Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ‘EDUCATE’ this teacher?

342 replies

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 16:03

DS has Type 1 diabetes. He has to put up with stupid comments like ‘did you eat too much sugar’ regularly.

At school today, a boy asked him this. Teacher nearby started telling him what Type 1 is and he asked if anyone could get it and could you get it randomly.

Teacher said No which DS was quite pissed of about as it seems to imply he’s done something to get it or it’s in his genes (it’s not). He’s not the type to correct a teacher so I think I should?

Quite annoyed as if you’re going to educate someone, do it correctly!

OP posts:
Deliana · 05/09/2023 21:52

OP, it's not true to say genetics aren't involved. They are, at least sometimes. People are more likely to develop it if their parents have it. That in itself shows a genetic inheritance of risk factors in at least some people with Type 1 diabetes.

TeresaCrowd · 05/09/2023 21:51

@Callyem yes. Even if you are not predisposed to the genetic influences that may cause T1 to develop, there’s nothing to stop you needing your pancreas removed due to an accident for example, or pancreatic cancer can also lead to insulin dependence, though I believe is now T3 for those without a pancreas, the needing insulin through no fault element is the same. Nobody is immune from ending up needing to take insulin for the rest of their lives.

MysteryBelle · 05/09/2023 21:48

simpledimple · 05/09/2023 21:00

I'm a parent of a T1 daughter and a teacher.
We have had health care professionals say the actual stupid things about T1D - 'Did you eat too many sweets?'
My daughter just rolls her eyes and explains that there are many causes of T1D, (never eating sugar) and that hers was due to an autoimmune reaction that has attacked her healthy pancreas and so it no longer works. Simple and stating the facts.
I wouldn't be angry or upset at the teacher.
The reason my daughter's autoimmune system chose to attack her pancreas may have been triggered as a result of a virus., that she 'caught'. Ultimately, her T1D was caused by both her autoimmune system malfunctioning (genetic) AND the virus (caught) that triggered it.
Other people in our family caught the same virus but it didn't trigger T1D as their genetic codes are different or they just happened not to be triggered on that occasion.
We do have a distant great, great uncle who had T1D so in our case we do seem to have the inherited gene.
Why get angry? Your child will encounter so much misinformation, ignorance and prejudice about T1D as they get older - show them how to deal with it calmly and without getting wound up, as this will help your child the most in the long run. You don't want your child to become an adult who spends their life angrily correcting people - your child is way more than just their condition and will be happier living with it if they can brush off questions quickly rather than reacting emotionally.
Perhaps 'help' your teacher by giving them a simple answer 'statement' that they can say - one that you are happy with and that your child can learn to use too in the future to deflect a question or 'wrong' supposition.

This is a great post. I want to say though, the op is upset and that’s ok too. She is coming here to vent and get support. Obviously she would think out exactly what she might say to the teacher and not go screaming and acting crazy.

Sometimes the British stiff upper lip goes to the extreme. I’ve noticed (from the USA) that I have to be careful to not have strong feelings or show emotion much here, or use an exclamation point ever no matter what, or use a strong adjective. Anyone who posts with a title of ‘aibu to be furious’ or similar emotional word, will get a furious kicking from every single poster 😂

I also try to never use “ instead of ‘, because that is apparently a crime too 😂 People are awfully wound tight as a wire to be set off so easily.

We all are human and will feel upset sometimes especially concerning our children. It’s like you all instinctively want to gang up on a poster who is feeling emotional. Look through all that and see what her concern is. Actually, it is illogical to meet an emotional outburst with another, in the name of squashing the emotion. ‘Ffs’ incoming I’m sure. Give the op a break. Goodness.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/09/2023 21:47

Primrosesanddaisies · 05/09/2023 17:54

There is no 't1 gene' there is no 'autoimmune disease gene'. Of course there are genetic factors - everything we are as a human is to some extent. However it is not hereditary. You can have predispositions to diseases of the immune system but the actual triggers for T1 are not known. If it was solely genetic, the huge rise in autoimmune disorders cannot be explained. Environmental triggers must play a part but the truth is no one really knows.
I hope you don't teach it as black and white as that. Perhaps ask JDRF for guidance.

Thank you

I think it's quite worrying that a teacher who claims to teach it appears to misunderstand it to this extent.

TeresaCrowd · 05/09/2023 21:45

@MysteryBelle T1 daughter of a T1 ex-headteacher here so it probably does suit my skill set. You definitely do gain a certain ability to say ‘fuck off and shut up, you little prick’ in a way that sounds very happy clappy and socially acceptable after listening to someone dealing with 11 year olds for 20 years.

Basilthymerosemary · 05/09/2023 21:39

@Willyoujustbequiet

You are right that diabetes T1(disease) is not inherited but most people understand that we are talking about the genes being inherited.

Septemberdaysarehere · 05/09/2023 21:38

strawberriesarenot · 05/09/2023 20:49

I am sorry your son has Type 1 diabetes. However, I do think you are being very unreasonable. The teacher was clearly explaining that it wasn't contagious and you are just refusing to accept that obvious fact. Your 'educating' sounds very like bullying to me.

This. I also read you ‘educate’ as bullying and absolutely not on. It’s the start of term you are also having this third hand, as well as assuming what another pupil’s intentions were eg the boy said it to … you can’t know that. You are throwing around wild assumptions! You are being a bully and highly patronising. My daughter has hyper mobility - you can’t catch it, is it genetic? - no one in our family has it - she has - could be recessive gene for me and biological father -

Mamai90 · 05/09/2023 21:38

My best friend was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes at 21 years old. Even as teens she reckoned she'd get it at some stage as her Dad, her maternal grandmother and Uncle all had type 1. Her mum and maternal Aunt developed type 2 in their 30s.

When she was diagnosed they told her it was genetic and her diabetic team have told her to be vigilant because her two children have a much higher chance of getting it.

OP, I think it was just a misunderstanding with the teacher. You're being over sensitive which is maybe understandable given your situation but I'd honestly let it go.

Boredombeckons · 05/09/2023 21:38

Also just to add on, if the teacher wants to elaborate, I don't think there's any harm in talking about genetic predisposition, race, etc as significant higher risk factors.

It's good to know and nothing to be ashamed about, or to teach your child to be ashamed about!

MysteryBelle · 05/09/2023 21:36

TeresaCrowd · 05/09/2023 21:23

“You can’t catch it from sitting next to someone who has it, but anyone could develop it at any point in life, through nobody’s fault, now please get on with your work”

is how you deal with that question without othering the child with T1.

This is excellent.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/09/2023 21:32

Sidslaw · 05/09/2023 16:53

It is inherited though, that is how most people get it

No it's not.

Certain genes can mean you may be predisposed to it but its not inherited. There are many other factors..

uneffingbelievable · 05/09/2023 21:30

50 yrs since I was diagnosed - people ask questions - I answer them, educate them, I do not get pissed off and definitely have heard some BS.

Sorry OP - way too sensitive bigger things to worry about than that in the world of type DM.
Wait till yu get to my age 52 and now I am told even by GPs and practice nurses I have Type 2 DM now as that is what you have when you get older.

Boredombeckons · 05/09/2023 21:30

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 18:20

How the actual fuck is it ‘precious’ to not want my son to feel like shit by a teacher’s stupid remark about a life threatening medical condition when he is struggling to understand why it happened to him?

She could have just said ‘I don’t know’!

Yes, saying it can’t just happen to anyone and you can’t get it randomly does imply DS is somehow different.

I have absolutely no doubt DS relayed it as it was said. He has better comprehension that most on here.

To be fair, it's so obvious that you'd be on here ranting too if she had said "I don't know".

Plus, "I don't know" would mean children being more scared they could "catch" it from your child. That IS probably the present reality.

The teacher was probably trying to prevent your child being ostracised, due to the kids being afraid of "catching" diabetes from him.

If you would have liked the teacher to add that it's just bad luck (genes, magic, whatever), no fault of your son, etc, I would raise that point civilly. I don't think painting her as the bad guy is helpful when she's trying to stop your child being shunned.

anotherside · 05/09/2023 21:28

@TeresaCrowd

Teachers have to answer a dozen tricky questions a day, five days a week, forty weeks (?) a year. I hope you would be able to answer all 2000+ questions perfectly - on the spur of the moment and with other students and issues also demanding your attention.

Callyem · 05/09/2023 21:27

BackToOklahoma · 05/09/2023 21:26

“You can’t catch it from sitting next to someone who has it, but anyone could develop it at any point in life, through nobody’s fault, now please get on with your work”

is how you deal with that question without othering the child with T1.

This.

Is that true though? Or is it only true to those of use that meet certain genetic factors?

BackToOklahoma · 05/09/2023 21:26

“You can’t catch it from sitting next to someone who has it, but anyone could develop it at any point in life, through nobody’s fault, now please get on with your work”

is how you deal with that question without othering the child with T1.

This.

Basilthymerosemary · 05/09/2023 21:24

@MysteryBelle

So are you saying that all the scientific journals that do say there is a genetic component/inheritance (from people who have studied diabetes for years and are experts in their field) know less than you?

Ok then.

TeresaCrowd · 05/09/2023 21:23

“You can’t catch it from sitting next to someone who has it, but anyone could develop it at any point in life, through nobody’s fault, now please get on with your work”

is how you deal with that question without othering the child with T1.

jazzyfips · 05/09/2023 21:17

MysteryBelle · 05/09/2023 20:13

My son was diagnosed in summer, in a warm climate, no recent illness, was breastfed for over a year, and ate solid food earlier not later. No one on my side of the family or on my husband’s side of the family had T1, going back as far as possible. Not one person. So I doubt it is inherited. Usually when something runs in the family there will be more than one instance of it. More likely a bunch of instances.

Of course, when T1 ‘develops’ is earlier than when diagnosed, and viruses may indeed ‘trigger’ the underlying potential for it that was latent up to that point. The onset of puberty can play a significant part. My son’s drs said basically no one knows exactly what causes a child to have the potential for getting T1 but it could be that a virus may trigger it (he did have a bad cold a few months before and was at the age of onset of puberty so I consider those two things possible triggers in my son’s case) but the drs said scientists simply don’t know, just theories or ideas, and it is absolutely nothing to do with what the child eats, it’s not ‘eating too much sugar’. My son didn’t even eat sugar. He has never had a sweet tooth, always slim, he doesn’t even care for ice cream. So to have people tell me that my son caused this by what he ate or that they were afraid their own children might ‘catch’ it from him—yes both scenarios happened several times, the ignorance is breathtaking and infuriating.

So I empathize with the op very much. Op, do t pay any attention to any of the posters who have never been through what you and your son have been through. They don’t know anything about it, and they don’t know how you feel. They automatically lecture you. They have no ability to put themselves in someone else’s shoes. And I can tell they know nothing about it yet act like experts. People like the Op and I and our children are intimately acquainted with the subject 24/7 for years and years and have researched everything about it and also keep up with possible cures and new treatments. So, if you don’t have it, or someone in your immediate household doesn’t have it, and you aren’t supportive of the op, kindly shut up.

I don’t think you can tell someone kindly to shut up. Another post claims bullying but you are just as bad. The OP didn’t ask for advice on diabetes but on whether she should confront the teacher and people have given their verdicts on that. There is some poor understanding of diabetes on this thread but your understanding isn’t fully informed either.

Basilthymerosemary · 05/09/2023 21:03

MysteryBelle · 05/09/2023 20:50

A lot of obtuse bullies on this thread.

How has anyone bullied the OP?

They have explained how they believed the questions from the student was asked. Even OP cannot say as she heard it from her child.

So it is all about perception/ inference of the question.

They have also corrected or pointed out that the OPs wording itself was incorrect which means she is just as guilty of giving out misinformation.

TheFallenMadonna · 05/09/2023 21:02

towriteyoumustlive · 05/09/2023 20:43

YABU.

The boy asked if anyone could 'get' it as was clearly referring to whether it was contagious and the teacher corrected him and said no as diabetes is not contagious.

You should correct your son as he has clearly misunderstood the context here.

It's not clear at all, from those words, that that was what was meant. Clarity in questioning and answering questions is so important in teaching. I don't expect teachers to be experts. I expected them to treat my daughter as the expert in fact. If they are going to engage on the subject, I would expect them to be very clear and clarify the question they were answering as in a PP's answer re non communicable diseases. I also expected them to be aware of the impact of fluctuating blood glucose on her mood and engagement, as well as the emergency action for a hypo. There is a lot of focus, of course, on the emergency aspect, but for my daughter the day to day management, especially in the early days, was extremely tough. Her response was to become a fierce advocate for herself, but other children respond differently.

simpledimple · 05/09/2023 21:00

I'm a parent of a T1 daughter and a teacher.
We have had health care professionals say the actual stupid things about T1D - 'Did you eat too many sweets?'
My daughter just rolls her eyes and explains that there are many causes of T1D, (never eating sugar) and that hers was due to an autoimmune reaction that has attacked her healthy pancreas and so it no longer works. Simple and stating the facts.
I wouldn't be angry or upset at the teacher.
The reason my daughter's autoimmune system chose to attack her pancreas may have been triggered as a result of a virus., that she 'caught'. Ultimately, her T1D was caused by both her autoimmune system malfunctioning (genetic) AND the virus (caught) that triggered it.
Other people in our family caught the same virus but it didn't trigger T1D as their genetic codes are different or they just happened not to be triggered on that occasion.
We do have a distant great, great uncle who had T1D so in our case we do seem to have the inherited gene.
Why get angry? Your child will encounter so much misinformation, ignorance and prejudice about T1D as they get older - show them how to deal with it calmly and without getting wound up, as this will help your child the most in the long run. You don't want your child to become an adult who spends their life angrily correcting people - your child is way more than just their condition and will be happier living with it if they can brush off questions quickly rather than reacting emotionally.
Perhaps 'help' your teacher by giving them a simple answer 'statement' that they can say - one that you are happy with and that your child can learn to use too in the future to deflect a question or 'wrong' supposition.

brogueish · 05/09/2023 20:57

I've just been looking at BBC Bitesize and the 9 revision slides about Genetic Inheritance, happy to recommend it for anyone interested in a refresher of how genetic probability actually works. Some PPs might find it enlightening.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/guides/zg8f4qt/revision/1

Genetic inheritance - Genetic inheritance - AQA - GCSE Biology (Single Science) Revision - AQA - BBC Bitesize

Learn about genetic inheritance and revise the different types of genes for GCSE Biology, AQA.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/guides/zg8f4qt/revision/1

Sceptic1234 · 05/09/2023 20:53

Noseybear38 · 05/09/2023 20:44

I am sorry that you son is unwell and hope that you are able to manage his condition moving forwards.

It is hard to know from the OP whether the teacher concerned was a science teacher or another subject specialist and this just happened in their lesson.

As a science teacher, I would refer to diabetes as a non-communicable disease. Type 2 diabetes is mentioned as an example of a non-communicable disease where lifestyle is a risk factor. Covid-19, flu and chicken pox as communicable diseases which are caused by pathogens. It helps to give concrete examples to cement these definitions.

In my experience, students are often very inquisitive in biology and often ask questions based on personal experience. This can be because they are naturally curious but in other instances because students are deliberately trying to delay the lesson or upset students.

We also have to be very mindful that this can be very sensitive for some students particularly as cancer is another example of a non-communicable disease we have to teach and one linked to lifestyle factors. It is a very difficult balance and personally, I would have deflected with it is non-communicable disease and suggested we could perhaps discuss it at the end of the lesson with that student individually.

Thankfully, we no longer use Huntingdon’s disease as an example of an disease caused by a dominant gene instead using polydactyly and I don’t think we teach how haemophilia is inherited any more. We do our best to highlight positives with cancer for example the impact of the HPV vaccine on rates of cervical cancer.

We all want to make the very best start with our classes and students but please bear in mind the number of new students we teach. Often around 200-300 at secondary and there is a lot of information to retain about their individual needs. We all need time to get to know everyone at the start of the year.

Why not Huntington's??

MysteryBelle · 05/09/2023 20:50

A lot of obtuse bullies on this thread.