Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School bans ALL physical contact

262 replies

DataColour · 07/09/2023 09:48

The parents haven't been informed by the school of this rule, but the kids have been told they will get a warning for the first transgression and then a detention is it happens again. No physical contact at all permitted. How are they going to enforce it and is this the case is any other school (from a quick Google I found that a school in Essex has done this) and AIBU to think it's ridiculous? I have 2 DCs in this school so it will affect them.

OP posts:
Mumof2teens79 · 07/09/2023 13:46

How are they supposed to learn what's appropriate and what's not if all contact is banned?

Although it is a minefield. I put my arm round the shoulder of colleague who was upset and immediately worried it was unwelcome.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 07/09/2023 13:41

Cucucucu · 07/09/2023 11:35

I grew up in continental Europe and as teens we hold hands , kissed , jumped on each others backs , sat on each others laps , danced , etc etc etc , all that is normal in my view . Non consensual touching is never ok , no matter who from . Banning all contact will not help anyone learn what is right or wrong ! The world has gone bonkers . Kids in the U.K. are already so restricted with out of date uniforms rules , not being able to express themselves with a different hair colour or nail vanish etc . No wonder there is so much bullying and mental health issues . Let kids be kids , let them be heard , you will probably get much better behaviour from teens who have a voice than the ones you are constantly trying to dominate and control !

Agree totally with this.

Goldbar · 07/09/2023 13:29

I find the "snowflakes" and "no resilience" comments on threads about punitive and harsh policies in schools baffling. The general undertone is that "If kids don't suffer this or endure that, they'll have no resilience and won't be able to cope with life".

I thought we'd long since moved away from the idea that traumatic, humiliating or difficult childhood experiences build resilience to an understanding that resilience in children is developed through positive, encouraging and supportive relationships with caregivers, mentors, authority figures and peers.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 07/09/2023 13:17

RoomOfRequirement · 07/09/2023 09:59

Assuming boys wouldn't stop touching girls inappropriately.

This.

I started off thinking 'how unreasonable', then remembered my actual time in secondary school, and honestly, a rule like this would have been very welcome.

IsItThough · 07/09/2023 13:15

WeirdBarbie · 07/09/2023 12:13

Or, perhaps, if PARENTS instilled an understanding of consent and appropriate boundaries, rather than relying on schools to do that, a stupid blanket no-contact “rule” wouldn’t have to be enforced.

I cannot see the big problem with this rule. Lots of hysteria about high fiving without knowing the actual wording of this rule, and an insistence that hugging is ESSENTIAL (it isn’t).

I totally agree that this is also parents responsibility. However, we all know many parents simply do not have the wherewithal, and others are a big part of the problem, never having learned it themselves.

Schools can and do successfully create a culture of respect without blanket bans.

Appleontherocks · 07/09/2023 13:14

"I have been a teacher for 35 years."

That's usually a good reason to quit

Yalta · 07/09/2023 13:03

Must be a huge school with very few pupils. Imagine queuing up to go into a class, are they supposed to stand metres apart just in case

How does that even work.

Even in schools with wide corridors and a one way system there isn’t enough room for everyone to walk at once without bumping into someone else trying to get to the next class

Someone about to fall down the stairs

Let them fall as that would involve touching them.

I think you just leave the school then, if you are not going to support the school rules

Where do you draw the line. Sometimes when a rule that has holes in it is brought in it is only right that some critical thinking is done.

Those who are going to break this rule are going to still break it. It won’t make anyone safer. It just means as the victim, you get punished as well

greyflannel · 07/09/2023 13:01

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 11:23

OMG there are some people on this thread for whom the phrase "precious snowflake" doesn't even begin to cover it!

I have been a teacher for 35 years. Lots of things have changed in that time

One of the most striking is the total lack of resilience in some children.

If I had been told 35 years ago that in 2023 I would be speaking to parents online who actually thought their children could not cope with 7 hours without physical contact, and not only that, but thought their children were entitled not to have to!!

I would have said - well the world might go mad in the future, but surely not THAT mad,

And if someone had told me 35 years go that schools would be trying to ban physical contact between pupils, when at that point we encouraged children to dance together, play physical contact games together at break times to let off steam, comfort each other, make art and music together etc, I would have thought the world had gone mad.

As PPs have said, all reason seems to have left some schools who operate on the most petty and draconian lines, consigning large numbers of children to extended spells of incarceration in isolation for very minor infractions. Young people in the criminal justice system are afforded great rights and care for their welfare. And then we wonder why we have both an attendance crisis and a mental health crisis. There is an evidence base, including on what causes psychological harms, which some schools choose to ignore. I hope there are some class actions against academy chains. Might take this to shift the dial?

VeridicalVagabond · 07/09/2023 12:56

CalistoNoSolo · 07/09/2023 11:07

If children can't touch each other, they can't physically/sexually assault each other. If there is inappropriate touching its much easier to penalise the perpetrator if there is a blanket ban on all touching. As UK schools seem to be hotbed of sexual and physical assault I would say a no touching rule seems to be a sensible starting point.

Tell that to my friend whose daughter was sexually assaulted in a school with exactly this pointless rule. It's incredibly naïve to think if you just tell people to stop touching then sexual assaults will magically stop happening.

People who commit sexual assault don't give a shit about rules, or they wouldn't do it. Again, sexual assault is illegal. If that's not a deterrent then I don't see how "no touching or else!" will be.

Nanny0gg · 07/09/2023 12:55

theresnolimits · 07/09/2023 10:31

I worked in a boys’ school that had this rule25 years ago. It’s nothing new. It eliminated all those ‘friendly’ punches and pushes that were really micro aggressions that often flared into violence amongst teenage boys. It reduced bullying and made vulnerable boys feel much safer.

If I was the daughter of a teenage girl today I’d be delighted that young men were explicitly told touching them is unacceptable. Think that Spanish female footballer. Girls are too often embarrassed to call out boys who hug or grab then.

No one is saying that they are going to he deprived of human contact in the 50% of the day/night they’re not at school, at weekends or in holidays. It’s just about making the school environment a safer, more consensual environment. If you’d ever had to work with hundreds of hormonal teenagers crammed into small spaces, you might feel differently.

I'd like to see how that's going to work in my DGD's school where they've just converted all the loos to unisex so the staff have no idea what's going to be going on in them

And they were feral before. I'd hate to be a girl in school now

Zodfa · 07/09/2023 12:54

I received a huge amount of unwanted physical contact in lower secondary, much of it sexual. I still suffer from the psychological impact today. Obviously no contact at all is not ideal, but if it's the only practical way to keep people safe, I think it may be worth it.

user1492757084 · 07/09/2023 12:53

Were there some children being too demonstative in a romantic sense? There must have been a reason.
Maybe some kids were being touched and didn't at all like it.

Dilapidateddilapidate · 07/09/2023 12:47

SerendipityJane · 07/09/2023 12:00

The problem with fruitcake rules like this is they inevitably have to lead to a situation where there are "some exemptions", which are dealt with on a "case by case basis".

And before you know it, regardless of intentions, you will pretty quickly be able to work out whose exempted and who is not. And the prejudices and biases that will stir up.

Arbitrary laws are one hallmark of a fucked country and should be discouraged wherever possible.

Yep! You can not physically have over 1000 humans in a building for 6 odd hours, moving around and interacting and expect that none of them will in some way touch each other.

Throw in the teachers who will all have different levels of respect for, agreement with and just the will power and authority to impose the rules and you necessarily end up with a situation what X gets away with this because Y, you can do Xy in one class but not another, X did this yesterday and no one followed up but today they are etc etc.

Its the same with all school rules but a massive blanket rule like that is just going to be unworkable in any real way.

theresnolimits · 07/09/2023 12:46

As someone who has taught in a school with this rule, which made many vulnerable children feel far safer I think we should be mindful if the fact that sadly some physical interactions are not innocent nor beneficial. And when a bully constantly torments a child ( kicking, flicking, pushing, brushing up against them) and the child feels unable to defend themselves (‘it was just a laugh miss, he/she doesn’t mind’), it can be a minefield. Does one child’s right to hug trump another’s right to feel safe?

And just another point about those terrible prison Warder teachers - I have yet to meet a teacher who wants school uniform. I hate it. Every day would start with a negative interaction about shoes, skirt length etc. when all I wanted to do was teach. But every time we asked parents to go no uniform there was an outcry - uniform lets the school have the clothing battles, not the parents. Europe, USA, Canada - none of them have uniforms unless it’s a very specific type of school. It doesn’t improve results or act as a social leveller - it’s just a daily waste of time. But the governors/ parents set the uniform rules and we mugs on the front line get sanctioned if we don’t enforce.

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 07/09/2023 12:46

Hoogieflip · 07/09/2023 12:36

"More parents are happy with the no touching rule than unhappy with it". Will you provide a link to this evidence, please?

I strongly suspect we'll be waiting forever for that.

Hoogieflip · 07/09/2023 12:36

"More parents are happy with the no touching rule than unhappy with it". Will you provide a link to this evidence, please?

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 07/09/2023 12:35

This is utterly ridiculous.

Touch is big part of human nature. If they ban it then it will be seen as something dirty, something that needs to stay hidden and this will lead to problems with inappropriate touch and consent.

It's so sad.

Foxesandsquirrels · 07/09/2023 12:31

@TotalOverhaul what policy? The op hasn't even got a copy yet. This is all hearsay and assumptions.

CaptainMyCaptain · 07/09/2023 12:31

Sceptic1234 · 07/09/2023 12:26

I know a school that had a "two foot rule" in the late 60s .......needless to say it was "more honoured by the breach than the observance"

Ours was 3 foot 🤣. We were closer than 3 foot in lessons.

TotalOverhaul · 07/09/2023 12:28

@Foxesandsquirrels - I meant this policy is not an answer - not your answer is not an answer. I completely respect your different opinion.

TotalOverhaul · 07/09/2023 12:27

Foxesandsquirrels · 07/09/2023 11:28

@TotalOverhaul I think you have absolutely no clue about the severity of behaviour problems in schools at the moment if you think a little bit of tumbling around is nothing.
I'm sorry but this is a perfectly reasonable policy and most schools have it. The OP doesn't even have a copy of the policy and they're already moaning which says a lot about their attitude.

I'm fully aware of the problems in schools right now and this is not an answer.

Sceptic1234 · 07/09/2023 12:26

CaptainMyCaptain · 07/09/2023 12:19

Physical contact between boys and girls was banned in my grammar school in the late 60s/early 70s. It didn't work then and I doubt it would work now.

I know a school that had a "two foot rule" in the late 60s .......needless to say it was "more honoured by the breach than the observance"

ManateeFair · 07/09/2023 12:21

its the same in most workplaces, isn't it

Er... no?

I've worked in some very right-on organisations and I've honestly never worked anywhere that banned all physical contact between human beings.

I would be interested to see how the OP's kids' school is going to manage PE lessons. Don't they do any contact sports? You'd have a hard time playing football without touching anyone, for instance.

CaptainMyCaptain · 07/09/2023 12:19

Physical contact between boys and girls was banned in my grammar school in the late 60s/early 70s. It didn't work then and I doubt it would work now.

Chippy4me · 07/09/2023 12:16

I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve been on a night out and been touched by men.

Perhaps if these no touching rules were put in place in schools, then there would be a lot less of this and they would be taught how to act appropriately.

(obviously this should be a parents job but many parents are lazy and inadequate and don’t teach them these things, so school has to).

Swipe left for the next trending thread