Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Sara Sharif father and stepmother statement makes no sense

599 replies

Bramblecrumble22 · 06/09/2023 11:23

So they released a video. I don't know the point of it. Sm is not upset or even pretending to be sad about her death. There is no explanation about why they fled. She claims it's an incident, while media have been lying about the father giving a statement on it being an accident where she fell down the stairs. An incident to me is non-accidenal.

They are in hiding but have no food, they want to cooperate, how? not asking for anything or showing remose.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Fizbosshoes · 11/09/2023 18:46

It must be very confusing and disruptive for the other children not only being taken abroad presumably abruptly, not seeing their sister, being left with a relative (who, if abroad they might not know especially well) and then being taken by the police. The one year old at least (I don't know how old the others are) won't have the faintest idea what's going on, but very unsettling. Even if it was an accident that is a huge upheaval and trauma to put the siblings through

Candlelight34 · 11/09/2023 18:35

Im glad the children have been found and im glad they were not with parents.
Surprised they hid 5 children in their house.
I dont agree with grandfather lying but im.glad he didnt let the father and step mother take them.

MarshyMcMarshFace · 11/09/2023 17:54

And surely the police spoke with the grandfather in his house? He concealed 5 kids? One of whom was a 1 year old so hard to keep quiet?

MarshyMcMarshFace · 11/09/2023 17:53

So the parents were lying about the children having no food etc. What was the point of all that?

The grandfather has been doing a fair bit of lying.

And those poor kids. If we assume they were OK and safe with the grandfather (though of course that can't be guaranteed) , of course they would be terrified, seized out of a house in a raid by many police. How will they be looked after now?

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 11/09/2023 17:50

Until today, no one had asked me about the children.
"They kept asking me about Urfan, Faisal and Beinash, no one asked me about the children.

if that’s true it’s utterly bizarre. I’m not believing it though

Rounee · 11/09/2023 17:34

VictoriaVenkman · 11/09/2023 17:25

So glad the kids are safe now

But a bit weird where they were found.

The grandad obviously knows more than he's letting on.

Also I'm sure in the statement they gave.

The stepmother said they were running out of food for the kids. And mentioned the kids.

Pellets · 11/09/2023 09:21

Would like to clarify my comment about mugshot: I meant it literally; the photo of the uncle looks like a police booking photo. This was an observation made about the Constance Marten and Mark Gordon case - on this site.
I am really sorry that my post has been totally misunderstood although I'm not sure why.

Noopnoop · 10/09/2023 21:21

There are a few things we do know.

  1. A child has died.
  2. The child did not receive medical attention immediately prior to her death.
  3. It has not been confirmed how she died.
  4. She has injuries that lean towards prior physical abuse.
  5. She died whilst the legal responsibility of her father.
  6. There were at least two other adults living at the property.
  7. Her father and two other adults left the country with her siblings / step siblings.

We don't know how she died. We don't know when she died. We do know that someone inflicted those injuries upon her. We do know that her father left her and only called the authorities once they'd arrived in Pakistan.

I simply don't understand how any parent can leave their child whilst that child was dead or dying. They had the forethought to pack, get the relevant passports, book flights and travel.

I don't buy in the slightest that they were terrified of the British Police especially as they're now saying the same of the Pakistani police. I hope they're found and brought to face justice in the UK.

Barr77 · 10/09/2023 20:40

@Zarah123 as a daughter of Irish immigrants, who experienced terrible racism and prejudice particularly between the 70’s and 80’s in rbe UK, I find the term white privilege antagonistic, polarising and unhelpful. I have Peggy McIntosh’s essay, "White Privilege and Male Privilege’ and I accept many of her arguments. I do however object to depicting an entire race of people (in this instance white people) as ‘oppressive’ which is racist in itself as it is a race based negative generalisation.

And these Irish slurs still exist, as do the outright racism against Romanian and Albanian immigrants to the UK. And yet if we accept all the arguments of white privilege perspective it diminishes and reduces the experiences of each due to the colour of their skin.

But again to prevent the thread of being detailed - and I put my hands up:
guilty as charged here - I do believe the authorities and Police in Pakistan are doing their utmost to bring the suspects in.

”Truth is strong, and sometime or other will prevail”. Let’s hope so.

ShipSpace · 10/09/2023 20:20

Jesus Christ. I give up.

They were in Pakistan and they knew she was dead, alone in the house.

And pointing out that this makes them guilty of a criminal offence means I am racist.

Amazing.

Ascendant15 · 10/09/2023 20:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Fizbosshoes · 10/09/2023 20:05

I'm pretty sure the reports are that they rang from abroad and she was found dead, alone in the house the day after they left.
Regardless of how or when it happened they are at least guilty of not summoning help more promptly

ShipSpace · 10/09/2023 19:55

They rang the police from Pakistan to tell them about it.

Did you think they might have had a Psychic Sally moment to tell them she was lying there dead?

Ascendant15 · 10/09/2023 19:48

At the very least, the known facts are that they left that little girl dying on the floor whilst they booked travel tickets, packed up and left the home for a foreign country.

I am not defending anyone but those are not known facts. To date not even the coroner / police have determined how she died, when she died, who was there or anything else. These are the same " known facts" that led multiple posters on this site to name Nicola Bulley's husband / family as having something to do with her death.

Vigilante mobs are not best placed to determine facts or to mete out justice.

And actually people were definitely inferring guilt based on the fact that the photo must be a mugshot, and therefore he is a bad person, which means that he could be guilty of anything so he must be guilty of this. If you can't read that then you aren't trying.

You, and most people on this thread, know more facts than the police know. More facts than the coroner knows. Your "facts" are guesses. They may be correct. But they also may not be. People have then gone on to extrapolate what they say one or two people may have done and accused an entire people - millions of people- of being the same.

Lynch mobs are not a sign of a civilised society, even if they are "only" on line.

I know that posting facts and rational arguments on threads like this are a waste of time. Every now and then I forget how truly toxic and hate filled this site can be. I suspect its a lovely outlet for people the say the things they'd never want anyone irl to know they think.

ShipSpace · 10/09/2023 19:25

Zarah123 · 10/09/2023 19:12

Actually it’s you have done that to yourself.

Multiple posts have been deleted on this thread because they’re racist. Maybe read the thread before commenting.

And many more have been left to stand because the MN moderators are majority white and still experience white fragility.

😂😂

Zarah123 · 10/09/2023 19:12

ShipSpace · 10/09/2023 19:04

As I said, sanctimonious. In the extreme, actually.

At the very least, the known facts are that they left that little girl dying on the floor whilst they booked travel tickets, packed up and left the home for a foreign country.

We may not know what led to it, but that alone is enough to find all three of the adults involved guilty of several criminal offences.

So no, nobody’s decided anyone is guilty ‘because of the way they look’, but you have made yourself look a bit silly suggesting so.

Actually it’s you have done that to yourself.

Multiple posts have been deleted on this thread because they’re racist. Maybe read the thread before commenting.

And many more have been left to stand because the MN moderators are majority white and still experience white fragility.

ShipSpace · 10/09/2023 19:04

Ascendant15 · 10/09/2023 17:40

😂Have you read the thread??

On this thread there has been the most appalling racism, and outright allegations made against individuals that could prejudice a trial. Unlike every other person on this thread, I have absolutely no idea what happened to Sara. Obviously, her death is awful, and where someone is responsible for that, I would want them brought to justice. But since I do not know what happened I will not be joining the mob - I will wait until there is clarity and then I would hope that a court of law will deal with the matter appropriately.

If being anti-racist and civilised is sanctimonious, then I am guilty as charge.

As I said, sanctimonious. In the extreme, actually.

At the very least, the known facts are that they left that little girl dying on the floor whilst they booked travel tickets, packed up and left the home for a foreign country.

We may not know what led to it, but that alone is enough to find all three of the adults involved guilty of several criminal offences.

So no, nobody’s decided anyone is guilty ‘because of the way they look’, but you have made yourself look a bit silly suggesting so.

Ascendant15 · 10/09/2023 17:40

ShipSpace · 10/09/2023 12:42

Bit sanctimonious

😂Have you read the thread??

On this thread there has been the most appalling racism, and outright allegations made against individuals that could prejudice a trial. Unlike every other person on this thread, I have absolutely no idea what happened to Sara. Obviously, her death is awful, and where someone is responsible for that, I would want them brought to justice. But since I do not know what happened I will not be joining the mob - I will wait until there is clarity and then I would hope that a court of law will deal with the matter appropriately.

If being anti-racist and civilised is sanctimonious, then I am guilty as charge.

Zarah123 · 10/09/2023 17:36

Ascendant15 · 10/09/2023 11:43

Whilst I find it difficult to imagine a good explanation, I will await actual facts rather than speculation before making judgements.

But really - my passport photo looks like a mugshot and I am a really nice person. Have we descended to the point where people are guilty because we don't like the look of them?

As I said, I find it hard to think of a good or valid explanation for any of this, but the wild speculation and outright racist tone of much of this thread is a very cogent argument as to why someone might think that they wouldn't get a fair trial in the UK if they happened to be of Pakistani descent and/or Muslim.

Well said. The racists are out in force today after a rest.

Barr77 · 10/09/2023 16:32

@Ascendant15 “very cogent argument as to why someone might think that they wouldn't get a fair trial in the UK if they happened to be of Pakistani descent and/or Muslim”.

Very convenient argument to excuse the reprehensible act of leaving Sara to die alone, though presumably she had already died, in order to flee to a country where there is no extradition treaty with the UK, where they could be hidden by family and friends in a huge country whose police force are even more corrupt than the one here. Except it didn’t work as they thought it would.

”He (the father) ...discussed this matter with a British lawyer authorities who advised to run away otherwise….will hand them (childen) over to other people who may be of the Jewish faith or any other religion..” Nice bit of antisemirism there too from the lawyer.

Trying to play the victims here is sickening. The only victim here is that 10 year old child.

ShipSpace · 10/09/2023 12:42

Ascendant15 · 10/09/2023 11:43

Whilst I find it difficult to imagine a good explanation, I will await actual facts rather than speculation before making judgements.

But really - my passport photo looks like a mugshot and I am a really nice person. Have we descended to the point where people are guilty because we don't like the look of them?

As I said, I find it hard to think of a good or valid explanation for any of this, but the wild speculation and outright racist tone of much of this thread is a very cogent argument as to why someone might think that they wouldn't get a fair trial in the UK if they happened to be of Pakistani descent and/or Muslim.

Bit sanctimonious

Pellets · 10/09/2023 12:39

No , I meant it literally looks like a police photo , like he's been booked. I certainly wasn't implying that he 'looked' guilty. 😂

Ascendant15 · 10/09/2023 11:43

Pellets · 10/09/2023 08:24

Yep. His picture in the press looks like a mugshot, so he's probably not a very nice character.

Whilst I find it difficult to imagine a good explanation, I will await actual facts rather than speculation before making judgements.

But really - my passport photo looks like a mugshot and I am a really nice person. Have we descended to the point where people are guilty because we don't like the look of them?

As I said, I find it hard to think of a good or valid explanation for any of this, but the wild speculation and outright racist tone of much of this thread is a very cogent argument as to why someone might think that they wouldn't get a fair trial in the UK if they happened to be of Pakistani descent and/or Muslim.

Pellets · 10/09/2023 08:24

Yep. His picture in the press looks like a mugshot, so he's probably not a very nice character.