Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most people don't have savings?

366 replies

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 14:03

I realise this is going to get a whole range of different views and experiences and I am interested to hear them all, but I recently read some research saying that most families in the UK have less than £600 in savings. This got me wondering - I am a single mum with two teens and a mortgage, and I don't have savings as such but I do have a private pension (had it for nearly 20 years now) that I pay roughly 5% of my salary into (as well as a work pension) and I overpay on my mortgage. I consider this a more effective use of my money than saving, which I can't afford to do as well. Do most people have pensions AND savings? Or neither?

Just really curious as I spend my salary every single month and all my friends do the same. That might be just my peer group! I suppose I could save if we never went on holiday - but I'd rather have the holidays tbh. You only live once and you can't take it with you, etc etc.

OP posts:
Missflowers1981 · 05/09/2023 17:17

I have a 2 year fixed ISA with £3000 in it I intend to put another £3000 in it next April when the renewal comes up as I found when it’s in an ISA I don’t spend it so I consider it long term savings. I’m only £200 away from this so will meet this target next month. £6000 in the ISA. Once this is met I will then save £500 a month into a holiday/ trip fund from October. For next summer mainly. I could use this in an emergency too if needed for repairs. Thr following year in September I do the same get to the £3000 mark for the ISA and then save for a holiday.

I was attempting to save £500 a month which I do but I found that when I left it in a just a normal bank account I’d be tempted to withdraw it if I fancied a treat/ clothes/ theatre tickets etc

I do also have a state and teacher pension that comes out automatically before my net pay.

Monzo has helped me to budget a lot especially as it has pots you can assign a category for monthly spending.

However I can do this because whilst I have a partner I own a one bedroom flat in a new build where I live alone and bills and mortgage are generally low. If I had kids I’m pretty sure I would not be able to save £500 monthly.

YouJustDoYou · 05/09/2023 17:13

Had I been on my old wage, no savings at all, wouldn't have even been able to afford rent, council tax, bills, food.

sandyhappypeople · 05/09/2023 17:09

I like to have a buffer, so if I need the money I don't have to pay any interest on it, so instead of using my overdraft (I have got one for emergencies) I'd rather have £1000 in the bank and use that as a 'zero' balance, I also like to have 1-2 thousand in savings for eventualities.

For instance, my car has just been written off in a no fault (on my part) accident, courtesy car isn't bloody forthcoming(!), DH works shifts so needs his car, and we go on holiday at the end of next week , because I've got that bit of savings I can go and get a new (used) car now with no faff, and in the meantime I don't have to worry about making repayments or paying interest on what I've 'borrowed' from my savings, the insurance payout will mostly pay it back - when it pays out! I could use my credit card if I needed to, but some circumstances it's not accepted and you need to have actual cash in the bank to pay for things.

A two person household who both work full time it can be achievable to do this, but for single parents or single person households, it's just not doable a lot of the time, you have no choice but to just manage month to month. the problem with that is if you DO need money for anything unexpected it's likely you will have to borrow and then start paying interest as you can't afford to pay it back straight away, which you've got no way of getting out of, and if you do default any options you did have are suddenly revoked, it's a slippery slope and the banks are all to ready to give you the rope to hang yourself with. I've been there when I first moved out in my 20's, it's awful to feel so powerless, and it's a lot of peoples day to day reality.

ellie09 · 05/09/2023 17:04

I'm a single full time working mum and I have a 35k yearly salary.

I have been lax about saving in the past and thought YOLO, ill just have that holiday or what not. I also vape, so trying to quit this very expensive habit.

Some months I can save, others I can't.

I have £1,500 in savings at the moment and a pension plan with work (and all previous jobs)

AperfectMess · 05/09/2023 17:03

Even if some posters do talk to friends about how much savings they all have,🙄 I wonder how many will exaggerate, bend the truth, or outright lie out of embarrassment, knowing their friend has apparently thousands in savings.

PetiteNasturtium · 05/09/2023 16:59

As mentioned the people, I know that are well off are older Gen X and therefore house prices were much cheaper and in long term relationships. The friends I have who divorced or who coupled up much later in life are far worse off. My mate met the love of her life at 47, she had always lived alone. She was on a very similar salary to me but she had to pay for everything for all those years. She also refused to house share, we were very young when we became friends. So she lived in a two bed flat alone and I slummed it with housemates but everything was split four ways. That was her choice but it meant I could start saving when very young. My shared house was a dump but was so cheap, it was also in a very rough area.

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 16:59

Hufflepods · 05/09/2023 16:53

Mind you, I am very middle class and none of my close friends has pots and pots of savings. @horseyhorsey17

How do you know though? I don’t sit around and discuss how much my friends save each month or have saved in total. Do many people?

Sometimes I think the “I have no savings and no one I know cares about saving” is the adult equivalent to the whole “I never revise” of school times. Most people do and just quietly get in with it.

Yes, we talk about everything. Plus I've known most of them for years and they'd definitely have got a few rounds in if granny had left them a few K!

OP posts:
Freshstarts23 · 05/09/2023 16:58

But equally what if you never do the things you enjoy because you’re saving for retirement and then you have bad health or die early and never get to enjoy the benefits of a lifetime of saving.

Applesaarenttheonlyfruit · 05/09/2023 16:57

Hufflepods · 05/09/2023 16:53

Mind you, I am very middle class and none of my close friends has pots and pots of savings. @horseyhorsey17

How do you know though? I don’t sit around and discuss how much my friends save each month or have saved in total. Do many people?

Sometimes I think the “I have no savings and no one I know cares about saving” is the adult equivalent to the whole “I never revise” of school times. Most people do and just quietly get in with it.

That is so true. We have a lot stashed and no mortgage, but I still discuss mortgage rates with people as if they impact me.

weirdoboelady · 05/09/2023 16:56

No, most people do NOT have savings. See https://themoneycharity.org.uk/money-statistics/january-2023/ (my understanding is that the debt figure here does NOT include mortgage.)

Also, some of the earlier posts on overpaying mortgages are total bollocks rather misleading. Of COURSE it is better to invest at 6% than to overpay at 2%, but really, who still has a 2% mortgage? Read Martin Lewis on the subject, don't just guess!

https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/mortgages/mortgages-vs-savings/

The Money Charity's Money Statistics Report January 2023

January 2023's Money Statistics update on personal finance in the UK. Produced by The Money Charity, the UK's Financial Capability charity.

https://themoneycharity.org.uk/money-statistics/january-2023

AperfectMess · 05/09/2023 16:56

"Whereas I think I just have a deeply embedded working class mindset and I don't think I'm broke until I'm standing in Cash Converters with a box of old phones 😂"

🤣🤣 maybe I should be LOL

StoatofDisarray · 05/09/2023 16:54

I don't have any savings.

itsmyp4rty · 05/09/2023 16:54

We always had a bit of savings (probably a couple of grand) but mostly overpaid our mortgage. Once the mortgage was paid off saving became a lot easier!

Hufflepods · 05/09/2023 16:53

Mind you, I am very middle class and none of my close friends has pots and pots of savings. @horseyhorsey17

How do you know though? I don’t sit around and discuss how much my friends save each month or have saved in total. Do many people?

Sometimes I think the “I have no savings and no one I know cares about saving” is the adult equivalent to the whole “I never revise” of school times. Most people do and just quietly get in with it.

milveycrohn · 05/09/2023 16:53

I remember the money saving expert (Martin Lewis?) saying one should have at least 3 months of net income for emergencies. I suspect he was thinking of redundancies, as you cannot necessarily guarantee a payout, if the company goes bust.
I think that should be the aim, however little one earns, so that there is something for an emergency.

Applesaarenttheonlyfruit · 05/09/2023 16:52

I’m a saver, always have been. However, that’s easy as I’ve always been a high earner too.
Points when I’ve saved less we’re when the kids were very little.

We are extremely fortunate to have family money too.

I think people may be shocked at just how much some people have, and also how much some people don’t! This is the difference between appearing rich, and being wealthy. Impossible to tell.

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 16:52

ChevyCamaro · 05/09/2023 16:45

Thinking about it I do know a few (vey middle class) couples, in their late 40s who I know earn quite well (uni lecturers and the like) but have had their house for 20years, go on camping holidays and are always mentioning how expensive things are...I think they are the type of people posting here- they think they are broke when their current account dips below 5 k..and most of their money goes into investments and savings pots.
Whereas I think I just have a deeply embedded working class mindset and I don't think I'm broke until I'm standing in Cash Converters with a box of old phones 😂

I was booted out of home at 18 and experienced my 20s full of debt as I tried to keep my head above water as a single girl working in journalism (shit pay) in London with no safety net if it all went tit-up - so the idea of actually saving is something that's only been possible since my 30s. I didn't think I'd ever own my own house so am still quite chuffed with myself that I do. I also thought all this was normal - seems not!

OP posts:
ReadingSoManyThreads · 05/09/2023 16:51

Personally, I really love financial posts, so am drawn to these threads. I can confirm that:

  1. I am not a nepo baby
  2. Have never had a trust fund
  3. Have never been given sums of money from the bank of mum & dad, or anyone else!

I've just always grown up with a savings mentality, no idea why as my siblings are the opposite. Also, lucky that my husband and I are the same when it comes to savings and being financially responsible etc.

I promise I'm not one of the people who make shit up for entertainment and I'm not exaggerating!

There are people of all types in life, some are like me, some are like you, we're all different!

ChevyCamaro · 05/09/2023 16:47

God Barbara don't mention washing sheets, red rag to a bull!

ChevyCamaro · 05/09/2023 16:45

Thinking about it I do know a few (vey middle class) couples, in their late 40s who I know earn quite well (uni lecturers and the like) but have had their house for 20years, go on camping holidays and are always mentioning how expensive things are...I think they are the type of people posting here- they think they are broke when their current account dips below 5 k..and most of their money goes into investments and savings pots.
Whereas I think I just have a deeply embedded working class mindset and I don't think I'm broke until I'm standing in Cash Converters with a box of old phones 😂

Carebearstare12e · 05/09/2023 16:45

BarbaraofSeville · 05/09/2023 16:34

I think we should all know to never talk about money, food/drink or cleaning anything on here, lest it bring out the extreme views on all of these.

I was definitely thinking that yesterday when someone asked if people normally drunk more alcohol on holiday than they did at home and amongst all the people who said that yes they did, there was the predictable 'why would you need alcohol to enjoy your holiday' or 'I have one small glass of wine with dinner on a couple of nights, no-one needs any more than that' type comments that people can't resist posting.

Yes that's what I was getting at. The extremes. And I'm sure some people just like to be contrary.

The number of poster's who claim to have never even heard of someone doing something mundane but different to them, is astonishing. "You only wash your sheets once a week? I've never heard of anyone not washing their sheets every other day".

A stand-out a few months back was a poster who had supposedly never heard of the idea that adults sometimes give adults money in their birthday or Christmas cards. And decided it was 'immature and pathetic'.

And don't get me started on the poster's who were seemingly poleaxed by hearing some people put butter on their crackers before adding the cheese 😂

All these higher-educated, high-earning, well-travelled, middle class, sophisticated and stylish women (that is said by some to be the MN demographic) seem quite sheltered and lacking in life experience sometimes.

AperfectMess · 05/09/2023 16:40

@HideTheCroissants · Today 16:34

We have savings. TBH we have a lot of savings. I’m pretty sure most of my close friends also have decent savings but we are in our 50s, mortgage free etc.

I admire your comment, alot of people in their 50's and 60s forget the 'but.' Thank you for being real.

Bunnycat101 · 05/09/2023 16:36

I have always had budgeting pots for Christmas, insurances and big one-off purchases. I’ve done that whatever my income even as a student. We had a period where we were obsessed with pension savings and think we overdid it at the expense of the here and now. Im now in a mindset of life is for living and we’ve dropped our pension contributions down to make it easier to do nicer holidays. Probably not a financially wise decision but one I’m happy with and it feels like a better balanced life.

We’ve also become a bit more relaxed about credit. We’ve moved from saving in advance for something to actively looking for interest free deals. Have also slowly (not quite there yet) become more chilled about mortgage debt given that it’s being inflated away and we’re on a low interest deal for the next decade.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/09/2023 16:34

ChevyCamaro · 05/09/2023 16:21

I don't know why I ever open threads like this because I already knew it would be stuffed with posts saying " I'm 33 and can't sleep at night unless I know I have £200k in my savings account."
Honestly, some people I know probably have some savings. Knowing what they earn I doubt it's more than 20 k or so.
I have anything between a few k and a few hundred depending on how profligate I have been/ what has broken down.
I take my kids on holiday most years (thanks 0% purchase card) because one day it will be too late to do that and I want a life before I'm dead.
I know I will work until I am really old, and I'm happy with that. I saw how retiring at 60 shrank my mums life and I want to remain active.
I am, however, insured up the wazoo for all eventualities, so hopefully I won't end up a bag lady.

You sound a bit like me!

I also have a very secure job with a good pension - deliberately did this because I know I’m not good at “optional” saving and a pension deducted at source, with employer contributions, makes me think I’ve never had that money.

I have savings funds for the kids for Uni/ post 18 too.

BarbaraofSeville · 05/09/2023 16:34

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 16:28

I STARTED the damn thread and I knew it would be like that!

Starting to suspect the majority of people on MN are either trust fund babes or has had some serious help from the bank of mum and dad along the way. Although maybe these threads just draw out the more conscientious types and the ones who feel no guilt about using a credit card (again, nearly everyone I know) just avoid threads like this like the plague!

I think we should all know to never talk about money, food/drink or cleaning anything on here, lest it bring out the extreme views on all of these.

I was definitely thinking that yesterday when someone asked if people normally drunk more alcohol on holiday than they did at home and amongst all the people who said that yes they did, there was the predictable 'why would you need alcohol to enjoy your holiday' or 'I have one small glass of wine with dinner on a couple of nights, no-one needs any more than that' type comments that people can't resist posting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread