Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why relationship, marriage and kids are still seen as a ’ successful’ life?

220 replies

OnedayTwodays · 06/09/2023 14:29

Reading here and also IRL so many people, still, thinks that this the ’LifePlan’ everyone not only wants, but must have.

Some thread about perhaps not so nice people, people say it brings them joy to know they end up alone and old - as in being single is seen as some kind of a punishment.

Single, or god forbid if your childfree, stilm have to explain why.
Say your single and when asked you say you don’t hook up or having casual arrangement or whatever, and people look at you like you have two heads.

Will we ever move on and stop assuming everyone wants/lives the same way?
Will the stigma ever go away?

Why is it that even now being in a relationship/kids is seen the proper, mature, right way to live?

OP posts:
SallyWD · 07/09/2023 09:16

I think things are changing particularly in this country (compared to many other countries where to be single and childless is seen as much more tragic and shameful) but yes there's still a long way to go.
I am married with kids but absolutely see the benefits of a single child free life! I often think my happiest life would be me living alone in the countryside with a couple of cats.
It has always really pissed me off when parents start talking about the future lives of their kids and they always say stuff like "The proudest day of my life will be when I walk my daughter down the aisle" (men) or "when I go wedding dress shopping with my daughter" or "hold my first grandchild in my arms" (women) Ugh!! I hate all that! It's like maybe your kids don't want to get to married or have children!! Why is walking someone down the aisle seen as the pinnacle of parenting, the happiest and proudest day in the life of a parent?! I don't get it! Half of marriages are miserable and end in divorce! I'd be far more proud if my children live their best lives, do whatever they find most fulfilling and grow up to be kind, decent people.

KimberleyClark · 07/09/2023 09:15

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/09/2023 15:43

@Girliefriendlikespuppies

I think for some people they honestly can't believe a single person can ever be happy and I also think there's always been a general distrust of single women throughout history.

This is true. Men are threatened by single women because they don’t need anything from them. Women who do need men can’t understand them.

To be fair I think some women are also threatened by women who don’t need children to be happy.

ZenNudist · 07/09/2023 09:13

You are being paranoid. There's no stigma to being single or child free. You do what makes you happy. Most people are not happy alone so that's why the majority want a relationship. Life is often easier with a partner. Children bring a lot of love into lives but are hard work. There's a biological imperative to procreate.

Caro678 · 07/09/2023 09:13

Yes the only reason we’re able to have this conversation is because of the pill and women being able to control their fertility. Before that, if you wanted to have sex you had to get married and babies would usually follow as a natural consequence.

I don’t look down on single or child free people.I feel sad for the people I know who didn’t want to be in that position, and they are all gorgeous, funny, clever, people who had lots of interest from the opposite sex, but they were just unlucky or didn’t meet the right person at the right time. They still have meaning and happiness in their lives and there’s always time to meet someone, but I feel sorry that the family side didn’t work out as they had hoped. It could just as easily have happened to me, sliding doors and all that.

However, I can understand why some people don’t want to have kids and if a person has actively chosen this and taken the necessary steps to achieve it, then great! I wouldn’t make any particular assumptions about which camp someone fell into unless we were close and they chose to discuss it with me.

I think I probably would assume that most people in their ideal world would want a good and loving relationship with a significant other, if that was possible, but I understand that relationships can break down, one might choose to prioritise existing children, partners can disappoint and fall short, and people can be burned by bad experiences, so it becomes an active choice to stay single in the circumstances.

Smartiepants79 · 07/09/2023 09:12

OutsideLookingOut · 07/09/2023 09:04

Pretty sure humans generally have a desire to have sex. It is mainly societal influence about an urge to have children. That does not mean people don’t want children but that women throughout history have been fed a diet of motherhood being what is most desired for them, of the pitiable spinster etc etc.

Up until the last 100 years, having sex meant having a baby. The fundamental reason for sex is to produce offspring.
NOT having children is a product of scientific advances in medical contraception and changes in the role of women in our society. It has bugger all to do with our basic biology.
We forgot too quickly that we are just another type of animal.
Most women don’t want to have children because society tell them too. Some might. They have children because millions of years of evolution tells them to.

CurlewKate · 07/09/2023 09:09

@Thepeopleversuswork I don't think that's quite what I meant- I'll have a thing and rephrase.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/09/2023 09:08

OutsideLookingOut · 07/09/2023 09:04

Pretty sure humans generally have a desire to have sex. It is mainly societal influence about an urge to have children. That does not mean people don’t want children but that women throughout history have been fed a diet of motherhood being what is most desired for them, of the pitiable spinster etc etc.

Exactly. The "biological urge" is primarily a desire to have sex which most human beings experience. The "urge to have children" is largely socially conditioning layered on top. IMHO.

BrownTableMat · 07/09/2023 09:06

What about those who are single and/or childfree not by choice? Do you consider them “less than”?

OutsideLookingOut · 07/09/2023 09:04

Pretty sure humans generally have a desire to have sex. It is mainly societal influence about an urge to have children. That does not mean people don’t want children but that women throughout history have been fed a diet of motherhood being what is most desired for them, of the pitiable spinster etc etc.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/09/2023 09:04

CurlewKate · 07/09/2023 08:57

I don't deny that this happens-because it's people's experience. And right wing politicians and newspapers have a repulsive "pro family" agenda because then they can be vile to lots of other people. But I had no children for the first 37 years of my life, and in general, women with children were regarded in the workplace as inconvenient- an issue to be managed. Successful women with children tended to try to act as if they didn't! And I have been to lots of social and work events in my life, and have very rarely been asked if I have children. The times I have it's just been a bit of small talk, akin to "Have you been on holiday this year?" I must have been lucky.

This is the nub of it really. Despite the massive advances for women in economic independence, society still largely sees it as the default setting for women to be at home caring for children and supported by a man.

We may have moved past the days where being a working mother is seen as morally wrong, but the whole infrastructure of society still assumes that a working mother is an inconvenience and failing both at being an employee and a mother.

Workplaces still regard the fact that employees have caring responsibilities as an irritant for other unencumbered employees (ie men) and something which holds them back in career advancement, something which is constantly reinforced by this bullshit "all back to the office" ideology and a myriad of other microaggressions against working mothers.

Obviously not all mothers want to work and that's absolutely fine by me. But as long as people continue to parrot out "family values": the idea that a marriage and children is the pinnacle of achievement for most women, these sorts of attitudes will continue to prevail.

CurlewKate · 07/09/2023 08:57

I don't deny that this happens-because it's people's experience. And right wing politicians and newspapers have a repulsive "pro family" agenda because then they can be vile to lots of other people. But I had no children for the first 37 years of my life, and in general, women with children were regarded in the workplace as inconvenient- an issue to be managed. Successful women with children tended to try to act as if they didn't! And I have been to lots of social and work events in my life, and have very rarely been asked if I have children. The times I have it's just been a bit of small talk, akin to "Have you been on holiday this year?" I must have been lucky.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/09/2023 08:50

Smartiepants79 · 07/09/2023 08:34

Well from an genetic/biological/evolutionary point of view it makes sense for most females (and males) to have a fairly strong urge to procreate. If they don’t, the species doesn’t survive.
Genetic variation and other factors such as upbringing and personality have meant that, in humans, it’s not uncommon for women to not have the urge to have a baby.
Don’t think you’d find many (any?) members of the animal kingdom actively choosing not to breed.

Again, though, what does this actually mean? Does this mean people actively want to reproduce? Or does it just mean they want to have sex?

Obviously males and females (when young) have a strong biological urge to have sex which is underpinned by an evolutionary drive to procreate. But how much of this is actively wanting to procreate as opposed to wanting to have sex because its fun?

Let's be honest the vast majority of young men aren't interested in having kids at all, they just want to have sex. Young women want sex too and in a lot of cases this is linked to a desire to start a family but in a lot of cases this may be socially expected or conditioned, as opposed to an actual bit of biological programming which says "I want to have children". I know a lot of women claim they have this strong urge to procreate and I'm sure a lot do experience it as such but I'm sceptical as to how much of this is biology vs social conditioning and want.

I don't know to what extent you can separate the two from an evolutionary standpoint.

munchmagic · 07/09/2023 08:48

Pleaselettheholidayend · 06/09/2023 15:45

I mean, I hear this the sort of sentiment you express a lot but I just don't think the fact that humans are social animals is ever going to change?
I get it, women should aim for more than marriage etc etc but the boring fact is a lot of people want intimate partnerships/to raise children/close ties to a community, usually of close friends and family?
Obviously this is more thorny in practice, especially for women, and can have many pitfalls and complications but I never why rugged individualism is supposed to be better/more evolved. Just would seem a bit shit and lonely at the end of your days.

Well said.

Smartiepants79 · 07/09/2023 08:36

And if you have and urge to have sex at all then that is your body telling you it’s wants to have a baby!
Your mind, and the fact that we now have reliable contraception, is overruling your body.

Smartiepants79 · 07/09/2023 08:34

Well from an genetic/biological/evolutionary point of view it makes sense for most females (and males) to have a fairly strong urge to procreate. If they don’t, the species doesn’t survive.
Genetic variation and other factors such as upbringing and personality have meant that, in humans, it’s not uncommon for women to not have the urge to have a baby.
Don’t think you’d find many (any?) members of the animal kingdom actively choosing not to breed.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/09/2023 08:15

Biologically she is correct. As is the case for all living things. The sole outcome of every lifecycle is to have offspring and pass on genetic material.
Humans have socially evolved so that the urge can be overcome by our brains, circumstances and other opportunities.
The biological urge is very strong though.
For the survival of a species it’s imperative to assume that all females want to breed and produce the next generation

That's probably true at an all population level: enough women have to have a biological urge to reproduce to push the species forward. I'm not sure what you mean by this though:

it’s imperative to assume that all females want to breed and produce the next generation

Do you mean all women have a biological urge to breed? I don't think that's true, tbh. I've never felt an "urge": I was distinctly 50/50 about whether to have kids at all. A lot of my friends feel the same tbh.

Some definitely know they want to be mothers but I think it's quite hard to pick apart how much of this is a genuine "biological urge" and how much is psychology, conditioning and expectation.

ie if you're one of these people who is desperate to pop out loads of kids from the age of about 17: is that biology or conditioning? Or indeed if you're someone who knows they don't ever want them. Would love to hear from anyone who actually understands biology.

thedevilinablackdress · 07/09/2023 08:12

Smartiepants79 · 07/09/2023 07:05

Biologically she is correct. As is the case for all living things. The sole outcome of every lifecycle is to have offspring and pass on genetic material.
Humans have socially evolved so that the urge can be overcome by our brains, circumstances and other opportunities.
The biological urge is very strong though.
For the survival of a species it’s imperative to assume that all females want to breed and produce the next generation.

I know that, and I suppose it partly explains the belief or innate feeling that doing so = 'success'.

Oblomov23 · 07/09/2023 07:44

"Instead of looking down on them?
Thinking they are less than."

I'm not looking down on anyone, who is choosing to be single or child free.

sammylady37 · 07/09/2023 07:42

Thing is - you're posting on mumsnet. Why?
They've only created a childfree board as it increases traffic

And, BINGO. We’re back to the ‘why are the childfree posting on mumsnet?’ comments. You missed an important bit tho, usually such posters capitalise the ‘MUMS’ bit to further the point they think they have.

FYI, people, parents or otherwise, post here because the discussion topics are wide and varied, the majority of them have sweet fuck all to do with parenting, and it’s one of the largest female-dominated spaces on the internet. And mumsnet HQ support the inclusion of all here, as long as they post within the guidelines.

Mumuser124 · 07/09/2023 07:40

@Defiantjazz

Well, we are fundamentally organisms so the sensible conclusion would be that it is a biological urge.

Your choice to not have children was a psychological decision. We are not simple organisms so I imagine this would would be enough to override the biological urge if you so choose.

OnedayTwodays · 07/09/2023 07:34

Shouldn’t there then be a big support for single and/or childfree people?

If they are ’lacking’ so much and are ’unhealthy’ because they don’t have these things?

Instead of looking down on them?
Thinking they are less than.

OP posts:
Defiantjazz · 07/09/2023 07:24

Biologically she is correct. As is the case for all living things. The sole outcome of every lifecycle is to have offspring and pass on genetic material.
Humans have socially evolved so that the urge can be overcome by our brains, circumstances and other opportunities.
The biological urge is very strong though.
For the survival of a species it’s imperative to assume that all females want to breed and produce the next generation

You don’t know the urge is biological though. It might be psychological. I wanted children when I was younger but when I realised/decided it probably wasn’t a good idea (for me) the urge went away never to return.

As for “the survival of the species” I don’t think population levels are at an all time low rn.

Defiantjazz · 07/09/2023 07:10

And there are lots of threads by people who are unhappily single and lonely, far more than threads started by people saying how much they love being single

Are there? I’ve seen some obviously but not “lots”.
There are more threads from women who are in unhappy, or worse, abusive relationships.

Smartiepants79 · 07/09/2023 07:05

thedevilinablackdress · 06/09/2023 15:31

You are joking?

If not I guess you haven't seen the Childfree board and the many male posters.

But, you are joking. Right??

Edited

Biologically she is correct. As is the case for all living things. The sole outcome of every lifecycle is to have offspring and pass on genetic material.
Humans have socially evolved so that the urge can be overcome by our brains, circumstances and other opportunities.
The biological urge is very strong though.
For the survival of a species it’s imperative to assume that all females want to breed and produce the next generation.

QwertyWitch · 07/09/2023 06:20

I know two people who are single and without children and they would love to be in relationships but it hasn't worked out for them. They're not desperate for children but they feel lonely and would have loved marriage.
Even health experts are recognising that loneliness is a health risk.
We are social beings and thrive in communities and with connections. If you don't have intimate connections then you need to rely on other connections especially those in your community. Those connections can't always fulfil all the needs someone has, especially if most around them aren't freely available due to their own intimate connections.