Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Sara Sharif father and stepmother statement makes no sense

599 replies

Bramblecrumble22 · 06/09/2023 11:23

So they released a video. I don't know the point of it. Sm is not upset or even pretending to be sad about her death. There is no explanation about why they fled. She claims it's an incident, while media have been lying about the father giving a statement on it being an accident where she fell down the stairs. An incident to me is non-accidenal.

They are in hiding but have no food, they want to cooperate, how? not asking for anything or showing remose.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
GonnaGetGoingReturns · 06/09/2023 17:41

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/09/2023 17:35

why the mother (was this because she was Polish or didn’t have access to a good solicitor?) couldn’t at least have got joint custody?

Going by her interview she had "equal access" from the court. The father just slowly prevented her from seeing them.

And many of us know how appalling the courts are at taking either side breaching an order to task..,

I thought that was the case equal access but father limited access (got confused) which as I know through work with this is sadly quite common. Can be quite hard to change access orders or to act on behalf of a parent when the other parent is refusing access, trust me have seen this in cases. I now don’t work in legal though.

Rounee · 06/09/2023 17:40

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 17:05

If your registered address is in Jhelum and you travel to khyber panktwar that’s a good 6 and a half hours drive or if you drive to Sindh that’s a good 15 hours, how would they find you? Like they clearly aren’t local to the family houses or they’d have been found by now. Pakistan is huge, someone will have helped hide them.

There's check points.

Where they regularly stop the vehicles search them and check identity documents.

Lifeomars · 06/09/2023 17:39

What is uppermost in my mind is the pain, fear and suffering that poor little girl must have endured. It almost brings me to tears looking at pictures of her face and thinking what her life must have been like in the time leading up to her death.

AnIndianWoman · 06/09/2023 17:39

Rounee · 06/09/2023 16:56

I find a lot of the comments about the photo a bit off.

It is common to put makeup on kids in South Asian culture for certain celebrations.

I don't see anything wrong with it. It's completely normal.

Some of the comments about the photo are disturbing and border on xenophobia.

And I think the main reason why the Pakistan Police force have been so accommodating is because of the heightened media attention.
As said before it is common for kids to get murdered or die. The reason the family went to Pakistan was because they thought they would be safe.

After the media attention they had to leave family and go into hiding.

Originally their family in Pakistan was covering for them,when grandad said father said it was an accident.
But now the Police have captured one of the dads brothers, not sure if they've all gone into hiding together or if the rest of the family have turned against them.

The Police are helping now to save face,not because they care about the actual crime. Only because there has been uproar. Not sure what the reaction from the public in Pakistan would be. But this news story would definitely be getting headlines in Pakistan.

It eould be the same with any murder. If the person who did could pay off the family or pay off the officials then they'd get away with it. If there is public uproar the Police may have to investigate fully.

The thing about Pakistan is,the Police force is actually very good.

They know the whereabouts of pretty much anyone- they have to be good with keeping an eye on people who have travelled in- due to their international relationships with other countries.

So if they are looking properly they will find the family. Very difficult to hide from them.

Several friends in Pakistan have said the opposite. The police force is useless and the minute you get to the border they won’t be able to track you. The only reason the India-Pakistan border is controlled well is because of Indian troops who often have access to the best technology.

Also the mood in Pakistan amongst the educated and elite is becoming disparing over it’s status as the backward, terrorist harbouring, female killing state it has become in the last 20 years. There is also a huge movement against non-resident Pakistanis who are viewed as part of the problem. Police are helping because the local media has tapped into that sentiment & they want to be seen as heroic and be seen to solve a crime they would have left to go cold had the parents been Pakistani residents.

Anewnamea · 06/09/2023 17:38

@Chaiandkaafee i agree. There’s even something called Cinderella syndrome to refer to the higher incidence of abuse occurring within homes with a stepparent. This is true across all cultures.

This is rooted in fact not prejudice. Biological parents certainly do harm their own kids on their own but I used to work in a social services background and the vast majority of kids removed were typically from households involving one bio parent and one step-parent OR an adoptive couple. This latter fact was a surprise to me - one in 4 of the kids looked after by the council I worked with were from adoptive families. 🤯

It isn’t necessarily only the stepparent doing the abusing btw, sometimes it is just the bio parent actively doing the abusing with the stepparent in the background, or more often both the bio parent and their partner(stepparent)… but my point is it occurs in households, where there is a step-parent figure the most. No matter which one of the two is actively doing the abuse.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 06/09/2023 17:38

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/09/2023 17:23

In respect to your comment that it was strange that the court barred her access there is 'no more to that story' as that didn't happen...

You could always go and read the mother's various interviews instead of making up lies about her and insinuating that she was somehow harmful to her child as well.

Unless you have access to the court documents or know the legal team who dealt with this then it’s still very easy for a parent to lose custody (especially if they’re a migrant/immigrant themselves with limited English language skills) with no or weak access to legal help - usually legal aid.

Don’t be so quick to paint the mother as at fault. I’ve worked as a legal PA and in immigration and family/divorce cases but only for private practice so do have some knowledge.

jannier · 06/09/2023 17:36

Lastchancechica · 06/09/2023 14:05

So why was the mother a flight risk but the father wasn’t? Of course the case needs to be reviewed! It’s not remotely racist.

All cases are reviewed unfortunately various things mean the issue isn't solved....people not wanting to get involved, leave it so school attitudes we've seen in another thread this week, lack of staff, overworked social workers with 3 times or more the case load they should have, no system for checking on off rolled children, fear of being accused of being racist, sexist etc. Parents being very convincing, telephone GP and hv appointments the list is endless.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/09/2023 17:35

why the mother (was this because she was Polish or didn’t have access to a good solicitor?) couldn’t at least have got joint custody?

Going by her interview she had "equal access" from the court. The father just slowly prevented her from seeing them.

And many of us know how appalling the courts are at taking either side breaching an order to task..,

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 06/09/2023 17:33

It looks to me that the father married and had DC with a non Muslim woman (Polish) his choice and due to their cultural and religious differences divorced and he got custody of the DC (just sharia court or did he influence English court?). Then probably new Muslim stepmother mistreated both DC as they were “mixed” and because she could, maybe the father approved this, maybe not. They fled to Pakistan for whatever reason but with the mixed DS.

Now the stepmother and father are facing questions of course they change their story. I thought it was strange the daughter was left and perished but had no idea she was abused. I do know some Muslims can be harsh on their DC.

The mother and grandmother’s interview sounds tragic as they really seemed to love and care for their DC/DGC but hands were tied due to court systems.

There needs to be reforms and inquiries here as to why father was given sole custody and why the mother (was this because she was Polish or didn’t have access to a good solicitor?) couldn’t at least have got joint custody? Were social services involved? Yet another child has perished and slipped through the net here. Very sad.

Goldflap · 06/09/2023 17:33

@RealHousewifeOfKarachi
True re my post I meant if they get extradited.
Your insight is really interesting and also very sad.
I have a family member that works in UK child protection and the complexities of dealing with families from non western cultures that have vastly different ideas about the rights and care of children and women is a constant battle taking up huge resources to an already overstretched system.

I hope you are right and this shines a light on some realities and that something positive can come from such evil.

jannier · 06/09/2023 17:29

Chaiandkaafee · 06/09/2023 13:52

It’s a classic tale seen time and time again in the west and the east…….stepmothers and stepfathers killing stepchildren and weak birth parents standing by and allowing it to happen! Turning this into a tale about honour killings and criticising Pakistan (who seem to have rightly put alot of pressure on the scum bags) doesn’t make any one party come out looking better! I think with the pressure being applied here an arrest does seem likely (fingers crossed).

As a side note: Sara not living with her birth mother also suggest the birth mother isn’t entirely innocent in this entire episode.

The only victim was poor Sara.

Again why assume the dad didn't do it blood can and does kill their own either or both can do the physical harming both watch and allow or encourage

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/09/2023 17:28

It's amazing that a child has been murdered in the home of her father and step-mother and people are still doing their best to put at least part of the blame onto her mother.

Anewnamea · 06/09/2023 17:26

This is a horrific case and I hope the dad and stepmom are brought to justice.

I do feel for the mum but hope the mother was fighting very hard to see her daughter because I take a dim view of men who claim they were stopped from seeing the child but didn’t really do all they could. Especially if they know said child is living with an unrelated male ie. Mums new boyfriend or husband.

To me, if I hear a child is living with an unrelated adult the risk is greater - nearly every single high profile case of extreme child abuse in the past few years has involved a stepparent & bio parent as opposed to just bio parents. Of course there are good stepparents out there too but a disproportionate amount of abuse is occurring in house with step-parents.

It’s just a very sad case, I can’t imagine how miserable and lonely Sara’s short life was.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/09/2023 17:23

FallingStar21 · 06/09/2023 17:17

With respect, you don't know if "there's no more to this story". If the dad and stepmum didn't follow court orders, did the mum not fight this?
I dont blame her for her daughter's death obviously. Just raising some questions.

In respect to your comment that it was strange that the court barred her access there is 'no more to that story' as that didn't happen...

You could always go and read the mother's various interviews instead of making up lies about her and insinuating that she was somehow harmful to her child as well.

AuntiePushpa · 06/09/2023 17:20

BodegaSushi · 06/09/2023 14:04

What bothers me about the reporting is the photo they are using of her. I understand that it was probably provided by the mother, but couldn't the papers request another?

A 10 year old in a full face of makeup and jewellery really already is seeming to portray her as 'not that much of a child' and I wonder what their motive is here.

I'm sure the photo was from the mother (see the photo with mum holding it) and that has made me feel less disturbed by it. I have seen another where Sara is wearing make up but more like for fancy dress. Also one in hijab with no make-up. I can guess why the papers haven't chosen that one... There is another image of her without make up in the press but she looks much younger so again can see why that one wasn't chosen.

Sara Sharif father and stepmother statement makes no sense
FallingStar21 · 06/09/2023 17:17

With respect, you don't know if "there's no more to this story". If the dad and stepmum didn't follow court orders, did the mum not fight this?
I dont blame her for her daughter's death obviously. Just raising some questions.

Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 17:14

I also wonder if jealousy played a part.

I know quite a few mixed heritage Pakistani women (and some men) and they tend to be stunning. The mum and dad may be plain or not, but when combined, their genes can produce very beautiful children.

Sara with her mixed heritage, would be an unknown quantity in her dad's family or her mum's family. It's unfortunate that her dad's home turned out to be murderous.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/09/2023 17:09

For those commenting about the Mother losing her access

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/sara-sharifs-mum-describes-horrific-30872564

"Ms Sharif said she had separated from her husband in 2015, and Sara and her older brother had been living with her until 2019 when the family court ruled they should live with their dad. She still had equal rights to see the children and said while that was easy to maintain initially it became increasingly harder over time."

She was not barred by the court from seeing her children. Her ex husband caused that.

Sara Sharif's mum describes girl's horrific injuries when identifying her body

Olga Sharif said she had separated from her husband in 2015, and Sara and her older brother had been living with her until 2019 when the family court ruled they should live with their dad

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/sara-sharifs-mum-describes-horrific-30872564

Notmytotoro · 06/09/2023 17:09

FallingStar21 · 06/09/2023 16:59

Strange that the mum was not given any access at all, family courts usually make a decision in the best interest of the children. Certainly wouldn't expect a mother to lose her rights solely on the father's unsubstantiated claim. By the same token, the mother could have argued that her children could be taken away to Pakistan?
To lose all rights to see her children there's probably more to the story and the reasons behind the court's decision.

she did not lose her rights but father and step mum did not follow court order, they alienated her.
Don't blame the mother, father and step mum killed the young child and fled. "There is no more to this story"

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/09/2023 17:06

FallingStar21 · 06/09/2023 16:59

Strange that the mum was not given any access at all, family courts usually make a decision in the best interest of the children. Certainly wouldn't expect a mother to lose her rights solely on the father's unsubstantiated claim. By the same token, the mother could have argued that her children could be taken away to Pakistan?
To lose all rights to see her children there's probably more to the story and the reasons behind the court's decision.

She didn't lose her rights in court. She was prevented from seeing the children by their father a little at a time until being completely prevented.

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 17:05

Rounee · 06/09/2023 16:56

I find a lot of the comments about the photo a bit off.

It is common to put makeup on kids in South Asian culture for certain celebrations.

I don't see anything wrong with it. It's completely normal.

Some of the comments about the photo are disturbing and border on xenophobia.

And I think the main reason why the Pakistan Police force have been so accommodating is because of the heightened media attention.
As said before it is common for kids to get murdered or die. The reason the family went to Pakistan was because they thought they would be safe.

After the media attention they had to leave family and go into hiding.

Originally their family in Pakistan was covering for them,when grandad said father said it was an accident.
But now the Police have captured one of the dads brothers, not sure if they've all gone into hiding together or if the rest of the family have turned against them.

The Police are helping now to save face,not because they care about the actual crime. Only because there has been uproar. Not sure what the reaction from the public in Pakistan would be. But this news story would definitely be getting headlines in Pakistan.

It eould be the same with any murder. If the person who did could pay off the family or pay off the officials then they'd get away with it. If there is public uproar the Police may have to investigate fully.

The thing about Pakistan is,the Police force is actually very good.

They know the whereabouts of pretty much anyone- they have to be good with keeping an eye on people who have travelled in- due to their international relationships with other countries.

So if they are looking properly they will find the family. Very difficult to hide from them.

If your registered address is in Jhelum and you travel to khyber panktwar that’s a good 6 and a half hours drive or if you drive to Sindh that’s a good 15 hours, how would they find you? Like they clearly aren’t local to the family houses or they’d have been found by now. Pakistan is huge, someone will have helped hide them.

BodegaSushi · 06/09/2023 17:04

@Rounee

I find a lot of the comments about the photo a bit off.

It is common to put makeup on kids in South Asian culture for certain celebrations.

I don't see anything wrong with it. It's completely normal.

Some of the comments about the photo are disturbing and border on xenophobia.

I've already stated that it isn't about why the photo exists, it's about why the media is choosing to use it.

Is it 'completely normal' in the British press to use photos of child murder victims where their faces are covered in makeup? I also compared her photo to photos of another child a similar age that was portrayed in a more childlike way.

Look up 'adultification bias', where children from ethnic minorities are perceived to be more 'grown up' than their white counterparts. This is where I think the choice lies.

Girls wearing makeup may be common in south Asian culture, but it is not typical in British culture, where the photos are being displayed in the British tabloids. I'm sure a school photo would have sufficed.

That's a lot of somersaults to try and prove some kind of point.

FallingStar21 · 06/09/2023 16:59

Strange that the mum was not given any access at all, family courts usually make a decision in the best interest of the children. Certainly wouldn't expect a mother to lose her rights solely on the father's unsubstantiated claim. By the same token, the mother could have argued that her children could be taken away to Pakistan?
To lose all rights to see her children there's probably more to the story and the reasons behind the court's decision.

Rounee · 06/09/2023 16:56

BodegaSushi · 06/09/2023 14:04

What bothers me about the reporting is the photo they are using of her. I understand that it was probably provided by the mother, but couldn't the papers request another?

A 10 year old in a full face of makeup and jewellery really already is seeming to portray her as 'not that much of a child' and I wonder what their motive is here.

I find a lot of the comments about the photo a bit off.

It is common to put makeup on kids in South Asian culture for certain celebrations.

I don't see anything wrong with it. It's completely normal.

Some of the comments about the photo are disturbing and border on xenophobia.

And I think the main reason why the Pakistan Police force have been so accommodating is because of the heightened media attention.
As said before it is common for kids to get murdered or die. The reason the family went to Pakistan was because they thought they would be safe.

After the media attention they had to leave family and go into hiding.

Originally their family in Pakistan was covering for them,when grandad said father said it was an accident.
But now the Police have captured one of the dads brothers, not sure if they've all gone into hiding together or if the rest of the family have turned against them.

The Police are helping now to save face,not because they care about the actual crime. Only because there has been uproar. Not sure what the reaction from the public in Pakistan would be. But this news story would definitely be getting headlines in Pakistan.

It eould be the same with any murder. If the person who did could pay off the family or pay off the officials then they'd get away with it. If there is public uproar the Police may have to investigate fully.

The thing about Pakistan is,the Police force is actually very good.

They know the whereabouts of pretty much anyone- they have to be good with keeping an eye on people who have travelled in- due to their international relationships with other countries.

So if they are looking properly they will find the family. Very difficult to hide from them.

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 16:54

They didn’t leave the kids here in the UK because they didn’t want them being taken into care and were terrified of that so they fled with the kids, now they have brought them into Pakistan where they now can’t keep them safe, they’re definitely going to lose the kids either way.