Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School bans ALL physical contact

262 replies

DataColour · 07/09/2023 09:48

The parents haven't been informed by the school of this rule, but the kids have been told they will get a warning for the first transgression and then a detention is it happens again. No physical contact at all permitted. How are they going to enforce it and is this the case is any other school (from a quick Google I found that a school in Essex has done this) and AIBU to think it's ridiculous? I have 2 DCs in this school so it will affect them.

OP posts:
Appleontherocks · 07/09/2023 11:31

I leave any school that has this rule. It's inhumane. How it is carried out differs between schools but the rule is generally no touching at all.

I once suggested the staff spend half of an INSET day adhering to the rigid school rules of the academy. Within 20 mins, a staff member had left and the rest refused to follow any sanctions for their repeated transgressions. The Head said it's because their adults and children need to get used to such control because of their chaotic and poverty stricken backgrounds.

IsItThough · 07/09/2023 11:29

More blunt measures by stressed, under-resourced schools.

Young people will never learn what is appropriate if all contact is banned.

I'm seeing visions of 1950s proms with teachers with rulers measuring the distance between couples dancing.

Be great if children were given better tools when young around bodily autonomy and everyone was taught about consent.

This won't stop fighting or bullying or inappropriate sexual contact because that is already not allowed.

Foxesandsquirrels · 07/09/2023 11:28

@TotalOverhaul I think you have absolutely no clue about the severity of behaviour problems in schools at the moment if you think a little bit of tumbling around is nothing.
I'm sorry but this is a perfectly reasonable policy and most schools have it. The OP doesn't even have a copy of the policy and they're already moaning which says a lot about their attitude.

Cucucucu · 07/09/2023 11:25

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:23

OMG there are some people on this thread for whom the phrase "precious snowflake" doesn't even begin to cover it!

I have been a teacher for 35 years. Lots of things have changed in that time

One of the most striking is the total lack of resilience in some children.

If I had been told 35 years ago that in 2023 I would be speaking to parents online who actually thought their children could not cope with 7 hours without physical contact, and not only that, but thought their children were entitled not to have to!!

I would have said - well the world might go mad in the future, but surely not THAT mad,

I would be a lot more surprised that a supposedly teacher thinks it’s ok for kids not to have physical contact and doesn’t realise how detrimental to their mental and physical well-being that is ! Clearly you worry very little about your students

Goldbar · 07/09/2023 11:25

Surely part of growing up is to learn how to judge when physical contact is appropriate and welcome? IRL we sometimes have physical contact with our friends and the people we're around and we have to make judgements as to when it's welcome/consensual and when it's not. A blanket ban means that children are missing out on learning about these nuances in relationships.

Tandora · 07/09/2023 11:25

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:23

OMG there are some people on this thread for whom the phrase "precious snowflake" doesn't even begin to cover it!

I have been a teacher for 35 years. Lots of things have changed in that time

One of the most striking is the total lack of resilience in some children.

If I had been told 35 years ago that in 2023 I would be speaking to parents online who actually thought their children could not cope with 7 hours without physical contact, and not only that, but thought their children were entitled not to have to!!

I would have said - well the world might go mad in the future, but surely not THAT mad,

attitudes like like yours are part of the reason that rates of teen suicide and self harm have never been higher.
https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/may/22/evidence-of-uks-child-mental-health-crisis-is-stark-and-compelling

Evidence of UK’s child mental health crisis is stark and compelling | Mental health | The Guardian

Analysis: addressing the sobering reality is a challenge for ministers, the NHS and society as a whole

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/may/22/evidence-of-uks-child-mental-health-crisis-is-stark-and-compelling

Cucucucu · 07/09/2023 11:24

Try and join with a few of the other parents and start a formal complaint , go above the head if needed . This is not just ridiculous, it’s actually extremely detrimental to them

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:23

OMG there are some people on this thread for whom the phrase "precious snowflake" doesn't even begin to cover it!

I have been a teacher for 35 years. Lots of things have changed in that time

One of the most striking is the total lack of resilience in some children.

If I had been told 35 years ago that in 2023 I would be speaking to parents online who actually thought their children could not cope with 7 hours without physical contact, and not only that, but thought their children were entitled not to have to!!

I would have said - well the world might go mad in the future, but surely not THAT mad,

Mistressanne · 07/09/2023 11:23

It’s lazy on the schools part.
Rather than work on appropriate boundaries and put effort into shaping rounded dc during difficult formative years they’ve chosen a blanket rule as a cop out.

Tandora · 07/09/2023 11:23

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:20

and what has that got to do with anything?

Part of your tactic in trying to justify/
normalise this completely bizarre, disproportionate and draconian measure, is your insistence that this is a perfectly ordinary school rule, just part of the culture, the way things are in the majority of schools, has been for time; nothing to see here…

CalistoNoSolo · 07/09/2023 11:22

Shouldbesolucky · 07/09/2023 11:12

Seriously? I genuinely feel sorry for you, that you have such an aggressive and hateful view of boys and men. Yes they’re undoubtedly many men out there that are cruel and vicious. But to feel such hatred for the entire male population is not healthy. I’m assuming you don’t have male a child?
Throughout my life I have experienced equally negative, cruel and violent behaviour by both males and females.
We need to focus on instilling respectful behaviour on all children not instilling hate and creating barriers against an entire sex- no good will come of that.

Jesus, you really need to reread what I wrote. I don't hate all men, or even most men but I do hate men that hate women, of which there are many. And if the ones that are a threat to women were all.locked up I wouldn't shed a single tear. If your son doesn't know how to behave appropriately around girls and women then I suggest you do something about it rather than using all your emotional energy up feeling sorry for some random on the internet. 🙄

Itwillonlygetworse · 07/09/2023 11:21

I remember a happy childhood of hugging, holding hands, play fighting etc. Schools are slowly trying to dehumanise children. My DD has school anxiety and her best friend holds her hand sometimes, last term the teacher told them not to hold hands but it was the same teacher who hits her hand on the table when she gets frustrated and tells the children to shut up. Schools are becoming institutional. I am going to homeschool soon and seeing these threads makes me realise I am doing the right thing. Children are not robots and nor should they be treated as such. Schools can’t even deal with bullying effectively so how they’re going to police the no contact ban is baffling.

BungleandGeorge · 07/09/2023 11:20

I’ve never heard of this before so I don’t think it is ‘common’. The reason they haven’t told parents is clearly that it’s absolutely ridiculous, detrimental to the children and they’re going to get kick back from parents. I’ve had numerous hugs of colleagues, all when something awful has happened and it’s been appreciated. There’s a very important message around consensual touching and you actually can’t teach and model that without allowing any contact.

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:20

Tandora · 07/09/2023 11:08

I’m sure whipping children was easy to regulate; and very much a part of school culture at one time.

and what has that got to do with anything?

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 07/09/2023 11:20

Shouldbesolucky · 07/09/2023 11:12

Seriously? I genuinely feel sorry for you, that you have such an aggressive and hateful view of boys and men. Yes they’re undoubtedly many men out there that are cruel and vicious. But to feel such hatred for the entire male population is not healthy. I’m assuming you don’t have male a child?
Throughout my life I have experienced equally negative, cruel and violent behaviour by both males and females.
We need to focus on instilling respectful behaviour on all children not instilling hate and creating barriers against an entire sex- no good will come of that.

Spot on.

ZadocPDederick · 07/09/2023 11:19

The most important thing your kiddos school should be doing instead, is focussing on teaching the kids about forming their own personal boundaries.

Well, yes. Imposing a blanket no touching rule clearly doesn't teach them that, though, does it? It just teaches them to conform to a wholly arbitrary boundary imposed by a third party.

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 07/09/2023 11:17

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:08

I don't really understand why people think this is "the way the world is going" - this has been a bog standard school rule in many schools, forever. Nothing new about it

That simply isn't true. You sound depressingly batshit.

Verbena17 · 07/09/2023 11:15

DataColour · 07/09/2023 10:00

But they are kids! Not working adults, they have different mental needs.

And actually, I can hug a colleague and receive no sanctions.

The workplace is totally different. Adults work in the workplace - their brains are pretty much fully developed, unlike those of secondary school age children. Contact in lots of forms is vital for forming bonds and learning.

The most important thing your kiddos school should be doing instead, is focussing on teaching the kids about forming their own personal boundaries.
Thats a skill/personality trait skill that often is lacking in older teens/young adults and which often will carry on into older adulthood - leaving those people vulnerable in all sorts of ways.

For my own child, forming their own boundaries is becoming really important now at age 21, and they have realised this being at uni in clubs and bars where they get a lot of very unwanted attention.
That doesn’t mean they don’t love hugs or whatever from those people they are close too!

Your child’s school clearly has their ‘woke’ goggles on and they need to get back to basics and stop being so clinical and stupidly strict.

AmIAutumnalNow · 07/09/2023 11:14

Parents:

Schools should do something. My child was hurt/bullied/assaulted/jostled/is scared at lunchtimes/etc

Schools: do something

Parents: but not that

😏

borntobequiet · 07/09/2023 11:14

This was standard in the (ordinary and typical) school I taught in until the early 2000s.

edwinbear · 07/09/2023 11:14

I'd be so incredibly sad if this was introduced in DC's school. Neither DD or DS touch other people inappropriately, but it's completely normal for the school nurse to comfort an upset child, or the PE staff to fist bump a child who has just won a race/scored a goal/try and for the kids to give a congratulatory back slap/group team hug, when someone has just equalised for the team. Or even if they've lost a game but played well.

Cloudsandyoghurts · 07/09/2023 11:12

I assume it makes it much easier to stop/punish genuinely problematic behaviour (which was rife in my secondary school days, boys grabbing girls whenever they felt like it) but they wouldnt actually punish a child comforting another child eg best friend's arm round shoulder of crying child, because teachers are also humans. In which case, fine.

ZadocPDederick · 07/09/2023 11:12

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:08

I don't really understand why people think this is "the way the world is going" - this has been a bog standard school rule in many schools, forever. Nothing new about it

It really hasn't. Fortunately most schools have more sense.

Shouldbesolucky · 07/09/2023 11:12

CalistoNoSolo · 07/09/2023 10:52

If they can't keep their hands, dicks and toxic thoughts to themselves, then yes, life would be much better for all women and girls if men and boys were under permanent permanent permanent house arrest.

Seriously? I genuinely feel sorry for you, that you have such an aggressive and hateful view of boys and men. Yes they’re undoubtedly many men out there that are cruel and vicious. But to feel such hatred for the entire male population is not healthy. I’m assuming you don’t have male a child?
Throughout my life I have experienced equally negative, cruel and violent behaviour by both males and females.
We need to focus on instilling respectful behaviour on all children not instilling hate and creating barriers against an entire sex- no good will come of that.

ZadocPDederick · 07/09/2023 11:11

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 10:44

If you are not going to support school rules, please withdraw your children and find another place for them! Honestly - if you repeatedly support them in breaking the rules then either they will have to leave anyway,( and it will be on their CV for life) or they will decide the school is being more reasonable than you are and you will permanently rupture your relationship with them. When parents continue to undermine the school, one or the other is the most likely result

I wonder why teachers believe exclusions are on people's CVs for life? I've never seen one that detailed anything about a person's school life other than the qualifications they gained. Employers really have zero interest in how someone behaved at the age of 13.