Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that we can't sort this ourselves without professional help - desperate situation

238 replies

phillers · 06/09/2023 11:39

Morning,

In a terrible situation. Years and years of poor communication and financial mismanagement have led us here. I am broken, ashamed and not sure if this is something that we can ever get out of. Terrified of losing our home

please be kind

Household Information[/b]
Number of adults in household........... 2
Number of children in household......... 2
Number of cars owned.................... 2[b]

Monthly Income Details[/b]
Monthly income after tax................ 4355
Partners monthly income after tax....... 2511
Benefits................................ 0
Other income............................ 250[b]
Total monthly income.................... 7116[/b][b]

Monthly Expense Details[/b]
Mortgage................................ 801
Secured/HP loan repayments.............. 386
Rent.................................... 0
Management charge (leasehold property).. 0
Council tax............................. 139
Electricity............................. 98
Gas..................................... 112
Oil..................................... 0
Water rates............................. 35
Telephone (land line)................... 0
Mobile phone............................ 67
TV Licence.............................. 13
Satellite/Cable TV...................... 36
Internet Services....................... 21
Groceries etc. ......................... 600
Clothing................................ 30
Petrol/diesel........................... 220
Road tax................................ 22
Car Insurance........................... 64
Car maintenance (including MOT)......... 30
Car parking............................. 0
Other travel............................ 0
Childcare/nursery....................... 0
Other child related expenses............ 120
Medical (prescriptions, dentist etc).... 9
Pet insurance/vet bills................. 28
Buildings insurance..................... 22
Contents insurance...................... 17
Life assurance ......................... 49
Other insurance......................... 9
Presents (birthday, christmas etc)...... 100
Haircuts................................ 20
Entertainment........................... 150
Holiday................................. 0
Emergency fund.......................... 100[b]
Total monthly expenses.................. 3298[/b]
[b]

Assets[/b]
Cash.................................... 0
House value (Gross)..................... 320000
Shares and bonds........................ 0
Car(s).................................. 14000
Other assets............................ 0[b]
Total Assets............................ 334000[/b]
[b]

Secured & HP Debts[/b]
Description....................Debt......Monthly...APR
Mortgage...................... 140098...(801)......4.11
Hire Purchase (HP) debt ...... 17000....(386)......0[b]
Total secured & HP debts...... 157098....-.........- [/b]

[b]Unsecured Debts[/b]
Description....................Debt......Monthly...APR
updraft loan...................21000.....360.......16.9
updraft loan 2.................8000......210.......18.9
Updraft loan 3.................6500......165.......18.9
overdraft......................2500......80........42
Creation Credit card...........7100......192.......21
very...........................700.......48........50
halifax cc.....................2400......24........0
fluid..........................3600......170.......39
LLoyds.........................3890......132.......8
HSBC loan......................7309......210.......7.9
Lloyds.........................10500.....269.......29
barclaycard platinum...........12600.....258.......4.9
barclaycard....................4960......109.......4.9
natwest........................2000......20........0[b]
Total unsecured debts..........93059.....2247......- [/b]

[b]
Monthly Budget Summary[/b]
Total monthly income.................... 7,116
Expenses (including HP & secured debts). 3,298
Available for debt repayments........... 3,818
Monthly UNsecured debt repayments....... 2,247[b]
Amount left after debt repayments....... 1,571[/b]

Cards are all cut up. No possibility of us moving to 0% right now as we have too much debt and are seen as high risk

Partner thinks that it's fixable if we budget properly and start on the highest interest debt. I wonder if we need professional help

AIBU to think that this is not fixable by simple budgeting

OP posts:
Sidslaw · 06/09/2023 14:10

Plenty of fat to trim, first and foremost can you sell one or both cars?

seems to be the biggest luxury on your list. save £338 a month - of course depends on what other travel expenses you would then have but £14000 straight into your debt

Cut your gas use, turn the thermostat right down and use jumpers instead, cool your hot water save £35

Mobile phone contract seems high - how many phones is that for? four? bring that down to £10 each, save £27

Get rid of satellite and cable tv £36
Bring groceries down to £400 ( save £200) and stop the hair cuts!(save £20) Do them yourself -

entertainment £150? What is that?

birthdays/christmas £100? that is £1200 a year, with 2 children that is £300 each for birthdays and for Christmas - cut that down to half. Save £50

Looks to me like hundreds of pounds of saving to be had -

yes, get in touch with step change or other debt charity, but there is so much you can do for yourself first

Dindundundundeeer · 06/09/2023 14:09

Please please please speak to the debt charities. They are going to at least be able to assure you that you are doing everything you can. This is going to hurt and by knowing 'it's the only way', will help you stick to this new money diet.

Also like a diet, you need some respite. If you have professional help you can have the odd treat within a proper plan, and it's also quantified.

My last piece of advice is change your mindset. This is not going 'without', but more securing your future and should be seen as positive.

Do not pay for any advice! Debt charities do not charge.

AuroraForever · 06/09/2023 14:09

Well done for facing up to the fact you have a problem and it needs to be dealt with. A lot of people don’t until it’s far too late.

A lot of good recommendations already especially talking to Stepchange. Even if you don’t go forward into a debt management plan it will be good for you to talk it over with them as it will give you someone to talk it through with and they are so so helpful, not judgy, and all decisions are yours.

Now is the time to create a solid plan of how you’re going to tackle it, set a realistic budget, bin off all the unnecessary overspending and get to work at clearing those debts. They are huge and it will be worrying but you have the means to get it under control. As you pay off each one close the account or cut up the card. Do whatever is necessary to stop you from adding more spends on.

Strongly recommend the moneysavingexpert website. It’s full of everything you need including how to set a budget, how to save money, template letters to creditors asking for interest to be stopped etc.

Very best of luck OP, you can do this.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 06/09/2023 14:08

Brighter people than me have worked out that you can pay your unsecured debt off in five or six years. However the issue for me is how you got into this position. Can you reverse that? If you’ve got a taste for luxury, can you develop a taste for frugality? If someone has a gambling problem, have then got help with it? And so on.

FunnysInLaJardin · 06/09/2023 14:07

DrSbaitso · 06/09/2023 14:04

It's the fear of losing your collateral.

if you consolidate and have lower payments the risk to your collateral is reduced as you have more spare cash and hence unlikely to default on your mortgage.

Obviously the caveat has to be to stop spending and don't build up more unsecured debt

BrandNewBicep · 06/09/2023 14:06

It does look like you have enough income to meet the payments, so with good budgeting you could sort this. CAP run an excellent budgeting course, also Dave Ramsey on YT is good, albeit a different approach. I do think it makes a difference as to how your debt accrued i.e. overspending on extras/luxuries. You will need to address that before you progress, but definitely doable. Good luck.

Whyemseeaye · 06/09/2023 14:05

www.ramseysolutions.com/dave-ramsey-7-baby-steps

Read this and then look up Dave Ramsey on YouTube.

It is a large mount but you have a good income. You may need professional help but you could make a good start by start a Debt Snowball.

I'd be calling up all my cards and explaining the difficulties you're having and they may freeze your interest

DrSbaitso · 06/09/2023 14:04

FunnysInLaJardin · 06/09/2023 14:03

I don't understand this fear of secured debt.

It makes complete financial sense to get rid of high interest debt with a lower fixed rate loan spread over the period of your mortgage.

It's the fear of losing your collateral.

FunnysInLaJardin · 06/09/2023 14:03

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/09/2023 13:10

Do not turn your unsecured debt into secured debt!

I don't understand this fear of secured debt.

It makes complete financial sense to get rid of high interest debt with a lower fixed rate loan spread over the period of your mortgage.

FallopianTubeTrain · 06/09/2023 14:03

Hi OP. Sorry you have found yourself here, money worries can be overwhelmingly stressful.

The advice so far on this thread ranges from excellent to awful. I would post again on the money matters board. The support there is more focused and knowledgeable and dragged me out of a horrible hole once.

For what it's worth I agree with those recommending Dave Ramsey, his approach is solid even if he is a little preachy and out of touch at times. I'd recommend

  1. Go through your current outgoings and cut what you really don't need to spend. Be ruthless in sticking to your new monthly budget.
  1. Put a nominal amount away for emergencies. Never ever touch it unless dire need strikes that threatens basic living e.g. broken car to get to work, heating repairs.
  1. Tackle the debts in turn smallest to largest using the snowball technique. Some do it based on interest rate highest to lowest but others find it really helps keep the momentum going to see things being paid off and out of your life.

The hardest part is sticking to your budget. I keep a spreadsheet and at the start of each day I write down yesterday's spending. I can tell you how much we have left in the budget for the month and what bills are left to go out at any given time and thats in the back of my mind when I'm considering any spending. It's taken a lot of practice to get here but it's a habit that got me out of a payday loan spiral just to cover interest on other debts 10 years ago to no debt other than my mortgage today.

It is doable. Also to add, your whole family need to be with you and pulling together to make it work.

Abouttimemum · 06/09/2023 14:01

StatisticallyChallenged · 06/09/2023 13:46

I don't disagree with remortgaging in general however the reality is that even if you declare it as being for consolidation you might struggle with not just this amount of debt but with so many debts. It's worth investigating but I'd look for a very good broker and only do it if you are absolutely sure you have the discipline to keep overpaying it.

Without remortgaging, I would start with the highest interest debt. According to your table that's Very, then the overdraft (also good to clear these as they don't look good on credit file)

So it looks something like this (I'm doing this quickly so there will be a bit of variation here, I'm not doing full calcs to work out the exact monthly interest being added)

Month 1: Very £700 (additional 652), Overdraft £928 (additional £848)

Month 2: Your excess in now £1548 (as you cleared Very). Overdraft should be around £1600ish, so you will be able to clear this completely once you include the £80 normal payment

Month 3: Excess now 1500+48+80 = £1628. Time to tackle Fluid. It gets £1628+170 = £1798

Month 4 = same again. That's Fluid cleared, plus possibly a little spare to throw at Lloyds

Month 5: excess is now £1798. Time to tackle a big one, Lloyds. It's going to get a payment of £1798 + the usual 269 = 2067. It'll be gone in 4-5 months as you will have paid a little off in months 1-4 already

Once Lloyds (bigger one) is clear then you've got £2067 spare. The next month you throw that all at the Creation credit card. Given you will have already made some payments to it in months 1-9 it will have reduced a little from the 7100, so you'll probably get rid of it in 3 months.

So by the end of year 1 you should be able to get rid of:
Very (£700)
Overdraft (£2500)
Fluid (£3600)
Lloyds (£10500)
Creation (£7100)

That's £24,400 cleared totally in year 1, roughly. Plus the others will have reduced a bit

Now you go in to year 2. But now you've got £1500+£48(Very payment)+£80 (overdraft payment)+£170 (Fluid payment)+£269(Lloyds)+£192(creation) = £2259 spare to throw at debts.

If your updraft loans have front loaded interest (pretty common) then you should find that as you get close to the end of those you can ask for a settlement so you might not have to pay quite as much as the current balance. But you'll get through the first one (number 3) in about 2 months given you'll have made the regular payments for a year. Then you've got £2424 spare. Updraft 2 is done in 3 months tops.

You can see how this goes from there. You don't have to stick that order exactly, for example you might find it mentally better to wipe out a few smaller ones next before tackling updraft 1 even though it's a higher rate. That's ok within reason as you need to find the motivation to keep going.

This is excellent advice!

shivawn · 06/09/2023 13:58

I can see why you're feeling overwhelmed just by looking at the sheer number of debts you have. That's quite a list!

Your budget looks good to me. Is this a new budget? Or have your wages increased? You obviously wouldn't be in debt if you had been on this budget and income all along. I have Ben guilty myself of making up very thorough and reasonable budgets and then loosing track and not sticking to them. Are you sure you're not spending any of the 1500 surplus every month.

For what it's worth, we're on a similar take home income and our monthly mortgage payment is 2.5 times higher than yours. You have good take-home pay, a low mortgage payment and a good surplus every month to tackle debt with so I don't think your situation is completely dire. I would tackle each debt one by one as others have suggested while continuing to pay the minimum on the rest.

JackyinaTracky · 06/09/2023 13:56

I would also not recommend extending your mortgage to pay off the debt (assuming you would even pass the criteria) unless
you have 100% addressed how the debts arose or you will end up back where you are but with more mortgage debt on top.

Trevorton · 06/09/2023 13:55

Icycloud · 06/09/2023 12:17

You get 7k a month after tax. Your mortgage is 800 and other basic living expenses low. I don’t feel sorry for you at all

Can you point me to the line in the OP where she is asking for us to feel sorry for her? It’s just that I’ve read it multiple times and I still can’t find it.. 🤷‍♀️

whatkatydid2013 · 06/09/2023 13:51

The thing is you need to understand if you are really spending what you list above. If you really are now I assume you’ve already made big changes vs when you accrued the debt. If this is just a plan you need to actually do it for a while and strictly track your spending to check it’s achievable

PleaseUseTheSanitaryBinsProvided · 06/09/2023 13:51

DrSbaitso · 06/09/2023 12:41

They are utter arseholes. Yes, people should be responsible with their money but once you, the lender, with the power to go to court and ruin someone to get your money back, can see the person isn't a good lending risk, you need to stop offering them more and more. You may not be responsible for their spending but you can refrain from exploiting their situation to get them in even worse trouble knowing it'll all result in more made-up money (credit) for you. You know someone in dire straits is in a vulnerable position when you offer them yet more credit that will give them a little temporary relief that's hard to resist under that kind of stress.

It's outrageous that they don't seem to apply the usual lending risk rules to cards. It's supposed to protect both borrower and lender.

They’re like drug dealers

JackyinaTracky · 06/09/2023 13:50

This is totally achievable OP. But as already said above I think you need to be honest with yourselves about how the debt arose and address that, then cut even more from your budget and channel that extra money to debt repayment.
if it were me I’d try and start with small but high interest and try and get those paid off asap. You could have 3 or 4 crossed off your list by Christmas and that would feel great!
Then snowball the payments from those debts plus the excess in your budget into the next one.
with a bit of trimming from your monthly spends you could easily put over 20k extra a year to paying off those debts (and that doesn’t even include selling a car) You could be debt free in 3 or 4 years. It will be tough and you will need to stay focused but it is more than achievable.
good luck, you will feel amazing when you get to the other side.

FFSWhatToDoNow · 06/09/2023 13:47

More than 4 weeks in a month - your maths is broken.

StatisticallyChallenged · 06/09/2023 13:46

I don't disagree with remortgaging in general however the reality is that even if you declare it as being for consolidation you might struggle with not just this amount of debt but with so many debts. It's worth investigating but I'd look for a very good broker and only do it if you are absolutely sure you have the discipline to keep overpaying it.

Without remortgaging, I would start with the highest interest debt. According to your table that's Very, then the overdraft (also good to clear these as they don't look good on credit file)

So it looks something like this (I'm doing this quickly so there will be a bit of variation here, I'm not doing full calcs to work out the exact monthly interest being added)

Month 1: Very £700 (additional 652), Overdraft £928 (additional £848)

Month 2: Your excess in now £1548 (as you cleared Very). Overdraft should be around £1600ish, so you will be able to clear this completely once you include the £80 normal payment

Month 3: Excess now 1500+48+80 = £1628. Time to tackle Fluid. It gets £1628+170 = £1798

Month 4 = same again. That's Fluid cleared, plus possibly a little spare to throw at Lloyds

Month 5: excess is now £1798. Time to tackle a big one, Lloyds. It's going to get a payment of £1798 + the usual 269 = 2067. It'll be gone in 4-5 months as you will have paid a little off in months 1-4 already

Once Lloyds (bigger one) is clear then you've got £2067 spare. The next month you throw that all at the Creation credit card. Given you will have already made some payments to it in months 1-9 it will have reduced a little from the 7100, so you'll probably get rid of it in 3 months.

So by the end of year 1 you should be able to get rid of:
Very (£700)
Overdraft (£2500)
Fluid (£3600)
Lloyds (£10500)
Creation (£7100)

That's £24,400 cleared totally in year 1, roughly. Plus the others will have reduced a bit

Now you go in to year 2. But now you've got £1500+£48(Very payment)+£80 (overdraft payment)+£170 (Fluid payment)+£269(Lloyds)+£192(creation) = £2259 spare to throw at debts.

If your updraft loans have front loaded interest (pretty common) then you should find that as you get close to the end of those you can ask for a settlement so you might not have to pay quite as much as the current balance. But you'll get through the first one (number 3) in about 2 months given you'll have made the regular payments for a year. Then you've got £2424 spare. Updraft 2 is done in 3 months tops.

You can see how this goes from there. You don't have to stick that order exactly, for example you might find it mentally better to wipe out a few smaller ones next before tackling updraft 1 even though it's a higher rate. That's ok within reason as you need to find the motivation to keep going.

PleaseUseTheSanitaryBinsProvided · 06/09/2023 13:45

Wakeywake · 06/09/2023 12:29

Would you be able to access a bank loan? Rates are around 6% at the moment, it would allow you to pay off some of the higher interest credit cards.

OP is unlikely to get a personal loan as a bank won’t want to take on the risk of this other debt with other creditors.

Happened to me. A DMP saved my sanity.

Abouttimemum · 06/09/2023 13:45

With £1,500 spare every month I feel like I’m completely missing something other than the fact you’ve made a mess of your finances but now you’re sorting it out and still have spare cash left over?

Anyway. No options to overpay? Tackle the biggest APRs first maybe. Otherwise loads you can do with that £1,500 to make the overall picture much better.

mrsm43s · 06/09/2023 13:45

Surely if you throw your "spare" £1500/month at your £93k debt, then you'll have paid it off in 93/1.5=62 months -so just a bit over 5 years? Presumably quite a bit quicker than that, as the monthly debt servicing amount will drop as you pay it off, so you can pay more off the capital of the debts each month?

You might need help with managing your attitudes towards money etc, as you've obviously made bad decisions in the past, but you've done a budget with a reasonable amount of slack in it, and can pay down your debt by a big chunk monthly, so I think the mechanics of paying it off are simple enough - you just need to stick to your budget and accept that there isn't money available for frivolous spends. I suspect that will mean adjusting your lifestyle quite significantly.

I'm not really sure what "help" you want?

5monthmama · 06/09/2023 13:43

I think I'd be tempted to sell the house settle all debt which would leave you with a good deposit still and start again but that's just because it would really stress me out. I do.tgunk it's possible to sort out over time though.
I would probably seek some professional advice because you may be able to consolidate it all in some way. Good luck with it.

BarleySugars · 06/09/2023 13:42

Not being an expert, from these figures I think you can do it but it wont be quick, and the snowball method is your friend. You can def scale back those groceries, we are a family of 3 and get EVERYTHING household out of 500/mo max - food, takeaways, cleaning products,dog food for 2 dogs and toiletries.... Bulk buy! Put everyone on the same shampoo and conditioner and buy 5l tubs etc

Pizzanight · 06/09/2023 13:40

That is alot of debt OP but seems manageable. I would take advise into consolidating your debts. My issue would be that you have accumulated these debts so without an accepted life style change they will continue to grow as something most see as a luxury you may consider a need. Or something most save up for you want immediately.

If I was advising someone I would say consider reducing down to one car. Is this possible?

You pay £386 per month in HP. Are all of the items necessary or can they be returned?

Phone contacts can be stopped and move to pay as you go.

£36 a month on TV is unnecessary, get free view.

What are the child expenses of £120 a month? Are they necessary?

You cannot afford £100 per month on presents, that is £1200 a year a small budget for each DC a year and stop the rest altogether.

Entertainment £150 per month, that needs to be stopped whilst paying off debt is prioritised.