Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to be appointed at top of pay band

121 replies

MsFrost · 05/09/2023 18:29

I've been offered a new job in higher education and I want to go in at the top of the band becuase my current salary is above it.

AIBU to negotiate this? Would it make a bad impression to push for them to match my current salary, even though it means starting right at the top of the pay band?

Their policy is to start people at the bottom of the band.

OP posts:
Paq · 05/09/2023 21:01

Depending on the role you will be able to negotiate up. Remember the pensions and holiday allowances are often more generous so compare the whole package.

HE is tightening its belts at the moment so you could be offered some extra spine points now and more after 6 months if you pass probation successfully.

Stompythedinosaur · 05/09/2023 20:30

Most pay banded jobs recognise that the job is "worth" the top of the pay band and take money off employees for lack of experience.

If you can demonstrate you have relevent experience, then it is totally reasonable to ask to start on a higher band.

There is nothing wrong with asking at all.

NorthernGirlie · 05/09/2023 20:28

Know your worth!
I'm in FE, been there years so top of the pay scale

We've had loads of new staff lately. All are offered bottom salary. Some negotiated (and came out at various points - many top as we're desperate) others didn't and are at the bottom

There is a lot of upset once people find out that others came in at higher salaries but absolutely nobody has been moved up once in the role

Youonlygetonelife19 · 05/09/2023 20:21

I work in HE. Hiring manager can make a case for it. We often appoint above the bottom despite HR’s recommendation to start at the bottom and negotiate. But it is more based on equity with current staff based on qualifications and experience than matching current salary. I do work in a shortage area.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/09/2023 20:14

I don’t know how it works in HE

In the civil service they always appoint external candidates at the bottom of the payband - the pay bands are very misleading and really only “count” if you’re coming from elsewhere in the civil service and you’re already above the bottom of the band.

missymousey · 05/09/2023 20:13

I've done this successfully in a local authority, where it is also very much the policy to go in at the bottom and they don't expect to negotiate salary. I did it in the phone conversation with the hiring manager when she offered me the post.

GlasgowGal82 · 05/09/2023 20:11

Redbrickrebel · 05/09/2023 18:34

You can ask but you won't get it.

Unless you are moving between posts internally, you always start on the lowest band, which you then work through during the years.

The fact that you are taking a pay cut is your decision

That's not always the case. I'm a recruiting manager and our paperwork says that we normally appoint at the bottom of the scale, but I often make an offer above that point based on skills, experience, previous salary and benchmarking against other colleagues.

year12clueless · 05/09/2023 20:03

The thing is they're really not supposed to take previous salary into account when positioning pay. They need to position pay based on a balance between external competitiveness (the market rate for the role) and internal fairness. If there are other people in the role with experience doing it, then bringing in external people on substantially more messes up this internal equity, and existing employees are likely to be frustrated and ask for pay reviews.
Now- if your current salary is the market rate already then I'd say "go for it" and if you bring others up with you then so be it. The problem comes if you're moving sectors (say from private to public) when pay differentials are bigger.
Basically you can ask but there might be other issues at play.

ColleenDonaghy · 05/09/2023 19:56

Don't ask to go in at the top of the pay band - if you're bringing a lot of experience, ask to go in at the bottom of the pay band with a market supplement to match your current salary and reflect your experience. See what they say from there.

(Much less likely to work if you're junior or they have several suitable candidates to fall back on.)

Shadowchaser · 05/09/2023 19:48

I would ask!

As a side question to those posting on the thread. So say you’re a teacher with 10 years experience in one school and have progressed every year, if you move schools you’re expected to go back to the bottom again?
Sorry if I’ve misinterpreted but im surprised if so.

Calmdown14 · 05/09/2023 19:45

We wouldn't go up to the top of the band.

As previous poster said, one or two spinal points is possible but above that is very rare and causes a massive headache.

Lots of universities have recruitment freezes pending so if there was another candidate appointable I'd do that rather than risk having to do protracted request higher up that could mean I end up having to wait to appoint anyone.

It really depends on the quality of the other candidates which you can't know.

You'll get further being realistic on how far to push.

Zhougzhoug · 05/09/2023 19:45

I’ve asked three times and been successful twice. Once in charity sector and once in higher education (management, not academic.) Both times it was to match what I was currently on, e.g. new job advertised at £35k-£45k, I was on £38k and asked them to match it. I do not think it would have worked if I had been on £35k and just said to them that I’d like to see an increase in my next role.

The time it didn’t work they just told me they honestly didn’t have the budget in the current year but I could expect to go up a point next year. Didn’t laugh in my face or anything.

BugsyDrakeTableScape · 05/09/2023 19:44

I think top is harder to justify in many institutions because often in my experience

a) there are likely to be others on the lower points doing the same job, and if you don't have the experience it's hard to justify putting someone on a higher pay scale without that (bit saying that applies here but it is a factor) and

b) there is likely to be an automatic progression through the band each year maybe or maybe not linked to performance. So if you start at the top there is nowhere to go - and that makes you a potential retention problem. If you're going to be an expensive 1 year hire then it's not worth it.

Not a reason not to ask of course, but university finances are generally fucked so it needs to be a good case

notsallyrooney · 05/09/2023 19:36

I did this in HE. (Not the top of the band but negotiated up.) it does definitely happen!

AlltheFs · 05/09/2023 19:34

It depends how much they want you. I transferred from one HEI to another and did move across at the top of scale. But they don’t like it and will only do it occasionally.

They needed me more than I needed them though at that point. It isn’t achieved all that often. Mid point is easier, top is rarer.

IAmNoLady · 05/09/2023 19:34

I have recruited people in at 'top of band' and I have negotiated to start at 'top of band' myself.

Granted not your sector.

Nothing asked, nothing gained.

Aria2015 · 05/09/2023 19:30

I've done this in the civil service. I was clear when offered the job that I'd take it only if I was put in at the top of the band. I got it and was told to keep quiet about it!

Trebormints74 · 05/09/2023 19:24

@Redbrickrebel I have in both public and private sector jobs. In some cases I’ve been offered a match without asking.

shitetatts · 05/09/2023 19:23

We've had similar recently.

In the end we withdrew our offer, as the candidate would not accept any lower.

From our perspective we had others in the same role on less, that had been there 2-3 years. We did not want to pay a new starter more than the current staff. What they earned previously was not relevant, and they may have been very experienced in their previous workplace, but they were not as experienced in OUR workplace as our existing staff, so we declined to pay them a higher salary.

hatgirl · 05/09/2023 19:19

Redbrickrebel · 05/09/2023 18:34

You can ask but you won't get it.

Unless you are moving between posts internally, you always start on the lowest band, which you then work through during the years.

The fact that you are taking a pay cut is your decision

Not true.

I work in a professionally qualified role for a local authority. I've been qualified for over a decade and have a significant amount of experience. I have moved between local authorities on a few occasions and each time have requested and have received pay at the top of the banding or at the spine point within the banding that matched my salary in my previous role.

There would be no incentive for me to move roles (and my profession is significantly in demand) if each time I moved I had to start at the bottom of the pay banding and get the same as newly qualifieds in the team.

CallieTR · 05/09/2023 19:16

I have applied for jobs before that are advertised at £35k to £45k (as an example) and then upon job offer been told that they only appoint at the bottom of the band. This wasn’t made clear in the job advert or interview so I can see why people apply expecting to be able to negotiate to higher than the lowest advertised salary.

In my current role, I negotiated to towards the top of the band and when I had been in role for 6 months they re-banded my role to the next band up to give space for annual increases etc.

BarbaraWoodlouse · 05/09/2023 19:09

Private sector here but the issue in hiring in at the very top of a band is that you have nowhere to go in terms of annual merit increase unless there is a case to promote someone to the next role/band.

That’s not to say that people start at the bottom, it should be based on experience etc but sometimes you are not doing anyone a favour if you bring them in right at the top.

SoundTheSirens · 05/09/2023 18:59

I’ve worked in HE previously, including recruiting, and we had flexibility to appoint up to two points above the base salary (albeit supported with a business case) but not above that. Every institution will have its own rules so absolutely ask!

IchWill · 05/09/2023 18:57

I've worked in HE last few years. I had to put my current salary on application form and I was earning middle of university salary band.

When I was offered the job, I was offered starting salary. Which when you compared to my salary at the time and company car I had, it was a big pay drop.

I gently pushed back and stated I couldn't afford such a huge drop. The hiring manager said it was their policy to start at bottom of salary band. I said that unfortunately I genuinely couldn't afford to take such a drop and added I was gutted, as I really wanted the job. I also said that I'd be willing to trade some annual leave in if they had flexible benefits.

Hiring manager then came back and oddly offered more than I was seeking and I didn't have to trade any annual leave as they didn't do that.

During my time, I moved up a level in pay band each year and when I hired my team, I sought advice when a candidate pushed for higher and I was told it was up to me as the hiring manager to agree salary. HR added that starting a new job was the only time anyone can negotiate a salary at the university. That included internal hires too.

HandScreen · 05/09/2023 18:55

HandScreen · 05/09/2023 18:55

I make salary and appointment decisions, and I would award at the top of the pay band in this case.

In academia, I should say

Swipe left for the next trending thread