Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think on hindsight this was a massive safeguarding breach?!

137 replies

Hindsights2020 · 06/09/2023 19:30

Namechanged for this but was thinking recently about something that happened when I was a kid and it's only now I'm an adult with children of my own that it feels really weird, but not sure if times have changed since then (late 90s)

My Y6 teacher (female) lived fairly locally but In a different village. I happened to be friends with an older child who lived nearby which I mentioned in passing to my teacher who said something along the lines of 'oh you'll have to pop round one day'. Being that age I took her at face value and I somehow ended up with her address and we did indeed go round one day after school. I'm not really sure why. She gave us a drink and a snack, we chatted for a bit in her front room then left. I don't think we ever told our parents where we'd been, I expect they thought we were at the village park.

Absolutely nothing bad happened and I don't for a second think that she is unsafe in any way, but aibu to think on hindsight this was over familiar, inappropriate and probably broke all sorts of school safeguarding rules, or were things different back then?!

YANBU - That was weird and inappropriate even then
YABU - things were different then and she was doing no harm

OP posts:
Autieangel · 07/09/2023 06:14

Fairly normal back then. Massive safeguarding now.

I remember when I was early teens (early 90's) we had a teacher who was leaving. He was very close to my friend and they wrote to each other for a few years after he left. He arranged for the rest of our class to be pen pals with his new class and we met up a few times . Seems weird now but at time everyone accepted it.

WandaWonder · 07/09/2023 04:26

I don't remember the expression massive safeguarding breach" being used back then, people also fed children alcohol to help teething, did not use seatbelts, let children play out and roam the streets and let heaps of other things happen over the years a lot of people don't do now, sure we call say
'what happened to me 30 years ago would not happen now' but what is the point?

Threeboysadogandacat · 07/09/2023 01:42

In primary I was driven home by different teachers twice when I was unwell. In secondary I used to walk my geography teachers dog along with my own after school. Sometimes she would come with me and we would go in her car to a forest a few miles away to walk them. In 6th year some of us went to a university open day in the school mini bus with a teacher driving it. We stopped at his parents house on the way for tea and biscuits and to use the toilet before continuing on our way. Changed days!

TheLadyofShalott1 · 07/09/2023 01:41

Things were obviously very different in the 1960's for all sorts of reasons. My husband was brought up in a small Northern town, and whilst he was at Primary School his female teacher had him stay at her house overnight once, as his parents were going out somewhere. My mind still boggled a bit at the thought of it, but thinking about it now, probably everyone knew everyone, and had done for years, and the news wouldn't have been so full of news about paedophiles then, as it is now.

Hopefully there wasn't one living on practically every street then as there appears to be now. Also, I think the internet must have done so much damage in that way, as it not only lets people of like mind talk to each other and share pictures, but they probanly encourage each other to perform ever worse acts.

MojitoLil · 07/09/2023 01:40

...also, to show the other side, the teachers set up a rota to take it in turns to drive me to the hospital to see my parent who was ill at the time. I'd just show up in the car park, one of them would wave at me and I'd get in the car.

MojitoLil · 07/09/2023 01:37

When I was at school in late 80's/early 90's, we had some very young teachers who were always getting in and out of relationships with each other, and occasionally with an older pupil. I went clubbing with one of them and got pissed at another (female) teacher's house.

It was otherwise a good school, and my parents were otherwise sensible parents, but that stuff is mad to look back on.

mayorofcasterbridge · 07/09/2023 01:20

All the PC/safeguarding stuff (which I absolutely get) has taken away so much tat was just human kindness.

Biscuitandacuppa · 07/09/2023 01:15

When I sat my A levels one of the teachers went on maternity leave in the final year. She arranged with the class (only 5 students) to come to her house for revision during our study periods. I drove the class in my ancient car and she fed us lunch. It was a regular weekly thing.

Also recently I broke my ankle and couldn’t drive or walk, my dd’s primary school headteacher volunteered to pick her up in the mornings and take her to school if needed.

Melroses · 07/09/2023 01:11

I was driven home by my school violin teacher once, at his insistence. I was quite happy to get the two buses home. It was after school and I was the last lesson that week. I was wary because I had been warned of him by someone who was one of his private pupils who had turned up for a lesson and found him in the bath 😖but I couldn't get out of it.

He stayed for a cup of tea with my parents who were very impressed by him.

The school stopped the violin lessons after that so I didn't see him again.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 07/09/2023 01:09

At a safeguarding course I attended, we were told about an incident where school children had been taken on a walk around their local area. They happened to pass the house of one accompanying staff member who allowed some of the children to use their toilet. As a result the staff member ended up in big trouble.

My primary school did a trip every year where there weren't any loos but there was a family with children at the school who lived very close. It was arranged that we'd go there first, and leave our packed lunches in her fridge to be collected later.

We had to give Mrs Y a round of applause to thank her for looking after our sandwiches and letting us use her loo. Grin

This arrangement went on for years, I don't know what they'd have done if the family had moved house!

Ladyj84 · 07/09/2023 01:01

Why are you putting modern thinking now onto something totally different all those years ago..That's what's wrong.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 07/09/2023 00:59

Was your friend called Lavender and the teachers name Miss Honey?

Sugarfree23 · 07/09/2023 00:57

I think now adults are more aware of the risk of them being accused of doing something wrong.

How do you defend yourself against false accusations if you've been caught with a child in your house?

mayorofcasterbridge · 07/09/2023 00:56

My primary school principal lived in the house that belonged to the school, and was yards away from ours. He was a close neighbour as well as our teacher.

I started school when I was coming 5, and one day there was crazy snow. My dad carried me to school but there was only me and the principal's daughter because no-one else could make it. The principal carried me home. That just wouldn't happen now, but it was all totally above board.

I used to, as a child, love the company of elderly people. They had such tales to tell (how I wish now I'd written it down!). I used to visit them as a child to listen to their stories. There was one family in particular, 2 brothers, 2 sisters. One brother had been married but the siblings had hated his wife until she died, and he moved back home. The other three siblings never married. The oldest sister lived to be almost 100.

They lived in a tiny house with 2 bedrooms (one of them in their living room) and the 'girls' and the 'boys' had their own space. The house had a tin roof, and the floor was clay. They had no electricity. Their only modern convenience was a phone, which they used to keep in touch with various priests mostly. They had a cow they'd milked for years lol, and served tea so strong you could stand on it, plus the milk!

The younger sister used to get a lift to Mass every Sunday and rode her bike to ours and left it under shelter and was picked up from there. She did this in her 70s and possibly 80s and the lane up to their house was the steepest I have ever seen.

One time our whole family was stricken by a horrible flu. The younger sister then in her 70s arrived into our house like a guardian angel, and took over, with no fear of catching our lurgy!

I used to spend hours with them because I was fascinated by their stories. My parents knew where I was. Nowadays, our friendship would be considered inappropriate.

RIP Mary, Hugh, Rosetta and John. You added so much to my teen life.

StandingMyGround888 · 07/09/2023 00:53

We were driven home in the boot of my teacher's Volvo. We went to the headteachers house for squash and biscuits. Was a lot better back then. 90s.

JanglingJack · 07/09/2023 00:50

Oh FFS nothing like that 🤣

JanglingJack · 07/09/2023 00:49

JanglingJack · 07/09/2023 00:47

It still does happen, well going back to when my eldest was at secondary. He must have been 15. Anyway, my Mum, myself (both emergency contacts) took my 3 year old to a little show. With buying crap afterwards etc we were phones off and put of range for probably about 3 hours.

Out we get, both turn phones on. Ping, ping, ping, ping, ping both of us. Voicemail. Oh gawd!!

My son had broken his wrist in that 3 hours that we were out of contact. They'd taken him to A&E, he had splint thing and a sling, they brought him home and he'd had to let himself in with his own key. 😭 He was 15, but I still felt like the worst parent ever!
Big box of Heroes and a thank you card for the teachers next morning.

That would have been 3013? Something like that?

GeorgiaGirl52 · 07/09/2023 00:47

My mother was a cooking teacher in secondary school in the 70's. She made a point of inviting every girl in her classes to dinner at our home at least once during the school year. We had a dinner table that would seat six people. Every Friday night we had my mother, my father, me and three students at the table. It was semi-formal with silverware, china, tablecloth, etc. My mother thought that they should all see exactly how a dinner party should be conducted. Afterward my father would drive them home.

JanglingJack · 07/09/2023 00:47

It still does happen, well going back to when my eldest was at secondary. He must have been 15. Anyway, my Mum, myself (both emergency contacts) took my 3 year old to a little show. With buying crap afterwards etc we were phones off and put of range for probably about 3 hours.

Out we get, both turn phones on. Ping, ping, ping, ping, ping both of us. Voicemail. Oh gawd!!

My son had broken his wrist in that 3 hours that we were out of contact. They'd taken him to A&E, he had splint thing and a sling, they brought him home and he'd had to let himself in with his own key. 😭 He was 15, but I still felt like the worst parent ever!
Big box of Heroes and a thank you card for the teachers next morning.

TheFireflies · 07/09/2023 00:40

I had a Milly Molly Mandy book as a child where her new teacher came to stay in her spare room for a while. I used to secretly wish my teacher would come to live in my house.

In the 80s my whole class once camped overnight in our headteachers back garden, going into her (super posh) house to use the loo etc.

Wouldn't happen now!

Stella123456 · 07/09/2023 00:34

dancinfeet · 06/09/2023 21:40

I was driven home from school by my male form teacher in his lunch break when I had a migraine in the late 80s. (just me and him in the car) The school had called my mum to come and collect me but he remembered that my mum didn’t drive and so offered to drive me home and drop me off. My mum was very thankful as he saved her a round bus trip! Nothing happened, he was a lovely kind teacher (still in touch on FB). Things were very different back then!

I had exactly the same situation with my male teacher. Very kind. Drove me home. 1979

Stella123456 · 07/09/2023 00:31

ClusterFukt · 06/09/2023 19:42

Around that time 96/97 my two cousins (age 4) were taken out of school by their teacher when she had to pop home during the school day. She thought they were cute because they were twins so took them with her in her car to her house and gave them strawberries in her garden and took photos of them eating them. She actually printed them off and gave them to my aunt as a momento. My auntie didn’t bat an eyelid. I was agog at the time and I was only a teen myself. No one else though anything of it. So weird.

This is shocking and terrible but also so funny

Lizlibrarian · 07/09/2023 00:28

During harvest we used to walk around the community as a class and give the elderly tinned food. One year I couldn't be bothered to walk around our village so when one lady invited me in to her house I was overjoyed. I had a cup of tea and biscuits and watched TV. A couple of hours later one of my teachers knocked on the door to tell me it was time to go back to school, they didn't know exactly who's house I had been in so had knocked on a few. They knew I was not with the group for that 2 hours but decided to finish the task and find me after. Teacher thanked the lady for watching me all afternoon. No one cared. I told my mum when she asked what I did at school that day and she said that's nice, it was a non issue. I was about 6 at the time.

In secondary school we often went for parties with teachers at their house. Sometimes our parents would come and they would all drink together but sometimes it was just us kids. Nothing happened and we had a good time.

Lots of teachers gave lifts to students.

School Gates were always open so people in our community (mostly older people who were lonely) would just walk in and chat to us in the playground. Teachers didn't supervise breaks then. Random people often used the school grounds as a cut through and would stop and chat. If staff saw them they would say hi but were unbothered. They were probably glad to have someone else to entertain us for a while.

Life was very different then. Glad I got to live it.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 06/09/2023 23:57

I remember having an GCSE exam clash so had to be supervised between the first exam and when I could start the second (which had been sat by most people that morning). Another teenager and I were driven by a teacher to their house for lunch and then back a couple of hours later. Don't think any of us thought it strange!

BackAgainstWall · 06/09/2023 23:32

My male teacher friend used to go round to kids houses and round them up to take them into school on his way in.

It was boys that otherwise wouldn’t have bothered turning up.

A brilliant man and still is to this day.