Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Councils going bust are not all at fault?

141 replies

Turmerictolly · 05/09/2023 20:51

Another council (Birmingham) declaring bankruptcy/severe financial difficulties. Yes, there has been some financial mismanagement but decades of austerity and squeeze from a Tory government haven't helped. I have connections to Birmingham and feel sorry for the sorry state it's in - the streets are filthy and depressing in a lot of areas.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
jallopeno · 05/09/2023 22:52

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 22:46

That's not under dispute.

Do you understand the difference between a local authority and a private business?

Is more deaths amongst social care service users or reduced support for at risk children your desired outcome?

Course it isn't. I don't run the council. But if I personally had been underpaid for years I would want that to be rectified.

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 22:51

moragmafs · 05/09/2023 22:46

@MidnightOnceMore students should pay. They aren't exempt. Increasing wages doesn't mean anything when the cost of living is so high.

My point is students use the services, and don't contribute. So make them contribute, like the adults they are.

The amount of hassle they cause to local areas as well with their drunkness etc.

Students are exempt. That's the legal situation.

They bring huge amounts into local areas. The closest university to me has 10,000 well paid jobs. Students spend a fortune in the local economy.

Attacking the sector is shortsighted.

Dragging everyone down to poverty is not a growth strategy.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/09/2023 22:49

KnittedCardi · 05/09/2023 21:05

Actually it's usually mismanagement of funds by councils. Birmingham is equal pay, others are bad financial investments, or building numerous high rise flats which no-one wanted and they can't now sell, Woking. Woking even managed to invest in another councils development and that council went bankrupt. Wtf.

Also vanity projects, woke projects, anything that isn't actually delivering services.

This ^^

In fairness I've no direct knowledge of Birmingham council, but this is certainly the case in my own east midlands city and the one "next door"

Also the black hole they've created by underpaying women shows very clearly they haven't a clue what they're doing

Merrilydancing · 05/09/2023 22:49

This was an equal pay claim not a gender pay claim which is very different legally. Screw up on gender pay, nothing happens apart from bad headlines, screw up on equal pay and it can cost you big time as in this case.

Companies with a bit of intelligence keep a very close eye on equal pay for this reason. Doesn’t mean that they get it right every time, but in the most part try to correct any wrongs.

SkiingIsHeaven · 05/09/2023 22:47

I did some agency work for a local council and was shocked at how much waste went on.

Me moved offices and they threw so much stuff away even perfectly good stationary because they couldn't be bothered moving it.

They chucked out structural reports on their own housing stock, even when there was no back up copy. They said if they needed it then would just pay for a new one.

The amount of sickness was ridiculous. One lady tool two weeks off for a broken toe. He job was to sit on reception and she never normally moved around.

Two people would do the job of one person.

The waste of paper and photocopying was off the scale.

Coming from private practice I was shocked.

I really am not surprised that they are going bust.

No one was accountable for anything. It wasn't their money they were wasting.

Agnes12 · 05/09/2023 22:46

I’m sure during the many years women were routinely underpaid compared to men, the Council was probably employing a number of highly paid Equality & Diversity Officers who were clearly missed the elephant in the room. And where were the unions whilst this was allowed to go on for years? The Council and its HR function are completely to blame. Did they do no job/ pay comparison reviews ever?

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 22:46

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 22:43

The women get paid their due?

That's not under dispute.

Do you understand the difference between a local authority and a private business?

Is more deaths amongst social care service users or reduced support for at risk children your desired outcome?

moragmafs · 05/09/2023 22:46

@MidnightOnceMore students should pay. They aren't exempt. Increasing wages doesn't mean anything when the cost of living is so high.

My point is students use the services, and don't contribute. So make them contribute, like the adults they are.

The amount of hassle they cause to local areas as well with their drunkness etc.

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 22:45

moragmafs · 05/09/2023 22:38

@Theunamedcat so they don't use the bins, streets, local services etc?

So what if they are studying.

People going to work and a low wage pay CT, so should student.

Students have lots of money. They can contribute to the area they live in - unless they get no service due to say living on a remote campus etc.

They are only studying, they aren't special.

Students have lots of money?! Hahahaha

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 22:44

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 22:41

Yes, as was the case nationwide. The gender pay gap hasn't disappeared even now, this is not a Birmingham only issue.

The fact it was wrong doesn't mean the current councillors were responsible.

I'm not saying the pay situation was right, I'm saying it isn't something Birmingham residents should be responsible for paying for.

They have to pay it somehow. They can't go back in time. They should have been paying it all along so if anything it's like a loan being called in.

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 22:44

moragmafs · 05/09/2023 22:38

@Theunamedcat so they don't use the bins, streets, local services etc?

So what if they are studying.

People going to work and a low wage pay CT, so should student.

Students have lots of money. They can contribute to the area they live in - unless they get no service due to say living on a remote campus etc.

They are only studying, they aren't special.

No students shouldn't pay.

Wages for low income workers should be higher.

We have to stop trying to drag everyone further down.

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 22:43

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 22:42

It is ordinary taxpayers who will suffer.

What is the benefit of that?

The women get paid their due?

Pudmyboy · 05/09/2023 22:43

@MidnightOnceMore where do you feel the money should come from, out of interest?

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 22:42

Elvis1956 · 05/09/2023 21:48

My local authority spent £1.3m on a road scheme of about 300 yards.so bad it was raised in parliament. Has bought a decrepit pier and plans to renovate it. Is committed to buying a shopping centre when it was clear that retail is thermally ill.

Oh and councillors can claim expenses for going from one meeting to another....In the same building

Really? That's ridiculous- what's the expenses they claim? Wear and tear on shoes?

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 22:42

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 22:39

No. They as an organisation are though.

I can't dismiss a colleagues mistake from 10 years ago, I have to correct it.

It is ordinary taxpayers who will suffer.

What is the benefit of that?

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 22:41

Pudmyboy · 05/09/2023 22:25

Again: the underpayment post-dated the equal pay act, the council knew it was wrong but didn't care because it was low paid women who they did not expect to stand up for themselves!

Yes, as was the case nationwide. The gender pay gap hasn't disappeared even now, this is not a Birmingham only issue.

The fact it was wrong doesn't mean the current councillors were responsible.

I'm not saying the pay situation was right, I'm saying it isn't something Birmingham residents should be responsible for paying for.

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 22:39

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 21:24

Well no, of course they didn't have to, but it was a norm to pay women less.

That's why the legal changes were brought in - to correct the widespread issue.

The councillors in charge today are not to.blame for things that happened in the past, obviously.

No. They as an organisation are though.

I can't dismiss a colleagues mistake from 10 years ago, I have to correct it.

Orturo · 05/09/2023 22:38

Thing is that on a wide basis yes there is underfunding by central government.

But on a local level we all know of council mismanagement and idiocy - people barely out of their teens being elected as councillors and playing at politics with declarations of solidarity to various causes, hair brained schemes around 20mph zones and ltns that take no account of the necessary travel patterns of working people, fortnightly or even monthly rubbish collections that may or may not happen but no workable alternative in place etc, while we can see our physical neighbourhood environment degenerate before our eyes, and when we try to contact anyone there is no one to talk to, and our council tax liability goes up and up.

Councils are up against it, for sure, but they don't help themselves when they spaff our money up the wall on (for instance) installing cycling bollards on a 200 yard stretch of road with no integrated infrastructure or plan as to how that might add any benefit at all to the area while failing to keep the basics running.

moragmafs · 05/09/2023 22:38

@Theunamedcat so they don't use the bins, streets, local services etc?

So what if they are studying.

People going to work and a low wage pay CT, so should student.

Students have lots of money. They can contribute to the area they live in - unless they get no service due to say living on a remote campus etc.

They are only studying, they aren't special.

Pudmyboy · 05/09/2023 22:36

1970 equal pay act: what happened to the new edit button Mumsnet?!
(Ah: found it on this post: seems to be absent from posts which quote other posts)

Hoardasurass · 05/09/2023 22:34

@UsingChangeofName would you class pride events as essential then?

UsingChangeofName · 05/09/2023 22:31

It's a combination of so many factors.

Yes, some mismanagement / strange financial decisions.

Yes, the complete mishandling of the equal pay claims

Yes the computer system bought in for a price of £19million that still isn't completely sorted 3 years on and £100million spent so far

Yes, being the biggest LA and hugely cosmopolitan comes with it's own issues as well as all the positives.

Yes, having such a high % of U25s creates big financial holes - both high % of dc in the City, so all children and family services being provided by a relatively smaller % of adults than is usual. Also the high number of students attending the City's many Universities gives a disproportionate number of people not paying Council tax.

However, let's not forget the fact that £600million worth of cuts "savings" had to be made because of the Government cuts after bankers decided to gamble with other people's money prior to the crash in 2010. All "fat" was cut by about 2012, and then the cuts just kept on coming. They are talking about no "non-essential spending" being allowed, but that has been the case for the last 13 years. That isn't the City's fault.

Theunamedcat · 05/09/2023 22:29

moragmafs · 05/09/2023 22:15

Yes students should pay council tax

Why? They arnt working full time they are paying out exorbitant rent for a room and they are an investment for the future

CrotchetyQuaver · 05/09/2023 22:29

So have I got this right, they're not really bankrupt, but despite it dragging on since goodness knows when they've never allocated anything in any of the annual budgets to cover the cost of this equal pay award? And now the intention is to declare bankruptcy to get out of paying it
That's shocking mismanagement by a number of accountants and councillors over many many years.

I hope those women affected have a class action going.

Pudmyboy · 05/09/2023 22:25

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 21:24

Well no, of course they didn't have to, but it was a norm to pay women less.

That's why the legal changes were brought in - to correct the widespread issue.

The councillors in charge today are not to.blame for things that happened in the past, obviously.

Again: the underpayment post-dated the equal pay act, the council knew it was wrong but didn't care because it was low paid women who they did not expect to stand up for themselves!

Swipe left for the next trending thread