Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that we can't sort this ourselves without professional help - desperate situation

238 replies

phillers · 06/09/2023 11:39

Morning,

In a terrible situation. Years and years of poor communication and financial mismanagement have led us here. I am broken, ashamed and not sure if this is something that we can ever get out of. Terrified of losing our home

please be kind

Household Information[/b]
Number of adults in household........... 2
Number of children in household......... 2
Number of cars owned.................... 2[b]

Monthly Income Details[/b]
Monthly income after tax................ 4355
Partners monthly income after tax....... 2511
Benefits................................ 0
Other income............................ 250[b]
Total monthly income.................... 7116[/b][b]

Monthly Expense Details[/b]
Mortgage................................ 801
Secured/HP loan repayments.............. 386
Rent.................................... 0
Management charge (leasehold property).. 0
Council tax............................. 139
Electricity............................. 98
Gas..................................... 112
Oil..................................... 0
Water rates............................. 35
Telephone (land line)................... 0
Mobile phone............................ 67
TV Licence.............................. 13
Satellite/Cable TV...................... 36
Internet Services....................... 21
Groceries etc. ......................... 600
Clothing................................ 30
Petrol/diesel........................... 220
Road tax................................ 22
Car Insurance........................... 64
Car maintenance (including MOT)......... 30
Car parking............................. 0
Other travel............................ 0
Childcare/nursery....................... 0
Other child related expenses............ 120
Medical (prescriptions, dentist etc).... 9
Pet insurance/vet bills................. 28
Buildings insurance..................... 22
Contents insurance...................... 17
Life assurance ......................... 49
Other insurance......................... 9
Presents (birthday, christmas etc)...... 100
Haircuts................................ 20
Entertainment........................... 150
Holiday................................. 0
Emergency fund.......................... 100[b]
Total monthly expenses.................. 3298[/b]
[b]

Assets[/b]
Cash.................................... 0
House value (Gross)..................... 320000
Shares and bonds........................ 0
Car(s).................................. 14000
Other assets............................ 0[b]
Total Assets............................ 334000[/b]
[b]

Secured & HP Debts[/b]
Description....................Debt......Monthly...APR
Mortgage...................... 140098...(801)......4.11
Hire Purchase (HP) debt ...... 17000....(386)......0[b]
Total secured & HP debts...... 157098....-.........- [/b]

[b]Unsecured Debts[/b]
Description....................Debt......Monthly...APR
updraft loan...................21000.....360.......16.9
updraft loan 2.................8000......210.......18.9
Updraft loan 3.................6500......165.......18.9
overdraft......................2500......80........42
Creation Credit card...........7100......192.......21
very...........................700.......48........50
halifax cc.....................2400......24........0
fluid..........................3600......170.......39
LLoyds.........................3890......132.......8
HSBC loan......................7309......210.......7.9
Lloyds.........................10500.....269.......29
barclaycard platinum...........12600.....258.......4.9
barclaycard....................4960......109.......4.9
natwest........................2000......20........0[b]
Total unsecured debts..........93059.....2247......- [/b]

[b]
Monthly Budget Summary[/b]
Total monthly income.................... 7,116
Expenses (including HP & secured debts). 3,298
Available for debt repayments........... 3,818
Monthly UNsecured debt repayments....... 2,247[b]
Amount left after debt repayments....... 1,571[/b]

Cards are all cut up. No possibility of us moving to 0% right now as we have too much debt and are seen as high risk

Partner thinks that it's fixable if we budget properly and start on the highest interest debt. I wonder if we need professional help

AIBU to think that this is not fixable by simple budgeting

OP posts:
StatisticallyChallenged · 06/09/2023 15:01

A few people have commented on there being some fat in your budget to trim. I didn't suggest cutting it - because I think that will be the breathing space to let you stick to cutting back. Given the debt you've run up it's obviously already a big drop from what you've been spending.

I'd make sure that your budget is really liveable so that you don't end up dipping back in to the credit cards. This is a lot of debt and it's going to take you several years to clear - it needs to be achievable. Crash diets are very hard to maintain and the same is true of financial diets. It has to be sustainable.

If you get to month end abd you've not used all your budget then great, whack it on a debt. But you're not facing bankruptcy or an IVA yet.

Chippy4me · 06/09/2023 14:59

I agree with the PP.

Do you actually need 2 cars or does 1 spend most of its time on the drive?

If one of you is WFH or works locally, then there’s no need for 2 cars.

Chippy4me · 06/09/2023 14:57

You do have enough income to sort this out without outside help but I don’t think you should.

One or both of you are obviously very bad with money which is why you’re in this mess and that’s not just going to go away.

One or both of you may lose your jobs which will also mean you get less income.

You may also separate.

I would go to someone like stepchange and take out a debt consolidation loan.

The interest you’ll be paying on each of your debts must be extortionate.

Going through a special company will freeze the interest and allow you to try and get back on top of things.

I would also work out how you came to be in this situation.

phillers · 06/09/2023 14:50

GasPanic · 06/09/2023 14:40

I think it is do-able. One issue is how long you have that 4.4% mortgage for, as if you have to remortgage on a higher rate that could take up a big chunk of the spare money.

You need to cut out all the luxuries, reduce your discretionary spend as much as possible and go cold turkey for at least a couple of years to make inroads into the unsecured debt. The good news is the 93K of unsecured debt must have bought you a hell of a lot of stuff, so you won't be needing anything new for a few years.

Thanksfully we are fixed for 4 more years.

OP posts:
DollyDabble · 06/09/2023 14:44

Your statement of affairs looks like it is from a monney saving forum, have you asked the same question there? Snowballing would be useful for your credit card debt, unless you look at why and what you spent the money on, then it wont stop it happening again. Look at the debt free diaries and debt free challenges for ideas.

wannabetraveler · 06/09/2023 14:42

You've had lots of practical advice but I wanted to add - debt is a financial problem, not a moral weakness. Don't feel shame. It's not useful and it'll just grind you down. You acknowledge the situation you're in and you're going to get out of it. You'll get there.

Livinginanotherworld · 06/09/2023 14:42

I would try and consolidate all the unsecured debt into one, possible by remortgage or lower interest rate bank loan secured against the house, you are probably paying ridiculous amounts of high interest every month and getting nowhere.

MumLass · 06/09/2023 14:40

Have you considered selling your cars? Do you need 2? Buy one runabout (or 2). You can get a half decent runabout for about £1500. Buy 2, gain £11000 to pay of more than 10% of your unsecured debt?

GasPanic · 06/09/2023 14:40

I think it is do-able. One issue is how long you have that 4.4% mortgage for, as if you have to remortgage on a higher rate that could take up a big chunk of the spare money.

You need to cut out all the luxuries, reduce your discretionary spend as much as possible and go cold turkey for at least a couple of years to make inroads into the unsecured debt. The good news is the 93K of unsecured debt must have bought you a hell of a lot of stuff, so you won't be needing anything new for a few years.

ActDottie · 06/09/2023 14:35

How da f*ck you get that much debt! Your income is very healthy and your mortgage small!!!

Ofc you can pay it off you’ve got £1500 a month spare after paying off the unsecured debt. It’ll take time but doable.

Mulhollandmagoo · 06/09/2023 14:34

Looking at what you have put in your OP, you should be ok, you have £1500ish left over? Is this spent at the end of the month or are you saving ? Throw this at your debts each month, the quicker you pay, the better your credit rating will be and you will be able to move to 0%.

You do need to budget, tightly, as in live like paupers and you will be able to do it, cancel all of your TV subs, no entertainment money, very limited Christmas and birthdays and any savings you have need to pay off your debts. Can you manage with one car? If so get rid of the second one, you can sell it back to a dealership and they will pay your finance off and gibe you the difference in value if your car is half decent, again spare money to pay some debt off.

You could consider and IVA, but this will destroy your credit rating for a very long time, but it would clear some debt down, so it depends on which you would prefer.

The PP who asked why you were in debt has a really good point, as this will determine the advice you get - as it is what will need to change to get you out of debt and keep you out of debt.

bigredboat · 06/09/2023 14:34

If you racked up the debt on 'stuff' rather than 'experiences' can you have a ruthless clear out and sell on Vinted/Facebook marketplace? Do you really need 2 cars?

Coachvikki · 06/09/2023 14:31

A lot of people seem to be focusing on how you are going to pay this debt off, which is understandable, but with an 'on paper' surplus of £1.5k that is very doable. However, as a couple of people have touched on, to really get control of your situation and be able to stick to this 'on paper' budget, you need to understand how you got here in the first place.

You need to document your actual spending over the last few months. If you have built up debt, then you don't have a surplus, you have a deficit. Start by writing up a list of what you spend on, then go through all of the 'non essentials' and come up with a plan of how you are going to avoid spending these. Non essentials are different for everyone and you need to understand what yours are. I used to work in debt recovery when I was younger and I spent a lot of time setting repayment plans for people. They would always say they would give up smoking to pay off their debt, but I knew they wouldn't. No one does. So if I included that in the repayment plan it would just fail and they would be in a worse position. Be realistic about what you can give up and come up with plans on how you will avoid spending on the things you can give up.

For instance, if you end up paying for takeaways because you are too tired to cook, that decision is hard to control in the minute when you are tired and the kids are hungry. I think saving money or paying off debt is different when you have a lot of money coming in. It takes a different mindset. It is harder to deny yourself things when you have a lot of money coming in as it seems reasonable.

Don't beat yourself up about how you got here. It is not heathly and it is not helpful., but understanding it will help you avoid it in the future.

Best of luck.

Purplebunnie · 06/09/2023 14:30

Council tax - are payments spread over 10 months or 12 - some Councils will allow you to change to paying over 12 so that would be £116/month instead of £139 so an extra £23/month to pay extra off one of the debts.

If you stay at 10 months on those months you don't pay Council tax use the extra £139 x 2 to pay extra off one of your debts.

It's peanuts I know but to quote a well know phrase "every little helps"

Dagnabit · 06/09/2023 14:29

It’s an awful lot of debt but luckily, you both earn well and have excess money once your bills and basic debt repayments are made - lots don’t have that. I would list them in priority order and use the excess money to clear the top one then move on down. You can also shave some off your monthly expenses quite easily. Lots of free help out there but they do tend to be busy so you may have to wait for an appointment.

DuchessOfWonderland · 06/09/2023 14:28

The core income vs monthly expenses section is fine enough.

  1. What is the hire purchase? Cars? Can you close that out and just buy a cheap 2nd hand car?
  2. Credit card debts. If you can't do a balance transfer to get onto a cheaper rate, then 2step plan of action: a. Pay off some low balance cards, so it psychologically reduces the number of cards you owe on. B. Start paying down the highest interest rate cards, even if it means you reduce monthly savings a bit or squeeze on some monthly entertainment non-mandatory expenses for a few months
skyeisthelimit · 06/09/2023 14:27

I recommend these people - https://www.stepchange.org/

You do need to make some massive lifestyle adjustments and it is a short sharp shock that you need.

You might be able to re-mortgage the house to clear off all the debts, as the mortgage interest rate would be lower than the credit cards, but you should take professional advice on that.

Your budget should include essentials that you absolutely cannot exist without.

Cancel the sky tv and any other tv packages.

Get basic SIM only deals when your mobile contracts end

£150 a month on entertainment? You can't afford "entertainment" with that much debt

£100 a month emergency fund - you can't afford to save with that much debt.

Clothing - only buy when something falls apart

Kids clubs - they can't go if you can't afford them.

Credit card - never ever get them again.

You only accrue this much debt when you live beyond your means (assuming no gambling addiction etc).

It is a simple fact that you really can't afford luxuries and the nice things in life if you can't afford it. There are a lot of people out there who have had to tighten their belts and make cut backs.

Things like Sky tv aren't a necessity they are a luxury that not everyone can afford.

I saw somebody once build up £40K worth of debt. Their parent bailed them out to stop them going bankrupt. They then built up another £40K of debt and did go bankrupt and that included the loan from the parent. It was shocking.

https://www.stepchange.org

TattiePants · 06/09/2023 14:25

StatisticallyChallenged · 06/09/2023 13:46

I don't disagree with remortgaging in general however the reality is that even if you declare it as being for consolidation you might struggle with not just this amount of debt but with so many debts. It's worth investigating but I'd look for a very good broker and only do it if you are absolutely sure you have the discipline to keep overpaying it.

Without remortgaging, I would start with the highest interest debt. According to your table that's Very, then the overdraft (also good to clear these as they don't look good on credit file)

So it looks something like this (I'm doing this quickly so there will be a bit of variation here, I'm not doing full calcs to work out the exact monthly interest being added)

Month 1: Very £700 (additional 652), Overdraft £928 (additional £848)

Month 2: Your excess in now £1548 (as you cleared Very). Overdraft should be around £1600ish, so you will be able to clear this completely once you include the £80 normal payment

Month 3: Excess now 1500+48+80 = £1628. Time to tackle Fluid. It gets £1628+170 = £1798

Month 4 = same again. That's Fluid cleared, plus possibly a little spare to throw at Lloyds

Month 5: excess is now £1798. Time to tackle a big one, Lloyds. It's going to get a payment of £1798 + the usual 269 = 2067. It'll be gone in 4-5 months as you will have paid a little off in months 1-4 already

Once Lloyds (bigger one) is clear then you've got £2067 spare. The next month you throw that all at the Creation credit card. Given you will have already made some payments to it in months 1-9 it will have reduced a little from the 7100, so you'll probably get rid of it in 3 months.

So by the end of year 1 you should be able to get rid of:
Very (£700)
Overdraft (£2500)
Fluid (£3600)
Lloyds (£10500)
Creation (£7100)

That's £24,400 cleared totally in year 1, roughly. Plus the others will have reduced a bit

Now you go in to year 2. But now you've got £1500+£48(Very payment)+£80 (overdraft payment)+£170 (Fluid payment)+£269(Lloyds)+£192(creation) = £2259 spare to throw at debts.

If your updraft loans have front loaded interest (pretty common) then you should find that as you get close to the end of those you can ask for a settlement so you might not have to pay quite as much as the current balance. But you'll get through the first one (number 3) in about 2 months given you'll have made the regular payments for a year. Then you've got £2424 spare. Updraft 2 is done in 3 months tops.

You can see how this goes from there. You don't have to stick that order exactly, for example you might find it mentally better to wipe out a few smaller ones next before tackling updraft 1 even though it's a higher rate. That's ok within reason as you need to find the motivation to keep going.

I'm also going to repost this excellent advice. OP if you only take one piece of advice from this thread then make it this one. There's also some possible savings in your monthly spend. Can you try to get your food bills down from £600 per month, can you reduce subscriptions and entertainment, presents only for the kids? Is there anything that you don't use that you can sell? It may seem daunting but making a plan and sticking to it is achievable and as each debt is paid off, you should feel very relieved.

Papillon23 · 06/09/2023 14:24

Get yourself over to Money Saving Expert.com's debt free wannabes forum, and also call stepchange. You need to look at all options to get the interest frozen even if that's bad for your credit score I think, as the interest on that lot will be enormous. But that means making sure your mortgage is set up and stable. StepChange will be a good set of people to call, or Christian's Against Poverty.

Maneattraction · 06/09/2023 14:24

You have some really good advice on here from people.

Speak to step change

Look at Meaningful Money, and listen to the podcasts on how to get out of debt.

Look at Dave Ramsey and how to get out of debt.

Pick your method once you’ve explored the above, stick to it and make your self accountable.

Cut back where you can on food, utilities and your other spending etc. I’m not going to question your current amount of expenses, but sometimes you can cut back further if you shop around.

Use YNAB to log everything.

You CAN do this. You have the means, you have accepted the position you are in and are willingly to put the effort in.

Gh12345 · 06/09/2023 14:20

@StatisticallyChallenged this is exactly what I would do and very good advice.

Florencefox · 06/09/2023 14:20

Lots of sound advice on this thread but are you really being honest to yourselves? I say this as I can see on paper you have £1500 left over each month but you also have an overdraft of £2500 which you could/ would easily & quickly clear if you had £1500 left over each month.

Plus if you had £1500 left over each month this would have been accumulating each month …… so I would suggest you also look as to why this isn’t the case to date & what this is being spent on. If you base your recovery plan on this but it’s not really there, you’ll get into a worse position.

I do think you need support with this as you have a good income but it would appear a spending habit as well and all habits are difficult to break but not impossible. Good luck, I hope you do well in reducing the debt.

Justkeepsmilingx · 06/09/2023 14:19

Get some free advice from a registered debt advice service.

They are free and can offer various ways to help. Often these are run locally - The Salvation Army run some, some Offices of Fair Trading - Google and find one by you but don’t go to one that charges a fee.

There maybe an option to write to the people you owe non priority debts to and get them to reduce or hold the interest for a period of time to help get you on top of things abit.

Drop everything you don’t need such as entertainment channels, days out.

Try to sell things on market place you don’t use and put the money towards your debts straight away.

Drop a brand when shopping - shops own only.

Try to use the cash stuffing method if you think it will help to budget - google it.

Make sure you service your priority debts - mortgage and anything borrowed against your home / government owing def. Council tax / gas / electric.

But definitely ask for free debt or budgeting advice. You are far from the only one in this situation.

CherryPieMadness · 06/09/2023 14:15

You’ve got to move that debt to low or zero interest that’s the first thing. Are you sure you can’t get a 0% card?

If not, then a loan is an option but you can’t miss payments.

I’d also look into downsizing if you could with the house?
Or remortgaging and then you can put that debt into the house to make it more manageaable.

So moving the debt to

  • mortgage
  • lower interest

Is first. Then you can pay off over time.

Alexalee · 06/09/2023 14:13

You have plenty of equity, why can't you remortgage to consolidate the 90k. Would then give you a 230k mortgage on a 320k house.