical

You honestly think that going 7 hours without physical contact is "degrading" "dehumanising" going to damage someone's physical and mental health?

That is hysterical

I think mandating humans, children no less at a critical stage in development . to spend half their waking hours for 36 weeks a year in an institution that bans all physical touch is dehumanising and harmful to physical and mental health, yes. That’s not hysterical. the central importance/ function/ value of physical touch is underscored by social and medical science.

IsItThough · 07/09/2023 11:05

@Chippy4me my comment above not in response to yours - different circumstances and clearly a process in place around supporting your young people's developing understanding.

ZadocPDederick · 07/09/2023 11:04

They can't help a friend who has fallen down? Or touch a person who is distressed? Giving a detention for congratulating a friend with a high five is just absurd.

If claims of "playfighting" are a problem, surely you just ban all playfighting?

Viviennemary · 07/09/2023 11:03

No need for hugging or holding hands in school.

DataColour · 07/09/2023 11:03

Interesting to see the variety of responses.

I'm going to email the head of year to ask for the actual policy and why it hasn't been circulated to the parents and what the actual punishments are and how they are going to police it.

My DD who's 13 is very playful, and probably plays tag at breaktime, does those weird hand games like high fiving, so according to the rules this might get her into trouble now? How depressing.
Might my DS who's 14 at the same school, not be allowed to give her a hug if she is upset (not that she would want him to at school!!), or a friend pick her up if she's hurt etc. Need to know how they are going to police this.

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 07/09/2023 11:03

Tandora · 07/09/2023 10:29

What absolute nonsense.
totally fine to hug a colleague. This is utterly disgraceful

totally fine to hug a colleague.

If they want to be hugged. Several threads on MN have had OPs asking how do they tell colleagues they don’t like/want to be touched or hugged by said colleagues. Plenty of people of various ages don’t like being touched without their consent and in many workplaces unwanted touching could mean a report to HR.

IsItThough · 07/09/2023 11:02

If educators or education managers, cannot discern and convey what is appropriate human contact, what consent means, and when it is required, they are not fit to be in post.

More lazy, weak, unthinking leadership.

Chippy4me · 07/09/2023 11:00

We have this rule in my school (SEND).

Most of them are very sensory and like to hug and touch people.

Unfortunately there has been some physical violence and SA and false claims of both.

So we took the no hands on approach.

At first we were quite strict on it (police and SS were involved so we had to be) and then once they understood the rules a bit better we would just focus on the couple that needed to not touch/be touched and over look certain things.

If someone gives someone a quick hug and a pat on the back, we’d look the other way.
But if someone gives someone a hug that we think is for inappropriate reasons we will just say “no hands on” and then they stop.

Even if we hadn’t had negative associations with it (like violence, bullying or SA) it is still a good idea and some people don’t like to be touched.

We find our guys often think that complete strangers want to hug and hold hands etc and so it’s good for teaching them to ask for consent and have boundaries too.

I do think most kids need to touch each other and it’s sad and unfair if it a proper ban but it’s most likely similar to my school where accusations have been made so have to be careful but they won’t be too hot on it.

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:00

Tandora · 07/09/2023 10:53

Oh Bingo; I’m a woman who has a strong opinion that challenges yours: must be hysteria, that old womb going haywire again.

no, you have a strong opinion that is "affected by or driving irrational and wildly uncontrolled emotion" the definition of hysterical

You honestly think that going 7 hours without physical contact is "degrading" "dehumanising" going to damage someone's physical and mental health?

That is hysterical

Tandora · 07/09/2023 10:59

GrinAndVomit · 07/09/2023 10:57

Sadly, I think this is the natural outcome of the society we have been creating.

😢😢😢

AnIndianWoman · 07/09/2023 10:59

Are the governors muslim or the area a muslim one? It happened in Birmingham once and it turned out to be a governors trying to stop girls being homeschooled / sent to private Islamic schools that weren’t great.

GrinAndVomit · 07/09/2023 10:57

Sadly, I think this is the natural outcome of the society we have been creating.

Swipe left for the next trending thread