Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think on hindsight this was a massive safeguarding breach?!

137 replies

Hindsights2020 · 06/09/2023 19:30

Namechanged for this but was thinking recently about something that happened when I was a kid and it's only now I'm an adult with children of my own that it feels really weird, but not sure if times have changed since then (late 90s)

My Y6 teacher (female) lived fairly locally but In a different village. I happened to be friends with an older child who lived nearby which I mentioned in passing to my teacher who said something along the lines of 'oh you'll have to pop round one day'. Being that age I took her at face value and I somehow ended up with her address and we did indeed go round one day after school. I'm not really sure why. She gave us a drink and a snack, we chatted for a bit in her front room then left. I don't think we ever told our parents where we'd been, I expect they thought we were at the village park.

Absolutely nothing bad happened and I don't for a second think that she is unsafe in any way, but aibu to think on hindsight this was over familiar, inappropriate and probably broke all sorts of school safeguarding rules, or were things different back then?!

YANBU - That was weird and inappropriate even then
YABU - things were different then and she was doing no harm

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LoonyLois · 08/09/2023 18:28

At secondary school when I was doing GCSEs one of my teachers used to give me a lift home if I stayed late doing coursework. She’d always say she was “going your way”, but I found out a few years later she actually lived in the opposite direction. She was the one teacher who got me through secondary school and I’d love to be able to tell her now.

I always thought once I drove I would stop for school kids at bus stops in the rain and offer a lift, but of course now it’s not the done thing

ManateeFair · 08/09/2023 14:33

This wouldn't have been considered a problem 25-30 years ago.

AnAussieMum · 08/09/2023 14:28

About 30 years ago I slept over at my year 6 teachers house for a weekend. She wasn't my teacher at the time, it was probably 2 years after I had been in her class.
I was having a hard time and she lived in the hills. I am not sure how it came about actually.
I knew it was an odd thing at the time and I wasn't supposed to tell other kids about it. She was lovely, she had 2 older daughters who I really enjoyed spending time with and I still remember helping them brush their 2 sausage dogs teeth with bone flavoured dog tooth paste.
It would never happen now I know but I had severe depression and think that they thought it would help me somehow.

Zonder · 08/09/2023 13:50

liveforsummer · 08/09/2023 07:32

I find it strange you chose to interpret it that way , it was obviously clear to others why someone might wish to offer things to specific children.

However since it wasn't specified in the post it was clearly open to interpretation. And as professionals working with children we have to be seen not to have favourites. Up thread I mentioned the head teacher who took a group of boys sailing every week. That wasn't based on any kind of need.

liveforsummer · 08/09/2023 07:32

I find it strange you chose to interpret it that way , it was obviously clear to others why someone might wish to offer things to specific children.

Zonder · 08/09/2023 07:03

Well that's what the post sounded like @liveforsummer

liveforsummer · 08/09/2023 06:24

@Zonder all children are not treated equally in school - they are treated as individuals and their needs responded to as such. Some need extra support with learning or managing in the environment , some due to their home lives need nurture - you can rest assured though that no one is giving kids extra support because they are cute 🙄

Zonder · 07/09/2023 23:58

CurlewKate · 07/09/2023 09:43

@Zonder "A couple of kids you would love to take home or out for the day?

There's so much wrong with that statement. Thank goodness things have changed.

Why those kids? What about the rest of the kids?"

Presumably because the OP can see that the children concerned do not have the advantages the others do and are missing out. The OP would like to be able to fill the gaps.

What were you thinking?

Well she didn't specify that so you're making an assumption. For all we know she could just think those kids are particularly cute. It's an odd thing to say. We need to be impartial and treat all children equally.

Lizlibrarian · 07/09/2023 22:48

In my job now (obviously not teaching) I'm able to take children out alone in my car or walking or on public transport if necessary, out to an activity, to drop them off somewhere or out for food for example. I'm often alone with children and young people of all ages, in my car, office, their home. I have older children's (teens) numbers (in my work phone) and I message them to organise coming to see them or send updates. I'd never message just for the sake of it or take them to my house or to anything to do with my personal life of course. I do message to check in if I know something important is going on or I know they are having a hard time. I'm really glad this part of my job has not been taken away. I totally understand the need for safeguarding and protecting children and the teachers for that matter, but I'm still glad I get to do this as it's the best part of my job and why I stick around even though the rest of it is pretty rubbish.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 07/09/2023 09:58

One male teacher was a Jehova’s Witness and spent every spare minute he wasn’t teaching canvassing (his wife had died young while giving birth and he was still traumatised by it) - parents often felt sorry for him and so invited him for dinner. He ate dinner at a different students’ house everyday and would help with all manner of things - he fixed our boiler once and helped the lady next door with her visa. I can’t imagine any teacher being allowed to do this now but he was a real pillar of the community.

I think this is a completely different situation where adults have invited another adult from within the community into their homes. Adults are still allowed to be friendly with their children's teachers.

Fillyfrog · 07/09/2023 09:46

At primary school in the 90s, me and my friend decided to 'run away' because the teacher shouted too much. We were aged about 9 or 10. We walked straight out of the gate at dinnertime, went to my friends house who lived in the next street(nobody was in) and watched TV for around an hour until a teacher came and found us and we got returned. At the end of the day, they didn't even tell my mum what had happened! Imagine the uproar if it happened now...

CurlewKate · 07/09/2023 09:43

@Zonder "A couple of kids you would love to take home or out for the day?

There's so much wrong with that statement. Thank goodness things have changed.

Why those kids? What about the rest of the kids?"

Presumably because the OP can see that the children concerned do not have the advantages the others do and are missing out. The OP would like to be able to fill the gaps.

What were you thinking?

ButtonSister · 07/09/2023 09:43

This was the pre-Soham era, safeguarding changed a lot after that

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/09/2023 09:38

I think since the holly and Jessica murders we are all more aware of what could happen in a member of school staff home

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/09/2023 09:38

I remember when I was in 6th form
Some friends lived on the same road as a teacher and told her they were going trick or treating and might knock on her door - the next week she said in class she was disappointed she didn't see them as she'd got some prosecco in she'd have given them a glass 😂

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/09/2023 09:36

The safeguarding rules now are to protect teachers from allegations too as well as of course to protect the children. It's quite common that children will disclose or accuse a safe adult as a test to see if they are believed before they then go on to say who the abuser really is.

If a teacher has been in a room alone with a door closed with no window with a student, then it's their word against yours.

Cantstaystuckforever · 07/09/2023 09:21

Agree, a teacher at our local high school does this (it is designated and checked Vs casual, but that's probably better and also means more kids can be benefit).

I used to get dropped at sports competitions by my a teacher because they knew my family couldn't and otherwise I couldn't go, it was great but also can see how it would have been easy for it to go wrong. We also had quite a few creepy teachers and one 40-something teacher who had to leave after they discovered that a17 year old student had run away from home to move in with him, so there were real safeguarding issues, it's not just crazy bureaucracy like some posters here seem to think

Elefant1 · 07/09/2023 08:49

Village primary school in the 80s, no public swimming pool near by. A couple in the village let the school use the pool in their garden during the summer term. No changing rooms, we just changed on the grass by the pool.
The list of problems there would be with this now would be very long but it is one of my best memories from primary school.
I also used to get lifts to secondary school sometimes with a teacher who was friends with my parents as she drove past our house anyway.

circacircle · 07/09/2023 08:14

It used to annoy me when older children who had left school and gone to Sixth Form College would turn up at my house to get their passport application signed. I lived very locally to the school I taught at so they knew where I lived. They also would turn up in my classroom at Break or after school with instructions from their Mum that I was to sign it.( There is a lot more than just signing)
Another free favour teachers were expected to provide. Hope students don't ask any more.

ISeeMisledPeople · 07/09/2023 08:09

Things were very different then. My friend and I used to go running with our coach from athletics club, just the three of us. We were about 13, and he was well into middle age. No way would that be allowed now.

Loopytiles · 07/09/2023 08:02

yes. @RockaLock !

teachers’ decor and food offerings was a topic of gossip, like Come Dine With Me with teens and exam angst!

Zonder · 07/09/2023 07:59

RockaLock · 07/09/2023 07:37

When I was at school, if you had a public exam clash and couldn't sit one of the exams until the next day, you went home with a teacher and spent the night at their house to make sure you weren't in contact with anyone.

Unthinkable now, but totally normal for the 1990s!

I had forgotten this but it happened at our school too! We all used to quiz the people who got to stay at teachers' houses.

Zonder · 07/09/2023 07:58

liveforsummer · 07/09/2023 07:22

I also remember being given a lift by a teacher often in the late 80's as she was going my way. Didn't go to anyone a house but I have known people who had even been taken to houses from school like a mini trip. Now sadly it's a safeguarding concern but it wouldn't have been seen as one then. It's a shame as there are a couple of dc I work with that I'd love to take home or out for the day from time to time.

A couple of kids you would love to take home or out for the day?

There's so much wrong with that statement. Thank goodness things have changed.

Why those kids? What about the rest of the kids?

Astrabees · 07/09/2023 07:57

My head teacher in the early 60’s used to drive me, and two other children, to and from school. On the way home we would go to count the cows that she and her father owned in a field. If it was bad weather in the winter my father would drive us all in his breakdown truck. I also got lots of lifts home from sports day and after school events with the vicar. People were just nice and kind in those days.

Butteredtoast55 · 07/09/2023 07:45

I can remember way back when I was at school and the children in what is now Year 6 would be sent in pairs to the village shop to buy the Headmaster's ciggies and pop. We considered it a great treat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread