Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘Why did you have a baby with him?’

314 replies

Iftheydonlygetashifton · 05/09/2023 10:29

Inspired by the numerous threads on MN where the OP is in a very tough situation with kids and an abusive partner, and the responses run ‘why on Earth did you choose to have children with him? You were with him for 3 years before children’ … etc etc. My thoughts are:

a) the OP isn’t omniscient;
b) many relationships change after having kids. Often having kids exposes men to be man-children. Hence, all the single mums out there and the many fewer single dads. And the mental burden disproportionately borne by women in hetero relationships even if both do paid work FT, etc.
c) Give the OP a break.

YABU - people don’t change substantially after having kids therefore it’s on the OP if they chose a wrong un.
YANBU - people can change after kids, relationships deteriorate, we should lay off a pile-on and give practical advice and moral support.

thanks

OP posts:
TheEponymousGrub · 07/09/2023 15:38

It's just a way to score points off the OP.

TheEponymousGrub · 07/09/2023 15:37

Even if all the signs were there, and OP wilfully ignored them; even if she deliberately made stupid decisions; that only means - worst case - that OP is an idiot. It doesn't mean that she and her children doesn't deserve help!

"Why did you (etc)" really means "There is strong evidence you are an idiot." Nobody writes that because they can't pretend it's words of wisdom. But it's just exactly as mean and unhelpful.

howmanytimes34 · 07/09/2023 15:19

@Cantstaystuckforever @Didsomeonesaydogs

Both your posts resonate so strongly with me - I am glad to see you have got out of your respective relationships.

I am currently trying to extricate myself from my marriage. I can't quite bring myself to use the word abusive yet.

But the support I am getting is helping me to see that what I have normalised is pretty close to abuse.

Someone saying to me 'why did you have kids with him?' would categorically not be helpful . What would it achieve? Would they feel better to have me flagellate myself in front of them?

Believe me, I feel guilt ridden and full of intense regret as it is.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 13:11

You have no idea of what experiences I have of relationships and it is insulting for you to claim you do. If you don't like my perspective, then feel free to scroll on past and not quote me.

If you have had an abusive relationship, it's even more shocking that you have posted such inaccurate information.

It's insulting that you are so unprepared to hear others viewpoints who have lived experience oh abuse.

And it's a forum - replying to others is literally how it works. HTH

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 13:09

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/09/2023 11:19

It’s quite telling that not a single poster has said “I was asked that and it was the lightbulb/made me reflect”

And that’s despite lots of people who’ve left abusive and difficult relationships posting on the thread (all saying it’s not helpful).

Yet none of those determined it’s a good question to ask seem to be noticing or acknowledging that.

Great point.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 13:08

When people use the identical justification to rebut people contributing, yes it is linked - especially where the question is why did you have 1/2/3 children with anyone on a site called Mumsnet.

I didn't understand this at all, sorry. I can't work out the point you are making.

Snidely asking someone why they had children with an abusive / unpleasant partner never helps.

Saying that you choose to limit your family to afford a certain lifestyle is simply recounting your experience and not challenging another's 🤷🏻‍♀️

vivainsomnia · 07/09/2023 12:10

A bit of both. Ultimately, all the choices and decisions we make have consequences. Once we face these consequences, we've got to accept some responsibilities for having made those choices.

At the same time, things do change and couldn't be predicted.

And then there is a bit of bad planning and bad luck.

I do think there are a number of women who make obvious bad decisions but the call for a baby or more makes then turn a blind eyes to the almost inevitable consequences that are bound to show up later.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/09/2023 12:04

@thecatsthecats I agree with you- people always say on here - oh it's deliberate behaviour- I really don't think it is with some, I think if you have shown you will put up with shit at various points and not left it just becomes normalised to them and part of the day to day 'vibe' - my H once said to me 'problem is you internalise stress and frustrations, I externalise them' - that was indeed the case, but it can be very wearing to live with an externaliser- I genuinely don't think he was trying to piss me off or control - it had simply become part of his personality over the years- people do change.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/09/2023 11:55

@DaaamnYoullDo - exactly- lots of men talk the talk but don't walk the walk when reality creeps in

VictoriaVenkman · 07/09/2023 11:21

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 08:08

@VictoriaVenkman

Your posts are spectacularly stupid & insulting.

You clearly have no clue about the dynamics of abusive relationships or women in crisis.

The 'Why did you...' is never a tool that will aid reflection. Even if the woman could answer it, how will it help her make decisions now to address her abusive / unhappy relationship?

Stop repeating nonsense & perhaps listen to others who do understand it.

You have no idea of what experiences I have of relationships and it is insulting for you to claim you do. If you don't like my perspective, then feel free to scroll on past and not quote me.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/09/2023 11:19

It’s quite telling that not a single poster has said “I was asked that and it was the lightbulb/made me reflect”

And that’s despite lots of people who’ve left abusive and difficult relationships posting on the thread (all saying it’s not helpful).

Yet none of those determined it’s a good question to ask seem to be noticing or acknowledging that.

DaaamnYoullDo · 07/09/2023 11:08

My ex and I discussed at length how we would care for our baby for years before we tried for a child, he was dead set on being an equal parent and caring for me. When our baby was born via emergency c section he refused to help care for him and became abusive towards me to the point I had to leave everything behind before he followed through on his threats to kill me.

Cantstaystuckforever · 07/09/2023 11:05

@Didsomeonesaydogs it was my lived experience too 🙁What you've described about finding the joy and putting on a brave face is also so familiar to me - as is arguing with counsellors to insist that no, really, I was equally if not more at fault for the hole in the wall, for failing to manage his moods

The penny only truly dropped for me when a Relate counsellor communicated extremely sensitively after a few sessions that in our situation it would not be appropriate to continue with joint relationship counselling. Relate can get a bad rap on here, but that moment was life changing and possibly life saving for me, and I will forever be grateful for it.

thecatsthecats · 07/09/2023 11:02

In their minds it’s all justified - my STBXH describes his adultery partner’s STBXH as “controlling and manipulative”, with a completely straight face, despite displaying these traits in his own behaviours. Staggering lack of self awareness. But I’m going off track here.

I agree with this, and I always think that people ascribe deliberate intentions to control and manipulate to abusive men.

I think it's a bit more insidious than that. I think that during the love-bombing phase, these men aren't thinking "haha, she'll fall for this then I can start abusing her", it's more like "finally, a woman who isn't like all those other bitches, I'll shower her with affection", which later becomes "ungrateful bitch who didn't appreciate everything I did" to "she deserved it because she gives me such a hard time".

Part of the reason it's so believable to women is that the men themselves totally believe it.

thecatsthecats · 07/09/2023 10:57

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 08:26

Well, that makes perfect sense, but isn't relevant here.

Saying we can afford x lifestyle choice, as we decided to limit our family to y number of children, isn't the same as accusatorially asking 'why did you have a baby with him?'

It's not even linked!

When people use the identical justification to rebut people contributing, yes it is linked - especially where the question is why did you have 1/2/3 children with anyone on a site called Mumsnet.

And sometimes it can be both.

Cantstaystuckforever · 07/09/2023 10:40

jax3068 · 07/09/2023 08:12

A lot of put downs and abusive insults towards posters who are just expressing (without any insults!) a differing view.
Interesting...

I don't agree with put-downs, but you and some others don't seem to appreciate that this is not an intellectual debating exercise, these phrases are putting women and children are risk of very serious harm.

Abused people already have the voice of their abuser telling them that this is all their fault and they make bad choices, they don't need to hear it when seeking help or advice.

On average, abused women try to leave 7 times before they finally cut ties. There are many good reasons why. https://www.womensaid.org.uk/information-support/what-is-domestic-abuse/women-leave/

Why don't women leave? - Women’s Aid

https://www.womensaid.org.uk/information-support/what-is-domestic-abuse/women-leave

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 09:33

I just told myself it wasn’t that bad, put on my best face, made the most of it, found joy where I could and accepted this was my “life”.

I was exactly the same. I felt quite emotional reading your post.

It also took me years of counselling to accept I had been abused.

A particular incident propelled me to action, thankfully, as I think I'd have had a nervous breakdown in the end & God knows what would have happened to my DC.

Didsomeonesaydogs · 07/09/2023 09:20

Crikeyalmighty · 07/09/2023 08:52

@Cantstaystuckforever - indeed it's exactly like that for many -- the men are often erratic and Jekyll and Hyde , I don't think they realise in lots of cases too how hard they are to live with. The nastiness gets normalised in their own head

In their minds it’s all justified - my STBXH describes his adultery partner’s STBXH as “controlling and manipulative”, with a completely straight face, despite displaying these traits in his own behaviours. Staggering lack of self awareness. But I’m going off track here.

@Cantstaystuckforever you have perfectly described my lived experience. It really is boiling the frog. I even argued with mental health professionals that I wasn’t being abused, that I just needed to behave in certain ways to “manage his moods”.

A year out, I still sometimes question my own judgement as to whether it was really abuse. Then I look at the list of ways I was mistreated and I’m ashamed I valued myself so little to put up with it for so long. But sunk costs, financial dependency, fear of him taking the kids, (and even the thought of him having the kids for any time at all on his own was a scary prospect), the shame of “failing” at marriage, and lack of any family support all kept me hostage in the situation. I just told myself it wasn’t that bad, put on my best face, made the most of it, found joy where I could and accepted this was my “life”.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/09/2023 08:52

@Cantstaystuckforever - indeed it's exactly like that for many -- the men are often erratic and Jekyll and Hyde , I don't think they realise in lots of cases too how hard they are to live with. The nastiness gets normalised in their own head

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 08:26

thecatsthecats · 07/09/2023 08:22

On threads described in the OP - yep, not helpful.

BUT I've seen the same responses trotted out on threads where the OP has asked "how do you afford xyz", and gets replies along the lines of "we stuck to 1/2 children".

And then I think it's a valid answer, even if the OP can't send a child back. If the answer is "we can afford it because we chose to have a smaller family", then another part of the picture is "OP chose the bigger financial risk of a larger family and now has to deal with it".

Well, that makes perfect sense, but isn't relevant here.

Saying we can afford x lifestyle choice, as we decided to limit our family to y number of children, isn't the same as accusatorially asking 'why did you have a baby with him?'

It's not even linked!

thecatsthecats · 07/09/2023 08:22

On threads described in the OP - yep, not helpful.

BUT I've seen the same responses trotted out on threads where the OP has asked "how do you afford xyz", and gets replies along the lines of "we stuck to 1/2 children".

And then I think it's a valid answer, even if the OP can't send a child back. If the answer is "we can afford it because we chose to have a smaller family", then another part of the picture is "OP chose the bigger financial risk of a larger family and now has to deal with it".

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 08:17

jax3068 · 07/09/2023 08:12

A lot of put downs and abusive insults towards posters who are just expressing (without any insults!) a differing view.
Interesting...

What do you mean?

In my case, no insults to any posters. I've commented only on what they've said, not them personally.

The reason it's frustrating is that many of us, with direct knowledge of these situations, have explained why it isn't helpful, and worse, is judgmental and sneery, making it likely the vulnerable poster will just shut down, feeling unsupported.

Not sure why that's so hard for you & some others to grasp.

jax3068 · 07/09/2023 08:12

A lot of put downs and abusive insults towards posters who are just expressing (without any insults!) a differing view.
Interesting...

AuntieStella · 07/09/2023 08:10

Yes it is a question worth asking. It is not victim blaming, it is asking an OP to reflect on their behaviour and what is causing them to make poor decisions

Until the question is asked and answered, we wouldn't know that OP did make poor decisions. Everything can seem fine until the start of a pregnancy or the arrival of a baby

EarringsandLipstick · 07/09/2023 08:08

@VictoriaVenkman

Your posts are spectacularly stupid & insulting.

You clearly have no clue about the dynamics of abusive relationships or women in crisis.

The 'Why did you...' is never a tool that will aid reflection. Even if the woman could answer it, how will it help her make decisions now to address her abusive / unhappy relationship?

Stop repeating nonsense & perhaps listen to others who do understand it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread