Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ‘EDUCATE’ this teacher?

342 replies

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 16:03

DS has Type 1 diabetes. He has to put up with stupid comments like ‘did you eat too much sugar’ regularly.

At school today, a boy asked him this. Teacher nearby started telling him what Type 1 is and he asked if anyone could get it and could you get it randomly.

Teacher said No which DS was quite pissed of about as it seems to imply he’s done something to get it or it’s in his genes (it’s not). He’s not the type to correct a teacher so I think I should?

Quite annoyed as if you’re going to educate someone, do it correctly!

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 09:43

Mary not at all, your posts are very clear & interesting - knew none of this!

But the final paragraph where you go back to the term 'genetic predisposition', it doesn't seem that's what you're saying - as you conclude with a reference to spontaneous change to DNA, which seems linguistically incompatible with the 'predisposition' aspect!

(But I recognise I know little to nothing here so am happy to take your word for it!)

Marynotsocontrary · 07/09/2023 09:34

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 07:59

@Marynotsocontrary

Thanks for that - interesting, and clearly explained.

However the poster I & another replied to said:

you need the genetic predisposition, which may or may not have been inherited

That sentence, linguistically, does not make sense, and having read your post, is not the same as what you said.

It does make linguistic sense.
I'm sorry, my earlier post was probably a bit confusing. It was the first part of it that was relevant really.

Humans grow. They also replace their cells all the time. Copying of DNA is going on all over the body all the time. Copying errors(mutations) can arise at any stage, sometimes for no apparent reason at all, sometimes external factors are involved.They can cause various medical conditions, skin cancer is an example. If the mutations don't occur in the germline they are not inherited.

I know mutation is an emotive word but it is not meant as such. It is very normal. It happens to everybody.

How serious these mutations are depend on when and where they occur. Their effects vary from negligible to detrimental. Sometimes (very rarely) they bring benefit. DNA changes that occur very early on in development, when a person is just a cluster of cells, have the potential to affect much of the body.

When genetic predisposition is spoken of it, yes, mostly this will be referring to DNA you've inherited. However the possibility can't be ruled out that an individual has a change in their DNA that occured at some stage during their development or during their lifetime (ie was not inherited) and that this change has contributed to their condition. It happens.

vickylou78 · 07/09/2023 09:18

I think you are over thinking this. Just let it go. Teacher was likely just trying to defuse the situation.

Hilsberry · 07/09/2023 08:24

I think your sensitivity to your child’s condition has maybe made you overreact to this. People do have preconceived ideas of what a condition looks like. For example I have Rheumatoid Arthritis and I’ve had comments ranging from “You’re too young to have arthritis” to “Sure we all gets aches and pains!” I wouldn’t go educating the teacher on purpose. Sounds like the teacher meant well. If the situation arises and it’s the topic of conversation you could gently tell her a little more about the condition.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 07:59

@Marynotsocontrary

Thanks for that - interesting, and clearly explained.

However the poster I & another replied to said:

you need the genetic predisposition, which may or may not have been inherited

That sentence, linguistically, does not make sense, and having read your post, is not the same as what you said.

Sidslaw · 07/09/2023 03:15

LostInTheColonies · 06/09/2023 21:07

@Sidslaw you inherited the gene. You didn't inherit cancer.

The cancer is the disease, in the same way that T1 diabetes is a disease.

Obvs I have no idea what kind of cancer you're referring to, whether it's double-recessive, or anything else.

With T1, you need the genetic predisposition, which may or may not have been inherited - could be spontaneous- and also need an additional trigger.

While we're at it, DD might pass the predisposition on. Or she might not - depends on how chromosomes split during meiosis (that's covered in GCSE biology as well).

wrong - I inherited the cancer. You are using the term "inherited" inaccurately.

Fivethirtyeight · 07/09/2023 00:33

I thought so too

Deliana · 07/09/2023 00:31

Misinformation · 06/09/2023 20:22

A previous poster kindly stated that people on this thread are deliberately being obtuse so I didn’t have to.

The fact is no one would know whether they had a genetic predisposition (if there is indeed one) to get Type 1 unless there was a history of it in their family so the first person to get it would indeed get it pretty randomly! By your thinking DS got it randomly out of his 3 siblings (same parents so same genetics) who were also exposed to Covid and other viruses and didn’t get it!

So therefore anyone could develop it anytime as they wouldn’t know they could get it until they did if there is no history in their family, just like DS.

DS is a highly intelligent 14 year old, can understand English and what what people say and is not prone to making things up (always an accusation on here if you say a thing about teachers) so he did not misunderstand what the teacher said.

My point was she shouldn’t have said something that wasn’t true that DS basically had something inherently wrong with him/had done something and that’s why he got it making the rest of the class think so too as they were all listening.

If she did say it to prevent the other child worrying that he may get it, that’s unacceptable as she should have thought how saying that would impact on the kid struggling with the life threatening illness! He knows that it was just shit luck but it’s understandably upsetting especially when you get people making stupid comments about sugar and connecting it to Type 2.

I personally think she got it mixed up with Type 2 because if she knew about Type 1 she’d have said it’s not known how people get it so she should be educated. Doing the email now.

I'm not being obtuse.

Your annoyance at the teacher stems from her telling the kids that this is not a disease that occurs randomly.
You maintain it does occur randomly simply because we don't know who will get it.

However, that is not the meaning of the word random when it comes to inherited disease. No matter how much you insist it is, it is not.

And I'm sorry. I know it's a very emotive subject. My kids also have conditions where they inherited a 'likelihood ' of developing a condition (they unfortunately did develop it).
Loads of people do.

Having a probable genetic predisposition to T1 diabetes does not make it any more your DS's 'fault' than a virus alone causing the damage does.
And alluding to these types of predispositions doesn't mean his teacher was implying there was something 'inherently wrong' with your DS as you seem to be thinking?
In truth they are just part of being human. Every single one of us is predisposed to something or other and it's not a character weakness.

For some reason I don't fully understand (guilt?) you want what happened to your DS to be a totally random occurrence. Just a chance encounter with a virus, and nothing at all to do with his DNA.

But it's very unlikely that's the case.
And that's not his teachers fault and what she said was not wrong.

jazzyfips · 06/09/2023 23:20

OP, you’re massively over sensitive as is your son.

Marynotsocontrary · 06/09/2023 23:07

Ok, am I wildly misinformed in thinking all genes are inherited, in pairs, from both parents? Therefore how can a genetic predisposition be spontaneous?

No, you're exactly correct.

Some of these posts 😬 forget biology, they don't understand English!

Ahem. Sorry @EarringsandLipstick, but you're wrong there, as is pp.

Spontaneous mutuaions - copying errors - arise all the time in our cells, we all have them in our bodies. Sometimes they have negative consequences, sometimes they don't.

If they occur in the germline ( ie egg or sperm cells) they can be subsequently passed on to offspring, ie inherited. So a new spontaneous 'change' can occur in the DNA of sperm or egg that can then be passed on. They're called de novo mutations.

EarringsandLipstick · 06/09/2023 22:10

@Sidslaw

I'm impressed with your calm perseverance on this thread!

EarringsandLipstick · 06/09/2023 22:09

Callyem · 06/09/2023 21:20

"With T1, you need the genetic predisposition, which may or may not have been inherited - could be spontaneous- and also need an additional trigger."

Ok, am I wildly misinformed in thinking all genes are inherited, in pairs, from both parents? Therefore how can a genetic predisposition be spontaneous?

No, you're exactly correct.

Some of these posts 😬 forget biology, they don't understand English!

Teder · 06/09/2023 21:43

electriclight · 06/09/2023 21:22

Kid asked if you can get it randomly, can anyone get it.

Teacher said 'no' without any further discussion or elaboration.

To me, this is a busy person dealing with a PITA kid. She was shutting it down to get back to the lesson, her meeting, her marking, whatever.

I'm surprised your 14 year old kid didn't speak up if he was so upset. Even if it was quietly to the teacher afterwards. And I'm surprised you're so cross about it too. As a teacher, the tone of your email would determine whether I read it or deleted it without reading.

and if that child was being a wind up merchant, it was better the teacher shut them down without properly engaging. If the child wasn’t asking genuinely, not sure any level of education would have helped.

LostInTheColonies · 06/09/2023 21:29

Callyem · 06/09/2023 21:20

"With T1, you need the genetic predisposition, which may or may not have been inherited - could be spontaneous- and also need an additional trigger."

Ok, am I wildly misinformed in thinking all genes are inherited, in pairs, from both parents? Therefore how can a genetic predisposition be spontaneous?

This is a pretty good explanation

www.sciencelearn.org.nz/resources/208-meiosis-inheritance-and-variation

Justonemorecoffeeplease · 06/09/2023 21:27

OP I wasn’t there so can’t comment on what the teacher meant but in all honestly it sounds like they were trying to move things on in a calm way. I’d advise not going in all guns blazing as I’m not sure what you’ll get from it other than a sense of satisfaction. Perhaps clarify things but as for ‘EDUCATE’ I can only foresee that being interpreted as a really hostile approach to be filed under ‘FFS!’

electriclight · 06/09/2023 21:22

Kid asked if you can get it randomly, can anyone get it.

Teacher said 'no' without any further discussion or elaboration.

To me, this is a busy person dealing with a PITA kid. She was shutting it down to get back to the lesson, her meeting, her marking, whatever.

I'm surprised your 14 year old kid didn't speak up if he was so upset. Even if it was quietly to the teacher afterwards. And I'm surprised you're so cross about it too. As a teacher, the tone of your email would determine whether I read it or deleted it without reading.

Callyem · 06/09/2023 21:20

"With T1, you need the genetic predisposition, which may or may not have been inherited - could be spontaneous- and also need an additional trigger."

Ok, am I wildly misinformed in thinking all genes are inherited, in pairs, from both parents? Therefore how can a genetic predisposition be spontaneous?

LostInTheColonies · 06/09/2023 21:07

@Sidslaw you inherited the gene. You didn't inherit cancer.

The cancer is the disease, in the same way that T1 diabetes is a disease.

Obvs I have no idea what kind of cancer you're referring to, whether it's double-recessive, or anything else.

With T1, you need the genetic predisposition, which may or may not have been inherited - could be spontaneous- and also need an additional trigger.

While we're at it, DD might pass the predisposition on. Or she might not - depends on how chromosomes split during meiosis (that's covered in GCSE biology as well).

Mumof118 · 06/09/2023 21:04

We all have unique ‘faults’, just as we all have unique talents and strengths. I teach children with T1, Cystic Fibrosis, severe eczema, alopecia, coeliac disease, autism, ADHD, heart defects, epilepsy and deaf and blindness.

Firstly, I don’t know how or why each of these conditions occur. I do know that you can’t catch them, as in spread them from pupil to pupil. Neither is the origin of each disease or condition important. As long as I know how to deal with them in the context of the school day.

It’s awful for any child to have a disease like type 1 diabetes and I sympathise. But, if I’m trying to teach a hazardous technology lesson and I just want to put to bed some unkind ‘banter’, then I’m just going to say ‘no, you can’t catch T1’, shut it down and leave it at that. I haven’t got time for an educational moment. In no way would I be implying …no, that boy is different, he’s just faulty. That is where you are being over sensitive.

If I received your email following such an interaction, I’d probably roll my eyes, write back a generic, ‘thank you for bringing this to my attention’ and delete. This really is over the top.

If the teacher was mistaken over how to treat your son’s condition, I’d understand your annoyance. But I think you need to explain to your son the likelihood of what happened and help him realise that we’re all different and will continue to develop differences at various life stages.

CostelloJones · 06/09/2023 20:56

Mine too. How old are these kids? that will make a big difference surely

When we were about 7 a school friend was diagnosed with type 1 and I vividly remember our teacher having to explain it’s not something you can “catch”

Vynalbob · 06/09/2023 20:49

This👍

Sidslaw · 06/09/2023 20:44

For goodness sake! some people don't seem to understand what inherited or genetic means! I have a genetic fault which causes cancer, Around half my relatives do. They don't all get cancer. The ones without this gene will never get the cancer related to this gene. The one with this gene might. It is genetic. I inherited it. That did not mean I would definitely get it. But I did. And my relatives with the same faulty gene might not get this form of cancer, but might pass it on, and on, and on, and their great grandson might get the cancer, and think "gosh, no one else in my family has this" but yes, they did, they just didn't develop the associated cancer

Callyem · 06/09/2023 20:39

It is generally understood that people without certain combinations of genes do not get it. Therefore it is genetic. The triggers are exactly that, triggers. No environmental factor (eg virus) will trigger type 1 diabetes in a person without those genetic factors. As the genes come from BOTH parents, it is perfectly likely that someone can have the genetic factors despite no history of T1 diabetes.

JellyBabiesSaveLives · 06/09/2023 20:30

Type 1 diabetes is not an inherited disease.

You can inherit the combination of genes that make you susceptible to autoimmune diseases and live your whole life without ever developing a single one of them.

Also, although scientists are working towards finding out what causes Type 1 diabetes, and autoimmune genes are a major topic of interest, they don't actually know what causes it yet. It is not a proven fact that "you don't get it if you don't have the genes for it" - that is, at present, just a theory.

The massive increase in new diagnoses since March 2020 would seem to support the "triggered by particular viruses" theory though!