Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Sara Sharif father and stepmother statement makes no sense

599 replies

Bramblecrumble22 · 06/09/2023 11:23

So they released a video. I don't know the point of it. Sm is not upset or even pretending to be sad about her death. There is no explanation about why they fled. She claims it's an incident, while media have been lying about the father giving a statement on it being an accident where she fell down the stairs. An incident to me is non-accidenal.

They are in hiding but have no food, they want to cooperate, how? not asking for anything or showing remose.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Skinthin · 07/09/2023 10:03

Barr77 · 07/09/2023 09:51

@Zarah123 I don’t know when Sara was removed from school or how long she’s had been home-schooled.

And we don’t know yet whether neighbours and teachers did try to report what they had observed. We know services are in such desperate straits at the moment that, just like the other children you mentioned in your previous threads, another poor child is once again a victim of a system that is chronically understaffed and under-funded, and not fit for purpose.

Edited

It’s not just that though. In this case the system actively intervened to compel her to live in (what appears to have been) at least an unsafe and probably abusive household. This is happening more and more with the new doctrine of an assumption of shared parenting and fathers for justice/ men’s rights movements. We need to be talking about this and fighting this horribly abusive and patriarchal system that is inflicting harm on so many children and women.

FallingStar21 · 07/09/2023 10:10

Cazzie1979 · 07/09/2023 08:09

Also once a child is de-registered from school and Sara was home schooled from April this year, it is then up to the local authority to check on them.

That's the thing, in theory you can't just take your child out of school to homeschool, unless you can show that you'd be capable of teaching them to the same professional standard. I doubt very much the dad or stepmum could have passed this requirement and you'd think they'd have been checked upon.
With so much horrific child abuse these days, taking a child out of school should also be a major red flag.
If Sara came in with visible bruises teachers should have spoken to her and raised concerns. I just can't believe that no one knew she was abused and SS were not involved... literally nothing until she's "suddenly" dead with so many injuries inflicted over time.

Zarah123 · 07/09/2023 10:13

FallingStar21 · 07/09/2023 10:10

That's the thing, in theory you can't just take your child out of school to homeschool, unless you can show that you'd be capable of teaching them to the same professional standard. I doubt very much the dad or stepmum could have passed this requirement and you'd think they'd have been checked upon.
With so much horrific child abuse these days, taking a child out of school should also be a major red flag.
If Sara came in with visible bruises teachers should have spoken to her and raised concerns. I just can't believe that no one knew she was abused and SS were not involved... literally nothing until she's "suddenly" dead with so many injuries inflicted over time.

I agree. I was watching Nadia Sawalha's vlog on YT about Sara and Nadia said when she home schooled her own child, there very many checks in the home for the child's wellbeing.

I would be very surprised if the same has happened for Sara.

Cazzie1979 · 07/09/2023 10:24

@FallingStar21 Yes I agree that it’s unlikely the parents were able to home school her to a high standard. But if they remove her and de-register her, could they actually have been forced to return her back to the school? Totally agree that removing a child from school is a red flag and it should immediately be followed up with a referral to social services and I really hope the school alerted them.

Like I said, she told one child she’d fallen off her bike and probably said the same to her teacher. I’m sure they would have questioned the parents but if they say the same thing and even tell social services the same thing, what else could be done then? I don’t know if she came into school with any other bruises other than that specific incident. Other injuries could have been on parts of her body that were hidden or happened after April when she was no longer at school. It is hard to believe nobody knew but we just don’t know how often she came in with injuries.

Zarah123 · 07/09/2023 10:32

Cazzie1979 · 07/09/2023 09:58

@Zarah123 I’ve read many news stories where the school, neighbours etc have reported allegations of abuse but nothing was followed up by social services. We don’t know how many bruises or injuries she came in with - she explained one was from falling off her bike and that could easily of happened (my daughter fell off hers). The school could have questioned the parents and that might have been what triggered them to take her out of school. After that, they can make a referral to social services but then they can’t have any further involvement because she’s no longer a pupil. I really hope they did all they could.

If it’s true that the school can no longer have any involvement once a child is. taken out for home schooling, then that seems a shame and a possible lost opportunity, given the teachers would have seen the child every day and would be able to spot any changes in demeanour.

Cazzie1979 · 07/09/2023 10:40

@Zarah123 My sister is a teacher and that’s what she told me happens when a child is removed to be home schooled.

Zarah123 · 07/09/2023 10:53

Thanks, I understand that teachers have a hard enough job with the children they teach and won’t have capacity to check on children taken out for homeschooling, but it does seem a real shame.

Magnoliainbloom · 07/09/2023 13:19

Candlelight34 · 07/09/2023 08:46

I take strong objections to the entire Pakistani population been called abusers because of a 'lived experience.'
Labelling children as delayed so questioning parenting skills of an entire population?
You may see it as a 'debate' but others dont and can call it out for what it is.

Anyone of any colour can call out racism.

As a Pakistani with an incredible father and brother, I, too, object to an entire group of people being abusers. It wasn’t my intention to suggest this, however, I do stand by my belief that that abuse is embedded within the culture, and often abusers are shielded by their families to protect their honor. There is so much that is underground and will never be reported. It is class and education agnostic (eg a wealthy mother of a highly respected consultant I know decided to change the locks of the house to bar her daughter-in-law entry into the martial home; she wasn’t told why she had been kicked out) , and there is no support for women via the mosques. Abuse is rife in all cultures, however, the reasons why and ways they are handled are hugely complex, with family members complicit or passively watching as it continues (seems to be the case in Sara’s abuse). I had to engage a rather brilliant (English) lawyer who has a very specialist practice dealing with Asian abuse. The cases he had dealt with were truly appalling. Just because something cannot be objectively measured or compared with other cultures doesn’t mean it’s existence isn’t real. There isn’t a single Pakistani female I know who doesn’t have experience of this in some form. We are conditioned to shut up and put up until it’s too late.

jannier · 07/09/2023 13:23

Skinthin · 07/09/2023 10:03

It’s not just that though. In this case the system actively intervened to compel her to live in (what appears to have been) at least an unsafe and probably abusive household. This is happening more and more with the new doctrine of an assumption of shared parenting and fathers for justice/ men’s rights movements. We need to be talking about this and fighting this horribly abusive and patriarchal system that is inflicting harm on so many children and women.

It's not that simple though we have many cases where the child lives with the mother and dies at the hands of mother and step father. There needs to be funding and support with active recruitment and mental health support for social workers ....many are off with stress related illness (dealing with the children whilst worrying they will be the Scape goat must be awful) along with some system that monitors children after they are removed from social services registers and ones not attending formal education.

Skinthin · 07/09/2023 13:45

jannier · 07/09/2023 13:23

It's not that simple though we have many cases where the child lives with the mother and dies at the hands of mother and step father. There needs to be funding and support with active recruitment and mental health support for social workers ....many are off with stress related illness (dealing with the children whilst worrying they will be the Scape goat must be awful) along with some system that monitors children after they are removed from social services registers and ones not attending formal education.

Is there a case where the child has been actively removed from the care of their father where they were previously resident , and then placed in the care of mother + step father and ended up dead?
Even if they were, the situation wouldn’t necessarily be comparable.

Rinoachicken · 07/09/2023 13:55

This was reported in the mirror (by a parent of a child in Sara’s class) - if true surely being removed from school with no prior warning following injuries would have raised MAJOR alarm bells?

“Jessica said: "Just before the Easter holidays she was in school and had cuts and bruises on her face and her neck. My daughter had asked what had happened and she said she'd fallen off a bike and then kind of walked away. The next day the teacher announced she had left school and she was being home-schooled."
It was around then, she said, that the Sharif family moved to Woking and Jessica never saw the young girl at school again.”

dontbepetty · 07/09/2023 14:42

Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 15:29

Flowers

so so sorry this happened to you.

Noopnoop · 07/09/2023 15:55

It's hardly surprising that the father and step-mother fled to Pakistan as Pakistan has a woefully poor record when it comes to criminal justice especially in its treatment of women and children. Pakistan is a corrupt country and it permeates every level of Pakistani society.

No-one in their right mind would suggest that there are issues with all Pakistani men but there are with certain aspects of the religious fundamentalist Pakistani culture.

Just look at the way people have been murdered for "blasphemy" or for the notion of insulting Islam.

There are the issues in the UK with Pakistani parents harrassing teachers for teaching children about LGBTQ+ people existing. Or the teacher that was suspended and had to be given a new identity for simply showing a picture of Mohammed.

howrudeforme · 08/09/2023 18:39

Father and stepmum come across as knuckle dragging bastards.

the father sits in the background - what a man. Stepmum doing the dirty work reading from an A4 pad of paper. They mention lawyer. Surely their lawyer didn’t get them to write this shit?

I reckon the want a deal where they come home but children stay in Pakistan’s (the kids are witnesses). The kids must be in real danger.

tescocreditcard · 08/09/2023 22:06

I don't think the 13 year old boy will want to stay in Pakistan his mother is polish so he could go and live with her is he choose

SocialLite · 09/09/2023 10:58

MintJulia · 06/09/2023 13:22

The family court gets it wrong again and another child dies.

I hope Sara's brother is now returned to the custody of his mother.

Maybe... but in fairness, have we seen evidence that the mother's care was good? That may not have been the case.

Sorry if there is clear evidence of that, but I haven't seen it.

Evieanne · 09/09/2023 12:55

SocialLite · 09/09/2023 10:58

Maybe... but in fairness, have we seen evidence that the mother's care was good? That may not have been the case.

Sorry if there is clear evidence of that, but I haven't seen it.

I’m sure the mum claimed it was equal access with the father being the resident parent but alleged that the father was the one who restricted her access, and not the courts?

Skinthin · 09/09/2023 15:02

SocialLite · 09/09/2023 10:58

Maybe... but in fairness, have we seen evidence that the mother's care was good? That may not have been the case.

Sorry if there is clear evidence of that, but I haven't seen it.

Was it worse than ending up dead?? Ffs. There are people who will defend this shit no matter what .

MintJulia · 09/09/2023 15:22

@tescocreditcard 'I don't think the 13 year old boy will want to stay in Pakistan his mother is polish so he could go and live with her is he choose'

If he's been raised in a house where it is permissible to beat a 10yo girl to death, then I hope he is returned to his mother as soon as possible. Can you imagine...? Seeing his sister killed must have left him traumatised, poor kid.

tescocreditcard · 09/09/2023 20:04

Yes it's heartbreaking.

Updated today though - 10 members of his family have been detained now.

Soon he will have to venture out for food and then they will get caught.

Constance Marten had to go out for food and was caught
Daniel Khalife had to go out for food and was caught

Anyone helping to hide them or bring food to them will be in trouble no doubt.

Rounee · 09/09/2023 20:29

I hope they catch them soon

VictoriaVenkman · 10/09/2023 06:30

If he's been raised in a house where it is permissible to beat a 10yo girl to death, then I hope he is returned to his mother as soon as possible. Can you imagine...? Seeing his sister killed must have left him traumatised, poor kid.

Or he could be being raised to think what was done was necessary.

loislovesstewie · 10/09/2023 07:50

Apparently the parents left the UK on the advice of a solicitor??? The claim is that they would be mistreated for being Muslims in the UK. So, don't phone an ambulance for your daughter, just leave the country?

Pellets · 10/09/2023 08:15

The uncle's photo in the press looks like a mugshot. So probably also a dodgy individual.

Pellets · 10/09/2023 08:24

Yep. His picture in the press looks like a mugshot, so he's probably not a very nice character.

Swipe left for the next trending thread