Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School bans ALL physical contact

262 replies

DataColour · 07/09/2023 09:48

The parents haven't been informed by the school of this rule, but the kids have been told they will get a warning for the first transgression and then a detention is it happens again. No physical contact at all permitted. How are they going to enforce it and is this the case is any other school (from a quick Google I found that a school in Essex has done this) and AIBU to think it's ridiculous? I have 2 DCs in this school so it will affect them.

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 07/09/2023 12:15

If schools weren't spending so much energy and time enforcing ridiculously stringent and unnecessary uniform regulations (see other thread) , perhaps they would have the time and energy to ensure proper safeguarding and create a culture where consent is understood and young people learn appropriate boundaries and behaviours.

If you've ever read The Peter Principle, you'd know that when you can't do what you are supposed to do for whatever reason (but usually incompetence) then a good way to divert attention is to find something else that you can do, and make that your rasion d'etre. So pratting around with shoe colours and skirt lengths is a great way to avoid talking about grades, results and prospects.

WeirdBarbie · 07/09/2023 12:13

I mean, this thread literally has teachers explaining the rule and parents losing their shit. Mad! 🤣🤣

Chippy4me · 07/09/2023 12:13

What about brushing by another pupil in a crowded corridor?

It depends.

Brushing past someone because the corridors are busy - absolutely fine.

But ‘brushing’ past someone who happens to be a scared little year 7 and no one else or a group of friends ‘brushing’ past 1 individual and no one else - not fine.
Lots of bullies use the corridors to intimidate people.

It is easier and safer for the pupils to have a blanket rule of no physical contact and then overlook certain things.
Than have certain physical contact ok and others not.

I lost count of how many times boys would grab my boobs when I was young and I know this is still a regular thing that often goes unreported.

When I reported it they always replied with something like they went to touch my arm or shoulder.
They cannot get into trouble for going to touch your shoulder or arm and so they’d get away with it, which they knew and is why they did it.

If this rule was put in place then they would have gotten in to trouble for touching me because once is an accident but twice is intentional.

Most SA isn’t someone just walking over to you and putting their hand up your skirt.
Its often done over a period of time of regular touching that isn’t inappropriate, so when it does become inappropriate they can say it was an accident or they were led on.

Having a no touch rule isn’t going to instantly stop all bullying and SA but it can help to reduce it, which surely can only be a positive thing.

WeirdBarbie · 07/09/2023 12:13

IsItThough · 07/09/2023 12:10

If schools weren't spending so much energy and time enforcing ridiculously stringent and unneccessary uniform regulations (see other thread) , perhaps they would have the time and energy to ensure proper safeguarding and create a culture where consent is understood and young people learn appropriate boundaries and behaviours.

Or, perhaps, if PARENTS instilled an understanding of consent and appropriate boundaries, rather than relying on schools to do that, a stupid blanket no-contact “rule” wouldn’t have to be enforced.

I cannot see the big problem with this rule. Lots of hysteria about high fiving without knowing the actual wording of this rule, and an insistence that hugging is ESSENTIAL (it isn’t).

IsItThough · 07/09/2023 12:10

If schools weren't spending so much energy and time enforcing ridiculously stringent and unneccessary uniform regulations (see other thread) , perhaps they would have the time and energy to ensure proper safeguarding and create a culture where consent is understood and young people learn appropriate boundaries and behaviours.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 07/09/2023 12:00

DataColour · 07/09/2023 10:00

But they are kids! Not working adults, they have different mental needs.

And actually, I can hug a colleague and receive no sanctions.

My dd hates hugs but she tolerates them as this seems to be the norm amongst teenage girls. She would love this rule. Not all kids want to be all over each other all of the time and the wants of those who like physical contact don’t trump those who don’t.

And I would never feel the need to hug a colleague. Perhaps dd gets it from me.

SerendipityJane · 07/09/2023 12:00

The problem with fruitcake rules like this is they inevitably have to lead to a situation where there are "some exemptions", which are dealt with on a "case by case basis".

And before you know it, regardless of intentions, you will pretty quickly be able to work out whose exempted and who is not. And the prejudices and biases that will stir up.

Arbitrary laws are one hallmark of a fucked country and should be discouraged wherever possible.

Dilapidateddilapidate · 07/09/2023 11:58

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:06

It is part of school culture, it is very very easy to regulate, no issues at all

If you actually think that the kids in your school aren’t doing all this stuff you are very naive.

And I’ve yet to know a school without bullying and ‘inappropriate touching’, both consenting and not, no matter what rules the teachers think they are instilling! You can’t actually have that number of humans in one place without it happening.

tobee · 07/09/2023 11:55

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:23

OMG there are some people on this thread for whom the phrase "precious snowflake" doesn't even begin to cover it!

I have been a teacher for 35 years. Lots of things have changed in that time

One of the most striking is the total lack of resilience in some children.

If I had been told 35 years ago that in 2023 I would be speaking to parents online who actually thought their children could not cope with 7 hours without physical contact, and not only that, but thought their children were entitled not to have to!!

I would have said - well the world might go mad in the future, but surely not THAT mad,

But that presupposes that "precious snowflake" children have only been holding hands, hugging etc recently.

This is just another example of heads and teachers thinking that schools are only about getting through the curriculum and passing exams sausage machines.

Appleontherocks · 07/09/2023 11:53

"What about brushing by another pupil in a crowded corridor?"

It all depends who sees it
I've seen an autistic boy be repeatedly sanctioned for something like this because the teachers refused to believe he could "be that clumsy" and they said he does it when he's in a bad mood. What they meant is that when he has been highly stressed in a classroom, he finds it harder to focus on his motor skills and spatial awareness once he leaves. He ended up in a PRU

gogomoto · 07/09/2023 11:45

How are they going to play rugby then??? Seems extreme but I'm guessing they have had issues

Thosesummernights · 07/09/2023 11:43

Does this include sport, a lot of which is contact at secondary school? What about brushing by another pupil in a crowded corridor?

I guess the reason they have put this rule in place is to give the school some weight when bullying is taking place. All other examples of touching I’m sure wouldn’t need to be dealt with and so it’s not about friends not being able to be affectionate, but more a case of being able to come down harder on bullies who use physical contact as a form of aggression.

Appleontherocks · 07/09/2023 11:41

When this came out earlier this year, I was surprised that only two schools were cited as having this rule. It's been a thing in at least 5 schools I've worked with or in.

One of the schools I worked in had it in their behaviour policy until they were very recently given an OFSTED for the first time in 12 years. They went from Outstanding to Good. However, they still sanction children for consensual physical contact. Particularly kids where they want to increase their "sanction points" to justify exclusion.

They know that a child who already has social, learning and/or behavioural issues is likely to vigorously defend themselves from such an unfair move by someone in authority. It turns from a minor wanring to exclusion very quickly.

Chippy4me · 07/09/2023 11:38

It’s lazy on the schools part.
Rather than work on appropriate boundaries and put effort into shaping rounded dc during difficult formative years they’ve chosen a blanket rule as a cop out.

Is stroking arms and legs ok?

I remember doing this regularly as a child with my friends but some may feel it’s inappropriate now.

As a parent I would not be happy with some random 16/17 year old boys regularly hugging or touching my 11 year old DD.

Just because the actual act isn’t inappropriate, doesn’t mean it doesn’t always have inappropriate meaning behind it.

If you’re on duty with 100 students and you see a couple of groups of students hugging and touching and then one claims to be touched inappropriately, you cannot guarantee that they weren’t.

There has obviously been an accusation which is why there has been a blanket ban.

If you see a student looking uncomfortable because their friend keeps touching them you just remind them that there is no touching.

If it’s harmless touching or hugging then you wouldn’t say anything.

It’s not lazy, it’s about safeguarding children which is way more important.

Tandora · 07/09/2023 11:38

Cucucucu · 07/09/2023 11:35

I grew up in continental Europe and as teens we hold hands , kissed , jumped on each others backs , sat on each others laps , danced , etc etc etc , all that is normal in my view . Non consensual touching is never ok , no matter who from . Banning all contact will not help anyone learn what is right or wrong ! The world has gone bonkers . Kids in the U.K. are already so restricted with out of date uniforms rules , not being able to express themselves with a different hair colour or nail vanish etc . No wonder there is so much bullying and mental health issues . Let kids be kids , let them be heard , you will probably get much better behaviour from teens who have a voice than the ones you are constantly trying to dominate and control !

❤️

BungleandGeorge · 07/09/2023 11:37

I’m pretty sure that students who want to physically or sexually abuse others are not going to do it whilst school staff are looking on. They’re very sneaky so what is this actually going to achieve anyway?

WhatWhereWho · 07/09/2023 11:36

So if parents have not been officially informed by the school how do you know that it's true?

Esgaroth · 07/09/2023 11:36

Sadly it doesn't seem that surprising after the attitudes expressed during the pandemic that totally dismissed the importance of social and physical contact as if these things were just frivolous hobbies rather than central to our wellbeing.

Cucucucu · 07/09/2023 11:35

I grew up in continental Europe and as teens we hold hands , kissed , jumped on each others backs , sat on each others laps , danced , etc etc etc , all that is normal in my view . Non consensual touching is never ok , no matter who from . Banning all contact will not help anyone learn what is right or wrong ! The world has gone bonkers . Kids in the U.K. are already so restricted with out of date uniforms rules , not being able to express themselves with a different hair colour or nail vanish etc . No wonder there is so much bullying and mental health issues . Let kids be kids , let them be heard , you will probably get much better behaviour from teens who have a voice than the ones you are constantly trying to dominate and control !

Goldbar · 07/09/2023 11:34

There does seem to be drive in some secondary schools in this country to achieve order and conformity at all costs...in particular, at the cost of ending up with a punitive, sterile, emotionally vacuous, depersonalised, infantilising school environment, where children are punished harshly for minor infractions such as forgetting a pen or taking off a jumper without permission.

I find it odd because primary schools on the whole do such a fantastic job of nurturing children and gently encouraging them to take on more responsibility and meet their own needs. And then they get to 11 and suddenly they don't need care and nurturing any more, apparently.

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 07/09/2023 11:34

@BorrowedThyme , you sound like you're more suited to being a prison warden than a school teacher.

BungleandGeorge · 07/09/2023 11:34

There are some teachers who just don’t have the skills and understanding to work with young people. Thankfully I think it’s much less than when I was at school. I look back and realise that some were bullies, openly racist, had a violent temper etc. I think that’s why it’s important that school rules like this are not just made up by a very small team of SLT. Nobody else gets away with not involving all stakeholders which in this case would be students, parents, mental health services, pastoral services, SEN services..

RicherThanYews · 07/09/2023 11:33

Wow, I'm trying to fathom how 11-16 year old me and cohorts would have coped with this rule as we walked everywhere with arms linked.

Esgaroth · 07/09/2023 11:32

I'd be horrified at this. Friendly, consensual physical contact is natural human behaviour and hugely important for mental health and resilience especially when you're going through something difficult or stressful.

We're humans, not machines. It's actually horrible to try and stamp natural and healthy behaviour out of children.

Zebedee999 · 07/09/2023 11:31

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 09:58

It been the same in many schools I have taught in, including the one I teach in now - so much better and safer for everyone - no playfighting, etc, no excuse of "we were only playfighting" when someone is hurt - and its the same in most workplaces, isn't it, so good preparation

Yes I agree it's a good thing. The only physical contact I got at school was the thumps from bullies so a good thing in my view. Also good life lesson that disputes and arguments need to be resolved without resorting to pushing/shoving etc. Hopefully the end of school physical bullying.

Swipe left for the next trending thread