Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Councils going bust are not all at fault?

141 replies

Turmerictolly · 05/09/2023 20:51

Another council (Birmingham) declaring bankruptcy/severe financial difficulties. Yes, there has been some financial mismanagement but decades of austerity and squeeze from a Tory government haven't helped. I have connections to Birmingham and feel sorry for the sorry state it's in - the streets are filthy and depressing in a lot of areas.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
KnittedCardi · 06/09/2023 07:03

Don't worry, the council leaders will all get big pay outs, go off for a bit of gardening leave and then pop back up in another local authority in a few months time. Just like the NHS.

Kpo58 · 06/09/2023 06:57

ScarletWitchM · 05/09/2023 22:23

Do they need to pay £100-200k for these jobs?

Yes they do as that pay is low for private directors and if you pay peanuts you get monkeys. Do you think that Gavin from the mailroom on min wage would be able to lead a council? No, you need proper experience and that does cost money.

Simonjt · 06/09/2023 06:32

moragmafs · 05/09/2023 22:38

@Theunamedcat so they don't use the bins, streets, local services etc?

So what if they are studying.

People going to work and a low wage pay CT, so should student.

Students have lots of money. They can contribute to the area they live in - unless they get no service due to say living on a remote campus etc.

They are only studying, they aren't special.

Students have lots of money? Where, in fantasy land?!

Fairyliz · 06/09/2023 06:25

Wsmi · 05/09/2023 21:18

Councils have some of the most unproductive workforces of any sector. High absence rates, huge pensions, poor management, no accountability, massive overspending on projects.

All true, I worked for one for over 40 years.
They are also very keen on wfh, so you can imagine how little work actually gets done.

jallopeno · 06/09/2023 06:18

jcyclops · 06/09/2023 01:40

The equal pay claims led by the unions have been plodding along for years all around the country, and the councils almost never win. A council with which I am more familiar (with a budget about half that of Birmingham) initially intended to fight all the way to the Supreme Court, but in the end, settled the claim. This was around 12 years ago at a cost estimated to be around £20m for which they had been making provisions as the case proceeded through tribunals, lower courts and appeals. The Birmingham case originates back in 2008 so they have had 15 years to settle and prepare to pay, but they appear to have done nothing.

It is yet another example of local government being badly run. Councils thought they could run property development better than property developers and failed at horrendous cost. They thought they could run energy supply businesses better than the private sector, and these all went belly up at massive cost to their local taxpayers.

The future for Birmingham residents could well be that council tax will increase by well over the maximum allowed by the government for the rest of the country each year for the next few years. For example the increase for 2023 was limited to 5% across the country, but Croydon, under a Section 114 notice had to put their council tax up by 15%.

Yes they should have seen it coming

DdraigGoch · 06/09/2023 02:05

Starseeking · 05/09/2023 23:36

@DdraigGoch I've no connection to BCC, so not familiar with that Director or their experience (what you've mentioned sounds like a recruitment issue rather than a problem with the salary level).

My initial post should have been more explicit with regards to salary expectations at that size of the organisation. Apparently BCC is the biggest local authority in Europe, and having looked it up, it has a budget of £3.2bn.

I'd expect Assistant Directors and up to CEO to be on £100-300k for overseeing a budget if that size. Clearly they didn't look after it well, so something has obviously gone very wrong.

I'm not sure that "recruitment issue" quite explains his appointment. Given his political connections I wouldn't be surprised if it was more than just "appointing the wrong candidate" (a pretty big cock-up in the context of the lack of relevant experience) and that there was something more to this appointment. Verging on corruption perhaps.

jcyclops · 06/09/2023 01:40

The equal pay claims led by the unions have been plodding along for years all around the country, and the councils almost never win. A council with which I am more familiar (with a budget about half that of Birmingham) initially intended to fight all the way to the Supreme Court, but in the end, settled the claim. This was around 12 years ago at a cost estimated to be around £20m for which they had been making provisions as the case proceeded through tribunals, lower courts and appeals. The Birmingham case originates back in 2008 so they have had 15 years to settle and prepare to pay, but they appear to have done nothing.

It is yet another example of local government being badly run. Councils thought they could run property development better than property developers and failed at horrendous cost. They thought they could run energy supply businesses better than the private sector, and these all went belly up at massive cost to their local taxpayers.

The future for Birmingham residents could well be that council tax will increase by well over the maximum allowed by the government for the rest of the country each year for the next few years. For example the increase for 2023 was limited to 5% across the country, but Croydon, under a Section 114 notice had to put their council tax up by 15%.

CredibilityProblem · 05/09/2023 23:38

DdraigGoch · 05/09/2023 23:23

I thought that it was usually the landlord who paid council tax (where due) for a HMO.

Fair point - that would help with enforceability.
DC1 is getting endless council tax enforcement letters addressed to a previous occupant of their HMO though.

clopper · 05/09/2023 23:38

No doubt people will be along soon to talk about back room waste, bloated councils and pay

I have relatives who work for two different councils, one is a relatively senior staff member. They all say that there is a lot of waste and some ( not all) staff members WFH are much less productive than they were when working in an office in teams and apparently it is quite difficult to discipline or sack them.

Starseeking · 05/09/2023 23:36

@DdraigGoch I've no connection to BCC, so not familiar with that Director or their experience (what you've mentioned sounds like a recruitment issue rather than a problem with the salary level).

My initial post should have been more explicit with regards to salary expectations at that size of the organisation. Apparently BCC is the biggest local authority in Europe, and having looked it up, it has a budget of £3.2bn.

I'd expect Assistant Directors and up to CEO to be on £100-300k for overseeing a budget if that size. Clearly they didn't look after it well, so something has obviously gone very wrong.

hiredandsqueak · 05/09/2023 23:25

@Awittyfool no we are East Midlands, our SEND dept is in meltdown it isn't functioning at all. They miss 98% of statutory deadlines and are now averaging 85 formal complaints a week. That said people are formally complaining because they haven't reopened the phonelines since Covid and there have been an out of office response to all emails stating they aren't responding to emails or giving updates due to capacity issues. That the Head of SEND has as his out of office "I will delete all emails receieved unless I am in the office" so considering he's either on flexi leave, annual leave, sick leave, TOIL or working from home he isn't responding either. Ofsted due any day and they have apparently been practising every Monday for months presumably practising hiding and covering up the reality.

DdraigGoch · 05/09/2023 23:24

Starseeking · 05/09/2023 23:13

Those sound like pretty commercial salaries to me, considering they would also have gold plated pensions on top.

The "Director of Strategy, Equalities and Partnerships" is on such a six-figure salary, despite coming into the job with no relevant experience at all.

DdraigGoch · 05/09/2023 23:23

CredibilityProblem · 05/09/2023 23:11

Central government tops up the local government grant pro rata to the student population - so towns and cities with a disproportionate number of students shouldn't lose out in theory - though in practice it's a pretty murky calculation and I'm sure some towns feel shortchanged.

You could make students pay council tax, but in order for them to afford it you'd probably have to increase their maintenance loans, most of which would need to be paid off by the tax payer. And enforcing it on a population of housesharers who move every year, many of whom are overseas students, going to move back abroad at the end of their degree would be hugely expensive.

I thought that it was usually the landlord who paid council tax (where due) for a HMO.

DdraigGoch · 05/09/2023 23:21

RafaistheKingofClay · 05/09/2023 23:04

I think they are old claims from 2012 and before when it wasn’t labour controlled.

It’s to do with bonuses. Low paid jobs typically done by women E.g. TAs, carers, school cooks etc didn’t get bonuses. Jobs typically done by men E.g. bin men, street cleaners did. GMB are taking a number of other councils to court for this so Birmingham are unlikely to be the only council who ends up going bankrupt.

I’m not quite sure why the liability bill is being paid now though. It’s a bit difficult to piece together from the media stories.

These are not old claims from the 2012 court case (which is still being paid off), these are extra and relate to decisions made in the last five years or so.

Starseeking · 05/09/2023 23:13

ScarletWitchM · 05/09/2023 22:23

Do they need to pay £100-200k for these jobs?

Those sound like pretty commercial salaries to me, considering they would also have gold plated pensions on top.

CredibilityProblem · 05/09/2023 23:11

moragmafs · 05/09/2023 22:46

@MidnightOnceMore students should pay. They aren't exempt. Increasing wages doesn't mean anything when the cost of living is so high.

My point is students use the services, and don't contribute. So make them contribute, like the adults they are.

The amount of hassle they cause to local areas as well with their drunkness etc.

Central government tops up the local government grant pro rata to the student population - so towns and cities with a disproportionate number of students shouldn't lose out in theory - though in practice it's a pretty murky calculation and I'm sure some towns feel shortchanged.

You could make students pay council tax, but in order for them to afford it you'd probably have to increase their maintenance loans, most of which would need to be paid off by the tax payer. And enforcing it on a population of housesharers who move every year, many of whom are overseas students, going to move back abroad at the end of their degree would be hugely expensive.

DivingForLove · 05/09/2023 23:10

@Wsmi absolutely! Let’s get the private sector to show them how it’s done - they’re so much better! We can start by handing over our water companies so the private sector can clean up the water!

Oh . . . hold on. That didn’t work did it 🙄

ZadocPDederick · 05/09/2023 23:05

YANBU. It is ludicrous that councils literally cannot afford to comply with their statutory responsibilities to provide for children with SEN, and that's just one example of their gross underfunding.

maddening · 05/09/2023 23:05

StefanosHill · 05/09/2023 20:58

Bloody hell

Well that’ll do it

Why so high

And that is what they still owe - they have already had to pay 1 billion.

RafaistheKingofClay · 05/09/2023 23:04

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 20:56

I mean that kind of is their fault then

I think they are old claims from 2012 and before when it wasn’t labour controlled.

It’s to do with bonuses. Low paid jobs typically done by women E.g. TAs, carers, school cooks etc didn’t get bonuses. Jobs typically done by men E.g. bin men, street cleaners did. GMB are taking a number of other councils to court for this so Birmingham are unlikely to be the only council who ends up going bankrupt.

I’m not quite sure why the liability bill is being paid now though. It’s a bit difficult to piece together from the media stories.

Awittyfool · 05/09/2023 23:03

hiredandsqueak · 05/09/2023 22:08

If you deal with LA SEND depts then you see an awful lot of money just thrown away and it's hard to have sympathy tbh. Our LA regularly uses barristers against unrepresented parents at Tribunal and still lose 99%. Where is the sense in spending hundreds and thousands of pounds to win one or two Tribunals a year? I was forced to appeal again this year, I wanted a £20k package, they forced me to appeal without having any alternative option then conceded the day before to an £80k package. Where is the sense in that? Dd is 20 the £80k would have seen out the end of the EHCP. Only it gets worse, rather than commissioning provision for 38 weeks they commissioned them for 52 so adding an extra 27% to the £80k because they didn't bother to establish the number of weeks. Last week they asked me to send links to the tech needed, it cost £875 but they didn't wait for the link they sent me a budget of £1200. That's one EHCP, so much wasted time and money.

I don’t know where you are but my SE LA is doing this too. So much money wasted because so many people are involved in what are often straightforward allocation of resources tasks
I really hope we are the same LA and it’s not country wide.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/09/2023 22:56

Similar experiences here, SkiingIsHeaven. Only last week I went into the Council House, where they have a new "take a ticket" system - only despite ample signs there were three people standing round a desk to tell pople this, two more at the very simple machine to "help" and yet another two pointing out the chairs (5 yards away) where visitors had to wait

Yes, thank you for pointing out that's a chair - I'd never have worked it out without you Hmm

TedWilson · 05/09/2023 22:55

Birmingham City Council is a disgrace and has been for years.

They sold their "crown jewels" the NEC Group for £300m which was an absolute joke to settle this claim which is still ongoing.

Two years later the purchaser sold it on for £800m. Same management team in place, no major changes.

Added to this the number of times essential services have fallen in to special measures or near to.

It's too big and out of control. I'm absolutely mortified for what they have done to our city.

KHeathen · 05/09/2023 22:55

Oh dear.

Birmingham CC has always been a hugely unwieldy behemoth. I'm a Brummie and was shocked that I pay considerably more council tax than some London boroughs.

It's shockingly mismanaged. And I say that as someone who was on their payroll.

The ridiculous Oracle system completely fucked up my pay and that of several colleagues.

The historic underpayment of female staff is an absolute disgrace.

I temped in a BCC dept recently and was shocked by how many people were off long-term sick / got away with doing very little / were a total waste of space. I'm not talking about the teachers / TAs / binmen / hands on frontline staff. The admin is Kafka-esque in the bureaucracy and pointlessness...

Frankly, I hope that this gives BCC a massive kick up the arse that it needs.

MidnightOnceMore · 05/09/2023 22:54

jallopeno · 05/09/2023 22:52

Course it isn't. I don't run the council. But if I personally had been underpaid for years I would want that to be rectified.

Yes obviously. That's why they've brought the claim.