Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School bans ALL physical contact

262 replies

DataColour · 07/09/2023 09:48

The parents haven't been informed by the school of this rule, but the kids have been told they will get a warning for the first transgression and then a detention is it happens again. No physical contact at all permitted. How are they going to enforce it and is this the case is any other school (from a quick Google I found that a school in Essex has done this) and AIBU to think it's ridiculous? I have 2 DCs in this school so it will affect them.

OP posts:
CharlotteBog · 07/09/2023 10:20

Daffodilwoman · 07/09/2023 10:14

I totally get the logic here. Staff are not there to sort out issues such as inappropriate behaviour, they are there to get the pupils through exams.
It will make sure that there is no inappropriate touching, no excuse can be made etc etc……,
I agree with the poster who said something has probably happened and they need to ensure it does not happen again:

That's such a poor way of managing the situation though.
It's akin to being in an office environment where someone spent all day on the phone and instead of management tackling the issue with that person, they take the easy way out and ban all personal phone calls.

Foxesandsquirrels · 07/09/2023 10:20

DDs school has always been like this. No touching. I can understand it tbh. She's never got in trouble for hugging a friend realistically.

AndrewGarfieldsLaptop · 07/09/2023 10:20

I was at an all girls secondary school in the early 00s and they did this.

TotalOverhaul · 07/09/2023 10:19

That's staggeringly bad management from above. Touch is natural and normal and we have actually become far too precious about it imo. To pathologise all forms of touch is teaching adolescents a poor lesson in appropriate boundaries.

What happens if someone accidentally brushes against another person in a lunch queue or when working on a project together? What happens if fingers touch when handing someone a beaker in chemistry. What about rugby tackles? Gymnastics? Not all touch is aggressive, sexual or breaching boundaries. Touch is healthy, healing, affectionate, necessary, soothing. A high five, a handshake, a hug, and arm around a shoulder, a pat on the back, a quick touch of the arm to get attention - these are completely healthy interactions.

it should be perfectly easy to draw up guidelines of what is and isn't acceptable touch - no jumping on people's backs, no sexual touching of any kind, no restricting people's throats or basic movements, no tripping or shoving.

i wouldn't want my DC to go to a school that is so badly run. How do your Dc feel about this rule. Do they want to campaign against its stupidity?

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 10:19

CharlotteBog · 07/09/2023 10:17

No football, or other sports where kids tackle each other or bump into each other?

How on earth are children meant to learn about appropriate physical contact if they are not allowed to touch anyone. Ever.

There is going to be physical contact in contact sport, obviously - but not outside of that.

They can learn all they want about physical contact outside of school.

CharlotteBog · 07/09/2023 10:18

CalistoNoSolo · 07/09/2023 10:16

If it stops girls being sexually assaulted by boys I'm all for it.

Why not take it a step further then, and just ban boys from leaving the home?

BabyofMine · 07/09/2023 10:18

I don’t know what kind of workplaces people work at that don’t have any touching?!
There’s loads of socially acceptable touching and it’s nonsense to say they can’t tell the difference.
Stuff I see every day in an office:
Handshakes (very very common)
High fives (see daily)
Fist bumps (not that fond but lots of the men seem to like greeting each other with these)
Hugs (really IS more women hugging each other but see men hugging people when someone is leaving/retiring or going on Mat leave etc)
Some people give each other shoulder massages!! One person is a trained masseuse and people ask them for a shoulder massage about once a week.
We have several couples who I’ve seen holding hands and never occurred to me to be offended, they aren’t kissing or anything at work!

I might work in a particularly touchy place, although I’ve worked other places like this, but to say there’s no touching in workplaces is nonsense, at the very least handshakes and high fives have been common everywhere I have worked.

CharlotteBog · 07/09/2023 10:17

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 09:58

It been the same in many schools I have taught in, including the one I teach in now - so much better and safer for everyone - no playfighting, etc, no excuse of "we were only playfighting" when someone is hurt - and its the same in most workplaces, isn't it, so good preparation

No football, or other sports where kids tackle each other or bump into each other?

How on earth are children meant to learn about appropriate physical contact if they are not allowed to touch anyone. Ever.

CalistoNoSolo · 07/09/2023 10:16

If it stops girls being sexually assaulted by boys I'm all for it.

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 07/09/2023 10:14

Shall we wait and read the actual rules?
Only OP found it on Google. (I can see articles from January) Her kids go to the school. Then a friend whose kids go to the school have emailed the school. Have the children 9 months later only just noticed they were the subject of lots of news articles almost a year ago? Have the parents?

Bit confused really. Or possibly not.

MagentaMadge · 07/09/2023 10:14

That will be difficult during PE, although I do agree with regards to the play fighting!

DS was knocked off his feet from behind by a charming young man on the playground! He had to have knee surgery and months of physio as a consequence and will possibly be forever plagued by knee issues!

The rule of no contact whatsoever though is ridiculous!

Daffodilwoman · 07/09/2023 10:14

I totally get the logic here. Staff are not there to sort out issues such as inappropriate behaviour, they are there to get the pupils through exams.
It will make sure that there is no inappropriate touching, no excuse can be made etc etc……,
I agree with the poster who said something has probably happened and they need to ensure it does not happen again:

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 10:13

MelodiousThunk · 07/09/2023 10:07

That's not how it works in a democratic society. Instruments of the state, such as schools, are beholden to citizens, not the other way round. If parents object to school policy, then the school needs to listen to them. The arrogance of SLTs and 'academies', and their utter disdain for their constituency (parents and pupils) is appalling. The whole "vote with your feet" attitude is fine in the commercial sphere, but has no place in civil society - although it is indicative of 40 years of the marketisation of public life.

Dont be ridiculous, there will never be any consensus between parents on how they want the school to be run.

Perfectly illustrated in lockdown when parents watched online lessons and were constantly emailing in criticisms that all neatly cancelled each other out 😂

Schools are not democracies and parents are not voters - either support the school rules or take your child out, it is up to you.

More parents are happy with the no touching rule than unhappy with it anyway, from the few times it has been mentioned - it is really a non issue in most schools, just of the time, just part of the culture

TimeForTeaAndG · 07/09/2023 10:12

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 10:02

only if it is consensual, if you hug a colleague that does not want it, you will get sanctioned!

And it is at school! They can behave differently outside of school. School is a learning environment.

Honestly, the amount of time I have wasted in my career attempting to untangle "playfighting" that goes wrong - it is much better for everyone to have the no contact rule in place

Surely then the rule should be no playfighting, not banning all contact.

jotajil · 07/09/2023 10:11

My grandsons school did that. He was upset cos he couldnt be matey with his friends.
So they are totally explicit about sex and ban physical contact.
I suppose they must have a reason. Maybe they could be up front about explaining.

TimeForTeaAndG · 07/09/2023 10:10

...where did my quoted bit go? Trying again...

fairyfluf · 07/09/2023 10:10

Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 07/09/2023 10:09

The kids need to push back. I would get all the kids to get into detention at once.

What with a massive group hug?

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 07/09/2023 10:10

Is this the school in Essex that hit the redtops for banning touching in January of this year? Or one that isn't in the news?

Could you provide a link @DataColour as you said you saw it on Google?

Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 07/09/2023 10:09

The kids need to push back. I would get all the kids to get into detention at once.

MelodiousThunk · 07/09/2023 10:07

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 09:59

I think you just leave the school then, if you are not going to support the school rules, but be prepared for your options to be limited going forward, as this is a common rule in schools and has been for a very long time

That's not how it works in a democratic society. Instruments of the state, such as schools, are beholden to citizens, not the other way round. If parents object to school policy, then the school needs to listen to them. The arrogance of SLTs and 'academies', and their utter disdain for their constituency (parents and pupils) is appalling. The whole "vote with your feet" attitude is fine in the commercial sphere, but has no place in civil society - although it is indicative of 40 years of the marketisation of public life.

fairyfluf · 07/09/2023 10:07

Faie enough. Until they can learn what is appropriate they might as well have a blanket ban. Presumably they'll have a pshe lesson on it?

It will also stop the spread of nits.

JSmithIloveyou · 07/09/2023 10:05

Schools are getting worse and worse... from what we hear from friends who kids are in school.. especially high schools.
Too many rules and regulations.. it's like Army camps or youth prisons.
Thank goodness you have the choice to de register and home educate.
Mental health over school education any time.

Colourfulponderings · 07/09/2023 10:03

This is so depressing.

The thing I noticed during covid was when kids went back to school they all came out of school crowding in groups, touching each others’ arms and laughing. It struck me how ingrained touch is in our nature and how it was impossible to police it in younger people.

BorrowedThyme · 07/09/2023 10:02

DataColour · 07/09/2023 10:00

But they are kids! Not working adults, they have different mental needs.

And actually, I can hug a colleague and receive no sanctions.

only if it is consensual, if you hug a colleague that does not want it, you will get sanctioned!

And it is at school! They can behave differently outside of school. School is a learning environment.

Honestly, the amount of time I have wasted in my career attempting to untangle "playfighting" that goes wrong - it is much better for everyone to have the no contact rule in place

Cowlover89 · 07/09/2023 10:01

That's ridiculous