Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think on hindsight this was a massive safeguarding breach?!

137 replies

Hindsights2020 · 06/09/2023 19:30

Namechanged for this but was thinking recently about something that happened when I was a kid and it's only now I'm an adult with children of my own that it feels really weird, but not sure if times have changed since then (late 90s)

My Y6 teacher (female) lived fairly locally but In a different village. I happened to be friends with an older child who lived nearby which I mentioned in passing to my teacher who said something along the lines of 'oh you'll have to pop round one day'. Being that age I took her at face value and I somehow ended up with her address and we did indeed go round one day after school. I'm not really sure why. She gave us a drink and a snack, we chatted for a bit in her front room then left. I don't think we ever told our parents where we'd been, I expect they thought we were at the village park.

Absolutely nothing bad happened and I don't for a second think that she is unsafe in any way, but aibu to think on hindsight this was over familiar, inappropriate and probably broke all sorts of school safeguarding rules, or were things different back then?!

YANBU - That was weird and inappropriate even then
YABU - things were different then and she was doing no harm

OP posts:
saraclara · 06/09/2023 23:23

My (very small) special school class of children came to my house when we had a class trip to a nearby attraction. We pulled up outside in the minibus, and they and my TAs all came in had a drink and biscuits and used the loo before we set off back to school.

My DD's teacher lived just a couple if roads away from us. I had an appointment that clashed with pick up and she offered to take her home with her so that I didn't have to change it.

All in the early 90s.

Maddy70 · 06/09/2023 23:14

It was different then. I remember going round timmy teachers and watching a film.

Nothing untoward happened. It was OK then

Toddlerteaplease · 06/09/2023 23:09

I used to to go Tesco with one of my teachers, to pick up tea and coffee for doing refreshments for plays. That was ok until he had his car stolen, and we were late back. He got in to trouble for not signing us out.

blackbird77 · 06/09/2023 22:11

This is a really lovely thread. It’s so warming to hear how many wonderful teachers and school staff there are out there who have shown so much kindness and humanity. As everyone has echoed, safeguarding is paramount these days but we have had to make a big trade off for it and have lost so much.

We need human interaction and communication and bonding more than ever. Everyone is so isolated or lonely or distrustful now or there is so much paedo hysteria. There is (or can be) so much good out there. As always, the 5% ruin it for everyone else and why we can’t ever have a high-trust/nice things society.

ithinkitsdone · 06/09/2023 22:09

In 1988 my family had to quickly move house to new area. This would have meant changing schools mid a levels.
I spent most of that year living with my enish teacher and his wife.

I loved it. Hours spent at their dining table debating, reading discussing current affairs. It seemed so wonderfully grown up. A far cry from domestic abuse at home. I think he knew that from my teenage creative writing and it was his way of keeping me safe?

He was an j credible teacher. Now a very successful author.

ZadocPDederick · 06/09/2023 21:57

It's not even a case of "Things were different then". She was just being kind to a couple of children, and it would be the same if she did this now.

Lolasyms · 06/09/2023 21:51

When my daughter was in reception, her teacher took her to school for me. She lived in my village, my husband was working away and I had a hospital appointment that meant I would have struggled to get her to school and get to my appointment. My daughter is now in high school, but I still think of that teacher as one of the kindest and caring teachers I know. I of course understand why safeguarding is in place, but the school felt like a big family and she really helped me out when I was stuck!

BoogLoaf · 06/09/2023 21:45

When I was in primary school in the 1970's I was feeling ill one day and the caretaker walked me home. We didn't have a house phone but luckily my mum was home.

ASDMumof2 · 06/09/2023 21:42

We did something similar. Our art teacher was painting her internal doors! We chatted for a whole, met her hubby and said bye.

As soon as we got into 6th form we went to jazz clubs with our teachers, drinking and smoking.

Seriously, completely different era. Now we think everyone is a paedo!!!

dancinfeet · 06/09/2023 21:40

I was driven home from school by my male form teacher in his lunch break when I had a migraine in the late 80s. (just me and him in the car) The school had called my mum to come and collect me but he remembered that my mum didn’t drive and so offered to drive me home and drop me off. My mum was very thankful as he saved her a round bus trip! Nothing happened, he was a lovely kind teacher (still in touch on FB). Things were very different back then!

electriclight · 06/09/2023 21:39

I'm a teacher and kids knock on my door now. I don't invite them in but chat for a bit out of politeness. Thirty years ago things were very different - a sixth former at my school had a relationship with a teacher and they got married the month after she left school, everyone very happy for them.

Doyoureallyhavetoask · 06/09/2023 21:35

Also as a young teenager I used to visit an older man on our street because he was lonely. My mum encouraged it.

Doyoureallyhavetoask · 06/09/2023 21:34

@Callyem oh I'd completely forgotten about that! I went to a Brownie leader's house to do my cooks badge. No parent present!

I was only 6. Different times.

TaigaSno · 06/09/2023 21:28

This is how life used to be. I miss it and wish we could go back to trusting people again.
These days, and particularly on this site, everyone is a child abuser just waiting to lock you up in a cellar.
I grew up in the 80s/90s, happily popping in to see people. The neighbour with a new baby that I wanted to hold, the neighbour with an apple tree in the garden who let me pick some, the shop keeper who let me sweep the shop floor (I asked if I could!) in exchange for sweets, and so on. If a teacher had said to me I should pop in one day I would have felt really special and definitely would have gone!

But yes, unfortunately I like many others, I did experience abuse, but it was from someone my parents knew and trusted well and was in my own home. This is still the most like scenario for child abuse, not stranger danger. I don't think your teacher did anything wrong at all.

Kids need to learn how to engage with other people. This skill can really be developed with trusted adults (as well as other children) outside of the immediate family.

AnIndianWoman · 06/09/2023 21:14

I’m a similar age and lived fairly close to three science teachers. I do think it was a different age.

The female teacher used to always have kids round - she’d even help with homework / make dinners etc. Her daughter even made money babysitting her students and and their siblings which would never be allowed now.

One male teacher was a Jehova’s Witness and spent every spare minute he wasn’t teaching canvassing (his wife had died young while giving birth and he was still traumatised by it) - parents often felt sorry for him and so invited him for dinner. He ate dinner at a different students’ house everyday and would help with all manner of things - he fixed our boiler once and helped the lady next door with her visa. I can’t imagine any teacher being allowed to do this now but he was a real pillar of the community.

The other male teacher refused to socialise. If we bumped into him in the street he’d act as if he didn’t see us. He was a good looking man, girls often tried to get his attention after school and people just equated his behaviour to being scared of being seen as doing something inappropriate. Eventually he moved away. Weirdly he did end up marrying one of his ex-students from here and so maybe there was something nefarious about him.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 06/09/2023 21:14

HuwEdwardsBottom · 06/09/2023 20:14

My Year 2 teacher took the whole class to her house to see some birds in her garden, and we had a slice of cake and a drink of pop. This would have been in about 1989/1990.

And it did you no harm, HuwEdwardsBottom.

MimsyBorogroves · 06/09/2023 21:00

I was thinking about one of our English teachers today who used to throw a massive party at her house for students who had been in her plays.

Then I remembered that we had an elderly man who came to our primary school once a week to do woodwork. He volunteered with the church too. He took me and my friend out for the day to the seaside once - we must have been about 8.

Different times.

Theunamedcat · 06/09/2023 20:58

I somehow ended up at a teachers house helping her pick fruit with a couple of my friends she was sick so asked for voulenteers a parent dropped us off and i ended up climbing over an old broken car to get the fruit and sliding down the windscreen

Love a bit of health and safety 👌

Crochetpenguin · 06/09/2023 20:58

My secondary school was on a split site so teachers were often driving between the two sites. I lived halfway between the sites and teachers would often stop to give me a lift if they saw me walking. This was in the 80’s. I now work in a school and wouldn't dare offer a lift to students.

neverbeenskiing · 06/09/2023 20:52

lljkk · 06/09/2023 20:19

About 1988... Teen Friend was struggling in his personal life. His teacher used to turn up friend's house, knock on the door, wake him up, get him up & out & give him a lift to school. To makes sure he got there.

Today friend would just be allowed to fail school.

Hoorah! Safeguarding. It's so great. <waves limp flag>

I'm a Safeguarding Lead in a school. I regularly go to the homes of students who are struggling, or whose families are struggling for various reasons, to wake them up, give them breakfast and drive them to school, made sure they get into school, turn up for their exams, work experience placements etc. So do several of my colleagues. All done with parents agreement, documented, and not breaching any policies or procedures...these things happen in schools every day.

I have also frequently taken kids to medical appointments when parents refused to take them, taken kids to the dentist and opticians, driven them home when no one turned up to collect them from school.

"Safeguarding" doesn't prevent these things from happening, these things happen because safeguarding issues have been identified and adults in school take action to improve things for children. So yeah, hoo-fucking-rah for Safeguarding! <waves giant flag>

Serendipitoushedgehog · 06/09/2023 20:42

I think the Soham murders were a big turning point for safeguarding.

Verytall · 06/09/2023 20:41

Agree with the sentiments in here, safeguarding is a necessity and I wouldn't want to change the system now, but it does mean sacrifices. I've worked in children's homes, and remember one year feeling gutted for a child who on Christmas Day was the only one at the home - everyone else had some family that they could go to. We did our best to spoil her, but it was noticeably quiet and empty (usually five children lived there) Our manager (who was also a foster carer) told us that in the past if similar happened, they would lock up the home and taken them to his where'd he'd host a big family Christmas with his own family+ any foster children or children from the children's homes.

Moonflower12 · 06/09/2023 20:41

I was a Brown Owl in the 90s and early 00s in my village. I regularly had all my girls to the house as we had a lovely large garden, so they could play outdoor games, cook on a fire etc.
I'd also looked after nearly all of them in the local nursery too!

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 06/09/2023 20:41

bigageap · 06/09/2023 19:56

Our GCSE maths teacher (who also taught my mum) so shows his age, gave the entire class his phone number before we went on study leave so we could get help at any time! Nothing dodgy and entirely from the heart, he wanted to help! But clearly now I’d be horrified if it was my kids!!!

You've just reminded me that my tutor at secondary school gave all the parents (and kids!) his home phone number at the pre year 7 info evening, he wrote it on the board. It's a very memorable number - think 112233 - and I still remember it today, almost 30 years later! He still lives in the same house, so I could call him now if the mood took me! 😂

I also remember in primary school, halloween, a teacher telling us how some kids had knocked his door trick or treating, he'd invited them in, shut the door, and proceeded to give them a bollocking about going into strangers houses and how it was so dangerous and we mustn't do it either. We all just thought he was a miserable sod and felt sorry for the poor kids who didn't get any sweets!