Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to be appointed at top of pay band

121 replies

MsFrost · 05/09/2023 18:29

I've been offered a new job in higher education and I want to go in at the top of the band becuase my current salary is above it.

AIBU to negotiate this? Would it make a bad impression to push for them to match my current salary, even though it means starting right at the top of the pay band?

Their policy is to start people at the bottom of the band.

OP posts:
MendedDrum · 06/09/2023 13:17

MsFrost · 06/09/2023 12:23

@BugsyDrakeTableScape I get what you're saying but it's utterly nonsensical to knock someone back so they can 'progress' to where they already are.

Most people would rather be put at the top (matching their current pay) and not progress, than take a pay reduction so they can 'progress' back to where they currently are in a couple of years.

That's not progression, it's just knocking someone down and making them get up again.

University HR tried the same spiel on me - I called bullshit. Know your worth.

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 06/09/2023 13:12

MargotBamborough · 06/09/2023 09:41

No, if everyone did this then they would have to find the money to pay teachers, lecturers and nurses better wages.

That’s incredibly naive I’m afraid

VeloVixen · 06/09/2023 12:41

It really will depend on the job and your current job.

for example I know senior nurses at matron level who earn more than a lecturer salary but come in on the bottom a lecturer band as they have no teaching experience, no Masters, no pg cert. Now if they have gained some of these in their matron role then negotiation to the top of the band is far more likely. But even if they start mid band they won’t be able to go (initially) do the job as well as someone who started five years ago at the bottom of the band.

it does mean some course struggle to recruit lecturers, health courses, architecture, etc. the only degree course I know who pay on a totally different scale is medicine. I was always told that if you want to get into lecturing you do it because you’re passionate about education and are prepared to take the drop in salary. Or imho you hate working in the nhs so much you’re prepared to take the drop!

im not sure about professional services but I’d imagine it’s a similar argument. Someone could be an experienced admin/PA but do they understand exam boards, the software, the plethora of academic regulations?

BugsyDrakeTableScape · 06/09/2023 12:40

@MsFrost I can see how it might look and feel like that - but genuinely I think it's about trying to match skills and experience to the available pay for the role. It's not about 'worth' in that sense - but about how the skills and experience brought to the role are effectively remunerated. Progression is after all not all about money but also skills, experience competencies etc.

If you've got a case to argue for the top of the scale then do it! There are examples on this thread of people who have successfully done it so it's not unheard of at all. But culturally in HE I don't think just having a salary which is at that level already on its own is enough in the first instance - it's about matching those skills and experience to the role at that level. If you think about it - if they appoint usually at the bottom then someone at the top would be deemed to have 6 years relevent experience in that role - that's what they're looking for to match.

DrCoconut · 06/09/2023 12:38

@shitetatts I was just going to say that the OP can ask and may get but (and this is only based on my experience) can expect to be as popular as Covid 19 if existing staff find out that the new recruit is on a higher salary than them. These things create a lot of tension and ill feeling.

MargotBamborough · 06/09/2023 12:30

MsFrost · 06/09/2023 12:27

Public sector: "We're just going to knock you back a bit so you've got room to improve" - how ridiculous!

How about "we're going to increase the top of the band so you've got motivation to improve"?

No?

Didn't think so.

MsFrost · 06/09/2023 12:27

Public sector: "We're just going to knock you back a bit so you've got room to improve" - how ridiculous!

OP posts:
MsFrost · 06/09/2023 12:23

@BugsyDrakeTableScape I get what you're saying but it's utterly nonsensical to knock someone back so they can 'progress' to where they already are.

Most people would rather be put at the top (matching their current pay) and not progress, than take a pay reduction so they can 'progress' back to where they currently are in a couple of years.

That's not progression, it's just knocking someone down and making them get up again.

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 06/09/2023 12:21

MsFrost · 06/09/2023 12:03

If they ask that it would really be none of their business.

They advertised a pay band and the top of that pay band is a salary I would be happy to accept, so I feel I was perfectly fine to apply for the job.

I think if organisations only want to appoint at the bottom of the band they should say that on the job advert. This advert said that they 'usually appoint at the bottom of the band, dependent on current salary and experience' - implying that they would match my current salary or close.

You are absolutely right. In the civil service they advertise a pay band which is essentially fictitious. Occasionally someone might manage to be appointed towards the bottom of it rather than right at the bottom of it. But the way they word their advertisements suggests that you can be appointed anywhere on that pay band and that you then move up it. This is false. Where you start is where you stay, due to the pay freeze which has been in place for over a decade. The only people at the top of the pay band are the people who have been bimbling along at the same pay grade for 20 years without being promoted, but benefited from years of automatic pay increases prior to 2011, i.e. the dead wood. I worked with someone in that position. Utterly useless, she was. Didn't stop her constantly banging on about how impossible it was to get promoted, implying that there was some sort of discrimination going on, when the much more competent people who were actually getting promoted were going in at the bottom of the next pay band and basically getting paid the same as her, only with management responsibilities.

Public sector pay sucks, and you should definitely try as hard as possible to negotiate your starting salary, because that might be your only opportunity to negotiate.

BugsyDrakeTableScape · 06/09/2023 12:14

@MsFrost - and you are very valid in your points and feelings. All I'm saying is that in Universities the opportunities for other rewards are often limited. So that would be it for the foreseeable future, it is unlikely you would be able to negotiate a payrise from that point - there are no other avenues, no bonuses etc. Whilst I appreciate you say that works for you - for others the reality might be that after say 1-2 years of not improving financially they start to look elsewhere - which causes the recruitment issues. So people don't like recruiting at the top of the band because they think people won't stay as one of the 'perks' of HE is that ability to progress through the band with relative ease.

It's particularly relevant if they need to invest in any training etc for someone - if they don't get the ROI on that then it's an expensive recruitment exercise.

Again though - it:s not a reason not to ask. I'm just sharing my experiences of 25 years of recruiting in HE and the quirks of the sector. And ultimately you just need to ask the question and see what the answer is - the rest of this is just context as to why it's not as easy as a job offer negotiation in other sectors might be.

MsFrost · 06/09/2023 12:03

MabelMaybe · 06/09/2023 09:33

In HE, they would only recruit above the bottom of the pay band if you have a particular experience / skill set worth paying for, not just because you've previously been paid more. There's no way you'd get to come in at the top of the pay band because part of recruitment is an element of cost saving in HE right now; it's likely the previous person left at the top of the pay band.

Pay isn't something that can be negotiated in HE in the same way as in the private sector. You may find that they ask why you applied for a job that's lower paid than your previous role.

If they ask that it would really be none of their business.

They advertised a pay band and the top of that pay band is a salary I would be happy to accept, so I feel I was perfectly fine to apply for the job.

I think if organisations only want to appoint at the bottom of the band they should say that on the job advert. This advert said that they 'usually appoint at the bottom of the band, dependent on current salary and experience' - implying that they would match my current salary or close.

OP posts:
MsFrost · 06/09/2023 11:54

Once you're at the top of a band, it's very hard to progress payrise other than cost of living increases in a lot of institutions. If you go in at the top there is nowhere to go - so how likely is someone to stay if they aren't able to progress financially? Recruitment is expensive.

@BugsyDrakeTableScape This reasoning makes no sense whatsoever. I would be perfectly happy to be put on the top of the pay band and sit there, rather than being knocked down a grade or two and be made to climb back up.

I don't see it as giving me a chance to progress next year. All it's doing is putting me on the back foot this year and I then have to climb back up again. Which, to be honest, it much more likely to make me feel undervalued.

OP posts:
witmum · 06/09/2023 11:47

Of course you negotiate but give a clear reason why you deserve the higher pay.

I am not in HE but your time is worth money. If the team is on less that is not your concern. The market is open and you have a choice.

SD1978 · 06/09/2023 11:41

I'd apply with your criteria, and give your reasons why in the interview. If they say no, but are willing to compromise to an extent then the choice is yours. Not applying because you assume (and let be real, probably correctly) that they won't, means you'll never what they can/ will offer if you're the best candidate

HBGKC · 06/09/2023 09:57

@hatgirl may I ask what your job title is?

jazzyfips · 06/09/2023 09:44

Redbrickrebel · 05/09/2023 18:34

You can ask but you won't get it.

Unless you are moving between posts internally, you always start on the lowest band, which you then work through during the years.

The fact that you are taking a pay cut is your decision

You don’t always start on the bottom. It can be negotiated. I’ve done this in several sectors.

MargotBamborough · 06/09/2023 09:41

GCSister · 06/09/2023 09:27

If everyone did this then there would be no teachers, lecturers, nurses etc.

No, if everyone did this then they would have to find the money to pay teachers, lecturers and nurses better wages.

MabelMaybe · 06/09/2023 09:33

In HE, they would only recruit above the bottom of the pay band if you have a particular experience / skill set worth paying for, not just because you've previously been paid more. There's no way you'd get to come in at the top of the pay band because part of recruitment is an element of cost saving in HE right now; it's likely the previous person left at the top of the pay band.

Pay isn't something that can be negotiated in HE in the same way as in the private sector. You may find that they ask why you applied for a job that's lower paid than your previous role.

GCSister · 06/09/2023 09:27

ManyMaybes · 05/09/2023 21:58

Pay bands are bullshit excuses to pay people less. Tell them what you want and take nothing less.

Then if they don’t increase your salary in a reasonable manner each year (I.e. because you are already at the top of the band) then leave.

If everyone did this then there would be no teachers, lecturers, nurses etc.

pastypirate · 06/09/2023 09:06

It's normal in my sector (local gov) to get salaries matched

ColleenDonaghy · 06/09/2023 09:04

AlltheFs · 05/09/2023 23:31

You can’t do that in this sector. The pay bands are national, just like NHS and other public sector. They are bargained collectively annually and set in stone.

There’s a London weighting but that’s it. If you are a Senior Lecturer in the South East you get paid the same in the North West. There is no negotiating outside of the pay band.

Not true. I have a market supplement that means I earn more at Lecturer than my DH does at Reader (just about). I'm far from the only one in my department either.

BugsyDrakeTableScape · 06/09/2023 09:03

MsFrost · 06/09/2023 06:43

Just to be clear, I'm not trying to negotiate outside of the payband.

If, for example, the pay band is £31-36K, I mean I'm asking for 36K (which is lower than my current salary but I'm prepared to accept - there are various reasons I want this job).

In the advert it said that they usually appoint at the bottom of the band but that current salary and experience can be taken into account.

But on the phone, the manager seemed a bit put out about me asking not to start on the bottom.

Once you're at the top of a band, it's very hard to progress payrise other than cost of living increases in a lot of institutions. If you go in at the top there is nowhere to go - so how likely is someone to stay if they aren't able to progress financially? Recruitment is expensive.

With experience - I think in HE it depends on the role as to how much similar roles can be taken into account. For example in some HE data analysis roles unless you've worked within the specific data regulatory framework you will need to build up the knowledge and experience of it to make the right judgement calls on what to do. Having the skills to then do it would only be half the job. So appointing someone at the top of the grade paying more than others who do have that experience and would have to guide the new people is a difficult sell.

Absolutely you should ask for what you want - I'm a big advocate of that - but it is worth being aware of the limitations in the way the sector operates as to why it's not as straightforward as in other sectors.

GCSister · 06/09/2023 08:57

AlltheFs · 06/09/2023 08:46

It’s not the scale that is different it is the grading that can vary. The spinal points are the same, a spinal point 30 pays the same everywhere it is just the role benchmarking that can differ so a role could span slightly different spinal points between institutions but the spinal points are the same monetary value.

Except some universities have chosen to implement pay rises despite negotiations continuing.
Me and DH work at different universities and the points are not identical.

But none of this is really relevant to the OPs question anyway. They are asking about movement within a grade, which is possible at many institutions.

AlltheFs · 06/09/2023 08:46

It’s not the scale that is different it is the grading that can vary. The spinal points are the same, a spinal point 30 pays the same everywhere it is just the role benchmarking that can differ so a role could span slightly different spinal points between institutions but the spinal points are the same monetary value.

PinkRoses1245 · 06/09/2023 08:26

Yes I did this in higher education, I asked for top of the grade and they gave me one point below it. You get annual point increases anyway. Definitely worth asking.