Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most people don't have savings?

366 replies

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 14:03

I realise this is going to get a whole range of different views and experiences and I am interested to hear them all, but I recently read some research saying that most families in the UK have less than £600 in savings. This got me wondering - I am a single mum with two teens and a mortgage, and I don't have savings as such but I do have a private pension (had it for nearly 20 years now) that I pay roughly 5% of my salary into (as well as a work pension) and I overpay on my mortgage. I consider this a more effective use of my money than saving, which I can't afford to do as well. Do most people have pensions AND savings? Or neither?

Just really curious as I spend my salary every single month and all my friends do the same. That might be just my peer group! I suppose I could save if we never went on holiday - but I'd rather have the holidays tbh. You only live once and you can't take it with you, etc etc.

OP posts:
userxx · 05/09/2023 16:08

I've always been a saver, I used to squirrel away birthday and Xmas money as a child. I'm still the same now, not sure what I'm saving for though! Sometimes I get a bit obsessed with saving and need to remind myself to relax and enjoy life.

RudsyFarmer · 05/09/2023 16:07

I have savings that sit in premium bonds, as does my partner. We overpay the mortgage and I know he has some stocks and shares.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 05/09/2023 16:05

@AperfectMess I think you were replying to my comments there. We have lots of enjoyment in life, being frugal and not holidaying annually doesn't mean there is no fun or enjoyment in life! I personally don't like to holiday every year, my husband would but at the moment he knows it's not something we can do. We're aiming to be mortgage free within a certain not too far away timescale and when that time comes, we will start to have annual holidays. But we're also planning a large house extension so we're also saving for that too. So it's not like we're saving tens of thousands just for the sake of it, they are for good reason and will bring us a much better lifestyle in the not too distant future.

But as I said above, our life is filled with enjoyment, we're not boring and our children very much enjoy their life!

Alwaysgiraffe · 05/09/2023 16:05

Probably worth adding that I never go on holiday or eat out and the £300 is probably more like £150 since the cost of everything went up

Alwaysgiraffe · 05/09/2023 16:03

I get paid into account A and transfer enough for all bills into account B + £300.
that builds up to maybe a few k and is my oh shit fund for when the car breaks down, the boiler explodes or whatever. It never gets bigger than maybe 5k but I’m also never in a position where I can’t pay an unexpected big bill.
I should add tho that I’ve a good pension through work and pay a bit extra on my mortgage sometimes so it has some decent equity.
I’m a single parent though and have been since my child was 5, with zero help from my ex who quit work rather than pay child support. Sigh. So it’s important for me to feel in control and able to cope when shit happens
’Child’ has just finished University now so maybe there will be more chance to save.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/09/2023 16:03

Mumsnet is very odd in this respect. If you go by MN you’d think that everyone has pots and pots of savings, and puts aside about half of their income each month.

I don’t think that’s most people’s reality.

floribunda18 · 05/09/2023 16:02

AperfectMess · 05/09/2023 15:52

@floribunda18 · Today 15:46

We do not go on a foreign holiday every year, usually would do one on average every 4 years. Do an inexpensive UK holiday every 3 years or so. We do not eat out or get takeaways regularly. We are pretty frugal

Each to their own but I'd rather have the holidays and takeaways, and no savings.

If the house falls down that's what home insurance is for.

Yes, but I do believe it is a fine balance.
If you're fortunate enough to save some money for emergencies, great, that's what dh and I do. However if you're saving thousands upon thousands, that can't go beyond some ridiculously high level, without hardly any hols, enjoyments etc, than what is the point? Yes you can't act entirely on the "could be dead tomorrow' mindset but Jesus live alittle if you're financially 'able' to do so.

Yes quite, I agree.

Sounds like you are doing ok, OP, just carry on as you are.

I think with the massive inflation this year and energy prices doubling and more people are doing ok just to be managing TBH.

I'm just glad we've managed to afford household expenditure going up by about £500 a month in a short space of time.

A lot of people could save money if they weren't required to pay directly into the CEO of energy companies' and banks' wallets.

Tigger85 · 05/09/2023 16:01

I pay into a pension and I used to have savings in a joint account with my ex partner. We broke up because he was becoming increasingly abusive, social services became involved. The day I ended the relationship he emptied our joint current and savings account. I work part time since having children in a professional job, I cannot increase my hours due to the issues with social services and the children. He so far refuses to pay child support. All of this means I am struggling month by month often going into unauthorised overdrafts. But its also beneficial for me not to have savings right now, I need legal aid and you are not eligible for legal aid if you have too much in savings. Once cms have changed to collect and pay I will be putting abit aside each month as best I can to cover winter fuel bills.

Saurus72 · 05/09/2023 16:01

I’m (hopefully..!) 10 years away from taking early retirement and so suddenly everything becomes very focused - no longer a theoretical conversation about stopping work ‘one day’.

I have a final salary pension from a former job and I now pay into a very generous pension where my employer doubles my contribution.

I have 4 months’ equivalent of monthly expenses saved for unexpected expenses. This is purely for emergency use.

We have sinking funds for holidays, house expenses and presents that we contribute to all year, and also regularly use.

We are overpaying the mortgage each month with the aim of clearing it within 5 years. Once this is complete this payment will go into ISAs to help fund retirement.

I find it very difficult to save without a goal, but clearing the mortgage in 5 years feels very motivating because of the life benefits it will bring.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 05/09/2023 16:00

I've always had savings......even when we were on benefits for a short time, I'd take the cash out every week and whatever was left, even as little as £3 I'd pay into my savings account every week. We've never had a massive income and never had to struggle or go without mainly because I've always had savings and refuse to spend money I don't have.

Selfesteem23 · 05/09/2023 15:59

I have rainy day/holiday/house stuff savings. I have a very small pot being built for long term.

i also have a work NHS pension and over pay the mortgage too but I don’t see those as savings like you do as I don’t have access to that money.

Happyhappyday · 05/09/2023 15:59

We have 6 months expenses in cash savings, working to get this to a year. We also contribute 20% to our pensions. We have separate investments that we don’t touch but not adding more to that at the moment because we are prioritizing getting our cash savings to 12 months. How we do it, we are both high earners but have kept our lifestyle in check, we have one secondhand car we paid cash for that is 7 years old, won’t replace it for at least another 5 years. No debt and never had any apart from student loans which were paid off early, and mortgage which is fixed at 2.2% for 30 years. We don’t eat out that much and don’t go mad when we do, holidays are nice by general standards but way less expensive than we could afford. We buy good quality but not often. I also work for a big higher end retailer (not UK) and I am able to get a lot of our clothes and sporting goods at a big discount there so can buy good quality at a fraction of the price. I think keeping lifestyle in check is pretty key, but aware that’s easy for me to say with two people earning well into 6 figures. I grew up in a well off but very financially conservative household and have tried to continue same.

Turtlegurl888 · 05/09/2023 15:58

Since I've been earning money I have always had savings. When I was growing up with a single mom we never had any money for emergencies like new boiler, broken window, etc. I wouldn't say I'm tight as a result but I make sure I live well within my means and save at the very, very least £250 a month. I'm eating into savings a bit at the moment on maternity leave, but that's something I saved for intentionally. And the amount I can save will probably lessen temporarily when I go back to work and have to pay childcare.

Some people can't save, whether because they don't earn enough or because the more they earn the further they upgrade their lifestyle. Others are just bad with cash.
I think the majority of people have SOME savings though.

Lifeomars · 05/09/2023 15:58

I have some savings now, but didn't in the past. As a single mum with periods of unemployment due to several redundancies, never getting any child support and paying for every single thing for my child by myself it was impossible. I used to go without food sometimes and it was tough. Did pay off the mortgage though and put a little bit of money away after I had done that. My problem was caused by two things, not having much money and being financially illiterate. I really wish I had been taught about money management, I had an academic education but it did not equip me for life in the real world. I also had parents who never discussed money and how to manage it and while I take responsibility for my own incompetence I do think it would have made a difference if money management had been a thing when I was growing up. Always worked though and paid my own way and have of course paid into a pension.

NameNew · 05/09/2023 15:57

I'm late thirties, bought my house in my early 20s, saved my own deposit and haven't really had any significant financial help from family (parents bought washing machine and fridge freezer when I bought my house, grandparents bought and insured my first car for me for £500 for the car and I think about £600 for the insurance).

No student debt - was fortunate to go to uni with and NHS bursary and NHS funded course. I did go back to uni and took a significant pay cut to do so which meant I lived on my credit cards. Built up quite a bit of credit card debt during that time and have almost cleared that now. I used most of my savings to pay off a significant proportion of it. I have about £2000 left in savings now. I have four savings accounts and I have a standing order set up to pay in to them on pay day - only small amounts but it's something. At the end of the month, whatever is left in my current account, I pay to my savings and the credit card (I pay into my savings the odd amount above the hundred, the hundreds to my credit card eg if I had £275 left, the £75 would go to savings and the £200 to the credit card). I'm not really very good with money though I am getting better.

PrinnyPree · 05/09/2023 15:54

I have a SGW fund (shit goes wrong) and try to put £200 a month in it, first month I put into it I had an emergency car repair bill for exactly that amount lol. Right now it has 4 figures in it and would see me through a few months if I lost my job for any reason or the boiler broke or I had a massive roof repair.

You say you overpay your mortgage, if you are still on a good mortgage deal I wouldn't bother and just shove any overpayment money into a high interest savings account instead. (And pay it off at the end of your mortgage term) That way you have the benefit of savings incase you need them for an emergency and they'll earn more interest if you're still on a good mortgage deal.

I'd put it in a completely seperate account though if you're a spender and will see a big fat holiday just waiting to be had when it gets to 4 figures lol. Xx However if it will get spent maybe overpaying mortgage is sensible. (You can always ask for a mortgage holiday if you overpay too and shit does indeed go wrong)

I agree with having nice holidays and making fond memories though then just saving rentlessly for retirement (as long as it doesn't put you too much in the black) there's definitely a balance to be had x

AperfectMess · 05/09/2023 15:52

@floribunda18 · Today 15:46

We do not go on a foreign holiday every year, usually would do one on average every 4 years. Do an inexpensive UK holiday every 3 years or so. We do not eat out or get takeaways regularly. We are pretty frugal

Each to their own but I'd rather have the holidays and takeaways, and no savings.

If the house falls down that's what home insurance is for.

Yes, but I do believe it is a fine balance.
If you're fortunate enough to save some money for emergencies, great, that's what dh and I do. However if you're saving thousands upon thousands, that can't go beyond some ridiculously high level, without hardly any hols, enjoyments etc, than what is the point? Yes you can't act entirely on the "could be dead tomorrow' mindset but Jesus live alittle if you're financially 'able' to do so.

BIossomtoes · 05/09/2023 15:52

You cannot put all emergency repairs on credit cards, I don't know any tradesmen that we use who even take credit cards. You may get an unlucky year and need a new boiler, repair a gutter leak, repair a garden fence etc., and with being unable to pay for these things on a credit card, you'd be screwed.

I have an MBNA credit card with constant offers of 0% money transfer into your bank account. We have the money to pay for this stuff but it makes far more sense to use MBNA’s and leave ours in a high interest account.

5monthmama · 05/09/2023 15:52

I have a pension which I pay 9.8%, I save in a few other places, one main savings for basically whatever I can, two small savings both £50 per month for planned bigger holidays and £120 per month saved for my son. I also overpay £500 per month on the mortgage however we have two incomes couldn't save if I was alone I could maybe manage £100 or so a month, I always need a bit of money saved of it stresses me out maybe a minimum of £2000 (ideally more).

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 15:51

ReadingSoManyThreads · 05/09/2023 15:43

My husband and I are also both Generation X, like yourself, however, we've got different mindsets to yourself. We have made provisions for retirement. We would seriously lose sleep if our savings dropped below £10k, but they are significantly higher. We've both been avid savers since childhood.

We do not go on a foreign holiday every year, usually would do one on average every 4 years. Do an inexpensive UK holiday every 3 years or so. We do not eat out or get takeaways regularly. We are pretty frugal.

It is much more savvy to put what you'd like to overpay on your mortgage into a savings account (provided your current mortgage interest rate is lower than savings rates are at the moment), then when your fixed deal is up, or if the savings rates fall below your mortgage rate, then use the chunk of savings to overpay instead. This is what we do when we make overpayments and this is the most financially savvy way to overpay.

I'd personally urge you to save for an emergency fund of at least £5k, but preferably closer to £10k. You cannot put all emergency repairs on credit cards, I don't know any tradesmen that we use who even take credit cards. You may get an unlucky year and need a new boiler, repair a gutter leak, repair a garden fence etc., and with being unable to pay for these things on a credit card, you'd be screwed.

Personally, if I were you, I would:

  1. Open up a good interest rate savings account, such as a regular saver or an easy access ISA.
  2. Pop your current mortgage overpayment into this account instead to use on a larger overpayment when your fixed deal ends (providing the interest rate is higher than your mortgage interest rate).
  3. Open a second good rate savings account (you can only pay into one ISA per year, so probably better to use the mortgage overpayment savings for your ISA to take advantage of it being tax-free). This second account will be for your emergency fund savings.
  4. Consider forgoing your annual foreign holiday and just going every other year instead.
  5. Consider cutting takeaways down to once per month instead of twice.
  6. You say you are a humble writer, I'm not sure what type of writing you do, but is this something you could scale up? You could use David Gaughran and Matthew J Homes for self-publishing advice and scaling up advice. This could potentially increase your earnings.

I think where your mindset is slightly flawed (in my opinion), in terms of "I consider this a more effective use of my money than saving, which I can't afford to do as well." and "You only live once and you can't take it with you, etc etc." is that, yes although bringing down your mortgage capital is good, it's not the same as having an emergency savings funds for necessary repairs to your property etc. And yes, you do only live once, but you need to be able to afford to fund your life while you are alive and if you splash out on a holiday then your boiler packs up the following week, you're screwed without your emergency savings fund. If you're dependent on using a CC for an unexpected necessary expense you may struggle to pay it back should something awful happen such as you lose your job etc.

I wish you well and hopefully happy saving!!

Thanks - I already work full time (magazine editor), edit another magazine in my spare time and am writing a book so I don't really have the capacity for more work right now!

Holidaying every other year is too bleak for me - sorry. I have kids and going away with them is the thing I look forward to the most, as do they. I'd forgo savings for that tbh.

Already had the disastrous year where everything went wrong - boiler broke, front of house fell off (!), dog needed hideously expensive life-saving operation that wasn't covered by insurance, fence needed repairing (so other dog couldn't escape and get run over) plus I moved house post-separation and had to rewire it, replace carpets, paint everything etc so this has been the most expensive year of my life, I think. I did have some savings before that but now I do not! Hopefully there's not much left to go wrong again before I build up a bit of a rainy day fund - but having said that, 2024 is probably reading this and saying 'hold my beer!'

OP posts:
floribunda18 · 05/09/2023 15:48

It doesn't cost two grand to buy a new tumble dryer let alone repair one.

roastytoastysnowballs · 05/09/2023 15:46

DH and I both have good Civil Service pensions and a lot of savings (six figures) - the vast majority of that is tied up in a long term saver at 5.96%

We have a mortgage on a 5 bed detached, and I'm 33 - should have it paid off by the time I'm 40

My tumble dryer broke down today. Luckily I have a floating account of £2k of easy access so that was easily sorted

Appreciate we are very fortunate but it takes a lot of work to be streamlined. We consult the spreadsheet daily, shop in Lidl and our only big annual extravagance is a £5k all inclusive family holiday

We drive boring cars. Volvos

floribunda18 · 05/09/2023 15:46

We do not go on a foreign holiday every year, usually would do one on average every 4 years. Do an inexpensive UK holiday every 3 years or so. We do not eat out or get takeaways regularly. We are pretty frugal

Each to their own but I'd rather have the holidays and takeaways, and no savings.

If the house falls down that's what home insurance is for.

Hufflepods · 05/09/2023 15:43

32, very working class background, parents have never earned close to 20k.
Went to uni on the lowest band of household income, started working on a 17k salary now around 40. DH similar age, always earned less than me until may leave when he took over but nothing astronomical.
Saved about 30k by 28 to purchase a property, 20k on a wedding about 15 months later, another 15k to put towards renovation a year or so later.
Personal pension is about 25k, DD’s savings 3k, 2k emergency pot, 2k in a pot for some work on the house next year but might leave this as extra emergency fund while on 2nd mat leave, about 3k in the mat leave pot with £600 a month diverted to this for the next 4 months.
Once I return to work the spare ~£1k or so a month will go into a savings pot for a house move.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 05/09/2023 15:43

My husband and I are also both Generation X, like yourself, however, we've got different mindsets to yourself. We have made provisions for retirement. We would seriously lose sleep if our savings dropped below £10k, but they are significantly higher. We've both been avid savers since childhood.

We do not go on a foreign holiday every year, usually would do one on average every 4 years. Do an inexpensive UK holiday every 3 years or so. We do not eat out or get takeaways regularly. We are pretty frugal.

It is much more savvy to put what you'd like to overpay on your mortgage into a savings account (provided your current mortgage interest rate is lower than savings rates are at the moment), then when your fixed deal is up, or if the savings rates fall below your mortgage rate, then use the chunk of savings to overpay instead. This is what we do when we make overpayments and this is the most financially savvy way to overpay.

I'd personally urge you to save for an emergency fund of at least £5k, but preferably closer to £10k. You cannot put all emergency repairs on credit cards, I don't know any tradesmen that we use who even take credit cards. You may get an unlucky year and need a new boiler, repair a gutter leak, repair a garden fence etc., and with being unable to pay for these things on a credit card, you'd be screwed.

Personally, if I were you, I would:

  1. Open up a good interest rate savings account, such as a regular saver or an easy access ISA.
  2. Pop your current mortgage overpayment into this account instead to use on a larger overpayment when your fixed deal ends (providing the interest rate is higher than your mortgage interest rate).
  3. Open a second good rate savings account (you can only pay into one ISA per year, so probably better to use the mortgage overpayment savings for your ISA to take advantage of it being tax-free). This second account will be for your emergency fund savings.
  4. Consider forgoing your annual foreign holiday and just going every other year instead.
  5. Consider cutting takeaways down to once per month instead of twice.
  6. You say you are a humble writer, I'm not sure what type of writing you do, but is this something you could scale up? You could use David Gaughran and Matthew J Homes for self-publishing advice and scaling up advice. This could potentially increase your earnings.

I think where your mindset is slightly flawed (in my opinion), in terms of "I consider this a more effective use of my money than saving, which I can't afford to do as well." and "You only live once and you can't take it with you, etc etc." is that, yes although bringing down your mortgage capital is good, it's not the same as having an emergency savings funds for necessary repairs to your property etc. And yes, you do only live once, but you need to be able to afford to fund your life while you are alive and if you splash out on a holiday then your boiler packs up the following week, you're screwed without your emergency savings fund. If you're dependent on using a CC for an unexpected necessary expense you may struggle to pay it back should something awful happen such as you lose your job etc.

I wish you well and hopefully happy saving!!