Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most people don't have savings?

366 replies

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 14:03

I realise this is going to get a whole range of different views and experiences and I am interested to hear them all, but I recently read some research saying that most families in the UK have less than £600 in savings. This got me wondering - I am a single mum with two teens and a mortgage, and I don't have savings as such but I do have a private pension (had it for nearly 20 years now) that I pay roughly 5% of my salary into (as well as a work pension) and I overpay on my mortgage. I consider this a more effective use of my money than saving, which I can't afford to do as well. Do most people have pensions AND savings? Or neither?

Just really curious as I spend my salary every single month and all my friends do the same. That might be just my peer group! I suppose I could save if we never went on holiday - but I'd rather have the holidays tbh. You only live once and you can't take it with you, etc etc.

OP posts:
DontBeATwatPlease · 07/09/2023 00:40

Could you try being a tad more judgemental please? Don't go SAVING all those awful feelings inside,keeping them to yourself. you might explode or something - then who would be scathing at the peasants?

Taxbreak · 07/09/2023 00:26

As one of the sandwich generation - paying for parents and kids - I think much of your future financial position is set by the time you're 20.
Of the three parents who have died, none have left any money and the biggest liar left a big financial mess to clear up.
If you are part of a small family with an expectation of inheritance from grandparents and other relatives, you can afford to take a lot more risks when you're young. The increasing numbers without such expectations will need to become savers early and know their worth in the job market.
My personal experience is that it's a lot harder than it should be to build up a nest egg while working PAYE - as most of us do. I get more earache from friends with million pound pension funds and hundreds of thousands in savings than I do from friends who remain potless, despite working hard.
I will probably still be working when I die, but I do have a great relationship with the offspring, some great friends and family and I smell the roses as I pass by.

NosinaBook · 07/09/2023 00:06

What about things that may need updated such as kitchen/ bathroom windows, doors or roofing? We know that we probably won't need anything major for hopefully 10 years but we have savings there and add to it each month. I'd say a home owner needs about 10k in the bank to cover upkeep, maintenance and upgrading. We upgraded the bathroom last summer so we are adding extra to our house savings to bump us back up. We only go abroad every 2 years, caravan holiday the other year and only have weekends away if we can afford it. We have a bunch of saving accounts, including one for holidays.

anotherside · 07/09/2023 00:05

It’s not in the interest of the elite for the public at large to be financially literate, re. savings/investing/current and future salary etc. The system only works when only a smallish minority know how to play it.

Calmdown14 · 07/09/2023 00:05

I have savings. Like a PP I have since my very first job at 15.
I worked alongside A levels and started uni with a few grand saved. There was no bank of mum and dad to turn to as they had no money as separating and my dad had been made redundant. You learn to budget if you have no choice.

I worked through uni and several jobs in holidays. I had a student loan I'm still paying but finished with a positive bank balance.

Bought my first flat in 2007 for 100k having saved a 20k deposit without parental help. Was renting first but moved 300 miles to a cheaper area.

Flat didn't make anything as it is not an area that's had much of a house price boom, in fact it's up now for £110k having been extensively renovated (I put in new windows, kitchen, bathroom all of which came to more than the 10k it rose by).

Moved onto a house after first child this time with husband. Where I was lucky is taking a tracker mortgage which was over 6% at the time but dropped after 2008. I carried on paying same though as I knew if I got used to a tiny mortgage the extra money would just disappear.

Have now paid off 90% of our mortgage but I've not been abroad in a decade, have never had my nails done, don't spend on haircuts, buy very few clothes. Our household income is under 50k so not big earners. My outgoings are a lot less than most.

I saw my parents have to sell the family home because we couldn't afford it. It was awful and I never wanted to be in that position so have always wanted a cushion. I couldn't enjoy things without that.

I made choices, like moving, to put myself in this position. Those same choices are still available in parts of the UK. Young people wanting to live here could buy the same flat for the same price I paid at about the same interest rate and they'd likely be on a higher wage than I was.

Itsjustmeee · 06/09/2023 23:58

I have different pots of savings
one goes from 4k -7k I dip into that as and when but I do add to it most months this is for holidays bits and pieces stuff that I don’t necessarily need but want 😂

I have around 2k in cash in a safe in the house with my passports and birth certificates

I have about 15k in a a isa
and around 35k in a savings account ( left from an inheritance )

about 2500 in my everyday bank account that rarely goes below that amount

DH has similar amounts
we have always kept our money separate we both prefer it like that

but we have no mortgage / childcare

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 06/09/2023 23:56

Moveoverdarlin · 05/09/2023 14:38

I would take what your friends say with a pinch of salt, if you are talking about finances and moaning about COL, no one is going to chirp up and say ‘yeah I’ve got a nice little nest of £100k’ but mark my words lots of them will have.

Yes!! I have a friend who is always scrimping and saving , like would only get a bus or walk never get a taxi even if it's snowing or thunderstorm etc- she recently paid off her mortgage to avoid the interest rate increase. I had always assumed she was a low earner - turns out she's a decent earner who was just very very very reluctant to spend more than she did in her student days, and saved everything!

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 06/09/2023 23:54

So I have a friend with an income of 20k per month who has no savings at all. Just spends it all every month! It's unbelievable to me that I have more savings than her and it's unbelievable to her that I can have money just sitting there when there are so manny nice things to spend it on!

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 06/09/2023 23:51

Unless your mortgage is new and on a higher rate then don't over pay!
My mortgage is 1.49% but savings accounts are 5% so much better for me to save a bit each month than to over pay (until the end of my mortgage term).

I have a pension through work and I also transfer £300 a month into my savings account which is what I use for anything big like new car or work on the car or my flat, holidays, Botox, christmas etc. also have savings account for DC. I guess if you can get into this habit then you can use savings for holiday rather than having to pay interest on credit card which makes them cost more overall.

I think people can only afford to retire young if they bought their home cheaply in the 80/90s and have paid it off long ago!

TheNightTroll · 06/09/2023 23:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ŁadnaPogoda · 06/09/2023 23:47

I’ve always saved 20-30% of my take home pay, as has DH. It was very, very tough at times, but we paid off our mortgage when we were in our 40s, invested well and now have savings in excess of £300,000. We’re about to use a big chunk of this for house renovations.

Bunny44 · 06/09/2023 23:45

@BarbaraofSeville Agree with this- it's what I'm doing as I have another 2.5 years on 1.5% whereas my ISA is almost 6% - obviously better to save!

girljulian · 06/09/2023 23:38

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/09/2023 14:39

I've always saved, even as a young child. I tend to treat savings like a bill, it goes out the day I get paid.

As well as a pension and mortgage over payments like others I have three broad categories of savings -

Long term investment - a stocks and shares ISA

Emergency savings - a cash ISA with money to be used in the event of job loss, illness and major house repair emergencies.

Slush fund to help smooth monthly expenses - so we will dip in to it for holidays, big ish ticket items (new shoes, new coat, new mobile etc..) or fun stuff.

Edited

Yes, this. I have a direct debit which goes into a savings account when I get paid. It's the only way to do it, I think. If that money was never there for you to spend, you can't spend it. Whenever I've had a pay rise I've incrementally increased the monthly amount, although admittedly for the past couple of years I've left it as it is.

emziecy · 06/09/2023 23:36

I'm originally from the UK but have lived abroad for some time. I am now a highly qualified professional but struggle every single month just to pay rent, bills and feed my family. We live in a beautiful country and I wouldn't move back to the UK, but I have literally never ever struggled so much financially as I am now, due to the huge cost of living increase, which I do appreciate is worldwide. I was much better off financially when I lived and worked as a non qualified person in the UK and was eligible for child tax credits People saying oh just put £50 a month away, I genuinely can't put anything away now. We rarely eat meat any more, even fresh fruit is a massive luxury.

Cornishclio · 06/09/2023 23:36

We have always saved. For new cars, holidays, home improvements, emergencies and extra in pensions and ISAs for early retirement. We did in fact retire at 58.

There is no magic secret to being a successful saver. We always budgeted and put money into savings when we got paid so made it as much a priority as bills and food.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 06/09/2023 23:34

We normally have savings and pension but the savings has been decimated by needing two new (to us) cars this year - both our old cars had to be replaced. Now paying back parental car loan then will save again.

LaydeeDi · 06/09/2023 23:34

Mumof2boys999 · 06/09/2023 23:02

Better to overpay the mortgage than to have instant access savings. Normally when youoverpay on the mortgage you can then have a payment break or withdraw funds if you get in a tight spot ut in the long term you are saving yourself from the interest on the mortgage.

Depends on what the rates are. The interest on my instant access savings account is quite a bit higher than my mortgage rate. If I don't need the savings, I can overpay the mortgage with a lump sum. Much easier than what you suggest.

crawfy86 · 06/09/2023 23:30

Another thought that’s worth mentioning is, you say if your boiler needed replaced you’d just put it on a credit card which is absolutely fine but what are the chances you’d ever be made redundant? How much payout would you get? We absolutely had not considered this until there were the threat of redundancies at my husbands work. He made about 10 x what I did at the time so it was a massive stress and hadn’t been at the company long so the payout wouldn’t have sustained us for long. We saved harder after that!

LaydeeDi · 06/09/2023 23:30

Going by the recent thread on the man who feels skint on 65K, no. People are saying I'm decadent for saving £500 towards emergencies. I'm the sole earner and mortgage payer. If I can't pay for emergency repairs, they can't get done. I would not feel secure at all if I couldn't save anything. I wouldn't be able to enjoy things like holidays or takeaways or clothes knowing that if something went wrong, I'd be screwed. I grew up in poverty and was determined not to ever put my children in the same position.

I've sacrificed so much in my pursuit of financial stability, including having children at all. It's really odd to me that the majority of those telling me I'm so privileged have children. No hint of irony. No hint of self awareness that if they hadn't had the children, they could afford to save as much as I do and have spent more time working.

Very odd.

Oli529 · 06/09/2023 23:26

I can’t imagine not having savings!
If you’re earning, put some away for future use then you’ll never be in the awful situation of not having enough for something that you need now.
Eating out and takeaways are not necessary. Having savings for a rainy day are.
There will be countless times in the next years or decades when you need money and those takeaways you ate won’t help you then!

I’ve saved since late teens and never spent my whole wage even when it was tiny. Over the years I’ve grown enough nest egg to not have to worry. Better to wait to “treat myself” to eg a new pair of boots or a weekend away or a better car in a few months or years when doing so will still leave money in the bank.

When our income was smaller we scrimped and saved. Clothes from charity shops and only if really needed. Holidays camping. No eating out. No cinema trips. Cheap second hand phones and bicycles. Second hand toys. We had oodles of fun! So much can be done for free. Walk in the park and play board games bought in a charity shop. Play charades and bounce a tennis ball around the garden. Buy fruit from a market and make art from it then eat it. Libraries! Free museums! All low cost and just as enjoyable as buying into the consumerism trap.

Now after decades of that attitude we’re really well off.
I really can’t imagine spending it all as soon as it’s in the bank. Seems mad to me!

mummyp1310 · 06/09/2023 23:22

We don’t have any savings, hubby is a good earner circa £63000 p/a and I have just started a new job at a moderate pay, although we don’t have savings we change our mortgage when the fixed rate is up and cut years off our mortgage every time, so although no physical savings in no time we will be mortgage free which will then allow is to save.

crawfy86 · 06/09/2023 23:20

This is really difficult to answer because there are so many variables? Most obvious being how much money you make vs how much you have to spend on bills etc.

my level of saving has varied throughout my life. When I got my first job at 14 I started saving because I wanted to go to uni and my parents had no money.

then I saved up for my first mortgage etc. at that stage holidays etc we’re minimal. We saved by putting what was left at the end of each month into a savings account (sometimes £20 or similar). Now that we’re older and have more healthy incomes and our outgoings are pretty stable we decide how much we want to save and put it into savings at the start of the month. Some goes into instant access and some into places that we can’t access until much further down the line.

Overpaying your mortgage and having a private pension IS saving as if you needed to do a big house repair you could take from your mortgage if needs be.

That said, it sounds like you’re not living on the breadline and I do think if I was you I’d find life so much more comfy if I was sitting on even a smallish pile of instant access cash, just in case. Maybe you miss the foreign holiday one year and put the few thousand that you saved into a savings account and that becomes your new minimum?! It’s obviously personal choice and if you’re happy sitting without the savings then there’s nothing wrong with that!

Highandlows · 06/09/2023 23:16

I am like Floribunda. Holidays are so enriching and priceless memories with my family. They come first but still have a small safety net for emergencies.

Mumof2boys999 · 06/09/2023 23:02

Better to overpay the mortgage than to have instant access savings. Normally when youoverpay on the mortgage you can then have a payment break or withdraw funds if you get in a tight spot ut in the long term you are saving yourself from the interest on the mortgage.

Radioshark · 06/09/2023 22:54

I had very little saving when I had a mortgage to pay. Now I am getting old and have savings but with the cost of living I am having to dip into it. The cost of a funeral etc. is a lot so older folk need to have enough for when that day happen so that the family don't have to pay for it. Property rich, money poor that is me.