Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ‘EDUCATE’ this teacher?

342 replies

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 16:03

DS has Type 1 diabetes. He has to put up with stupid comments like ‘did you eat too much sugar’ regularly.

At school today, a boy asked him this. Teacher nearby started telling him what Type 1 is and he asked if anyone could get it and could you get it randomly.

Teacher said No which DS was quite pissed of about as it seems to imply he’s done something to get it or it’s in his genes (it’s not). He’s not the type to correct a teacher so I think I should?

Quite annoyed as if you’re going to educate someone, do it correctly!

OP posts:
JellyBabiesSaveLives · 05/09/2023 19:17

https://jdrf.org.uk/knowledge-support/about-type-1-diabetes/causes-of-type-1-diabetes/
another nice clear explanation
Note that 90 per cent of people who develop type 1 diabetes have no family connection with the condition. I think it is important that that is the fact that people remember, because otherwise people ignore symptoms, convinced they can't have it because no one else in the family does.

The truth is that no one actually knows what causes Type 1 diabetes (certainly not the GCSE exam boards). The scientists have some hypotheses but that's still all they are.

The answer to "can anyone get it?" Is very much "yes".

Causes of type 1 diabetes - JDRF

https://jdrf.org.uk/knowledge-support/about-type-1-diabetes/causes-of-type-1-diabetes/

Upwiththelark76 · 05/09/2023 19:15

ActDottie · 05/09/2023 16:24

To me it sounds like the kid was asking can he get it like you get a cold and the teacher said no to this.

This was my first thought too !

FoodFann · 05/09/2023 19:15

Don't go after the teacher. What’s she supposed to say to children worried they might get poorly? (after just living through a pandemic, contagious diseases are going to be an anxiety for this generation of kids).

“Yes Jonny, anyone can get diabetes, could be you next!” 🥴

NoTouch · 05/09/2023 19:12

It is unreasonable to expect others to know about things they have no experience of, how much did you know about type 1 diabetes before your son was diagnosed?

Even scientists are still unclear on how many autoimmune diseases are caused. Teachers are not medics and don't need to know the ins and outs of every condition the hundreds of pupils they teach every year might have, they can only speak from their own experience/knowledge. They are also not responsible for educating other children on medical conditions.

I think your time and energies would be better spent developing your ds's resilience and confidence.

Teach your son he is the subject matter expert in this topic. Teach him to have the confidence to state the facts about his diabetes and while it is also not his responsibility to educate others, it is in his gift to do so if he chooses. He can also choose how he reacts and perhaps forgive those who are not familiar with it and might make factually incorrect, but well intentioned statements.

Sirzy · 05/09/2023 19:10

Baconisdelicious · 05/09/2023 19:02

I've counted up to 60 medical conditions on my time table in the past

how many of those could result in the death of a child if mismanaged at a crucial moment?

But knowing the root cause of the illness won’t make the slightest difference in the case of an emergency.

ds has two potentially life threatening diagnosis. One pretty common the other less so. School have action plans on what to do in an emergency, they have emergency medication in school. As far as I know they don’t know the history of the cause of the illness - certainly neither me or the specialist nurses have told them.

you don’t need to know the ins and outs to manage it daily.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 05/09/2023 19:10

I've counted up to 60 medical conditions on my time table in the past

how many of those could result in the death of a child if mismanaged at a crucial moment?

Would not knowing the details of how people get Type 1 diabetes result in the death of a child? No, it wouldn't.

There are often quite a few students in school with conditions which can be very dangerous, including anaphylaxis, severe asthma, epilepsy and heart conditions.

electriclight · 05/09/2023 19:08

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 18:20

How the actual fuck is it ‘precious’ to not want my son to feel like shit by a teacher’s stupid remark about a life threatening medical condition when he is struggling to understand why it happened to him?

She could have just said ‘I don’t know’!

Yes, saying it can’t just happen to anyone and you can’t get it randomly does imply DS is somehow different.

I have absolutely no doubt DS relayed it as it was said. He has better comprehension that most on here.

But surely you can differentiate between a callous or purposely unkind remark, and a well-meaning but inaccurate one?

It is obvious the teacher was telling the pupil that they couldn't catch it. Maybe they should have gone into a more thorough explanation but were trying to teach a lesson, get to a meeting or manage a safeguarding issue.

Sometimes good people say the wrong thing. You might even have done it yourself at sim point in your life. Why not help your ds to see that he wasn't being insulted or othered, and that there is no need to take offence where none was intended.

cansu · 05/09/2023 19:08

Baconisdelicious
Teachers work in buildings with telephones. There are people on the staff with first aid training and they have access to care plans for students with life threatening conditions. There are also other staff in the building to assist. They can contact the emergency services and can also contact a child's parent. An individual teacher does not and in fact cannot be an expert in any one condition.

Englishrosegarden · 05/09/2023 19:07

My DH is T1, his dad and his dad's brother were both T1. Both our sons are also T1.
That is a 3 generation direct line of 5 type 1 males - none of the females got it.
As a family we took part in genetic testing to see if they could identify anything unusual. No obvious results. One son now has 2 male children. We are watching them carefully.
In our case it is definitely inherited.
Oh and son was told during the genetic testing that any children he had would have a 50/50 chance of getting it too.

BackToOklahoma · 05/09/2023 19:04

This boy started the discussion by deliberately trying to wind up DS for his medical condition.

This sort of behaviour should be swiftly dealt with by any teacher and this would be what I would contact the school about primarily.

cansu · 05/09/2023 19:04

For all those foaming at the mouth about teachers not knowing about the life threatening conditions of their pupils...

  1. Teachers are not required to know the causes of or have in depth knowledge about medical conditions such as diabetes. Teachers in a secondary school may teach hundreds of students.
  2. Teachers are usually given brief bullet points on what to look out for and how to respond if a child is unwell or needs specific treatment. Many of these plans will tell the teacher to send for help or to contact 999 or to call a parent.
  3. In the case of a T1 diabetic, most older students manage their diabetes themselves but the schools know how to respond if there is an issue or the student needs help or medical attention. With younger students, there is sometimes a named person who has had more specific training.
However, the OP would likely not be satisfied regardless as she has some kind of axe to grind here.
MMorales · 05/09/2023 19:03

But their current DNA will still not be identical

Baconisdelicious · 05/09/2023 19:02

I've counted up to 60 medical conditions on my time table in the past

how many of those could result in the death of a child if mismanaged at a crucial moment?

anotherside · 05/09/2023 19:02

I think the best thing you can do on this issue is encourage your son to clarify/correct comments others make (if/when necessary) regarding his condition. That will be a lot more beneficial than going in guns blazing on a well-intentioned reply made to a vaguely worded question made by some Maths/Geography etc teacher.

Sidslaw · 05/09/2023 18:58

Qilin · 05/09/2023 18:53

I can almost guarantee that if the teacher had just said "I don't know" as suggested then there'd be a thread saying "this teacher should be educated on this now and it isn't right that they don't know what my child's medical condition is/how it works."

I've counted up to 60 medical conditions on my time table in the past....

Baconisdelicious · 05/09/2023 18:58

irrespective of anything he could have done to prevent it

there is nothing at all that can be done to prevent type 1 or other autoimmune condition.

Yalta · 05/09/2023 18:57

Dh is type 1 diabetic.
His fathers uncle was diagnosed as having type 1 diabetes. But after that
no one in his family was diagnosed with diabetes

I read somewhere that everyone carries a gene that is either Gene A or Gene B or Gene C
2 Gene A parents or 2 Gene B parents and their children will not get diabetes However children of a Gene A parent and a Gene B parent have a 50% higher chance of having Gene C which is the diabetic gene but even then it takes a trigger to actually become diabetic.

For dh it was a paper cut that got infected and took 2 courses of antibiotics to clear up that we think triggered his diabetes

Callyem · 05/09/2023 18:56

The way I have interpreted what I have read is, you must have certain combinations of a selection of genes to be able to develop it and whether you do or not depends on environmental factors.

Thus, there are people walking around without those genetic combinations who absolutely will never get it regardless of exposure to those triggering environmental factors.

Therefore not 'anyone' can develop it and the teacher was not wrong in her response. Also, it is OK to be different and you should be teaching your son this message.

YourNameGoesHere · 05/09/2023 18:56

Qilin · 05/09/2023 18:53

I can almost guarantee that if the teacher had just said "I don't know" as suggested then there'd be a thread saying "this teacher should be educated on this now and it isn't right that they don't know what my child's medical condition is/how it works."

Exactly. The teacher once again couldn't bloody win.

I'm still curious for the op to answer a previous posters question on what exactly they would have said as a reply.

Orange67 · 05/09/2023 18:55

If the teacher had said you could catch diabetes and then all his friends fell out with him and no one wanted to sit next to him, I suspect you'd be on here complaining about the word 'catch'.

SemperIdem · 05/09/2023 18:54

MonkeyDoodles · 05/09/2023 18:49

@SemperIdem Applogies but you are going to have to explain that one for me as I am lost....

They’re called sesquizygotic twins. I don’t think there have been many recorded cases of that kind of twins, to be honest. I came across an article about types of twins years ago and remember being really surprised!

SecretSoul · 05/09/2023 18:53

The link that the OP provided from Diabetes UK says this:

"Is type 1 diabetes to do with genes or lifestyle? Type 1 diabetes is thought to develop due to a combination of genetics and other factors which are not yet fully understood. But we don’t know more than that. There is nothing to indicate that lifestyle plays a part."

The OP has been furiously denying on this thread that it's genetics, while at the same time linking to Diabetes UK who say that it is.

OP also says the fact her other family members are fine proves it's not genetics. As others have said, having a genetic predisposition to something doesn't mean that you'll definitely develop the condition. There's often something else that pulls the trigger. In this case it sounds like the COVID infection.

It may be uncomfortable for you OP, but genetics are almost certain to have played a part. The teacher wasn't wrong in what they said, even if they didn't provide a completely full explanation. As others have pointed out, it's unreasonable to expect a teacher to have in-depth knowledge on every conceivable subject that a child could raise. I think the answers that were given by the teacher are reasonable. You can't "catch" diabetes.

I think you and your DS probably are still in the throes of wrapping your heads around his diagnosis and all that it entails. I know it's rough and I'm sorry. I have two DC with disabilities (which have a genetic predisposition) and I understand that it's not easy.

Research spotlight - what causes Type 1 diabetes?

Our immune system normally protects us against infection and illness. But in Type 1 diabetes, the immune system attacks the cells in the pancreas that make insulin – the hormone responsible for regulating levels of glucose in the blood. Scientists are...

https://www.diabetes.org.uk/research/research-round-up/research-spotlight/research-spotlight-what-causes-type-1-diabetes#genes

Qilin · 05/09/2023 18:53

I can almost guarantee that if the teacher had just said "I don't know" as suggested then there'd be a thread saying "this teacher should be educated on this now and it isn't right that they don't know what my child's medical condition is/how it works."

GuardiansPlayList · 05/09/2023 18:53

Teachers have no medical training. Ask yourself how much you know about other serious diseases (unless of course you are a medic) - would you know the inheritance/cause of those OP?
Teachers are currently being asked to assess buildings for structural soundness/identity RAAC. They frequently have to be parents, counsellors, social workers, dieticians, nurses, you name it - none of which is in their job description.

mathanxiety · 05/09/2023 18:52

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 18:12

So explain how DS has 3 siblings (all older) who don’t have Type 1. Parents without it. 24 cousins on both sides who don’t have it. Nor any other relatives on both sides going back 100 years who had it!

DH and I have 13 full siblings between us.

The link I posted stated there may be a genetic predisposition (but they don’t actually know) so again anyone can get it unless scientists manage to isolate a gene, test everyone for it and nobody passes it on!

medlineplus.gov/genetics/condition/type-1-diabetes/#inheritance

A little reading material about HLA genes.

There's a lot more to the genetic component of T1 than you seem aware of.

Swipe left for the next trending thread