Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How long should a laptop last?

116 replies

BorrowedThyme · 05/09/2023 16:48

I bought an expensive, high spec laptop to teach in lock down. Now the charging is intermittent, the screen is splitting away from its frame, and the mouse keeps freezing.

AIBU to think something that cost £600 should last longer than 3 and a half years?

OP posts:
Netcam · 06/09/2023 11:22

ntmdino · 06/09/2023 10:51

Good on him - although it's totally reasonable to buy the pre-built option as an alternative to HP/Lenovo/etc. Parts availability looks great, the business definitely seems like it's going to last, and the upgrade option is incredibly attractive - not only do you have the ability to just upgrade the motherboard, you can use the old one as a standalone computer (I think you can even buy commercial cases for them now, not just using 3D-printed ones).

Agree that the pre built option looks great too, I would probably go for that for simplicity. But he wanted to choose his own OS and have the experience of building it himself, he is very techy!

Until he got this a couple of weeks ago he was using my ancient HP laptop that I bought for about £300 ten years ago. Despite it not being officially upgradable, he'd managed to take it apart and install an SSD, a new screen, a replacement battery and a Linux OS.

Sgtmajormummy · 06/09/2023 10:52

We’ve just got rid of an 8yo Acer which did DC1 for 2 years high school and 2 years of university, lockdown and 3 years high school of DC2. So a fair amount of wear and tear.
The battery no longer worked and it had frozen twice in the last year (repair shop).
It didn’t owe us anything.

ntmdino · 06/09/2023 10:51

Netcam · 06/09/2023 10:47

My son has just got a Framework laptop, he is just about to start 6th form and it looked like the best option for him. He got the 'build it yourself' option which he loved and installed a Linus OS himself. It looks great, when my Thinkpad finally gives up I will get one myself next time.

Good on him - although it's totally reasonable to buy the pre-built option as an alternative to HP/Lenovo/etc. Parts availability looks great, the business definitely seems like it's going to last, and the upgrade option is incredibly attractive - not only do you have the ability to just upgrade the motherboard, you can use the old one as a standalone computer (I think you can even buy commercial cases for them now, not just using 3D-printed ones).

Dotjones · 06/09/2023 10:50

Generally you get what you pay for. My experience is the more I spend on a laptop the longer it lasts. £600 isn't very much in the grand scheme of things so I'm not surprised it's wearing out after this amount of time. (I mean for a laptop it's not very much. If you need to find it suddenly for an unexpected bill it might be a huge amount.)

It depends on how well you take care of it of course too. The problems you describe in the OP sound more like misuse or at least normal wear-and-tear more than anything else. Batteries are consumables and after a few years of being charged/discharged over and over they will lose effectiveness and capacity. The problem with the mousepad might be a result of rough handling or it might be a sign your computer is cluttered up with junk and is trying to use more resources than it has the capacity for. The screen splitting from the frame definitey sounds like ill-treatment.

I'm not a fan of mid-range laptops like a £600 one would be. I'd usually tell people to either by a "cheap as shit" one for £300 or so and accept it won't be very powerful or last long, or spend at least a thousand on something more robust and powerful. Mid-range ones tend to be the worst of both worlds, expensive but still a bit shit.

Netcam · 06/09/2023 10:48

Linux not Linus, typo!

Netcam · 06/09/2023 10:47

ntmdino · 05/09/2023 19:07

Apologies, didn't mean to sound insulting! The sad fact, though, is that unless you're spending £1k+ on a laptop, you can't expect more than 3-4 years of useful life out of it.

For what it's worth, my next laptop will be a Framework - every component is replaceable and upgradeable.

You might be able to find a smaller workshop who'd be capable of fixing yours, but it's unlikely to be cheap.

My son has just got a Framework laptop, he is just about to start 6th form and it looked like the best option for him. He got the 'build it yourself' option which he loved and installed a Linus OS himself. It looks great, when my Thinkpad finally gives up I will get one myself next time.

DyslexicPoster · 06/09/2023 10:45

It should last way more than 3 years. I had a few as I'm ex IBM and I had a work one for 5 years that was dropped countless times and used every day. It was a workhorse.

I have had two 2nd hand ones from CEX last me years as well

LondonPapa · 06/09/2023 10:42

BorrowedThyme · 05/09/2023 16:48

I bought an expensive, high spec laptop to teach in lock down. Now the charging is intermittent, the screen is splitting away from its frame, and the mouse keeps freezing.

AIBU to think something that cost £600 should last longer than 3 and a half years?

I'd expect a £600 laptop to last 3-4 years before it shows signs of aging. My Dell laptop I got during lockdown is starting to give up the ghost. Compared to my MacBook Pro from nearly 10 years ago still going strong, it really is a different experience.

You get what you pay for at the end of the day.

Netcam · 06/09/2023 10:41

I think Lenovos vary hugely, depending on the model. I bought a heavy duty Lenovo Thinkpad in 2016 and 7 years later it is still going strong. The Thinkpads are made to last, but they are expensive. But one of their cheaper models might not be so long lasting.

egowise · 06/09/2023 10:41

My Dell xps13 is still perfect after 5 years, but that was top of the range i7 when I bought it.

I wouldn't expect that long for a £5-600 depending on usage.

FanDeath · 06/09/2023 10:39

Depends how heavily you use it. I've had laptops throughout my life, and when I've been using them heavily (like 12hr per day) they rarely make it much past 2yr. I used to budget to buy a new laptop every couple years and then be chuffed if it lasted longer.

Depends what you use it for too. Basic stuff like word processing, YouTube videos? Lasts longer. Very resource-intensive games? It won't last as long.

Tessisme · 06/09/2023 10:37

I had a Toshiba laptop that lasted about 8 or 9 years. Big bulky thing, but absolutely reliable. Then I replaced it with an HP and it started to go after about 2 years. When I took it for repair, it was referred to as 'old'. It was in perfect condition and didn't get much use, but the keyboard had started to fail. The price of a new keyboard was ridiculous, so I told them just to leave it. I used it for a while with a separate keyboard I already owned, then the battery stopped charging🙄

HappiDaze · 06/09/2023 10:36

My MacBook Air from 2017 is still going strong. It had a new battery a couple of years ago.

FFSWhatToDoNow · 06/09/2023 10:35

My MBP is 8 years old and still going strong……..

KimberleyClark · 06/09/2023 10:34

My HP Pavilion that I bought just before lockdown for £750 still works perfectly.

Nw22 · 06/09/2023 10:25

I dont think 600 is an expensive laptop. I wouldn’t expect it to last more than a couple of years

suetees · 06/09/2023 10:21

I am using a Dell latitude that I bought refurbished five years ago. It was made in 2016 I think, it has served me well. The only reason I will upgrade will be if I want/need Windows 11 and then again only spend £200-250 on another refurbished one.

This is based on working at a consultancy and discussions with the procurement and maintenance people in the IT department- they supply laptops for 3000 or so people like me working across Government and the private sector, many of us out in the field so transporting our laptops around. They always used Latitudes because all parts are replaceable and they are more robustly built than 'home' models in the first place. They also have room to upgrade memory and other items if required in the future

If you buy a Dell Latitude or Lenovo Thinkpad that has been refurbished they will have checked the keyboard, mouse, screen and battery and replaced if necessary -and if these components go in the future they will be easily replaceable.

VeloVixen · 06/09/2023 09:59

My personal HP laptop is 5 years old and works as well as my new work HP laptop.

AnythingILike · 06/09/2023 09:54

3 years is my rule for all laptops

Delphigirl · 06/09/2023 09:52

I have two MacBook airs. One 2015 which I now use as a second screen/back up laptop. It pretty much lives on my desk on its own little pedestal but it still is in full working order and is used daily for videoconferences. My main one which is 2020 and gets carried around to and fro, abroad etc. It has been dropped a few times. The rubber seal around the screen is coming away so I ought to get that looked at but otherwise it is also trouble free. I’ve never had a non-Mac live past 3 years and they have all been slow and troublesome at the end of their lives. I get given work laptops but don’t use them.

Mr85 · 06/09/2023 09:42

As others have said, it depends on how it's treated. My work laptops are still like new after 8 years but that is because they sit on my desk open almost all of the time with an external keyboard and mouse. I only touch it maybe 10 times a year when going off site.

Opening and closing the screen will wear it out and if you have it on your lap applying pressure to the charge plug it will eventually work loose and stop charging.

rileynexttime · 06/09/2023 09:30

@andymary could you say more about overcharging ?
How is this avoided?
And @andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow how is it best to store a laptop?
And any other things we should and shouldn't do with laptops?

mjf981 · 06/09/2023 06:02

I'd be pissed off if my laptop only lasted 3 years, assuming I'd taken care of it. use macbooks and love them. My current one is about 9 years old and not a thing wrong with it (for what I need it for anyway). Will only ever buy macbooks for he foreseeable.

Simonjt · 06/09/2023 05:56

My macbook is 9 years old, never had any issues. My son has my super old white case macbook that I used at uni, yes some things aren’t compatible, but you can watch streaming services etc, web, play my older games etc, I would have bought it around 2008.

RonObvious · 06/09/2023 05:38

I have a house full of laptops - the oldest is over 20 years old (original orange clamshell macbook) and still works fine. But I also maintain them - make sure software is up to date, replace batteries, upgrade RAM if possible. Mouse freezing sounds like a software issue, not holding a charge could be a dodgy charging port, or an issue with the charger (we've had to replace plenty of those!), or you could just need a new battery. Screen coming away is more down to the build, and I would definitely not be happy with that after only 3.5 years!

Swipe left for the next trending thread