Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ‘EDUCATE’ this teacher?

342 replies

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 16:03

DS has Type 1 diabetes. He has to put up with stupid comments like ‘did you eat too much sugar’ regularly.

At school today, a boy asked him this. Teacher nearby started telling him what Type 1 is and he asked if anyone could get it and could you get it randomly.

Teacher said No which DS was quite pissed of about as it seems to imply he’s done something to get it or it’s in his genes (it’s not). He’s not the type to correct a teacher so I think I should?

Quite annoyed as if you’re going to educate someone, do it correctly!

OP posts:
Hoogieflip · 05/09/2023 18:34

@Sidslaw Will you share a source for this, please, as I'm unable to find one. (The closest I can find from a reputable source is that genes definitely play a role in type 1.)

donquixotedelamancha · 05/09/2023 18:34

Maybe read my first post. The boy asked if you could get it randomly and could anyone get it. Teacher said NO implying that DS is not like ‘anyone’, didn’t get it randomly and has some sort of deficit.

It's doesn't imply that at all. Just because PP doesn't agree with your conclusion doesn't mean they haven't read your post. Most people seem to disagree with you.

The teacher's explanation was simplistic (perhaps age-appropriately do) but not at all critical of your son. I think you will make your son's life harder if you don't teach him how to accept that not everyone will always be perfectly sensitive to the challenges he faces.

Cowlover89 · 05/09/2023 18:34

Yanbu

AIstolemylunch · 05/09/2023 18:33

Of course it is genetic. Everything in your body is related to your genes so anyone with type 1 diabetes has a genetic mix that lends itself or means they are highly likely to developing type 1 diabetes, irrespective of anything he could have done to prevent it, which is why young kids get it. As opposed to my mother who has Type 2 diabetes because she is overweight and has a terrible diet so she developed it in her late fifties.

I don't get why you don't like an explanation that shows that it is not his fault, there was nothing he could have done to prevent having it and it wasn't due to him hving unhealthy habits? Saying something is genetic is not necessarily the same as saying something is hereditary.

Chippy4me · 05/09/2023 18:33

It is something that you can basically ‘catch’ and anyone can get it.

You cannot catch diabetes FFS because it’s contagious.

Your poor kid.
You’re going to alienate him until he has no friends.

Thank goodness he at least has an adult around him with some common sense, his teacher.

Someone started a thread and asked why people say the OP sounds like hard work.
If they read this thread they would understand.

JudgeJ · 05/09/2023 18:32

ActDottie · 05/09/2023 16:24

To me it sounds like the kid was asking can he get it like you get a cold and the teacher said no to this.

But on MN many never mniss a chance to fabricate complaints against teachers! What did the OP expect the teacher to say? It's not the teacher who needs educating, look in the mirror OP!

Againstmachine · 05/09/2023 18:31

How the actual fuck is it ‘precious’ to not want my son to feel like shit by a teacher’s stupid remark about a life threatening medical condition when he is struggling to understand why it happened to him?

Except the teacher didn't make a stupid remark, stop reaching we get about your sons health but stop lashing out at everyone.

Someone made a stupid remark in this thread stating you can catch it that was you.

BloodyHellKen · 05/09/2023 18:31

bruffin · 05/09/2023 18:19

Diabetes UK have a good explanation he could understand

https://www.diabetes.org.uk/research/research-round-up/research-spotlight/research-spotlight-what-causes-type-1-diabetes#:~:text=There's%20no%20single%20gene%20that,chances%20of%20you%20developing%20it.

"the genetics of Type 1 diabetes isn’t simple. There’s no single gene that, if inherited from your parents, means you’re going to develop Type 1 diabetes.
In fact, there are a number of genes involved in Type 1 diabetes. These genes don’t ‘give’ you Type 1 diabetes, but increase the chances of you developing it. The more high risk genes you have, the more likely you are to develop Type 1 diabetes.
But having several high risk genes doesn’t mean you will definitely develop Type 1. Take genetically identical twins as an example. There are pairs of identical twins where one twin develops Type 1 diabetes, and the other doesn’t. This means that our risk of Type 1 diabetes isn’t solely linked to our genetic make-up".

Thank you for this @bruffin . I find genetics and autoimmunity a fascinating subject not least because almost all women on my mums side developed some autoimmunity in young adult hood but not me, though I expected to. But here is the kicker. I clearly carry the dodgy genes as 2 of my adult children have autoimmune diseases. I would love to know how/why I appear to have protection.

When my oldest developed T1D we both had the same nasty flu bug. I made a full recovery he developed T1D.

Inkpotlover · 05/09/2023 18:30

OP, I get you are protective of your child - I watched my uncle and aunt cope with my cousin getting a T1 diagnosis at 7 and it is SO hard as a parent. But I wonder if your DS' sensitive reaction to the teacher's clearly-no-malice-intended remark is a reflection of how you tend to react? Taking offence is counterproductive because the other kids now know to bait him to wind him up. Isn't it better to encourage him to shrug it off and just calmly put them straight, teacher included?

paddyclampofthethirdkind · 05/09/2023 18:30

I have Type 1 diabetes and it’s an extremely misunderstood condition.

I think the teacher did the right thing in telling the trouble maker that it isn’t caused by eating too many sweets.

It is caused by having a genetic predisposition though. I was the first in my family but my nephew got it in his teens as well.

I suspect what is getting some people’s’ backs up on here is your condescending and aggressive tone towards the teacher who is only doing his or her best.

Do not think they’ve got enough to deal with this early in the term?

I think your DS will have to grow a thicker skin as he’ll deal with far worse than this when he’s an adult with T1!!!

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 05/09/2023 18:29

I hope you don’t talk like this to your son. You sound over intense.

MonkeyDoodles · 05/09/2023 18:29

A teacher at my school once asked a boy/girl twin if they were identical.
Worse still she was a science teacher !

Sidslaw · 05/09/2023 18:28

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 17:50

Maybe read my first post. The boy asked if you could get it randomly and could anyone get it. Teacher said NO implying that DS is not like ‘anyone’, didn’t get it randomly and has some sort of deficit.

Damn right I’m ‘sensitive’ as a parent of a child who’s life revolves around his glucose levels, weighing and counting carbs in everything he eats, who worries about dying if he goes into a hypo or into a coma if he goes high and has struggled to understand why he got it his terrible disease in first place and if he did something wrong!

He told me as soon as he came out of school so it was obviously on his mind.

I said you can ‘catch’ it on here meaning anyone could potentially ‘catch’ it in the sense of there is a lot of evidence that viruses are the trigger. DS had Covid 3 times in quick succession months before he was diagnosed. He was asymptomatic apart from the 3rd infection.

@Sidslaw If you are teaching that Type 1 is inherited, perhaps you need to inform the exam body that the syllabus content is wrong. Surely as a teacher, you have a duty to teach correct information.

https://www.diabetes.org.uk/diabetes-the-basics/types-of-diabetes/type-1/causes#:~:text=We%20don't%20know%20the,history%20of%20it%20at%20all.

Because it is not wrong, and even if it were wrong, students have to learn what the exam board says they have to learn. There are aspects of the GCSE that are factually wrong, but this it not one of them.

Chucking random scraps of internet dirge at me doesn't change that.

A - I am a biology teacher and B- I come from a family where many people have inherited it

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 18:26

DNAnucleotide · 05/09/2023 18:15

i reckon this is OP: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/4740606-ramifications-of-teacher-lying-about-a-training-course?page=6&reply=123868371

Shes posted a few times, always about her T1 child and always out for blood.

Good god. Are you a teacher?

Can you add up the years between primary school age and age 14 considering that thread is dated 12th Feb this year?

OP posts:
adomizo · 05/09/2023 18:25

Goodness. Calm down..you are being massively oversensitive about this.. I know several people who developed type 1 diabetes in their 20s. There are certainly some genetic elements to how these auto immune diseases are triggered and how this develops into type 1 diabetes. The teacher was just giving a diplomatic answer explaining that you can't catch diabetes. They did not seem to be suggesting you child did anything. You need to stop over thinking this.

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 05/09/2023 18:24

@BloodyHellKen because it means the OP doesn’t need to feel responsible for her son having that condition. Which she absolutely shouldn’t, it is not her fault, but the majority of the time when parents refuse to look or understand the facts and evidence it’s because they feel like they’re the ones to blame.

BloodyHellKen · 05/09/2023 18:23

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 18:12

So explain how DS has 3 siblings (all older) who don’t have Type 1. Parents without it. 24 cousins on both sides who don’t have it. Nor any other relatives on both sides going back 100 years who had it!

DH and I have 13 full siblings between us.

The link I posted stated there may be a genetic predisposition (but they don’t actually know) so again anyone can get it unless scientists manage to isolate a gene, test everyone for it and nobody passes it on!

I don't understand why you are so adamant that your son doesn't have a genetic predisposition for T1D OP. He obviously does or he wouldn't have developed it.

As I just said to another poster obviously spontaneous cases can occur but having a genetic predisposition to T1D doesn't necessarily mean others in your family also have T1D, they can have other autoimmune disease in the same family like hypothyroidism, Reynaud's, pernicious anaemia.

It's the genetic predisposition to autoimmunity that is passed on, not a specific autoimmune disease.

Eg my mum has hypothyroidism, as do some other women in that side of my family. I am autoimmune free (touch wood) but my son has T1D. I have passed on the predisposition. No one else in the family in living memory has ever had T1D.

Inkpotlover · 05/09/2023 18:22

ActDottie · 05/09/2023 16:24

To me it sounds like the kid was asking can he get it like you get a cold and the teacher said no to this.

That's how I read it too.

chillidoritto · 05/09/2023 18:21

YABU. Saying you can “catch” it implies it’s contagious, which it isn’t.

The teacher told the boy it wasn’t caused by life style, which is correct.

If the boy was trying to wind your DS up, the teacher was probably trying to quickly diffuse the situation.

Teachers just can’t win can they?!

pepsimax00 · 05/09/2023 18:21

Type 1 for 22 years get used to it and yes, educate them if you can. DS will be doing it himself in time

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 18:20

How the actual fuck is it ‘precious’ to not want my son to feel like shit by a teacher’s stupid remark about a life threatening medical condition when he is struggling to understand why it happened to him?

She could have just said ‘I don’t know’!

Yes, saying it can’t just happen to anyone and you can’t get it randomly does imply DS is somehow different.

I have absolutely no doubt DS relayed it as it was said. He has better comprehension that most on here.

OP posts:
bruffin · 05/09/2023 18:19

Misinformation · 05/09/2023 18:12

So explain how DS has 3 siblings (all older) who don’t have Type 1. Parents without it. 24 cousins on both sides who don’t have it. Nor any other relatives on both sides going back 100 years who had it!

DH and I have 13 full siblings between us.

The link I posted stated there may be a genetic predisposition (but they don’t actually know) so again anyone can get it unless scientists manage to isolate a gene, test everyone for it and nobody passes it on!

Diabetes UK have a good explanation he could understand

https://www.diabetes.org.uk/research/research-round-up/research-spotlight/research-spotlight-what-causes-type-1-diabetes#:~:text=There's%20no%20single%20gene%20that,chances%20of%20you%20developing%20it.

"the genetics of Type 1 diabetes isn’t simple. There’s no single gene that, if inherited from your parents, means you’re going to develop Type 1 diabetes.
In fact, there are a number of genes involved in Type 1 diabetes. These genes don’t ‘give’ you Type 1 diabetes, but increase the chances of you developing it. The more high risk genes you have, the more likely you are to develop Type 1 diabetes.
But having several high risk genes doesn’t mean you will definitely develop Type 1. Take genetically identical twins as an example. There are pairs of identical twins where one twin develops Type 1 diabetes, and the other doesn’t. This means that our risk of Type 1 diabetes isn’t solely linked to our genetic make-up".

Research spotlight - what causes Type 1 diabetes?

Our immune system normally protects us against infection and illness. But in Type 1 diabetes, the immune system attacks the cells in the pancreas that make insulin – the hormone responsible for regulating levels of glucose in the blood. Scientists are...

https://www.diabetes.org.uk/research/research-round-up/research-spotlight/research-spotlight-what-causes-type-1-diabetes#:~:text=There's%20no%20single%20gene%20that,chances%20of%20you%20developing%20it.

Baconisdelicious · 05/09/2023 18:18

maybe you should be teaching him to be more resilient. A complete over reaction

Resilience? Ha! All type 1s have resilience in abundance. If they didn’t, they’d just give up and die.

BloodyHellKen · 05/09/2023 18:18

housethatbuiltme · 05/09/2023 18:03

No.

I know several type 1 diabetics (including a sibling) and non 'inherited' it.

The causes of T1 diabetes are not 'proven' but it most commonly is linked to immune system issues that cause organ damage.

I know several T1 diabetics and non are in a inherited 'chain' of diabetic family members, they are all stand alone cases.

It could possibly increase your risk as there maybe genetic elements in families that could make pancreatic damage risk higher if you have a direct T1 diabetic family member but its not just 'passed on'.

Obviously spontaneous cases can occur but having a genetic predisposition to T1D doesn't necessarily mean others in your family also have T1D, they can have other autoimmune disease in the same family like hypothyroidism, Reynaud's, pernicious anaemia.

It's the genetic predisposition to autoimmunity that is passed on, not a specific autoimmune disease.

Eg my mum has hypothyroidism, as do some other women in that side of my family. I am autoimmune free (touch wood) but my son has T1D. I have passed on the predisposition. No one else in the family in living memory has ever had T1D.

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 05/09/2023 18:17

You and your DS are being way too sensitive about this. There was no harm intended and the teacher was technically correct - you can’t “catch” T1 diabetes. You can develop it but you definitely cannot catch it because it is not contagious.

But for what it’s worth, I understand and sympathise with the sensitivity around it. DS has his own conditions that also cannot be “caught” and I can be quite sensitive about him feeling othered by it too. But it’s one thing to feel sensitive about it and quite another to go in all guns blazing over what was a factually correct conversation.