Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ‘EDUCATE’ this teacher?

342 replies

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 16:03

DS has Type 1 diabetes. He has to put up with stupid comments like ‘did you eat too much sugar’ regularly.

At school today, a boy asked him this. Teacher nearby started telling him what Type 1 is and he asked if anyone could get it and could you get it randomly.

Teacher said No which DS was quite pissed of about as it seems to imply he’s done something to get it or it’s in his genes (it’s not). He’s not the type to correct a teacher so I think I should?

Quite annoyed as if you’re going to educate someone, do it correctly!

OP posts:
CantFindMyMarbles · 06/09/2023 20:25

You are being unreasonable.

You don’t have the full context in which the question was asked or how/what was actually said.

You only have your sons experience. Whilst his feelings are absolutely valid very young children are not accurate story tellers.

instead of being arrogant in educating the teacher have a conversation and give advice arojnd what you say to people.

Misinformation · 06/09/2023 20:22

Deliana · 06/09/2023 16:54

So how do you know that you weren't born with the propensity to develop it if you've never had that test?

You don't.
That doesn't mean people develop it randomly though or that just anyone will get it. The teacher was correct.
It's just we often don't know who will develop it, which is a different thing. We don't have that information. But the propensity to develop T1 diabetes is predetermined to a large degree. It's not fully understood but genetics definitely play their part.

A previous poster kindly stated that people on this thread are deliberately being obtuse so I didn’t have to.

The fact is no one would know whether they had a genetic predisposition (if there is indeed one) to get Type 1 unless there was a history of it in their family so the first person to get it would indeed get it pretty randomly! By your thinking DS got it randomly out of his 3 siblings (same parents so same genetics) who were also exposed to Covid and other viruses and didn’t get it!

So therefore anyone could develop it anytime as they wouldn’t know they could get it until they did if there is no history in their family, just like DS.

DS is a highly intelligent 14 year old, can understand English and what what people say and is not prone to making things up (always an accusation on here if you say a thing about teachers) so he did not misunderstand what the teacher said.

My point was she shouldn’t have said something that wasn’t true that DS basically had something inherently wrong with him/had done something and that’s why he got it making the rest of the class think so too as they were all listening.

If she did say it to prevent the other child worrying that he may get it, that’s unacceptable as she should have thought how saying that would impact on the kid struggling with the life threatening illness! He knows that it was just shit luck but it’s understandably upsetting especially when you get people making stupid comments about sugar and connecting it to Type 2.

I personally think she got it mixed up with Type 2 because if she knew about Type 1 she’d have said it’s not known how people get it so she should be educated. Doing the email now.

OP posts:
Sidslaw · 06/09/2023 19:58

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/09/2023 19:01

You are/did

They said Type 1 isn"t inherited and you came back with it is genetic....what don't you get....

When they didn't say it wasn't a genetic disposition in the first place.

The disease itself is not inherited. A potential genetic predisposition that increases your risk if there are certain triggers/environmental factors is not the same thing at all.as inheriting the specific disease. And this is why the vast majority of type 1 have no family link.

but they will still have the genes for it... because it is genetic!

This is an inherited disease

This is an inherited disease

This is an inherited disease

etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc and so on ad infinitum

it doesn't matter how much you quibble, it is STILL an inherited disease.

You dont get it if you don't have the genes for it

hence, it is an inherited disease

Toomuchtrouble4me · 06/09/2023 19:48

Op - you asked if you were BU. Most people think YABU.
why ask if you are not willing to accept any part of the answer? YABVU.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 06/09/2023 19:44

You don’t know the context. The teacher was probably just saying that you can’t catch it like a cold. I think you’re looking to make a fuss about nothing. YABU

Sillyname63 · 06/09/2023 19:30

I would have a look on the Diabetes UK website for some leaflets explaining what Type 1 is exactly and give a copy to the teacher, perhaps you can suggest at the time that it might be a good subject to address when they have their personal education time, ( sorry I'm not sure what it is called these days) if there is a school nurse perhaps could take this forward. People need to be educated to type 1 as everything in the press is about Type 2 and refers to obesity.

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/09/2023 19:01

Sidslaw · 06/09/2023 12:07

I am not back tracking, it is the same thing

You are/did

They said Type 1 isn"t inherited and you came back with it is genetic....what don't you get....

When they didn't say it wasn't a genetic disposition in the first place.

The disease itself is not inherited. A potential genetic predisposition that increases your risk if there are certain triggers/environmental factors is not the same thing at all.as inheriting the specific disease. And this is why the vast majority of type 1 have no family link.

beyourselfj90 · 06/09/2023 18:58

<a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?q=jdrf.org.uk/for-professionals/school-pack/schools-e-learning-module&source=gmail-imap&ust=1690543212000000&usg=AOvVaw0hijzk-vg7NrF9ducv6aV4" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">https://www.google.com/url?q=jdrf.org.uk/for-professionals/school-pack/schools-e-learning-module&source=gmail-imap&ust=1690543212000000&usg=AOvVaw0hijzk-vg7NrF9ducv6aV4

^^ send the teacher a link to this website with free training all about diabetes.

loislovesstewie · 06/09/2023 18:53

D1nopawus · 06/09/2023 12:30

I've returned to this thread today and re-read some of the OP's comments.

She says that her DS developed diabetes after a viral illness, so I take that to mean that in looking for an explanation - the human need to blame something - she has landed on the virus and to her that means her DS caught it, and so could anyone else. This is a very understandable reaction to a child developing a serious illness. One which has potential for serious complications.

I don't think educating the teacher in capitals is required, but I understand why she is upset.

Well the thinking was that some people are born with a propensity to get T1, but something has to trigger T1, and that may well be a virus/viral infection. Those not inclined to T1 might get the virus/viral infection and just feel off colour for a few days. My adult child became diabetic as a youngster and it was almost immediately after having a very odd illness which the hospital couldn't diagnose. He had an extremely odd rash, high temp ,and was off colour for a couple of days, then seemingly OK. Franky I think that the odd virus he had started T1.

MannyTeddy · 06/09/2023 18:15

Do you know everything about every medical condition there is out there?

Seagull97 · 06/09/2023 17:58

Not at all, but what good it will do remains to be seen. My daughter has EDS and I attempted to educate her teachers. Went in for a meeting, armed with books, printouts, highlighted quotes from her specialist, handouts from the hypermobility society especially for schools and they smiled in my face and just carried on. It was a continuous uphill struggle with them (one teacher in particular so FU Mrs Burk). I was so glad when she left there.

Deliana · 06/09/2023 16:54

So how do you know that you weren't born with the propensity to develop it if you've never had that test?

You don't.
That doesn't mean people develop it randomly though or that just anyone will get it. The teacher was correct.
It's just we often don't know who will develop it, which is a different thing. We don't have that information. But the propensity to develop T1 diabetes is predetermined to a large degree. It's not fully understood but genetics definitely play their part.

Baconisdelicious · 06/09/2023 16:24

She says that her DS developed diabetes after a viral illness, so I take that to mean that in looking for an explanation - the human need to blame something - she has landed on the virus and to her that means her DS caught it, and so could anyone else

It is not looking for an explanation, it is what you are told when your child is diagnosed. Nothing at all to do with blaming anyone or anything. And given that type 1 is a condition we know little about when it comes to who may or may not develop the condition, then it is anyone who can develop it. There are tests which can be run on siblings when one child is diagnosed but there is.no general testing. So how do you know that you weren't born with the propensity to develop it if you've never had that test?

Mumof118 · 06/09/2023 15:31

I thought you were very clear. Excellent analogy.

Marynotsocontrary · 06/09/2023 12:53

The official is the virus in that analogy by the way. The numbers represent different genetic backgrounds.
Okay, I've probably added to the confusion 😅

Marynotsocontrary · 06/09/2023 12:47

think we are arguing over semantics at this point.

I think a lot of this is semantics tbh. There's some confusion about the meaning of 'random' for a start.

Say there are 10 people in a room. Each has an envelope with a number 1-10 written inside. Nobody knows what number they have.

An offical comes to the door, draws a number from a box in a lottery type situation and one person is chosen. That's random selection.

Conversely, say an offical comes to the door and picks number 3...because he almost always does...that's not a random selection. To the people in the room (who have no idea what number they have) it may appear random as if anyone can be chosen. But they can't. The selection isn't random, it's blinded. That's different.

The teacher was correct to say that T1 doesn't occur randomly. Not everyone has the genetic background to develop it. They don't have the no. 3 envelope.* Her answer needed more detail of course - to explain that we mostly don't know who will get it, we're blinded - but there's a time and a place and maybe that wasn't it.

  • obviously a serious oversimplification to make a point
D1nopawus · 06/09/2023 12:30

I've returned to this thread today and re-read some of the OP's comments.

She says that her DS developed diabetes after a viral illness, so I take that to mean that in looking for an explanation - the human need to blame something - she has landed on the virus and to her that means her DS caught it, and so could anyone else. This is a very understandable reaction to a child developing a serious illness. One which has potential for serious complications.

I don't think educating the teacher in capitals is required, but I understand why she is upset.

Sidslaw · 06/09/2023 12:07

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/09/2023 11:49

You are backtracking.

@LostInTheColonies did not say there wasn't a genetic disposition. They specifically said T1 is not inherited. They are correct.

I am not back tracking, it is the same thing

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/09/2023 11:49

Sidslaw · 06/09/2023 01:12

It is genetic. Your daughter will pass on the genes to any children she has. What don't you get?

You are backtracking.

@LostInTheColonies did not say there wasn't a genetic disposition. They specifically said T1 is not inherited. They are correct.

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/09/2023 11:30

Basilthymerosemary · 05/09/2023 22:33

@Willyoujustbequiet

Apologies if I misquoted you.

But you are being pedantic in your response by saying T1 is not inherited- yes the disease is not inherited but the multiple genes that have been identified as being a factors in developing T1 are inherited. This is what most people are saying (although admittedly may be unclear) and you must be aware that is clearly what they mean.
Yes scientists do not exactly understand what triggers development of T1 but they do (majority) say there is a high genetic (therefore inheritance) component in the development of T1.

Please don't feel you need to answer the next question- as it's personal. But unless you have had your entire genome sequenced- you cannot possibly know you haven't passed on any of the autoimmune linked genes.

I think we are arguing over semantics at this point. I said the disease itself wasn't inherited ...which it isn't and which you admit. The rest I have no issue with.

As to your question well no but that is true for everyone the world over and countless conditions. The vast majority of type one (90%?) do not have a family connection to it so I think it's very unhelpful when people insist it's inherited as the vast majority cannot make that link and may be lulled into a false sense of security and dismiss potential symptoms.with potentially disastrous outcomes. I know we/our family GP did.

Sueveneers · 06/09/2023 10:18

Had to select YABU because it's quite obvious the teacher said no to the suggestion that it's CONTAGIOUS, ie can anyone catch it (from someone). You're getting upset because you misinterpreted the question asked and the answer given.

BloodyHellKen · 06/09/2023 09:43

Also, OP @Misinformation I feel for you, I really do. You sounds stressed and unhappy at your sons diagnosis. I've been there and even though my son was older than yours when diagnosed (late teens) I was devastated for him. For a long time it was the last thing I thought about at night and the first thing I thought about in the morning. I thought life would never be the same again and I came from a good place as an ex staff nurse so I already knew lots about T1D which I assume you don't. Fortunately my son just gets on with it and I am immensely proud of him.

You will get used to it and it will become part of everyday life. Your son will grow up and learn to manage it all by himself. The best you can do is learn how to manage it. I don't mean obsess over every mmol, but fit it round your lives, not the other way round. You have the opportunity to support your son and help him learn how to manage his blood sugar.

In a way it's not relevant how he developed it (although this is something I still think about too much 3 years on) but it helped me to consider that my child could have be diagnosed with something much, much worse and diabetes treatments these days are so much better than when I was nursing.

I also recommend a Libre sensor or Dexcom as the arrows they show are invaluable x

BloodyHellKen · 06/09/2023 09:33

For all the people on the thread saying x has T1D and no one else in the family has and this 'proves' xy&z etc etc T1D is an autoimmune disease of which there are many.

There may not be others in the family with T1D but there could be (living and dead) relatives who have/had hypothyroidism, Reynaud's, lupus, pernicious anaemia, MS, coeliac, psoriasis.

They are all part of the same 'family' of autoimmune diseases and means the decedents of those with a certain autoimmune disease are more at risk of developing an autoimmune disease than the general population. I am one of those people, but I have been lucky, so far. My own children weren't so lucky and the genetic predisposition to autoimmunity has passed from me (with a family history, but no auto immunity myself) to them. My son is the first and only person in our family to have T1D but I have no doubt he developed it as a result of his (autoimmune predisposing) genetic makeup.

electriclight · 06/09/2023 04:33

The teacher knows the other kid better than you do - she knows whether he'd genuinely be receptive to a five minute discussion about diabetes or whether he was being an arse and just needed shutting down quickly.

She was also present to hear his question. We have all discussed what he meant by the question but she was there to hear it, tone of voice and so on. Was it a genuine question or trying to string out a conversation to delay a lesson. Was he angling for info that he could use against your ds. Was he genuinely worried that he could catch it.

Very few teachers are genuinely unkind, so let's give her the benefit of the doubt - unexpected conversation, probably trying to get back to something else, probably trying to protect your son and shut the conversation down, probably no detailed or personal knowledge of diabetes.

I think it's fine to offer more information but unreasonable to be angry with her when it's clear she responded with good intentions.

sashh · 06/09/2023 03:45

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 17:05

It is something that you can basically ‘catch’ and anyone can get it. They haven’t separated a gene that contributes to T1 if there is one so anyone can get it as they wouldn’t know they have a gene.

DS is 14 and he knows what he heard. He would not challenge a teacher unfortunately.

It is not known exactly what causes Type 1 but likely to do with the body’s reaction to a virus. Big increase in T1s since Covid according to DS’s diabetic team.

The teachers response did make DS feel
’othered’.

It is not inherited in the case of DS or any of the other DC in our local T1 group but go ahead stating it is.

This boy started the discussion by deliberately trying to wind up DS for his medical condition.

Why should the teacher protect his feelings by giving incorrect information and by doing so upsetting DSs, if that’s what she was doing?

But you don't 'catch' it in the way we normally talk about catching a virus.

I would say anyone can develop it. Or say that it happens when the pancreas doesn't work properly / stops working. I'm quite a literal person though.

If the child was trying to wind up your son then he/she might have wanted to close the other child down quickly. A discussion of genetics + viruses = identical twins where only one id type 1, what the pancreas is and what it does takes time, and that is something the teacher probably doesn't have.

The teacher knows the other child better than you do. I'm not going to say don't contact the teacher, but maybe listen to the teacher's side.

Swipe left for the next trending thread