Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think on hindsight this was a massive safeguarding breach?!

137 replies

Hindsights2020 · 06/09/2023 19:30

Namechanged for this but was thinking recently about something that happened when I was a kid and it's only now I'm an adult with children of my own that it feels really weird, but not sure if times have changed since then (late 90s)

My Y6 teacher (female) lived fairly locally but In a different village. I happened to be friends with an older child who lived nearby which I mentioned in passing to my teacher who said something along the lines of 'oh you'll have to pop round one day'. Being that age I took her at face value and I somehow ended up with her address and we did indeed go round one day after school. I'm not really sure why. She gave us a drink and a snack, we chatted for a bit in her front room then left. I don't think we ever told our parents where we'd been, I expect they thought we were at the village park.

Absolutely nothing bad happened and I don't for a second think that she is unsafe in any way, but aibu to think on hindsight this was over familiar, inappropriate and probably broke all sorts of school safeguarding rules, or were things different back then?!

YANBU - That was weird and inappropriate even then
YABU - things were different then and she was doing no harm

OP posts:
RockaLock · 07/09/2023 07:37

When I was at school, if you had a public exam clash and couldn't sit one of the exams until the next day, you went home with a teacher and spent the night at their house to make sure you weren't in contact with anyone.

Unthinkable now, but totally normal for the 1990s!

RonniePickering · 07/09/2023 07:34

My brother and his school friend (aged 10/11) used to be taken abseiling and on other activities by our PE teacher in the school holidays (she never took me or anyone else, she didn’t have children of her own). I always found that weird, my parents didn’t bat an eye lid.

CurlewKate · 07/09/2023 07:33

@Hindsights2020 Is there something that's troubling you about this in particular?

liveforsummer · 07/09/2023 07:28

JanglingJack · 06/09/2023 20:25

I had my son late 90s and I'm not sure safeguarding really existed then unless you were under the dreaded Social Services.

With Dunblane came locked school gates and with Ian Huntley came the then CRB checks.

Primary schools didn't have locked gates. Middle and Upper schools didn't have gates.

Lots of abuse going on from teachers whilst I was growing up. Things that shock my kids today. Being forced to shower naked at middle school from aged 9-12 with a male teacher exclaiming come on girls I'm not looking.

We needed those showers of course after a 30 minute game of netball. Boys didn't!

All sorts went on.

Fwiw I live in Scotland and the gates of schools in our city are only locked when the schools are closed. You need to be buzzed in to the buildings (although in hot weather classroom doors can be open) but the grounds aren't locked

itsgettingweird · 07/09/2023 07:28

And on the flip side it also meant teachers came to our house for BBQs etc as they were mums friends and I went to teachers of the schools house for exactly the same reason.

Ok, my parents were there, but I was alone with them outside of school.

itsgettingweird · 07/09/2023 07:26

Mumofsend · 06/09/2023 19:34

It was a different era so can't really be viewed from today lenses

This.

My mum was a teacher in my school.

We often had kids turn up to call for me who would wait sit chatting to a teacher from school whilst I got ready.

No one batted an eyelid.

trulyunruly01 · 07/09/2023 07:25

When we finished 5th year in 1983 (yr11 now) our form teacher squashed many of us into his vw camper van and took us to the pub for a couple of hours. We were joined by the metalwork and woodwork teachers and had a jolly time in the pub garden.

neonjumper · 07/09/2023 07:25

lljkk · 06/09/2023 20:19

About 1988... Teen Friend was struggling in his personal life. His teacher used to turn up friend's house, knock on the door, wake him up, get him up & out & give him a lift to school. To makes sure he got there.

Today friend would just be allowed to fail school.

Hoorah! Safeguarding. It's so great. <waves limp flag>

Not true ... some schools have 'collectors'. They do exactly this .

Bringbackniles · 07/09/2023 07:22

We had a popular teacher at our primary school in the 90s who was gay. It was an open secret among the parents. He used to invite boys back to his house sometimes (primary age) and I remember my dad expressly forbidding my brother to go if he was invited.

Not sure what happened but he was sacked because he was caught doing something publicly with a man (a bit of a George Michael situ).

Amazing that the school and parents knew he was inviting boys to his house but no one did anything about it. Being gay seemed to be more of an issue.

liveforsummer · 07/09/2023 07:22

I also remember being given a lift by a teacher often in the late 80's as she was going my way. Didn't go to anyone a house but I have known people who had even been taken to houses from school like a mini trip. Now sadly it's a safeguarding concern but it wouldn't have been seen as one then. It's a shame as there are a couple of dc I work with that I'd love to take home or out for the day from time to time.

RichardsGear · 07/09/2023 07:21

My brother did A level English in the mid 80s - the teacher (who was universally adored by her students) had the class round at her house for get togethers, with wine IIRC. She treated them more like university students - they loved it and nobody gave a toss.

Zonder · 07/09/2023 07:20

I have been teaching since the early 90s. A head teacher in my placement school used to take a group of boys sailing every Friday afternoon on his boat on his own. It was definitely a different era. Imagine the risk assessment now!

grass321 · 07/09/2023 07:15

Our German teacher also used to hold parties at his house for sixth formers where alcohol was served. Nothing untoward happened, he was just trying to be cool but I look back and think WTF.

grass321 · 07/09/2023 07:14

MouseKeys · 06/09/2023 19:54

Ironically I also went to my youth leader's house once with some other members of the group which again my parents were fine with at the time. Absolutely nothing happened at all apart from him serving us the most disgusting meal I’d ever had to eat in my life but it did cause quite a stir when he was later arrested and it turned out that he was a p**phile, I don’t think I was allowed to go anywhere for a bit after that!

If it's the person currently in the news for inappropriate relations with male teenagers, I did the same and went to his house regularly (in a group).

Clevs · 07/09/2023 07:11

Our deputy head formed a walking group where those that were interested could go on a hike somewhere with her and her husband. There wasn't many of us in the group and one Sunday afternoon we'd been for a walk and they took us back to their house and she made some non-alcoholic punch for us all. I can't remember how we got home from her house but it wouldn't surprise me if she dropped us all off.

This was early-mid 90s.

Mble · 07/09/2023 07:04

Loads of teachers do private tuition and music lessons in their own home and nobody bats an eyelid. Children go to friends houses. childminders and babysitters. It isn’t exactly the same but the risks probably much the same.

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 07/09/2023 06:56

Our headteacher used to host a massive barbecue at her house for year six every summer (with parents) and the kids would stay for a sleepover afterwards.

Nobody batted an eyelid and it was a great end of school tradition that everyone always looked forward to.

FlamingoQueen · 07/09/2023 06:53

You have to relate things like this to the period of time when it happened. We once went on a school trip (there were only 4 of us going) in the male teachers car and no one thought anything of it. Nothing dodgy happened!

If nothing happened then there is nothing to worry about. Times were different back then (god, I feel ancient saying that!) and teachers weren’t on their guard or paranoid about any little slip up.

LittleGreenHearts · 07/09/2023 06:52

Where we live, most of my DS’s nursery school teachers live in the same village the nursery is. one of the young girls that works there still lives with her mum, who happens to go overboard with the decorations for Halloween/Christmas etc.

Halloween last year, they took the nursery children on a “Pumpkin walk” and the kids (with parents permission) went to this Girls house, looked at the decorations, chatted to her mum and had a snack in the garden. I thought it was cute.

I would have found it a bit weird if they went inside though

As it happens she’s also done a lot of babysitting for many of us when she was younger/before working at nursery so maybe that skews my view a bit

Globules · 07/09/2023 06:34

MojitoLil · 07/09/2023 01:40

...also, to show the other side, the teachers set up a rota to take it in turns to drive me to the hospital to see my parent who was ill at the time. I'd just show up in the car park, one of them would wave at me and I'd get in the car.

I love this. I'm so sad this wouldn't happen these days, despite having teachers who still would want to do it.

Mistressanne · 07/09/2023 06:33

NeedToChangeName · 06/09/2023 20:08

Some lovely stories here about kind people doing something nice for children

Today's world may be safer, but we've definitely lost something too

I don’t think it’s safer.
There may be more safeguarding but paedophiles still manage to get round it.

electriclight · 07/09/2023 06:30

I remember missing my school bus when I was 14 and a male teacher drive me home, about ten miles. He let me choose the music and we had a nice chat. My parents were very grateful to him. No suggestion of anything untoward.

Globules · 07/09/2023 06:30

All these stories are describing a better world imo. I hate that we're forced to wrap chn in cotton wool under the guise of child protection. If anything, the internet has taken p'dos off the streets as they now get their fix on a computer. And most abusers are people known to a child, not a stranger.

I remember teaching my children to walk to the library by themselves aged 6 & 8 in the 2010s. They were avid readers and they would happily spend an hour or two in the local library, like I did at that age. So I taught them to get there by themselves, like I did at that age, and how to be safe, like I was at that age.

The amount of parents who condemned me for it as they weren't safe and "you don't know who's out there".

As a society we now over protect and mollycoddle from a young age imo. When something a bit tricky comes along, or a problem needs solving, we've not allowed chn to develop the skills to get themselves out of the situation. Which I think has an impact on how their self esteem and contributes to some of the issues we see in teens and young adults today.

Morph22010 · 07/09/2023 06:26

our form tutor took three of us for a day out doing a sport after a levels and then we called in the pub and had a drink after, and my brothers teacher took my brother and another boy from the class to an England football match at Wembley alone in his car. These were in the 80s and 90s. They were different times and they were just nice teachers doing nice things, I didn’t realise at the time but we were perhaps the more deprived kids in the class as were in a single parent family and on fsm and we didn’t get to to the things that some other kids did with their parents. I totally get the safeguarding thing as there would have been incidents going on that were not innocent but it also a shame that now nice teachers can’t just do nice things due to safeguarding

Autieangel · 07/09/2023 06:24

I also remember after our leavers disco we all went into town (age 16-18) The younger teachers came out too and a couple of them were snogging the year 13 girls

Swipe left for the next trending thread