Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a school can’t just cancel a GCSE/A-Level course halfway through?

134 replies

ChocBanana · 05/09/2023 21:01

This is on behalf of a friend who’s not on MN.
Her children have gone back to school today, one into Y11 and one into Y13. Both were taking the same subject, one at GCSE and one at A-Level.
They have been sent a letter today saying the school has dropped the subject with immediate effect and they won’t be able to take it this year.
They have said they will meet with each student “over the coming weeks” to discuss how to move forward. There was absolutely no prior notice and the teacher is still employed at the school. He only found out at the inset day on Monday.
I can’t find anything online to this effect to confirm or deny, but surely there is some kind of legal requirement to finish what they have started? I can almost understand not starting anyone new (my son was down to do the subject but is happy with the alternative because they have moved the timetable around so he can now take something he had to drop before).
But my friend is distraught and her 17 year old is frantically looking at his uni options because he doesn’t know if he will get in without this course.

Does anyone know whether this is legal/illegal and what law it come under? I’m going to help my friend to draft a response (English isn’t her first language).

Any ideas or advice?

OP posts:
Qilin · 06/09/2023 07:37

ZadocPDederick · 05/09/2023 23:04

They have said they will meet with each student “over the coming weeks” to discuss how to move forward.

This is far too leisurely. If students are potentially going to have to start another subject, they can't afford to waste further time.

If going into year 11 and 13 it's likely too late to start a new gcse or A level to be taken in May/June next year tbh.

EnidSpyton · 06/09/2023 07:34

@Takoneko

I think you’d be surprised at how scrapped for cash schools are.

I can’t imagine more than 1 or 2 students are studying Mandarin at the OP’s children’s school. Paying a FTE teacher salary for a teacher to teach that many students, when another FTE teacher potentially teaches 100x that many in the same contact hours, is completely unaffordable for a lot of schools and can’t be justified when it means that opportunities for all children are taken away to provide for a tiny few.

This is why most schools have a minimum number of students required for a course to run. This is particularly true for subjects that require a lot of equipment, like Music or Art - if you only have 3 children wanting to study an A Level that costs effectively £50k to run once you factor in the teacher salary and the equipment required to teach it, it’s not justifiable unless you’re a private school and parents are paying you to deliver this kind of one to one curriculum.

I don’t think it’s anything to do with results or the teacher and everything to do with money. If the teacher were unwell a new one would be found. Every subject has bad results from time to time - it doesn’t mean you pull the subject entirely - it means you learn from it and train the teachers so they do better next year. Pulling a subject mid course is because they can’t afford it. I’ve been a teacher and SLT member for a long time and I know how schools work!

There is probably nothing to be done now for the OP other than finding a tutor and arranging with the school to still let them sit the exams. Their school will be an exam centre so the school can enter them for the exam still, they’ll just have to pay for it as if they were an external candidate, as it’s not a subject offered by the school
any longer.

LynetteScavo · 06/09/2023 07:31

My guess is that the the students weren't predicted to get high grades in the final exams. Unless the student is speaking Mandarin at home I imagine they won't be getting the highest grade at school. If they are speaking Mandarin at home hire a tutor so they are exam ready and expect the school to enter them into the exam.

Having said that, I would be furious if it were my Alevel child as they may well need to spend another year at at school to gain three Alevels.

Takoneko · 06/09/2023 07:25

I’d be really surprised if this is just about the cost. The bad PR of pulling a subject halfway through is something most schools would avoid if at all possible. That’s expensive in itself.

Withdrawing a course for those about to start, yes, but not pulling it for kids halfway through. I think there has to be something else going on. I think either the summer results were awful or the school knows something you don’t about staffing this year. Perhaps the Mandarin teacher is seriously unwell and going to miss a lot of school, maybe they will be going on maternity or perhaps they have already resigned effective from Christmas and the school don’t think they can replace them.

Britneyfan · 06/09/2023 03:06

Pretty sure it’s not illegal. Definitely the school should be giving an explanation as to their reasoning and agree this is a crisis and they need to be meeting now to decide what to do next. I’d be furious if this was my child. Fair enough to not start any new students but to abandon ship halfway through is awful.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 06/09/2023 00:08

I'd be shocked if this was illegal/against any law, as there is no legal requirement for children to sit exams in the UK.

You should look at using a private tutor and/or an online or college course to finish the rest of the syllabus. Then they can sit the exams as an external candidate at an exam centre, this will cost anything between around £150-£250 per paper.

I've heard of schools pulling this crap before.

Merryoldgoat · 05/09/2023 23:44

Mandarin is notoriously hard - how did the cohort perform this year? I wonder if they’re not achieving good enough grades.

HeddaGarbled · 05/09/2023 23:43

They have said they will meet with each student “over the coming weeks” to discuss how to move forward

I think you do need to listen to what their suggestions are before you do anything, though I agree with @ZadocPDederick : the students and parents need answers this week not “in the coming weeks”.

HipHipWhoRay · 05/09/2023 23:38

A local private school has a scheme where it enters students for exams in their native language exams if their own state school doesn’t offer it as a subject. I think they do assess the kids to ensure they’re on track and do some Saturday teaching to keep them on track (as part of their charitable status I think)…so benefits everyone

TheHennaHairedHarridan · 05/09/2023 23:33

This happened to me many years ago - our teacher left halfway through our English language A level, and there were no other teachers who were qualified to teach it. We all had to swap onto English literature and do extra work to catch up 😱

Callyem · 05/09/2023 23:24

Is the course offered at another local school of FE? I know around here, where a subject hasn't been offered, it has been known for them to take one at a nearby school if schedules allow.

BringOnSummerHolidays · 05/09/2023 23:14

If you are near a city with a large Chinese population, there will be Chinese schools in the weekend.

RampantIvy · 05/09/2023 23:13

How many A levels is the 17 year old doing? Will he drop from four to three or three to two?

BringOnSummerHolidays · 05/09/2023 23:12

ChocBanana · 05/09/2023 22:25

Yes it is their other language (it’s Mandarin). I think possibly an external tutor may be the way forward, but wasn’t sure.

I see it’s mandarin now. Is there a Chinese school around where you are? My children go to one and they have pre gcse and gcse classes. I think they may also have A levels. The lower level classes are all ethnic Chinese students, but the GCSE classes have a lot of British students. I thought they go to get extra tuitions but now I’m not so sure. If it’s available to you, contact the Chinese school and see if they can enrol there.

VeloVixen · 05/09/2023 23:11

My nephew is teaching himself further maths as the school can’t accommodate the subject. They’ve agreed to enter him for the exam. I’d be looking at self teaching, tutoring and telling the school to still enter them for the exam (they may have to pay and enter him privately if the school refuse).

Handlecarefully · 05/09/2023 23:09

EnidSpyton · 05/09/2023 22:47

The school probably can’t afford to keep paying a teacher to deliver Mandarin to such a small cohort of students. This is the state of school budgets right now. Tough decisions need to be made. If 1 teacher is being paid to teach 3 students while another is being paid the same to teach 50 students within the same timetabled hours, it’s very difficult to justify the expense of the teacher who has very few students compared to everyone else. Mandarin is not a compulsory subject and the school has no legal obligation to finish a course of study. They should help to find alternative provision i.e. if a neighbouring school delivers Mandarin the students could go there for their lessons or could join a class remotely if possible. But they have no obligation to do so.

I would tell your friend to ask the school if an arrangement can be made with another local school. If that’s not possible then private tuition would be the only option.

This will be the answer I'm sure. I've recorded similar scenarios up in minutes of governors' meetings several times. Sometimes a subject is no longer viable, no longer effective use of the teacher's time.

ZadocPDederick · 05/09/2023 23:04

They have said they will meet with each student “over the coming weeks” to discuss how to move forward.

This is far too leisurely. If students are potentially going to have to start another subject, they can't afford to waste further time.

BarbieKew · 05/09/2023 23:02

Can you ask the teacher if he’d tutor them?

ZadocPDederick · 05/09/2023 23:01

voxnihili · 05/09/2023 21:11

We have had to do this with one of our subjects (only at GCSE though). The teacher left and there is no one who can take the classes on. We’ve tried to recruit but had no luck. We’re doing the best we can to get the students an additional qualification.

If someone needs the subject for further / higher education it might be worth looking into whether there is a private tutor available who could support them. The school may be willing to enter the student for the exam anyway if they’re being tutored outside of school (we would do this, and have done this).

Have you looked into whether it's available at any other local schools so you could send your students there for lessons?

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 23:01

HardcoreLadyType · 05/09/2023 22:53

That’s not the way it works, anymore.

AS level is a standalone qualification, not the first half an A level, like it used to be.

Oh! That's sad

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 05/09/2023 22:58

In Australia, so not exactly the same, but Specialist Math is not offered in year 12 (equivalent to A levels) at his school so the students go to a local Senior College just for that subject to undertake that subject.

However what often happens (and might well happen with my DS) is that the student moves to the senior college and does all their subjects there.

Schools should really facilitate something. Languages is often done as an evening option at specialist colleges to enable students wider choice as well, so for Mandarin that is what they would do.

HardcoreLadyType · 05/09/2023 22:53

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 22:32

Did the year 13 do an AS level - was the grade ok?

That’s not the way it works, anymore.

AS level is a standalone qualification, not the first half an A level, like it used to be.

EnidSpyton · 05/09/2023 22:47

The school probably can’t afford to keep paying a teacher to deliver Mandarin to such a small cohort of students. This is the state of school budgets right now. Tough decisions need to be made. If 1 teacher is being paid to teach 3 students while another is being paid the same to teach 50 students within the same timetabled hours, it’s very difficult to justify the expense of the teacher who has very few students compared to everyone else. Mandarin is not a compulsory subject and the school has no legal obligation to finish a course of study. They should help to find alternative provision i.e. if a neighbouring school delivers Mandarin the students could go there for their lessons or could join a class remotely if possible. But they have no obligation to do so.

I would tell your friend to ask the school if an arrangement can be made with another local school. If that’s not possible then private tuition would be the only option.

NewName122 · 05/09/2023 22:38

My child has just finished his and we got told this may happen if not enough students pick the subject. I was so shocked at how many different GCSE options his friend at another school had compared to him. Think council estate school vs non council estate school. Unfair giving them less options I thought.

Qilin · 05/09/2023 22:36

Many years ago my A level teacher left at the start of upper sixth, with no warning. We were left with no teacher to muddle through. Didn't really go well tbh.

Friend's son had his gcse course cancelled half way through year 10, a year and half ago. Teacher was still in school, and still is. They decided it was no longer financially viable to run the course. It was too late for most of the children to suddenly pick up a new subject, so the poor children just lost out on a GCSE option.

Swipe left for the next trending thread