Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if people use wedding registries?

58 replies

WeddingRegistry · 05/09/2023 16:55

I'm getting married in 2 weeks and have a wedding website with an online registry. While we have a mechanism for gifting cash I've also got a registry that took me many hours to make, got a good mix of gifts on there from £10 right up to big ticket items! Also suggestions for people who don't want to buy a specific 'thing' e.g 'plants for the garden' (not really plants but you get the idea)

Did anybody appreciate my effort in making life easier?

Nope, out of 40 guests only 3 have bought/reserved stuff.

Maybe people will think about it last minute, but what if people turn up with multiple toasters?? Or champagne flutes? Of course I'll write everyone a nice thank you note etc etc but still.

Chief of which... future H's parents... who made such a big fuss about the registry because 'friends will want to buy you gifts' and then crickets. If I'd known that nobody would care I wouldn't have bothered.

So tell me, people of MN... do you use registries, or just buy what you want?

FYI of course the day is to celebrate but I think I'm just annoyed at how this was made out to be a big deal and wasted so much of my time.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MariaVT65 · 07/09/2023 06:55

WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 22:20

I also thought that maybe they did a bulk for 'Summer'... which is peak wedding season and mine isn't really, so maybe it's on the 'after the summer holidays' list of things to do.

See your last sentence doesn't really make sense. You say weddings are expensive to attend and that a list of gifts implies the couple want more, in addition to the cost of attending. At the same time, with threads on here everyone is insistent that going without a gift is the height of rudeness!

FWIW my wedding isn't going to be expensive for the majority of the guests, they mostly live near the venue, dress code smart casual. The few that have kids are leaving them with family. This isn't relevant to people giving gifts, but, unlike some of the things I have read on here with formal outfits, needing to travel/accommodation etc it does seem quite simple in comparison.

Yeah I get what you’re saying, and I’d never go without a gift, but it’s the tone of how you ask for gifts. Most weddings i’ve been to have been very expensive to attend (i went to one last weekend that was in the middle of nowhere so everyone had to pay for very expensive taxis and accommodation). However, these couples have also said on their invites that they are not expecting gifts and that if you’d like to contribute, any amount of donation towards honeymoon would be appreciated. I think explicitly saying you don’t expect a gift is important especially if you’re going to provide a list of gifts.

I imagine though that as PP said, you may get more takers nearer the time. Just in the same way that if i arranged cash, i’d get it out a few days before.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 06/09/2023 22:58

I always do my wedding gift list shopping last min when I log on to find out where I'm supposed to be and when the night before the wedding so you'll probably get lots of gifts then!

Have fun

gogomoto · 06/09/2023 22:26

Years ago they were common but more recently people have lived together so it's cash or nothing (donations to charity are fairly common in my age group too)

WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 22:20

MariaVT65 · 06/09/2023 22:05

I’ve never been to a wedding with a registry. I think if I did, I probably wouldn’t be thinking about it far in advance though. People have other gifts to think of like birthdays in the meantime.

Also, yeah weddings are expensive to attend, so it really depends on how you then communicate the whole ‘here is a list of gifts we also want’.

I also thought that maybe they did a bulk for 'Summer'... which is peak wedding season and mine isn't really, so maybe it's on the 'after the summer holidays' list of things to do.

See your last sentence doesn't really make sense. You say weddings are expensive to attend and that a list of gifts implies the couple want more, in addition to the cost of attending. At the same time, with threads on here everyone is insistent that going without a gift is the height of rudeness!

FWIW my wedding isn't going to be expensive for the majority of the guests, they mostly live near the venue, dress code smart casual. The few that have kids are leaving them with family. This isn't relevant to people giving gifts, but, unlike some of the things I have read on here with formal outfits, needing to travel/accommodation etc it does seem quite simple in comparison.

OP posts:
WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 22:11

BarbieKew · 06/09/2023 22:05

I love a registry and buy early so there’s a good choice, I’d much rather give a present than cash, if possible. However, most people leave these things until the last minute, so I’m sure more will be ticked off your list.

Aww thanks.
Yes, I would also buy early so I can have my pick (plus I might forget). I guess others don't though.
Or maybe they prefer cash. Who knows?

OP posts:
forgotname · 06/09/2023 22:10

Got married last Friday, used Prezola (mainly for cash options) and John Lewis for other items. Nothing was purchased from JL list. Started to receive cash on Prezola a week before. Still receiving up until yesterday. We used one of them letter box things on the day and also received a lot of cards with cash in them.

WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 22:10

Pottedpalm · 05/09/2023 18:21

DS and DDiL used one for their recent wedding. They already had a lot of stuff but will move to a bigger place in Spring when DGCh is born. They included items for the new house as well as traditional crockery etc. About 2/3 of the items were purchased, with groups of work friends clubbing together for some big ticket items. A few (mainly family) gave money. They had about four gifts not from the register.

aww that's lovely. Congratulations on becoming MIL and the future grandchild! (ok well maybe you have other already married kids but still). It's nice to see that people used the registry!

OP posts:
MariaVT65 · 06/09/2023 22:05

I’ve never been to a wedding with a registry. I think if I did, I probably wouldn’t be thinking about it far in advance though. People have other gifts to think of like birthdays in the meantime.

Also, yeah weddings are expensive to attend, so it really depends on how you then communicate the whole ‘here is a list of gifts we also want’.

WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 22:05

supadupapupascupa · 05/09/2023 18:41

We had one with wrap it. It was a huge success. Over £800 was spent innit.
Then they went bust and we lost the lot

Oh dear, that's a shame!
I don't understand though - did they take the cash and not deliver you the gifts?
I thought it was all with third party suppliers anyway. All the registries just link to, say Amazon and JL

OP posts:
BarbieKew · 06/09/2023 22:05

I love a registry and buy early so there’s a good choice, I’d much rather give a present than cash, if possible. However, most people leave these things until the last minute, so I’m sure more will be ticked off your list.

WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 22:04

PurpleFlower1983 · 05/09/2023 19:55

I was thinking about this the other day, gift registries seemed to be a thing up to about 2010 then they completely disappeared from my circle anyway. I think they’re just out of fashion and people find it easier to give cash/vouchers.

That's interesting!
It certainly seems to be a big thing in American weddings (I work with a lot of American people). I can certainly discuss weddings with them as there's no way they'd even expect an invite.

Also wondering whether as a PP said a lot of people don't want 'stuff' anyway

OP posts:
MariaVT65 · 06/09/2023 22:03

Lemevoir · 05/09/2023 19:21

This is really odd logic... Why is it more thoughtful to buy the couple a gift that you think they might like or need, than something that they've specifically asked for and presumably do need and/or want?

We didn’t have a registry. We did get some really lovely and thoughtful gifts i’d have never thought to ask for though. Like someone got an artist to draw a small Harry Potter love potion picture with our names wedding date in it. It’s hung in our kitchen.

WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 22:02

@FionaChapman @floofball4 certainly opposite experiences here!
We're somewhere in between. We haven't been living together long - less than 2 years. We moved from our respective house shares into a flat, shortly before buying a house together a few months ago.
As such we haven't got a lot of stuff yet, neither of our previous homes had much space for anything other than the bare essentials.

OP posts:
WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 21:55

snowlady4 · 05/09/2023 18:23

Not a fan of the gift registry myself. Whilst you spent ages doing yours, picking things you'd like to receive, many shops/companies do a genetic list and then the bride/groom receive vouchers to that value- with an added extra as their incentive for doing their registry there at all.
I personally find the whole idea quite vulgar and old fashioned (sorry,) and think people should just be thankful for what they're given- weddings are a dreadful expense to the guests as it is, without being shown a list of gift suggestions.
Equally awful in my opinion is those poems you get in the invitation, trying to be cute about it, but actually requesting cash from guests!
However, now you've made the list- just enjoy what you are gifted from it- don't worry about it too much! You'll get loads in gifts/cash- people are super generous.
Congratulations and enjoy your celebrations!

Thank you for your well wishes

OP posts:
WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 21:54

Lemevoir · 05/09/2023 19:21

This is really odd logic... Why is it more thoughtful to buy the couple a gift that you think they might like or need, than something that they've specifically asked for and presumably do need and/or want?

I agree, I certainly would buy from a registry if attending someone else's wedding
I think I'd ask close friends directly.
For others, especially for people I don't know that well it's better.

The recent 'wedding cash' here was eye-opening... £100 per person for a cash gift? Not for my wedding but that made me really nervous what if I went for someone else's wedding and they thought I was cheap?

At least a registry is easier. In my case I didn't think it was really needed as the wedding isn't that big, we can manage people asking directly and most attendees we speak to regularly anyway.

OP posts:
WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 21:51

Also @MolkosTeenageAngst I do have 'suggestions' on there that aren't gifts. I use WithJoy so for example, one is 'some nice plants for front garden'.
I had no idea what's normal and every site I searched has different views so I just tried to cover all bases to not be seen as grabby.
One funny thing was... a very 'senior' relative bought the most expensive gift, FMIL was complaining to FDH about that, because then she and FFIL couldn't buy it!

Really can't win here can I? 😅

OP posts:
WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 21:47

Lemevoir · 05/09/2023 19:48

That's fair enough. I guess I was thinking of my own experience, similar to the OP's, where many guests who didn't really know us as a couple very well (for example, our parent's friends/relatives we don't see very often) didn't buy anything from our gift register and we ended up with lots of pottery/crystal bowls and vases/glassware - none of it matching and all rather too large to store in the tiny flat we lived in at the time 😄

Haha yes, that was FMIL's thinking!
Her other reason though was 'friends of the family' (who are not invited to the wedding) want to buy gifts and have asked her for ideas?
I don't know whether this is something common to her and her friends. She has sent gifts when she wasn't invited so maybe they're just 'repaying' what she's done?

@MolkosTeenageAngst I do think that also, some people think wedding gifts should be 'for the couple' (at least that's what comes up when I googled it) so PP who knew us individually might not know what to buy a 'couple'.

OP posts:
WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 21:35

@TedMullins @Maireas I wouldn't mind doing that, but FMIL thinks it's not the 'done thing'. Also, she said a lot of people would insist on giving gifts anyway so with a registry it would ensure that it wasn't duplicated or anything.
The logic of which i can't really argue with.

Perhaps a PP is right, it's too early. This is odd for me, as I am always organised, but if I don't do a thing when I remember it never gets done anyway.

OP posts:
PinkCherryBlossoms · 06/09/2023 20:57

Fwiw I can see that it'd be a bugger if you're ND OP. The etiquette in the UK has been on the move for a while, and people hold really different views. There's been a clear move towards cash, and having cultural heritage where that's the norm I think it's no bad thing. But it certainly hasn't permeated the whole of society yet.

Maireas · 06/09/2023 20:43

I agree, it's your wedding. You can clearly say "no gifts".
If you want, you could nominate a charity for donations if people want to give something.

TedMullins · 06/09/2023 20:35

WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 20:29

People can give cash online as well, that's what it means.
I don't 'care' about my wedding, other people do, and as evidenced by the threads on here almost everything you do has potential to offend people. Not only am I not British I'm also neurodiverse, and I don't really know what is acceptable or not. So I tried to give people a range of options. Future DH, also ND has no clue about any of this and FMIL is the only one having any advice/opinions!

Happy to have provided you some hilarity though, hope it makes your day better :)

Edited

Who cares what FMIL or other people might think though? Do what YOU want to do. If that’s put “no gifts”, then put no gifts! It’s your wedding, not your MILs

WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 20:35

LeiaOrganaBananaHamock · 05/09/2023 19:15

i got married recently and had an online registry- most gifts were bought the night before!

Aww hahaha that's encouraging - how did they arrive on time though?
Did they all arrive at your house after the wedding? So nobody brought anything to the venue?

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 06/09/2023 20:34

In the real world most people like giving wedding presents, be it cash, vouchers or something off a list.

We didn't live together before marriage so people were very happy buying us saucepans, plates, tea towels etc off the list!

PinkCherryBlossoms · 06/09/2023 20:34

I normally default to cash but yes, registries are fine too. Better than leaving me to work it out myself. Can't be arsed with the whole pretence that we don't both know full well I'm going to get you a present.

Haven't seen a registry in a few years though, now I come to think of it. And if I were one of your guests I probably would end up just doing cash.

WeddingRegistry · 06/09/2023 20:29

cocksstrideintheevening · 05/09/2023 18:27

I've never been to a wedding with a registry that I was aware of. Most people live together before marriage and don't need the stuff.

And what the fuck is a mechanism for giving cash?

You care about your wedding more than anyone else does, it'll be the same if you have a kid if you don't already. The hours you put into into it is a hilarious thought.

People can give cash online as well, that's what it means.
I don't 'care' about my wedding, other people do, and as evidenced by the threads on here almost everything you do has potential to offend people. Not only am I not British I'm also neurodiverse, and I don't really know what is acceptable or not. So I tried to give people a range of options. Future DH, also ND has no clue about any of this and FMIL is the only one having any advice/opinions!

Happy to have provided you some hilarity though, hope it makes your day better :)

OP posts: