Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Sara Sharif father and stepmother statement makes no sense

599 replies

Bramblecrumble22 · 06/09/2023 11:23

So they released a video. I don't know the point of it. Sm is not upset or even pretending to be sad about her death. There is no explanation about why they fled. She claims it's an incident, while media have been lying about the father giving a statement on it being an accident where she fell down the stairs. An incident to me is non-accidenal.

They are in hiding but have no food, they want to cooperate, how? not asking for anything or showing remose.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 18:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Agreed. I don’t want to deny anyone their lived experience but when someone is saying their experience is that ‘all Pakistani men = bad’ then it’s unrealistic to those of us who have a range of Pakistan men in our lives. It becomes as useful as #NAMALTing men.

TakeMe2Insanity · 06/09/2023 18:49

This thread 🤯. I’ve just read the whole thing start to finish and shocked at the extreme views on both sides.

Also shocked at realhousewifeofkarachi’s views, many people might not live there but certainly visit regularly/in touch etc. No idea if you are an expat on a posting or uk-Pakistani now living there.

Re the visa/using a Pakistani passport angle, as non resident person of Pakistani origin you can have a Pakistani id card that allows you almost visa free entry. So if the dad/kids had been recently/or had this made it would have been a case of just buying the flights.

Ultimately something happened in the house and they did not call an ambulance, instead their reaction was to buy plane tickets and leave the UK. That’s just wrong on so many levels. That poor poor little girl.

Re Pakistan, you can see that the family in Pakistan are getting harassed by the police (btw unless your family works for the police in Pakistan no one thinks the police are good there), so of course theres pressure on the dad/step mum to deflect. Once caught they are looking at definitely getting physical punishments, no clean water, no sanitary facilities etc.

Re the dad/step mum’s statement nothing like the reality of being on the run in Pakistan or potentially ending up in jail there of course they are desperate to get back to the uk.

jannier · 06/09/2023 18:45

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 18:24

Knowing she had severe injuries, would it not be more reasonable to assume makeup was used to cover those injuries up?

If the photo was taken by dad yes but wasn't it mums photo?

thisisasurvivor · 06/09/2023 18:43

Araminta1003 · 06/09/2023 12:06

The Polish mother said a U.K. court removed that little girl and gave the father custody. He then alienated the 2 children from the mother. And now the little girl is dead. What about the failings of the English court, did she go to school here etc.- what did social services know. Why are they not ordered to return the kids first. They are not safe. Someone needs to take responsibility politically first for the remaining children.

100 per cent

Candlelight34 · 06/09/2023 18:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 18:40

jannier · 06/09/2023 18:11

Children of colour are not treated as older than their age many emotionally and independence wise are less mature than their peers. Do you work with children?

And your post just shows this is all abstract to you.

This adultification bias turns into stereotyping when Asian girls become women.

A handful of my white colleagues (we’re all in professional roles) have assumed that I want to invite them home and make curry for them because I’m an Asian woman. They don’t expect it of white colleagues or even Asian male colleagues but they subscribe to the same old stereotypes about Asian women when convenient.

FallingStar21 · 06/09/2023 18:37

Candlelight34 · 06/09/2023 18:32

Give me strength.
'Lived experience ' can allow you to make such judgements about a whole nation.

Jesus. Are you a DM journalist?

Of course it can, the poster has obviously been born within the culture and is closely familiar with it. Just the way you can make your own generalizations about the British culture (or wherever you're from).

Magnoliainbloom · 06/09/2023 18:35

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 18:27

Your case is very different, you’re Pakistani like a few of us are so we are speaking from actual experience, not from a place of bias like that poster was. And with my lived experiences, it’s common for Pakistani families to abuse their kids harshly as discipline, plenty of the mothers do it to their own kids they just manage not to kill them or give them serious injuries so they get away with it and because they brainwash us we don’t realise we are being abused. So I can see it both ways.

I 100% agree with this re Pakistani mothers (my own is still terrifying despite me being a grown adult).

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 18:35

Candlelight34 · 06/09/2023 18:32

Give me strength.
'Lived experience ' can allow you to make such judgements about a whole nation.

Jesus. Are you a DM journalist?

There’s a difference between other ethnic origin people whose only knowledge of Pakistani culture comes from news articles and a place of bias, than someone who have actually lived in Pakistani families brought up Pakistani and know how common it is. Plus I was referring to a particular poster, so you needn’t get offended and assume I’m talking about a whole nation.

BigGlenda · 06/09/2023 18:33

frazzledasarock · 06/09/2023 18:29

I’m sure I read that Sara’s mother lost the legal battle as she had little understanding of the English legal system.

I’ve seen women (and experienced it myself), fighting abusive ex’s through the courts who always always want the abusive father to have contact, I’ve seen druggies who’ve repeatedly failed drugs tests, violent men, all get contact because well he deserves contact.

if the mother had not harmed the children and they were safe in her care, why couldn’t the father be given shared care and an order that neither parent could remove them from the uk jurisdiction without court consent.

I want to see the judge who gave residency to the father bought to answer for his ruling.

It does make me wonder where people get their news as there has been lots of comments about “well there must be something going on with the mother too”

because it’s been well documented and covered in the news this week! People are being given access to their children when they are known to be dangerous, sexually aggressive, violent, manipulative etc.. to the point where mothers are taking their own lives and taking their children abroad to keep them safe

Ascendant15 · 06/09/2023 18:33

I realise that I am utterly wasting my time, but I'll say it anyway. Threads like this are all over the Internet. They are the evidence necessary to support a legal argument against extradition based on it being impossible to get a fair trial. Nobody here cares any more about Sara than they suggest her family do. It's all about you. Your righteous indignation, your anger, your made up facts. If you want justice for Sara then stop this and let them be extradited (hopefully) so that the actual facts, not not up ones, can determine the outcome.

Candlelight34 · 06/09/2023 18:32

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 18:27

Your case is very different, you’re Pakistani like a few of us are so we are speaking from actual experience, not from a place of bias like that poster was. And with my lived experiences, it’s common for Pakistani families to abuse their kids harshly as discipline, plenty of the mothers do it to their own kids they just manage not to kill them or give them serious injuries so they get away with it and because they brainwash us we don’t realise we are being abused. So I can see it both ways.

Give me strength.
'Lived experience ' can allow you to make such judgements about a whole nation.

Jesus. Are you a DM journalist?

Magnoliainbloom · 06/09/2023 18:31

Candlelight34 · 06/09/2023 18:23

Wow.
Surely that is your experience though.
I have heard about men from all cultures been abusive.

I think statements like this are damaging to a whole nation.

Indeed. I have stated a tiny fraction of my experience. I know there is good and bad in every culture. It can’t be quantified. I stand by statement that abuse is embedded within Pakistani culture. I have travelled there in a professional capacity and the stuff I learned horrified me. Read up on “bacha bazi”, as an example. Yes, shit happens here, but there is accountability (despite the fucked up family court system). A lot of abuse in Pakistani culture is hushed up, so there’s no way of quantifying it.

Severalreasons · 06/09/2023 18:31

The photo of Sara was given to police by her mum, just saying

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 18:30

clotheshorsegym · 06/09/2023 18:27

I wonder what percentage of murdered Pakistani children these examples of convictions represent though. I imagine only a tiny percent.

There are the ones that are similar to Sara’s, highly publicised cases with connections either to the west or family with a bit of money and connections

frazzledasarock · 06/09/2023 18:29

I’m sure I read that Sara’s mother lost the legal battle as she had little understanding of the English legal system.

I’ve seen women (and experienced it myself), fighting abusive ex’s through the courts who always always want the abusive father to have contact, I’ve seen druggies who’ve repeatedly failed drugs tests, violent men, all get contact because well he deserves contact.

if the mother had not harmed the children and they were safe in her care, why couldn’t the father be given shared care and an order that neither parent could remove them from the uk jurisdiction without court consent.

I want to see the judge who gave residency to the father bought to answer for his ruling.

Candlelight34 · 06/09/2023 18:28

It is all tragic.

Such vile humans in the world.
They can be any culture, colour, class, religion.

MaybeanothertimeNotReally · 06/09/2023 18:27

MarshyMcMarshFace · 06/09/2023 11:51

The video comes after it was reported in the media that a PM could not establish the exact cause of death - so doubtless they now think they can explain their way out of it.

It also comes after his father has said publicly that he thinks his son should return to the UK and deal with the allegations. So maybe the lack of family support has left them isolated. The wider family are not appreciating being questioned - I think two have tried to take legal action against the Pakistani police.

To give her some benefit of doubt I wonder if she meant to say 'accident' instead of 'incident'. English seems not to be her first language.

But how self serving - the majority of the statement being 'poor us' and about their difficulties.

And no logic - they way out of their self imposed hiding is to surrender themselves for questioning.

(An obviously the 'no identified cause of death' won't help them because the injuries were found to have been sustained over a long period).

That poor, poor little girl.

Shara's stepmother is speaking with a Yorkshire/Asian accent so she was brought up in the UK but with an Asian twang in her accent. @MarshyMcMarshFace

clotheshorsegym · 06/09/2023 18:27

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 18:23

Zainab Ansari’s rapist and murderer was hung. Mayra Zulfiqar? Her murderer was arrested. A French national of Pakistani origin returned to Pakistan with her kids and was gang raped, her abusers sentenced to death.

I wonder what percentage of murdered Pakistani children these examples of convictions represent though. I imagine only a tiny percent.

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 18:27

Magnoliainbloom · 06/09/2023 18:20

As a British Pakistani woman, the most disgusting and abusive human beings I’ve ever met have been Pakistani men. One family member has been dragged through the courts - father of the child has been thrown out of his profession for sexually abusing a vulnerable person. He was also accused of assault against his cleaner. He has hit his kids and blames the mother for parental alienation. Everything points to him being a dangerous man, yet he is allowed to continue to have his day in court. I don’t know the national stats, but there’s been a high concentration of fucked up Pakistani men that have married into my family (not arranged/forced; all educated) who have abused their relatives, wives, kids. This is my lived experience and the actions of the cunt who killed Sara do not surprise me. Abuse of women and kids is embedded within our culture. If that makes me racist, so be it.

Your case is very different, you’re Pakistani like a few of us are so we are speaking from actual experience, not from a place of bias like that poster was. And with my lived experiences, it’s common for Pakistani families to abuse their kids harshly as discipline, plenty of the mothers do it to their own kids they just manage not to kill them or give them serious injuries so they get away with it and because they brainwash us we don’t realise we are being abused. So I can see it both ways.

BigGlenda · 06/09/2023 18:25

Really infuriating to read all the comments essentially insinuating that Sara’s poor mum gave up on trying to see her kids. We don’t know that.

She has not only lost her child in a horrific way but knows that she was abandoned dead or possibly dying. She has had to see the body of her child in an horrific state. She doesn’t know the whereabouts of her 13 year old son, only that he’s halfway across the world, and must be terrified she will never see him again… and people are speculating/subtly apportioning blame on HER when this terrible “incident” has happened in the care of someone who she should have been able to trust her children with? Someone who hasn’t even spoken himself about it but left it to someone else. Someone who fled to another country obviously in the hope they could flee prosecution.

disgraceful

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 18:24

jannier · 06/09/2023 18:20

Because there is a trend for parents to buy clothes and apply makeup that would be appropriate for a much older woman. Make up traditionally was applied to appeal to men.

Knowing she had severe injuries, would it not be more reasonable to assume makeup was used to cover those injuries up?

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/09/2023 18:24

Candlelight34 · 06/09/2023 18:16

I guess they will be caught and bought back to the UK within 2 weeks.
They will all be charged and in my opinión be charged with murder.

Running away to another country will.add to the sentence length.

In my opinión they will all be serving a sentence on 25 to 30 years minimum if found guilty.

Rightly so.

I think it’ll take much longer than that.

Kriss Donald was murdered in March 2004. The three men who fled to Pakistan were not arrested until July 2005 and the special extradition was in October 2005.

There’s no way they’ll be back in 2 weeks. Even in a country with an extradition treaty it would take longer than that.

Lastchancechica · 06/09/2023 18:23

Magnoliainbloom · 06/09/2023 18:20

As a British Pakistani woman, the most disgusting and abusive human beings I’ve ever met have been Pakistani men. One family member has been dragged through the courts - father of the child has been thrown out of his profession for sexually abusing a vulnerable person. He was also accused of assault against his cleaner. He has hit his kids and blames the mother for parental alienation. Everything points to him being a dangerous man, yet he is allowed to continue to have his day in court. I don’t know the national stats, but there’s been a high concentration of fucked up Pakistani men that have married into my family (not arranged/forced; all educated) who have abused their relatives, wives, kids. This is my lived experience and the actions of the cunt who killed Sara do not surprise me. Abuse of women and kids is embedded within our culture. If that makes me racist, so be it.

That was a powerful post, thank you for sharing your insight. It must have taken a lot to put that into words.

Evieanne · 06/09/2023 18:23

clotheshorsegym · 06/09/2023 18:16

They know they are safe in Pakistan. There will be zero consequences there for them for having killed a girl.

Zainab Ansari’s rapist and murderer was hung. Mayra Zulfiqar? Her murderer was arrested. A French national of Pakistani origin returned to Pakistan with her kids and was gang raped, her abusers sentenced to death.

Swipe left for the next trending thread