Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that we can't sort this ourselves without professional help - desperate situation

238 replies

phillers · 06/09/2023 11:39

Morning,

In a terrible situation. Years and years of poor communication and financial mismanagement have led us here. I am broken, ashamed and not sure if this is something that we can ever get out of. Terrified of losing our home

please be kind

Household Information[/b]
Number of adults in household........... 2
Number of children in household......... 2
Number of cars owned.................... 2[b]

Monthly Income Details[/b]
Monthly income after tax................ 4355
Partners monthly income after tax....... 2511
Benefits................................ 0
Other income............................ 250[b]
Total monthly income.................... 7116[/b][b]

Monthly Expense Details[/b]
Mortgage................................ 801
Secured/HP loan repayments.............. 386
Rent.................................... 0
Management charge (leasehold property).. 0
Council tax............................. 139
Electricity............................. 98
Gas..................................... 112
Oil..................................... 0
Water rates............................. 35
Telephone (land line)................... 0
Mobile phone............................ 67
TV Licence.............................. 13
Satellite/Cable TV...................... 36
Internet Services....................... 21
Groceries etc. ......................... 600
Clothing................................ 30
Petrol/diesel........................... 220
Road tax................................ 22
Car Insurance........................... 64
Car maintenance (including MOT)......... 30
Car parking............................. 0
Other travel............................ 0
Childcare/nursery....................... 0
Other child related expenses............ 120
Medical (prescriptions, dentist etc).... 9
Pet insurance/vet bills................. 28
Buildings insurance..................... 22
Contents insurance...................... 17
Life assurance ......................... 49
Other insurance......................... 9
Presents (birthday, christmas etc)...... 100
Haircuts................................ 20
Entertainment........................... 150
Holiday................................. 0
Emergency fund.......................... 100[b]
Total monthly expenses.................. 3298[/b]
[b]

Assets[/b]
Cash.................................... 0
House value (Gross)..................... 320000
Shares and bonds........................ 0
Car(s).................................. 14000
Other assets............................ 0[b]
Total Assets............................ 334000[/b]
[b]

Secured & HP Debts[/b]
Description....................Debt......Monthly...APR
Mortgage...................... 140098...(801)......4.11
Hire Purchase (HP) debt ...... 17000....(386)......0[b]
Total secured & HP debts...... 157098....-.........- [/b]

[b]Unsecured Debts[/b]
Description....................Debt......Monthly...APR
updraft loan...................21000.....360.......16.9
updraft loan 2.................8000......210.......18.9
Updraft loan 3.................6500......165.......18.9
overdraft......................2500......80........42
Creation Credit card...........7100......192.......21
very...........................700.......48........50
halifax cc.....................2400......24........0
fluid..........................3600......170.......39
LLoyds.........................3890......132.......8
HSBC loan......................7309......210.......7.9
Lloyds.........................10500.....269.......29
barclaycard platinum...........12600.....258.......4.9
barclaycard....................4960......109.......4.9
natwest........................2000......20........0[b]
Total unsecured debts..........93059.....2247......- [/b]

[b]
Monthly Budget Summary[/b]
Total monthly income.................... 7,116
Expenses (including HP & secured debts). 3,298
Available for debt repayments........... 3,818
Monthly UNsecured debt repayments....... 2,247[b]
Amount left after debt repayments....... 1,571[/b]

Cards are all cut up. No possibility of us moving to 0% right now as we have too much debt and are seen as high risk

Partner thinks that it's fixable if we budget properly and start on the highest interest debt. I wonder if we need professional help

AIBU to think that this is not fixable by simple budgeting

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AliceOlive · 07/09/2023 20:07

Yep, I just think it takes a major mentality shift to clear that kind of debt.

The debt snowball sounded really stupid to me. Of course it’s smarter to pay off higher APR debt first. But I went to a series of Dave Ramsey classes and it’s difficult to argue with the results he is producing. It’s not for everyone and in fact, not really perfect for my exact situation at the time I attended. (Single woman, hitting retirement savings super hard and getting a great match, with some unusual external factors.)

But I’ve proven to myself repeatedly (paying off then again building up some cc debt) that what is logical is not the same as what’s likely to help me succeed.

OneHornedFlyingPurplePeopleEater · 07/09/2023 18:59

AliceOlive · 07/09/2023 17:05

https://www.moneysupermarket.com/credit-cards/overpaying-a-credit-card/

Credit card "overpayment" means something and it's not "paying more than the minimum.", even in the UK.

If someone is mentally telling themselves that paying more than the minimum on a credit card is doing over and above the expected, they are not likely to pay down as quickly as they could.

Plenty of people believe that the psychology is relevant to paying off debt. I didn't make this up myself.

OK, while I get your point, I don't think that's what anyone here was saying.

'Higher than minimum' doesn't really roll off the tongue. Plenty of people here suggesting OP pays higher than minimum payments to get debt cleared ASAP. Just because they've used the wrong word for it doesn't make it bad advise.

AliceOlive · 07/09/2023 17:05

https://www.moneysupermarket.com/credit-cards/overpaying-a-credit-card/

Credit card "overpayment" means something and it's not "paying more than the minimum.", even in the UK.

If someone is mentally telling themselves that paying more than the minimum on a credit card is doing over and above the expected, they are not likely to pay down as quickly as they could.

Plenty of people believe that the psychology is relevant to paying off debt. I didn't make this up myself.

OneHornedFlyingPurplePeopleEater · 07/09/2023 16:39

AliceOlive · 07/09/2023 16:14

What single word do you personally use for only paying the minimum?

Minimum

AliceOlive · 07/09/2023 16:14

OneHornedFlyingPurplePeopleEater · 07/09/2023 15:53

@AliceOlive as you're the expert, what word would you suggest everyone uses to describe a payment that is above the mimium monthly payment?

What single word do you personally use for only paying the minimum?

OneHornedFlyingPurplePeopleEater · 07/09/2023 15:53

@AliceOlive as you're the expert, what word would you suggest everyone uses to describe a payment that is above the mimium monthly payment?

AliceOlive · 07/09/2023 15:41

OneHornedFlyingPurplePeopleEater · 07/09/2023 14:44

A quick Google of 'overpayment' shows multiple banks having a mortgage overpayment calculator. It's standard wording, no one is suggesting the OP doesn't owe the money.

In addition to what I wrote above, banks make money from charging interest on your debt. They longer you owe them, the more they will make; pay them off earlier and their income decreases.

Of course their marketing teams understand human behavior and would use language that conditions people to believe carrying debt is the normal state of things.

AliceOlive · 07/09/2023 15:05

OneHornedFlyingPurplePeopleEater · 07/09/2023 14:44

A quick Google of 'overpayment' shows multiple banks having a mortgage overpayment calculator. It's standard wording, no one is suggesting the OP doesn't owe the money.

This is credit card debt, not mortgage debt. There is a massive difference in these types of debt. Purposely borrowing an amount, secured by an asset for a specific term and a set monthly payment is not the same as running up credit card charges at high interest rates that will take years to pay if only paying the minimum.

If someone doesn't comprehend that, I wouldn't take financial advice from them.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/09/2023 14:50

The problem is the interest rates that you’ve got on that borrowing I agree, which you can hopefully bring down a bit. That and making sure you do stick to the budget going forward.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/09/2023 14:47

If you can’t put it into your mortgage, a loan would also be much cheaper than the cards. Could well be possible.

Youre not going to lose your home on the budget you’ve set out. You’re able to pay it off

You could also take a six month repayment holiday from your (pretty low) mortgage to throw money at the higher interest debts.

OneHornedFlyingPurplePeopleEater · 07/09/2023 14:44

AliceOlive · 07/09/2023 13:24

I wouldn’t take advice from anyone using the word “overpaying” for paying off money you owe.

A quick Google of 'overpayment' shows multiple banks having a mortgage overpayment calculator. It's standard wording, no one is suggesting the OP doesn't owe the money.

civetcat · 07/09/2023 14:42

It may be possible to freeze interest rates and charges on cards (you may have to give the card up). StepChange will be able to advise on this and more. Don't go to a paid-for service as they are often in the business of just selling one huge loan to cover your debts

AliceOlive · 07/09/2023 13:25

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/09/2023 13:18

Many people find Ramsey useful. That's not the same thing as efficient. There is a place for both approaches.

But the other thing to remember is that Ramsey is in a very different legal jurisdiction - the difference in the implications of defaulting on different types of debt can be significant.

For example, if you default on a mortgage in the US you hand back the keys to the house and you're all square. Do that in the UK and if the lender can't sell the house for more than the debt, you remain liable for the difference.

This is not true about defaulting on a house in the US. Again, I wouldn’t take advice from people that hold themselves out as knowledgeable about a topic but have such glaring misunderstandings.

AliceOlive · 07/09/2023 13:24

I wouldn’t take advice from anyone using the word “overpaying” for paying off money you owe.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/09/2023 13:18

Many people find Ramsey useful. That's not the same thing as efficient. There is a place for both approaches.

But the other thing to remember is that Ramsey is in a very different legal jurisdiction - the difference in the implications of defaulting on different types of debt can be significant.

For example, if you default on a mortgage in the US you hand back the keys to the house and you're all square. Do that in the UK and if the lender can't sell the house for more than the debt, you remain liable for the difference.

Maray1967 · 07/09/2023 13:03

BarbaraofSeville · 07/09/2023 12:48

Snowballing starting with the smallest debt (unless you have a few very small debts that you can get out of the way to simplify admin) is utterly stupid and will lead to paying thousands in interest unnecessarily. I find it hard to believe that someone who positions themselves as a 'debt guru' would give such ridiculous advice.

In what world would you bother to set yourself up with a 0% balance transfer and then throw it away by overpaying it because you owe less than the other loan/card that's costing you 20/30/40% interest?

Paying debts off in order from highest to lowest interest rate is what gets people out of debts fastest and at least cost.

He’s a debt guru who has got millions of people out of debt. It works because it is built on an understanding of how people behave. If you borrow on 0 percent interest and congratulate yourself for earning a bit more in savings interest rather than paying it off, you overspend and end up in more debt , or at least carry round the burden of the debt, niggling at you all the time Been there, done that.

To properly sort your finances out after a mess you need to change your ways properly - then you follow through and shift the debt.

Maray1967 · 07/09/2023 12:58

shivawn · 07/09/2023 10:50

I think paying off the smallest debts first is beneficial to some people due to the mental boost and motivation that clearing each debt gives them to keep going.

I agree with you though, for me attacking the highest rates first is the most financially sensible way.

Human psychology is massive though - the Ramsey methods works because initial small successes are motivational. Mathematically the avalanche works better, but fewer stick to it.

BarbaraofSeville · 07/09/2023 12:48

Snowballing starting with the smallest debt (unless you have a few very small debts that you can get out of the way to simplify admin) is utterly stupid and will lead to paying thousands in interest unnecessarily. I find it hard to believe that someone who positions themselves as a 'debt guru' would give such ridiculous advice.

In what world would you bother to set yourself up with a 0% balance transfer and then throw it away by overpaying it because you owe less than the other loan/card that's costing you 20/30/40% interest?

Paying debts off in order from highest to lowest interest rate is what gets people out of debts fastest and at least cost.

Maray1967 · 07/09/2023 12:40

tescocreditcard · 06/09/2023 12:09

I recommend following The Dave Ramsey Money Makeover - it's very good indeed.

Agreed. You need to get on to Dave Ramsey. The snowball method works far better than messing about with which has the biggest interest rates, due to basic psychology. Once you pay the smallest off you get a sense of momentum. You then tackle the next smallest and so on. He calls cutting up the cards a ‘plasectomy’….

You might find the anti-Biden tone a bit off putting but the debt repayment method works.

Florencefox · 07/09/2023 12:00

I agree with @Giles81 - Im not convinced your current financial summary is 100% accurate & it appears to have a reasonably high degree of optimism bias as it appears you're about £4K out on your plan!

Your plan shows you currently have an overdraft of £2500 so you don't have a surplus of £1500 each month after all your outgoings, if you did you wouldn't be £2500 overdrawn.

You need to reduce that recurringly which only brings you down to break even each month. I know that's in your unsecured outgoings section so I don't want to double count it, but you can't be both £2500 overdrawn & have a spare £1500 each month.

Once you've reduced your overdraft to zero, you've then got to find recurring savings each month of £1500 which means you've actually got to reduce your current spending recurrently by £4000 each month for you generate a monthly surplus of £1500.

Personally, whilst there is a lot of sound advice, I think it would be a worthwhile investment to pay for an accountant who specialises in debt management to do a years review of your spending........ although not an accountant, I was involved the operational side of financial recovery plans for organisations for years, ie putting the recovery plan into action.

The principals are similar, as are the behaviours & it's was always an eye opening when the forensic debt accountant team (as they were called) went through the spending.

I think you'll also need support to maintain behaviour changes as it will be a huge lifestyle change.

Lastly, I don't want to be negative & I'm offering this with the best of intentions but if you go over your overdraft limit you appear to be at high risk of everything collapsing. Totally agree that the snowball principle works very well to pay off debt but it also works the other way round. In my experience of organisations in financial trouble, those with lots of debt, loans, overdrafts etc, it was often the exceeding the overdraft that triggered the debt house of card collapsing. Banks treat this not only as a sign of financial distress but also poor financial control.

I really hope you sort this successfully but strongly advise you seek support now.

BarbaraofSeville · 07/09/2023 11:13

Well for the OP, it's academic as some of the smallest debts also have the highest interest rate.

But if you have loans, multiple credit cards with several £k on and then half a dozen catalogue type debts with a few hundred each on, even if the interest rate isn't high, it simplifies the admin, as well as a feeling of 'getting somewhere' to just pay them all off.

For the OP, I would first pay off Very and the overdraft (and stay out of overdraft). Then tackle fluid, then Lloyds. If the OP does pay off £4k pm, the first three will be gone by the end of the year.

I'd also keep an eye out for existing customer balance transfer offers, to see if I could transfer any of the Lloyds debt, otherwise, just keep throwing money at it and by the end of next year, that and the Creation card could be gone and then on with overpaying the loans, which I note have no settlement fees (googling suggests they're a consolidation loan company, which could be a strong indicator that the OP has gone through several rounds of 'paying off' credit cards before) so a lot of the debt could be interest and possibly late payment charges run up through disorganisation.

shivawn · 07/09/2023 10:50

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 07/09/2023 10:23

Exactly this. It's so simple.

All this nonsense about paying off the smallest debts and then you will have more to pay off the next one is utterly ridiculous.

It's all about the interest rates and you have to attack the highest rate debts first or else each month you are throwing away money on interest.

I think paying off the smallest debts first is beneficial to some people due to the mental boost and motivation that clearing each debt gives them to keep going.

I agree with you though, for me attacking the highest rates first is the most financially sensible way.

AlyssaHasAChaaaaild · 07/09/2023 10:23

lancashirebornandbred · 06/09/2023 17:19

Remember Martin Lewis’s best and most effective advice. You have to pay a minimum on each card you have debt on. Just pay the minimum and all your excess money goes on the one with the highest interest. Get that paid off first, then go to the next highest.

Exactly this. It's so simple.

All this nonsense about paying off the smallest debts and then you will have more to pay off the next one is utterly ridiculous.

It's all about the interest rates and you have to attack the highest rate debts first or else each month you are throwing away money on interest.

oiltrader · 07/09/2023 08:05

My DH said that its only when the tide goes out that you will see who is swimming with no trunks x

daisychain01 · 07/09/2023 05:26

@phillers its commendable that you at least have a clear understanding of your finances. Very often a family with your spending habits have lost visibility and control, or they become so scared, they bury their head in the sand and hope it will go away. You've realised the problem and you do have motivation to get things under control again.

Your finances are symptomatic of 13 years of capitalist government, everything is there tempting you to acquire an affluent lifestyle, cars, trinkets, holidays, all the trimmings.

Can you do a course on good financial habits, to re-educate yourselves on how to maintain a good lifestyle without reaching for the credit cards. Be mindful about every penny that leaves your account, try to stay exposed on a daily basis to the financial decisions you make - companies are all about "one-click" purchasing eg Amazon, instant loans like Klarna, they are all about hiding the reality, don't get sucked into any of it anymore.

My 4 year old car was on a PCP and the dealership spent weeks pestering me to trade in my vehicle (ultra low mileage due to COVID lockdowns, it had only done 20K miles). I was so tempted, nice new sparkly car, but I eventually said no. The £350 / month is in my account each month now, not in theirs! I'm really relieved I stood firm. These habits are formed over years, move yourself into a mental zone where buying stuff is less important than having peace of mind and security. You can do this!

Swipe left for the next trending thread