Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS doesn't want to go to uni after break-up

39 replies

Frecko · 05/09/2023 12:58

DS was in a relationship for a little over a year, she was a nice enough girl but he was definitely more into her than she was him. She had a lot of friends and was very likeable, conventionally attractive, basically she could have whoever she wanted and that just happened to be DS for a bit.
DS applied to the same unis as her, I really discouraged this. He didn't get into the first two, made the 3rd his firm choice as it was in the same city as her but I don't think he actually liked the uni. His insurance was the same as hers and local to home.
He got his exam results a couple weeks back and didn't get into the uni he had picked. His girlfriend had done ridiculously well in her exams so he was feeling a bit down about that, accepted his insurance choice not far from home.
On the Monday so barely a few days later, she broke up with him! Said she didn't want to do long distance, my son felt like it was another punishment for his exam results and has been devastated since.
It doesn't help that (according my DD) he still follows his ex on instagram and she's been off on holiday, posting pics looking happy as can be. DD also claims that there is a rumour she has slept with one of DS's friends since the break up. So DS is truly not doing well.

He is now saying he doesn't want to go to uni this year, wants to take a gap year, figure out what he wants, reapply to unis knowing his results (it was his maths grade that failed him a little, but he could get into other good unis for different non-maths related courses as he has A*ABC (B and C in maths and further maths)).

I think he should at-least try this uni, he likes the uni and it's still a good one!! I think if this girl hadn't broken up with him he wouldn't be thinking twice about it. I think it is awful the way she has gone about this but he needs to prove that he isn't just soppy and sad !!

AIBU to encourage him to still go to uni this year? Or should he wait and start next year?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
poetryandwine · 05/09/2023 16:37

Another university lecturer (and former admissions tutor here). I agree 100% with @Toobusytowee

Students who begin university without commitment and/or with unresolved issues usually cannot engage properly. They fall behind; they become isolated academically and socially; things spiral. These students are vulnerable to mental health problems.

With A star A B your DS will easily be able to secure an Unconditional offer once he works out what he wants to study and applies to appropriate degree programmes. He needs a good degree to have the best employment chances and he is much more likely to attain that when he is in the right programme. Please give him the time and space to work out what that is.

NerrSnerr · 05/09/2023 16:00

I think it is awful the way she has gone about this but he needs to prove that he isn't just soppy and sad !!

Would you have preferred that she stayed with him and lead him on even though she didn't want to be in a relationship? It would have been much worse if he followed her to university and she dumped him after a month.

He's 18- he's going to be sad his first relationship has broken up. That's ok- he doesn't have to pretend it's not because he's a man.

Zaaarrr · 05/09/2023 15:07

I think he should at-least try this uni, he likes the uni and it's still a good one!!

If he 'just tries' it he will still have to pay the £9000 fees and will have to pay for accommodation for the whole year if he doesn't live at home. It's not like ordering breaded mushrooms to just try. He needs to want to do it.

Aquamarine1029 · 05/09/2023 15:06

I think if this girl hadn't broken up with him he wouldn't be thinking twice about it. I think it is awful the way she has gone about this but he needs to prove that he isn't just soppy and sad !!

What a load of misogynist bullshit. It's this girl's fault your son can't deal with disappointment? She was perfectly entitled to end their relationship anytime she wanted to. He needs to buck up and deal with life.

Autieangel · 05/09/2023 15:05

Of course he is sad did you not have a first love? He's also grieving the life he had planned. Don't dismiss that as insignificant. A gap year isn't a bad thing necessarily but ultimately it's up to him. Try to be supportive and understanding

HectorSalamanca · 05/09/2023 15:04

The poor girl, who did absolutely the right thing. Is getting a bit of stick on here.

she dated a teenager for a year, didn't treat him bad, but unfortunately, did 'ridiculously well' in her exams and is 'conventionally beautiful' (stated as though they are bad things)

She dumped her boyfriend BEFORE going to uni (sensible) and maybe did or didn't shag her ex's mate, when she was single.

She's 17/18. Like nobody else done anything daft at that age🤔.

OP, I think it's a great idea for your sone to have a gap year. It will do him the world of good. Especially if he goes travelling

HardcoreLadyType · 05/09/2023 15:01

It may seem very harsh, but I think your DS’s ex has done the right thing. I cannot think of a single school relationship which has lasted after the couple went in their separate directions to university.

Your DC’s maths results are not his ex’s fault, even though with her having such stellar results it seems like adding insult to injury, just at the moment.

A gap year is not a bad idea, if he has a plan. Even just working and getting some money and experience behind him would be good. Or volunteering in an area around what he wants to study. Or improving his maths grade. Obviously, not navel gazing for a year, though!

It is hard for him just now, and you are worried about him, but he will be fine.

Lydiala · 05/09/2023 14:59

Student finance eligibility is not unlimited - you’re only entitled to a certain number of years.

If he starts a degree he is unsure about and then drops out, he will have permanently used up one of his years. It’s not something I would be encouraging.

yogasaurus · 05/09/2023 14:56

Cosyblankets · 05/09/2023 14:14

I think it is awful the way she has gone about this

What way would you like her to have gone about this?

err, this. What on earth has she done wrong?

Toobusytowee · 05/09/2023 14:52

Hi, university lecturer here. If he isn’t 100% into the course and his choice of uni, he should not go. The demands of the course, moving away from home and trying to grow up are all quite stressful anyway, even if he did my have the complication of a relationship breakdown.

If he isn’t completely committed, he will limp on for a bit and then start failing. If he gives it a go and then fails, it will be harder for him to then re-evaluate and change course. It is better he stops now and has a really good think about what he wants to do.

I have had many students that are on a course because that was just what was expected of them or their parents encouraged them onto the course. Students have to be completely behind this kind of commitment they are making.

Starsnspikes · 05/09/2023 14:43

My boyfriend and I broke up a week or two before uni started, having chosen the same place and even moved in together. It was a fucking disaster, of course my parents saw it coming but they knew I had to make my own mistakes.

I couldn't face uni, thankfully they let me defer and I took a year out. It was the best decision ever, I travelled for a bit and then worked, and when I started the following year I felt truly ready for it. I know it might seem like he's making a rash decision but this could lead him down an equally great path. As hard as it is, I think you have to let him make his own decision and support him either way.

TotalOverhaul · 05/09/2023 14:39

I would listen to him. What's the point in racking up huge debts at a uni he isn't certain he wants to go to, especially if it's the new uni in a town where his ex with the stellar exam results is at the Russell Group? That would just exacerbate his feeling of being second best. And he might see her around with a new man.

Taking a year out to reassess his options and maybe aim for a course or place more suited to him is a really mature idea. Better than going somewhere he isn't excited about, feeling low about his girlfriend and then starting to feel down.

Going to uni should be something you feel great and excited about. He needs time to get over his relationship and to figure out exactly what uni course he wants to take. Sit down with him and work out a few possible plans for a gap year. Exciting stuff that he genuinely looks forward to. Maybe finding a job locally until after Christmas and then working abroad for a while or going travelling for fun. Passing his driving test if he hasn't already. Getting the next music grade on an instrument. Or doing some free online courses related to his uni subject which might impress a uni he is borderline on getting into. Maybe coaching a local sports team or volunteering at his old school.He could save up some money for when he's a student. Check out some other uni towns and courses by visiting their open days.

i have never understood the need to sausage factory our kids straight from school to uni, especially those who have missed some social development due to covid restrictions. A gap year is a great idea.

ButterflyOil · 05/09/2023 14:23

Also try not to fall into the trap of thinking oh he hair needs to get on with it and dismiss his feelings. People so often so that with teens and their first heartbreak but it can be so so painful, not least because you’ve never experienced it before, so don’t know you can recover. First heartbreak is awful so try and take it seriously. Not saying he should be allowed to do nothing all year of course, but let him breathe a bit and not rush into making more decisions about uni.

Uni will be there next year and loads of people take gap years - it can actually work in their favour if they can save money and have an extra year to mature.

Cosyblankets · 05/09/2023 14:14

I think it is awful the way she has gone about this

What way would you like her to have gone about this?

itsmyp4rty · 05/09/2023 14:07

I think it would be a bad idea to go to a university he's not that interested in. It would also be a bad idea to take a gap year and do nothing with it.

I think you need to sit down with him, show him some empathy towards his relationship situation, tell him you know what it's like because you remember being that age (and who broke your heart). Then talk to him about taking a year out, what's he think he's going to do, work? travel? volunteer? Talk about why he doesn't want to go to uni, where he might apply next year and just get him to remember he does have a future and it has lots of options! Maybe take a look at the workaway website, it has a lot of opportunities all over the world.

JustMarriedBecca · 05/09/2023 14:01

6 months in a bar job earning money and making friends. Then 6 months travelling and having a brilliant time. Come back and start University then.

Doesn't sound like he's committed to his course and I think it's sensible. Maths is HARD and if that's the struggle, better to change subjects now and reapply again knowing his strengths.

villamariavintrapp · 05/09/2023 13:54

I think a gap year sounds good, let him mature a bit. Picking uni based on a relationship at age 17ish was a bit silly, but this is a good opportunity to get to know himself a bit and find out what he wants to do in life.

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 05/09/2023 13:52

Gap year OK if he's no longer sure about the course or the university, but he must get a job, not spend the time moping around. Any job for now, he can always move on in a few months if he finds something he likes better.

Did he have a summer job he could stay on at?

YellowDots · 05/09/2023 13:52

I think he should take the GAP year because he's screwed up picking universities that he should not have picked. There is no point getting into £60,000 of debt doing something you don't want to do.

What's he going to do in this gap year if he takes it? Travel round Australia or play call of duty? That is what I would want to know. I think he will feel very left behind if he just gets an ordinary job.

Duckingella · 05/09/2023 13:47

I think the girlfriend would have ditched him anyway;the long distance thing was just a get out outta jail free card.

He should go university;he'll meet new people;expecting his GF to stay with him was the reali

JC89 · 05/09/2023 13:40

YABU, he's having second thoughts about his degree choice and he hasn't started yet - much better to work out what he wants to do before starting (uni is seriously expensive - how much will "just try this uni and course" cost him? £15,000 for a year? More?)

Agree with PP suggesting getting a job (or volunteering to build up skills if money is not important), maybe travelling... He knows more now, knows what grades he has so might look at different degree options now the situation has changed. Or apprenticeships / degree apprenticeships can also be good. Deferring uni for a year is not unusual, particularly when circumstances (such as A Level results) change.

Mirabai · 05/09/2023 13:37

I think he should do what he likes. So if he wants a gap year and reapply to a different uni that’s what he should do.

Might he want to retake his maths? It can be done in 6 months now.

waterrat · 05/09/2023 13:30

And agree that you are wrong to say 'it's awful how she has gone about this' - she is an 18 year old who ended a relationship - she has done nothing wrong. Even if she could/ should have thought about this before he made his uni choices - she is just naive like he was. L

Encourage your son to accept this is healthy and natural if her feelings were not strong enough so he can move on with dignity. Do not encourage anger in him.

waterrat · 05/09/2023 13:29

he should 100 per cent NOT make any decision based on proving something to her! tthat is terrible advice.

Let's look at the facts here - he made what sounds like crap choices for his university based on a girlfriend (as you say not wise ) -

He has broken up with her - so why not let him make some better choices?

take a year off, work, relax, make some new friends, find a new girl ! Go travelling?

Can you try and talk calmly to him? Does he now see that he made shit choices and regrets it? Why should he go to a uni he doesn't want just because he was loveblind

What would be kind to impress on him is that it's absolutely natural that they broke up - of course they did they are young! While his heart is broken, he needs to take a deep breath, stop following her on insta (easier said than done) and make his own decisions for once.

There is a bit of a feeling in your post OP that suggests she is not being kind? She has every right to break up with him - for whatever reason she wants - it probably has absolutely nothing to do with exam results but you know what - if she is super bright and hard working and that just isn't him - she probably is likely to look elsewhere in life.

But please don't encourage him to feel angry/ pissed off with her - it's natural at their age and at Uni time for relationships to break up. He is naturally going to have anger and sadness but you don't need to reiterate that to him.

WaltzingWaters · 05/09/2023 13:28

If he’s not sure what he wants to do and his head and heart aren’t in it right now, a gap year sounds like a great idea (provided he doesn’t use that time just sitting around gaming or something equally useless).
Let him work, gain some money. Go travelling for a while. Then maybe in that time he’ll figure out exactly what he wants to do and won’t waste time studying for the wrong course or just studying when he’s not got his head in the right place.

Swipe left for the next trending thread