Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most people don't have savings?

366 replies

horseyhorsey17 · 05/09/2023 14:03

I realise this is going to get a whole range of different views and experiences and I am interested to hear them all, but I recently read some research saying that most families in the UK have less than £600 in savings. This got me wondering - I am a single mum with two teens and a mortgage, and I don't have savings as such but I do have a private pension (had it for nearly 20 years now) that I pay roughly 5% of my salary into (as well as a work pension) and I overpay on my mortgage. I consider this a more effective use of my money than saving, which I can't afford to do as well. Do most people have pensions AND savings? Or neither?

Just really curious as I spend my salary every single month and all my friends do the same. That might be just my peer group! I suppose I could save if we never went on holiday - but I'd rather have the holidays tbh. You only live once and you can't take it with you, etc etc.

OP posts:
LaydeeDi · 08/09/2023 12:46

OhamIreally · 08/09/2023 12:25

I think whether or not you stay married is key to your financial landscape.

There's lots of "we have this" and "we have that" but if you end up getting divorced it all has to be split.

I have some savings, pension, 5 years to go on the mortgage and do go on a lot of holidays but if my ex hadn't thrown in the towel we would have paid off the mortgage and been retired by now.

He was a terrible saver though.

Also, marrying the right person. Generally, two incomes are far better than one, and being single is ridiculously expensive (I'd have at least an extra £1000 a month in disposable income just from splitting my mortgage and bills), but someone who is bad with money can ruin your own financial stabiity. My friend's partner is dreadful. He pisses away money on absolutely nothing - crap like several takeaways a week, pints after work multiple days a week, new trainers he doesn't need, going to the expensive corner shop because he can't be arsed going to Tescos - and then he'll tell her they're broke and they can't afford a holiday. The poor woman hasn't had a holiday in five years, even though as a household they earn far more than me and have similar expenses. She'd be better off single.

LaydeeDi · 08/09/2023 12:42

Nina1013 · 08/09/2023 10:59

We have no savings, we have decent ish pensions, equity in the house, and high earnings (albeit we do manage to spend everything every month….). We spent around £3k a month on a mix of holidays, weekends away, eating out, all sorts. So if we had something like a boiler, would just spend less that month.

We have private school fees which stop when uni starts so no need to save for that, as we will just swap one expense for another.

We absolutely should be more financially responsible however we had the kids very young and my stance is I’ll save when they’re grown up, we will still be under 40 at that point and until then I want to enjoy their childhoods to the full….

Are you not worried about one or both of you getting sick and not being able to earn or do you have good insurance for things like that?

OhamIreally · 08/09/2023 12:25

I think whether or not you stay married is key to your financial landscape.

There's lots of "we have this" and "we have that" but if you end up getting divorced it all has to be split.

I have some savings, pension, 5 years to go on the mortgage and do go on a lot of holidays but if my ex hadn't thrown in the towel we would have paid off the mortgage and been retired by now.

He was a terrible saver though.

Nina1013 · 08/09/2023 10:59

We have no savings, we have decent ish pensions, equity in the house, and high earnings (albeit we do manage to spend everything every month….). We spent around £3k a month on a mix of holidays, weekends away, eating out, all sorts. So if we had something like a boiler, would just spend less that month.

We have private school fees which stop when uni starts so no need to save for that, as we will just swap one expense for another.

We absolutely should be more financially responsible however we had the kids very young and my stance is I’ll save when they’re grown up, we will still be under 40 at that point and until then I want to enjoy their childhoods to the full….

Singlespies · 08/09/2023 10:24

I overpay my mortgage and pay large pension contributions because I like to see growth and get tax back.

I don't save into a traditional account. I have never been out of work so think it is unlikely I will need a few months salary.

House repairs are covered by a large sinking fund (I live in a flat and manage the freehold).

I assume that if I need money for something I will just spend a few months not overpaying mortgage or pension and quickly save some money.

This has worked for last 25 years! May not last forever.

shivawn · 08/09/2023 08:18

I save a lot every month and I have a public service pension but also pay into a private pension because I plan to retire at 60.

I don't overpay on my mortgage but my housing costs are low enough to feel insignificant at €515 a month and I live in Ireland so there's no large council tax bills to worry about on top of that. We bought our house in 2016 when it was worth less than half of what it is today. If I was still renting or trying to buy today in the middle of a major housing crisis I'd be in a much much worse position, just luck really.

Also we don't have childcare costs because my husband and I work different hours and grandparents child mind for free (at their insurance) on the days we overlap. Again, just lucky. If we had big mortgage repayments and childcare bills we'd probably save far less.

Muthaofcats · 08/09/2023 05:46

You’re a single mother with a mortgage, pension and kids and still able to manage on your own and go on summer holidays! I’d say you’re rocking it !

Cluelessat33 · 07/09/2023 21:39

I'm a single Mum. I save probably obsessively. I have a low income, but have set up several savings accounts for different things; 'oh shit', holidays, Christmas and birthdays, school stuff for my daughter, home stuff, daughters isa. I put £5-10 each in these per week, and have done for years. I also have 6k which came from the sale of my marital home when we separated. It was money I didn't realise I would get above what I'd accounted for, for the deposit on my home. It's in the 'absolutely never touch' pile, until my mortgage comes up for renewal, and I will add it to my deposit. In the meantime it sits in a savings account.

Since day one on my own, saving was a must and I cut all other spending to the absolute minimum. I have nobody else to ask for financial help I'd never countenance asking my parents for help if I needed to pay for repairs in my car.... so I've saved like a daemon. I've also skimmed off of my current account at the end of the month, if I've had anything left, have been paid a bonus, or overtime etc, and that has always gone straight into savings. I'm getting a pay rise this month and have set up a direct debit to take that amount straight into savings. I can't miss it if I didn't have it.

TeamGeriatric · 07/09/2023 20:23

Sounds like you are doing an amazing job financially and you are definitely saving. We are a dual income household and we both have roles that pay reasonably well, which clearly makes the financial situation easier. My husband is the primary breadwinner in our house, his earnings cover food, rent, utilities, running the car, uniform, clothes, extra curricular activities for the kids. I work less and do more of the childcare, but still have a role that pays well, 15% of my income goes into a pension, the rest is either saved or spent on luxury things like holidays. We travel quite a lot, it's a high priority for me and I would say are pretty frugal when it comes to other spending, the car is > 10 years old with no plans to change it. We are renting in the UK but have a house overseas we bought 13 years ago, and the tennant's are (slowly) paying off that mortgage. Our savings were bolstered by money I was left by my grandparents when they passed away. We are definitely very fortunate.

Lottiebe · 07/09/2023 16:27

I have to say you are doing really well. You ARE saving. You are paying extra on your mortgage, into a work pension AND savings for your kids. Honestly you are smashing it. On top of that you are having life fun too with your kids, they are only young once and you are making the most of that plus savings in the ways that you are. Well done you.

Lalalalala555 · 07/09/2023 15:40

Personally I try and save a lot of my income.
But that's because I rent and I'm hoping that things in life will come my way one day.

I live in a flat with the cheapest rent so u can save more.
I save towards a house deposit, I save towards my pension, I save for an emergency fund (which is there incase anything bad happens as a cushion).

I save towards other things like holidays and gifts, but this goes. Because I spend it so I don't see it as saving in the same way.

I spend my income in rent, then bills and food, and allow a buffer for life incidentals and a bit of shopping/weekend money.

But i dont have a car yet, I don't have kids, I'm not engaged, and I don't own a house. I'd like all those things one day. Plus a cat. So I'm just trying to save a good amount towards those. Hoping that they'll be a possibility.
I would also like to go on a long hike some time, and take a month or two off work to have an adventure. So that's saving up for as well.

I'm quite 'behind for my age'. As I had a lot of illness in my 20s. So I am trying to compensate for missed income. I would have been able to reach my goals more gradually had I been working for longer. But instead it's quite an aggressive approach I'm taking so that I hopefully don't run out of time.

If you've already got kids, car, house, marriage, good credit score. I imagine you'd want savings incase you lost your job or became Ill. Or something in the house needed fixing. But then people get loans. I don't know.

I find it comforting to have a bit of savings so I know if shit hits the fan, I've got my own back.

Katela18 · 07/09/2023 13:03

We have a small savings pot (circa 5k) and we add 200 pm in.
We have workplace pensions each and 1 private pension.
We have another pot which I put money into across the year to help with bdays and Christmas.

We can't really afford holidays atm and use our salaries every month - however we do currently spend £1200 pm on nursery so once both children are in school hopefully things will improve! I think we would up the amount we put into savings, and start to over pay on mortgage

Onceuponatime56 · 07/09/2023 10:46

I have a small amount of savings which we can’t add to at the moment due to cost of living. I also save child benefit separately but this is to go towards bigger costs such as new car seat, clothes or school trips.
Ideally I would like a small amount in short term savings and a larger one in an ISA. Plus some premium bonds

BoredZelda · 07/09/2023 10:37

I suppose I could save if we never went on holiday - but I'd rather have the holidays tbh. You only live once and you can't take it with you, etc etc.

I have an elderly relative who lived like this with her husband. She is now widowed, living on a basic state pension in sheltered housing paid for by her children (who, as a result, can't save for their futures) She has said with hindsight she wishes she had foregone some of the spending and planned better for the future.

UsernameNotAvailableArghh · 07/09/2023 10:32

I’m single and under 50, self sufficient kids. I have tiers of savings, a years rainy day salary in accessible accounts, full premium bond holding, 2 houses 1 of which provides a modest rental income and seven figures invested in a pension. No debt or mortgages and very minimal outgoings ie £400pm

Oli529 · 07/09/2023 10:28

I think not having savings but spending on luxuries (takeaways, holidays, new clothes, Netflix, new furnishings) is like building a house and buying expensive furniture before you have installed windows!
I know the cost of living is tough right now but that';s even more reason to "scrimp and save" so there is always a cushion to fall back on.
I recommend making a budget:
page 1 - total net income.
page 2 vital unavoidable expenses eg rent, heating, food, transport to work (and look to see can this be pared down at all).
page 3 disposable income - then categorise that into eg clothing for adults, clothing for children, shoes for children, toiletries, replacing household goods, car repairs/insurance/tax.

Monzo savings app has "pots" you can use to allocate your income into these sorts of categories. Then you will not mistakenly spend on luxuries things that you might need next month for vitals like bigger shoes for children, or sanitary towels 😂. This method also helps us see where we are actually spending, and where we can cut back. And you can make a pot where as soon as you are paid, x amount goes straight into car repair pot, y amount goes straight into children's clothes/hoes account, and z amount goes into rainy day fund. If you can't keep those pot topped up then buying takeaways and holidays seems a bit risky.

IDK if you have children, but they get more expensive as they grow. Little ones need nappies and toys and endlessly bigger shoes. But young adult offspring need much more pricey things like driving lessons, cars, university fees, rent, house deposits, and weddings - (weddings are another topic entirely it can be done for £3K we did it!)! Would you not like to be gradually building up a pot to help them with those things?

Our modern culture tricks us into confusing necessities with luxuries, because there is profit to be made by selling us dreams like new cushions and earrings, and no profit to be made by telling us to go for a country walk and take a picnic. Life can be cheaper than we think.

Ways to save on necessities:

Potatoes, rice, onions, beans and spices bought in bulk.
Cook from scratch using what's on offer.
Drink only tap water or tea. Really, this can save £££s.
How many outfits do we really need?
Invite friends for baked potatoes in our home instead of an evening out. Instead of a Netflix account, play charades or fishbowl, read library books.

I don't think I ever bought new furniture except beds and mattresses, and my home is beautiful - second hand can be gorgeous and environmentally healthy too!
I do spend more on footwear and waterproof coats because these make for comfort and wellbeing. And I do buy new underwear and PJs, but for years everything else was second hand and really cool! As well as environmentally responsible.

It really can be truly rewarding to live like that. We did for about ten years, then as savings grew and salary grew, we gradually became more financially secure and NOW can enjoy more luxuries - with some left for the future too - than we would have had we spent it as soon as it came in.

sorry it is so long winded.

AffIt · 07/09/2023 10:25

KnittedJimmyChoos · 06/09/2023 21:13

@AffIt

What interest on bonds

5.5% with Bank of Scotland, which was the best available. I believe Skipton are offering 6.2% to current account holders.

Kanelsnegl · 07/09/2023 09:54

I don't think it's an age thing. I'm late 20s and have always had savings and prioritised it above most other things. The amount goes up and down as it depends. A year and a half ago for example my cat got cancer, and while my insurance covered most, due to the type of the cancer it took a lot of time and specialists to even diagnose it and not all was covered which took a huge chunk of my savings.
Monthly I save at least 200 into my help to buy a month, currently pregnant so also saving 300 a month for a maternity leave buffer that my husband saves a decent chunk into too. Then I have various other pots for smaller things like a gift savings so Christmas is less daunting, extra payments for my student loan (not UK so won't be written off and overpayment make sense), a general for smaller emergencies and a small S&S that I add to as and when I can with the view I'll spend it in 10 or 20 years on something great or just add it to retirement. Oh and I pay into my NHS pension and have paid into a pension since I was 18.

I grew up poor (my dad once stole a chicken for food. Good thing my mum grew up in the country and knew what to do with it, cause he certainly didnt). And while they never made it our problem I've always been desperate to not feel financially very insecure and not having any savings would keep me up at night and I generally stress and worry a lot about it. I definitely don't have a healthy mindset to money but it has come in handy in the past.

whatkatydid2013 · 07/09/2023 06:32

I have a final salary pension and put 5% of my gross pay into a share based savings scheme. I’ve done it for the past 20 years and never withdrawn from it. At this point its value is a little over 3 times my contributions and it’s enough to cover both mine and my partners net pay for a full year. It’s the pot we will use if there is a really expensive emergency or (hopefully) towards extra funds in retirement. That aside we tend to put about 10% of our net pay away split between shorter term savings for more expensive months (when we have holidays/Christmas) and mid term ones for bigger house repairs/ improvements and similar. In the past when my partner had bonuses we saved those to use towards a deposit when moving home. We have had money we’ve inherited in the past and that’s tended to be spent on bringing forward home improvement projects. In general I think if you have the money to make choices about saving vs spending there is a happy medium. I wouldn’t have wanted to scrimp all through my 20s/30s to be mortgage free or close to it now. I get why other people want to but for me it’s always in my mind that you never know how long you have and so you want some of those experiences now. Equally I wouldn’t spend every penny I earned unless there was no choice as I’d feel uncomfortable not knowing how we could cover an unexpected bill. Everyone has a different level where they feel comfortable and think you just need to stick to yours and not worry too much what others do by comparison

MixedCouple · 07/09/2023 06:19

My Dad has a private pension and regretted it the Tax goes up yearly and he barely gets anything from it now. He wishes he invested in Gold or just Plain old Savings!!!

Despite the tiny amount he receives he gets a lot of issues while trying to seek help as theynsay to him you have 2 pensions..they look at Gross and not after Tax. Which is what matters. It infuriates me.

I do not have Private. I have savings and invest in other things to use later.

pompomdaisy · 07/09/2023 06:14

I have £21 k in one pot I never touch, I lose my bonus interest if I access that but it pays about £70 a month interest and then I try to keep a instant access savings account of £5k for stuff I might need. I also have 4 defined benefit pensions and a defined contribution pension pot which I pay into.

BarbaraofSeville · 07/09/2023 06:06

We all agreed though that our efforts were as a result of having middle class parents who always pushed aspiration into us to do well at school and drum home the need for a good job aswell as some financial guidance to make saving a habit , short term , medium term and long term , a bit for each

Can we please stop with the nonsense view that financial prudence and valuing education is unique to the middle classes?

I'm as working class they come (all older male relatives were miners, the women did bits of cleaning, or worked in a pub or fish and chip shop round their DHs shifts) and that was all exactly the same for people like us.

On the matter of 'saving should be taught I schools', are they not using the financial education text book that Martin Lewis wrote and made freely available?

If not,anyone can download it themselves and learn with their DC at home.

Rockmehardplace · 07/09/2023 01:25

I pay into savings every month by direct debit, once my “general” savings (which is dipped into to cover new household appliances/boiler etc if needed) reaches a certain point the excess goes into my ISA as longer term savings.

I don’t have tens of thousands saved but I am just about to go full time after several years of maternity/part time work round young children/I’ll health so hoping to really focus on saving now.

several years ago I had an operation. There were complications and I went into a coma for 3 months. I was still getting paid (part time wages) but had taken my card into the hospital with me and no-one could access my account. DP had to take 5 months off work (only 1 of which was paid) to look after our young children. We had only just bought our home and had no savings as everything had been ploughed into that. It was a horrific time in general and that was without me being aware that we very nearly lost the house. Since then, I would always ALWAYS prioritise having a certain level of savings even above a holiday etc.

NinaPip1 · 07/09/2023 00:47

My husband and I put 20% into pensions (gross pay), 25% of net pay into savings (which goes straight into savings on the days we are paid), and double pay our mortgage. We have to make quite large sacrifices to do this though, such as holidays, rarely eating out etc. We also do not have children (yet), so that makes things easier.

We bought our first home around 9 months ago, and there were many issues that were not expected (e.g. 18 new electric storage heaters needed, repointing roof; on top of things we knew, such as needing new windows for the whole house and needing a new woodburner.) Unfortunately that meant our savings were decimated (and likely will continue to be for sometime), hence the aggressive saving/paying down the mortgage.

DontBeATwatPlease · 07/09/2023 00:41

Why didn't that quote the judgemental prick I wanted to respond to?