Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most people don't have savings?

366 replies

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 14:03

I realise this is going to get a whole range of different views and experiences and I am interested to hear them all, but I recently read some research saying that most families in the UK have less than £600 in savings. This got me wondering - I am a single mum with two teens and a mortgage, and I don't have savings as such but I do have a private pension (had it for nearly 20 years now) that I pay roughly 5% of my salary into (as well as a work pension) and I overpay on my mortgage. I consider this a more effective use of my money than saving, which I can't afford to do as well. Do most people have pensions AND savings? Or neither?

Just really curious as I spend my salary every single month and all my friends do the same. That might be just my peer group! I suppose I could save if we never went on holiday - but I'd rather have the holidays tbh. You only live once and you can't take it with you, etc etc.

OP posts:
TenSheds · 05/09/2023 18:26

There's a generational difference. Most GenX friends do have savings/security, most millennials I know don't. Domestic set-up and career are factors here too.

Personally, I have almost the recommended 3 months' salary in savings. However, as I can only save £100/month, this takes ages to build up and is quite precious. I really begrudge having to dip into it when rainy days happen. Even though notionally it's a rainy day fund, it's also there to go towards supporting DD at uni, if she needs it. DH works p/t and currently doesn't have anything spare to save. If we really needed to we could find more, but small luxuries are also important. And as fairly senior professionals with a respectable income (sub £50K), it bugs me that we should have to scrimp to save.

I find I get tied in knots about everything I am supposed to be stretching my small savings and little spare cash to cover. I should be paying off a credit card (currently on 0%, and not even a 4 figure sum, but unavoidable major renovation work coming up, so will have a scary new balance). I should put it towards said renovation costs to reduce the borrowing. I should be paying more into my pension because I started it late. I should be overpaying the mortgage while we're on a low rate fixed deal. I should be starting a pension for DD, to make up for not being able to save more for her when she was younger. I should be saving for the longer term, when DH retires, or when we need a new car, or more home maintenance. I should be prioritising self-care and me-time.

And as a PP noted, rainy days do happen, sometimes too quickly to recover from the previous one.

TheAOEAztec · 05/09/2023 18:22

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 18:06

I totally agree - I wouldn't worry about what people say they're up to on here, who knows how much is real anyway!

Talking about that I strongly suspect your OP usws Lloyds article. Lloyds said 80%of THEIR customers have less than 500 or 600 with them, not in savings general. I am one of these people. All my savings go elswehere because lloyds wouldn't match instant or near instant access rates. Theae are quite different mumbers to overall UK situation

rainbowunicorn · 05/09/2023 18:11

floribunda18 · 05/09/2023 15:48

It doesn't cost two grand to buy a new tumble dryer let alone repair one.

Nobody said that it did. PP was pointing out that they have money in an easy access account so that if something breaks it can easily be replaced or repaired without wondering where they will find the money. It could just as easily have been a boiler that needed replaced as a tumble dryer.

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 18:06

User3735 · 05/09/2023 17:58

I have no savings and no pension. According to gov statistics our household income is quite a bit above average, and yet we can't afford to save or have holidays abroad and have debt. These posts always give me massive anxiety and confusion about our budget, but I really think the demographics are way off average, and therefore pointless to ask.

I totally agree - I wouldn't worry about what people say they're up to on here, who knows how much is real anyway!

OP posts:
SmudgeButt · 05/09/2023 18:03

I have pensions which I'm trying to sort out. All work schemes so basically enforced but I knew they would be good to have so didn't argue about having them. My saving has been done via work share schemes. I didn't get the money in my bank account therefore I didn't miss it. I'm currently waiting for the stock market to recover so I can cash in about 20k shares.

And I do have significant savings but only because I can't get at them. There in another country and the only way I can move them to the UK is to go into the bank branch over there and get the money shifted to an FX account. I'm off in a couple of weeks so hopefully I'll be able to get it all done. And fix up something that I can manage from here in the future as my foreign state pension is going into that same account.

So basically I've not really done anything myself - but have been forced into having savings.

LlynTegid · 05/09/2023 18:03

The figure the OP quotes does not surprise me.

I don't drive a car, am not someone beholden to the latest stupid fashion, don't do things like 'big' birthdays (all are 24 hours long), and save drinking for when going out. That enables me to live and save some money.

dinglethedragon · 05/09/2023 18:00

WC parents instilled in me the need to have "rainy day money", save as much as you can because you will, at some point, need it. My parents refused to let me have anything from my friend's mum's Kays catalogue - you don't buy things on tick, you save and buy what you can afford. I remember them being very nervous when, as a student, I got a credit card.

The only time I didn't have savings was in my final year as a student - and it made me very nervous, I relied on my CC. I had no one to fall back on financially. I've always lived within my means since then and pay my CC off every month. I'm nearly 70 now, and still can't bring myself to waste money. My savings are my security blanket.

User3735 · 05/09/2023 17:58

I have no savings and no pension. According to gov statistics our household income is quite a bit above average, and yet we can't afford to save or have holidays abroad and have debt. These posts always give me massive anxiety and confusion about our budget, but I really think the demographics are way off average, and therefore pointless to ask.

housethatbuiltme · 05/09/2023 17:51

Applesaarenttheonlyfruit · 05/09/2023 16:52

I’m a saver, always have been. However, that’s easy as I’ve always been a high earner too.
Points when I’ve saved less we’re when the kids were very little.

We are extremely fortunate to have family money too.

I think people may be shocked at just how much some people have, and also how much some people don’t! This is the difference between appearing rich, and being wealthy. Impossible to tell.

I think thats it. Some appear rich but are never the ones that are rich. If you spend it you don't have it anymore. Very few can have their cake and eat it.

My DH for example makes more than me, but spends every penny. New phone, new car, hobbies etc... he often runs out month to month and puts things on credit then pays it with half of his next pay check and rinse and repeat.

I have more money than him that I could access right now if needed because I save it and I only buy thing second hand like a secondhand CEX phone and cheap part-ex older car.

I have the stuff I 'need' that does the same job but I have the money too because I don't care about things being the newest or best like DH does.

MelodiousThunk · 05/09/2023 17:47

Msbluebozooka · 05/09/2023 14:52

Just curious are premium bonds worth investing in ? They don’t go up in value. Also has anyone u know won on them and how much would you put in.

They’re safe, tax free and instant access. We have the maximum amount at which point you can think of it as an interest paying account as you win every month (I think in ten years there has only been one month in which I didn’t win). If you only have a small amount in them, so there is much less chance of winning, then it’s not really an attractive investment. If you want growth then an equity ISA is a better choice. But they’re fine for cash savings as long as you can save a substantial amount.

FrostieBoabby · 05/09/2023 17:47

I think it depends on what stage of life you're at. I remember scrabbling round all my pockets and down the side of the sofa as I literally had no money left until payday and desperately wanted to pay off my £2.50 overdrawn bank balance as I didn't have an authorised overdraft, this was back in the times of ridiculously high bank charges, single parent no maintenance (selfish pig), working part time and universal credit didn't exist.

Not eating for days as could only afford food for DC, ended up weighing just under 8 stone at one point when I should be around 10st. It's a wonder my kidneys didn't pack in as I was pretty much living on water to stop my stomach rumbling.

Now I'm happily married, both working full time, mortgage free and no dependent kids and I'm so lucky to have more coming in than ever goes out so can save now. I'll never get used to though and know the good times might not last forever and I think I'll always be careful with my spending even though I don't really need to be now.

rainbowunicorn · 05/09/2023 17:46

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 14:49

Not sure that works because the interest on a mortgage is a lot more than the interest on a few hundred quid in the bank - so still makes more sense to get the mortgage paid off as quickly as possible. Unless my maths is wrong.

Yeah, your maths is definitely wrong. It doesn't work like that. You would be much better putting the overpayment for the mortgage into savings or pension.

housethatbuiltme · 05/09/2023 17:43

I have savings. They where saved by myself when alone, DH has no savings and we keep finances separate (because he is crap at saving despite making over twice what I do). I have been homeless and do not want to end up back there with my kids so always have at least 6 months if all income stopped.

I don't have a pension, virtually no one in my family actually lived to pension age and I'm one of the very few left. With my genetic health issues they say I am estimated to live to 70 (decade shorter than average expectancy). Thats not including illness or injury (both of which are increased for me too) so I could easily go long before then like everyone else.

I don't have a mortgage, I saved a deposit fairly young through my savings (but struggled to get a mortgage due to low income). Then unfortunately due to losing basically all my family young I have received some inheritance over the years to feed into my saved deposit until it was enough to buy which I am aware a lot of people don't have.

Prior to that (as I saved up) I just rented, cheap non city area and stayed in 1 place for decades with the rent locked so it basically never went up.

I would go for savings every time, I want to be able to access money as needed during my whole lifespan. While I agree with saving it up there is no point locking it all away for a future you are not guaranteed.

PositiveLife · 05/09/2023 17:41

I have about 4 months of bills in savings, but in reality it would last 6 months by cutting back and with child maintenance. I'd prefer to have a bit more really but I also want to enjoy my life.

I used to overpay my mortgage but it's currently on a lower rate than my savings account so I'm mostly putting into savings now.

I have just a standard pension through work. I think it's 5% from me and 3% employer.

DeedlessIndeed · 05/09/2023 17:39

Even when I was a student and spending £10 a week on food, I still saved (albeit a tiny amount now).

I think it's just a habit to be developed, like anything else.

Having a decent cushion and not having to ever worry about money is worth forgoing a few bits here and there. But then everyone has different tolerances for risk etc.

Gettingbysomehow · 05/09/2023 17:34

I've always had savings even when I was a poor single mum. I don't waste money, if I have any money left after expenses at all I put it into savings. Even if it's £5 it all adds up.
I know a lot of people just don't have anything left after expenses now but everyone who does should save as a priority. It's really irresponsible not to do so.

GraysPapaya · 05/09/2023 17:33

We don't have a huge amount of savings right now, as we over pay on the mortgage. We have a rainy day fund, and investments, which would cover emergencies, and we keep it topped up, but we're trying to get rid of our mortgage within the next year, so we don't waste (in my opinion), putting it in savings.

Mikimoto · 05/09/2023 17:32

ellie09 · 05/09/2023 17:04

I'm a single full time working mum and I have a 35k yearly salary.

I have been lax about saving in the past and thought YOLO, ill just have that holiday or what not. I also vape, so trying to quit this very expensive habit.

Some months I can save, others I can't.

I have £1,500 in savings at the moment and a pension plan with work (and all previous jobs)

So if you get sacked on Friday, how will you pay your rent/mortgage in two months' time?

Scottishskifun · 05/09/2023 17:31

We have savings (individual and joint) but we live very cheaply day to day despite both being in professional jobs, no finance deals if we need something expensive we save for it (took us 8 years in the case of the roof!) We do go on holidays but again save for them and live frugally the rest of the time.

My DH had a number of redundancies due to industry changes and I got myself out of a lot of debt so we are now extremely careful of budgeting and savings - spreadsheets etc!

CaveMum · 05/09/2023 17:31

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 14:55

Thanks, food for thought. My mortgage advisor told me to overpay on my mortgage so I just did that.

Generally speaking @horseyhorsey17 if you can get a better rate in a savings account than the interest rate you are paying on your mortgage then you should opt to save rather than overpay your mortgage. Santander are offering an easy access saver paying 5.2% for one year right now so assuming your mortgage rate is less than that you would be far better off putting the overpayment into the savings account and then paying it off your mortgage asa lump sum when the rate ends.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 05/09/2023 17:31

DH and I have always been quite cautious, having both been made redundant in our working lives, so we've never lived up to our means. This doesn't mean that we haven't had nice holidays but we don't drive expensive cars (and buy them outright) and rather than having two weeks in the Maldives, will have city breaks in Europe. Our house is also smaller than we could have afforded in theory.

Each month I pay something into savings as soon as I get paid, so it's gone. Occasionally I have to borrow from myself, but it's quite effective. I have always saved, right from my first job when I could only afford £100 a month, but I forced myself to do it.

If I were ill/disabled tomorrow I might regret not blowing money on a trip to New Zealand, but on the other hand I might not get there anyway now with long haul flights being an eco-sin (when I was very small I went there by boat!_

ChevyCamaro · 05/09/2023 17:29

I didn't think I'd ever own my own house so am still quite chuffed with myself that I do. I also thought all this was normal - seems not!
Well, it's normal for me, and lots of my friends.We were all independent from 17/18 and lots on either frontline public sector jobs or creative freelance jobs.I was a lone parent for years and years too so there just wasn't any extra money. Or, if there was, it seemed too little to bother saving ( see not the correct mindset there!)

Hufflepods · 05/09/2023 17:27

"There’s an extraordinary number of six figure earners on MN. And somehow they find time to post extensively throughout the day … 🤔"

The higher up you are in a role, and higher in salary by default, the more control you have over your own diary. The more you earn the more you are reviewing work than doing the work so these kind of roles are going to have much more availability to be on their phone than say a lower earner working in a call centre, on a shop floor or a building site where their output is more monitored.

DarkDarkNight · 05/09/2023 17:27

I think the people I know are a pretty 50/50 split between having good private pensions, savings, ISAs, investments and people who spend everything they’ve got either because they don’t earn a lot and live from payday to payday or because they’re reckless with money.

I would love to have savings. I have had them in the past but always seem to break in to them for something or other. I actually have some at the minute but it’s spoken for for house renovations.

I did plan on overpaying my mortgage but now rates are going up I won’t be able to afford it.

hattie43 · 05/09/2023 17:19

Given your user name OP horses are the biggest hindrances to being able to save . If I hadn't had them id would be a lot wealthier .

I agree with others in that your life stage and age plays a big part in how much savings you have .

All my friends are 50's and we're all very comfortable, probably because we're on the cusp of retirement and have saved for years .
For me I have an instant access emergency fund , a big fund for 3 holidays next year inc Japan and Thailand , a huge fund for vets fees should they be needed .
My most significant sum is my pension which is sat there until I decide to retire which as I love my job I'm not sure about .
Like most I lived pay cheque to pay cheque when young but always saved something when I got paid no matter how little .
We all agreed though that our efforts were as a result of having middle class parents who always pushed aspiration into us to do well at school and drum home the need for a good job aswell as some financial guidance to make saving a habit , short term , medium term and long term , a bit for each .
I feel very lucky.