Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mrs and Mr Smith

391 replies

Oysterbabe · 05/09/2023 10:00

When I write client letters I always put the woman's name first in the address and write
Dear Mrs & Mr Smith. The letters have to be checked before posting and my boss always swaps the names back because 'it doesn't flow properly'
AIBU for always writing the woman's name first?

OP posts:
PinkCherryBlossoms · 07/09/2023 15:29

IdleAnimations · 07/09/2023 14:39

Because whether you like it or not, the English formal language states it…

https://www.dailywritingtips.com/addressing-a-letter-to-two-people/

Same goes for if you don’t know the persons name. It’s ‘Dear Sir/Madam’ not ‘Dear Madam/Sir’. If you receive a professional letter it should always follow the traditional format.

Ultimately OP can do what they want but their boss is correct and by their boss correcting them continuously, they’ll just look incompetent and unable to follow their bosses instructions for something they have no backing for. Sorry but this is such a stupid hill to die on also incorrect if you’re following traditional English as most companies and even the public sector still do.

Whether you like it or not, the link you provide is nothing more than a claim from a website with no authority. You're going to have to do much, much better than that to back up the sort of claim you're making here.

IdleAnimations · 07/09/2023 15:27

Cosyblankets · 07/09/2023 15:00

I did give a reason.
Because I wanted to. Maybe I liked the sound of it. Maybe I wanted a new start. Maybe I just wanted to. But the point is I exercised my right to choose.
If that's not enough of an answer for you then I'm not really sure what you want me to say. My choice was stay or change.
I'm having chicken for tea. Because I want to. I'm going to Spain on holiday because I want to.
You seem to be of the opinion that any woman who changed her name is somewhat oppressed. I must be surrounded by oppressed women. Of my group of friends from university, at a guess about 12 of us, all married, all with degrees etc only 2 have kept their name. My married male friends, they must wear the trousers too because their wives changed. Not sure if it's a coincidence but neither of the two who kept their name live in the UK.
All those women I taught must be oppressed as well. At least 4 of them run their own business. At least 6 of them have professional qualifications. But they must be oppressed as they changed their name. I also have some same sex couples, one has double barrelled, the other two have chosen one or other of their names and used that so maybe they're oppressed as well.

This is the exact type of thing where I don’t call myself a feminist even being in a high end career in a male industry who does care about women’s CHOICES. There are so many rules and if you even inch towards tradition you’re deemed oppressed.

You want a matching surname - oppressed
You consult your husband on things - oppressed
You think fathers are important - oppressed
You want to be a SAHM and are not forced - oppressed
You don’t want to sleep around? - oppressed

It often makes feminism less about choice as shown by one poster stating they’d be disappointed if their daughter chose to be a SAHM. It’s appears to be more about dictating to women exactly what they must do or they’ll be insulted/mocked by the tribe. It’s not exactly endearing and I know many successful women who don’t prescribe to feminism either. I’m grateful for what the original feminists sought for me, I have a job, bank account, my own choice on contraception etc. But this new wave of constantly having a pop at women who’ve made a choice and are happy - nope.

IdleAnimations · 07/09/2023 15:15

Strawberryboost · 07/09/2023 11:41

I always wonder how these mumsnetters fare if their own daughters decide to, for example, take their husband’s name, become a SAHM

Are they as supportive and rooting for them as they are to women that choose not to do the above?

Edit @Strawberryboost so sorry didn’t mean to QT you! Don’t know how that happened.

@ErrolTheDragon how is it not grammatically incorrect if it’s always done that way and is also taught to most kids in school to layout letters that way? I remember learning this in school personally (alongside how to use things like ‘to whom it may concern’) and after that it has always been that way in the workplaces I’ve been in and I’m a millennial. I don’t understand and think a lot of posters are completely blindsided here because of their hate of how they perceive it as patriarchal when it’s just the traditional English format - which whether we like it or not is steeped in the masculine coming before the feminine.

I get that it burns as women (even though personally I don’t get so worried about it as I believe it’s just formal English) but the OP is being corrected by their boss rightly because it’s incorrect. This does change if the woman’s title takes on more importance e.g Dr. Ultimately I’d be correcting OP in the workplace too as I don’t like formats going astray but maybe I’m just a purist.

However for informal things such as cards, I address to the main recipient. So my friend who recently got married, because she’s my friend I directed the card to her with her husband second. But in a formal setting like my work - it’d be the traditional way.

Cosyblankets · 07/09/2023 15:00

RavingStyle · 07/09/2023 13:18

With respect, you have no idea why your FB acquaintances chose to change their names. Yes they had the 'right' to choose, but that's not to say they weren't swayed or influenced by convention or others' expectations.

You also didn't answer my question as to why you decided to change your name the 2nd time.
Saying "I had the choice to do so and decided I would" doesn't really explain anything or help anyone understand your reasons.

Why did you make that choice?

I did give a reason.
Because I wanted to. Maybe I liked the sound of it. Maybe I wanted a new start. Maybe I just wanted to. But the point is I exercised my right to choose.
If that's not enough of an answer for you then I'm not really sure what you want me to say. My choice was stay or change.
I'm having chicken for tea. Because I want to. I'm going to Spain on holiday because I want to.
You seem to be of the opinion that any woman who changed her name is somewhat oppressed. I must be surrounded by oppressed women. Of my group of friends from university, at a guess about 12 of us, all married, all with degrees etc only 2 have kept their name. My married male friends, they must wear the trousers too because their wives changed. Not sure if it's a coincidence but neither of the two who kept their name live in the UK.
All those women I taught must be oppressed as well. At least 4 of them run their own business. At least 6 of them have professional qualifications. But they must be oppressed as they changed their name. I also have some same sex couples, one has double barrelled, the other two have chosen one or other of their names and used that so maybe they're oppressed as well.

IdleAnimations · 07/09/2023 14:54

Tessabelle74 · 07/09/2023 10:26

It genuinely does my nut that some people care so much about other people's choices! I'm perfectly intelligent but I WANTED to adopt the traditions of being married, there's nothing wrong with that and it doesn't affect my intellect (or you) one little bit. My daughters are being raised to think for themselves. They know they can marry whomever they choose or not get married, that they can follow education as far as they want, or get a job at McDonalds if they wish. My sons are being brought up to do exactly the same around the house as my daughter's do, and that women aren't here to pander to them. I'm doing all that very successfully thank you as a Mrs.Myhusband. Now how about supporting women's choices rather than being so patronising because you're actually worse than a mysogynist with that attitude!

Edited

I don’t understand those who judge women for changing their name, they have a choice to do so. I kept my last name as an ode to my Father as the last in the line of that name. If you keep your maiden name, you’re keeping a male name anyway. All surnames are male in origin unless you decide to give yourself a brand new surname by deed poll.

Couples also hypernate names or simply want the same last name to have a family name. I don’t see any woman as less independent or strong because she wants a matching last name. As long as she’s happy with her choice, I am happy!

ErrolTheDragon · 07/09/2023 14:49

None of which makes inverting the order 'grammatically incorrect'.
That link gives various possibilities, some of which are contradictory. But as it says at the end:

Bottom line: If you know the couple, you should know how they prefer to be addressed.
If you are addressing a letter to people you do not know well, choose a respectful form of address that suits the occasion.

Mrsphilmiller · 07/09/2023 14:42

It’s like “mum and dad” can never be “dad and mum” can it?

IdleAnimations · 07/09/2023 14:39

PinkCherryBlossoms · 07/09/2023 06:46

How it is it grammatically incorrect? You've yet to explain that. You saying something is basic formal English writing certainly won't suffice.

Because whether you like it or not, the English formal language states it…

https://www.dailywritingtips.com/addressing-a-letter-to-two-people/

Same goes for if you don’t know the persons name. It’s ‘Dear Sir/Madam’ not ‘Dear Madam/Sir’. If you receive a professional letter it should always follow the traditional format.

Ultimately OP can do what they want but their boss is correct and by their boss correcting them continuously, they’ll just look incompetent and unable to follow their bosses instructions for something they have no backing for. Sorry but this is such a stupid hill to die on also incorrect if you’re following traditional English as most companies and even the public sector still do.

Addressing A Letter to Two People

Addressing A Letter to Two People - DAILY WRITING TIPS

One post often leads to another. The recent article “Conventional Letter Salutations in English” garnered several questions about how to address a letter to a

https://www.dailywritingtips.com/addressing-a-letter-to-two-people/

Superfood · 07/09/2023 13:50

Strawberryboost · 07/09/2023 11:38

What would your response be if your daughter chose to take her husband’s surname, which statistically speaking is more likely than not

It would be nothing to do with me. Although she is quite clear at the point that she doesn't want to get married at all...

I'd be surprised and disappointed, but it's her life.

RavingStyle · 07/09/2023 13:18

Cosyblankets · 07/09/2023 11:38

They were not giving in. They were doing what they chose. As was I.
You had a right to choose. You chose not to. I had a right to choose. I had been married and then widowed and been on my own for a good few years so i had plenty of time to think about it. I have plenty of life experience. We live in my house. I am totally independent. I changed for the simple reason that i wanted to. He did say he would be more than happy if i preferred to stay with my previous name. I chose not to. I chose to change. Simply because i wanted to.
You do you

With respect, you have no idea why your FB acquaintances chose to change their names. Yes they had the 'right' to choose, but that's not to say they weren't swayed or influenced by convention or others' expectations.

You also didn't answer my question as to why you decided to change your name the 2nd time.
Saying "I had the choice to do so and decided I would" doesn't really explain anything or help anyone understand your reasons.

Why did you make that choice?

Strawberryboost · 07/09/2023 11:45

@EBearhug But people will make assumptions and judge you, whichever you choose to use, whereas men just get Mr whatever.

how old are you?

Strawberryboost · 07/09/2023 11:43

I changed my name AND I kept it even when we divorced! 😂

Sayitaintso33 · 07/09/2023 11:42

EBearhug · 07/09/2023 11:36

And it doesn't necessarily disclose marital statues. A single woman can call herself Mrs and a married one Miss.And all have the option of Ms. So marital status is disclosed only if the woman wants it to be disclosed. Women have options. That's great.

But people will make assumptions and judge you, whichever you choose to use, whereas men just get Mr whatever.

I'm amazed you believe people judge about a woman's marital status in modern Britain (assuming that is where you are). Sorry that isn't meant to sound critical. I'm genuinely surprised.

Perhaps I'm just thick-skinned and/or unobservant but this isn't part of my world, at least I don't think it is.

Strawberryboost · 07/09/2023 11:41

I always wonder how these mumsnetters fare if their own daughters decide to, for example, take their husband’s name, become a SAHM

Are they as supportive and rooting for them as they are to women that choose not to do the above?

Strawberryboost · 07/09/2023 11:38

@Superfood

Strawberryboost · 07/09/2023 11:38

Superfood · 07/09/2023 10:11

Because 1) I'm a woman, and 2) have a daughter.

Every woman and girl is negatively affected by the perpetuation of the patriarchy.

Supporting the idea that women are inferior to men, and that our identities are defined by them, obviously harms us all.

What would your response be if your daughter chose to take her husband’s surname, which statistically speaking is more likely than not

Cosyblankets · 07/09/2023 11:38

RavingStyle · 07/09/2023 10:28

I'm also in my 50s and married in the 90s. Didn't change my name 🙂

Yes, your ex pupils had the choice, but why did they pick that option? If it was because it was expected of them, or because of 'tradition', then it wasn't so much a choice, as giving in. And if there is pressure on young women to do certain things that young men aren't expected to do then it's important to know, and question the reasons why.

Why did you want to change your name the 2nd time, if you don't mind my asking?

They were not giving in. They were doing what they chose. As was I.
You had a right to choose. You chose not to. I had a right to choose. I had been married and then widowed and been on my own for a good few years so i had plenty of time to think about it. I have plenty of life experience. We live in my house. I am totally independent. I changed for the simple reason that i wanted to. He did say he would be more than happy if i preferred to stay with my previous name. I chose not to. I chose to change. Simply because i wanted to.
You do you

EBearhug · 07/09/2023 11:36

And it doesn't necessarily disclose marital statues. A single woman can call herself Mrs and a married one Miss.And all have the option of Ms. So marital status is disclosed only if the woman wants it to be disclosed. Women have options. That's great.

But people will make assumptions and judge you, whichever you choose to use, whereas men just get Mr whatever.

Sayitaintso33 · 07/09/2023 11:04

Mikimoto · 05/09/2023 12:34

Why are you disclosing the woman's married status? That's quite mysoginistic in itself.

Not misogynisitic if the majority of informed, sober women prefer it.

And it doesn't necessarily disclose marital statues. A single woman can call herself Mrs and a married one Miss.

And all have the option of Ms. So marital status is disclosed only if the woman wants it to be disclosed. Women have options. That's great.

Didsomeonesaydogs · 07/09/2023 10:53

dunroamingfornow · 07/09/2023 07:16

This. When I booked my last holiday for me and DS the flight information and hotel bookings came addressed to him. He's 7!

I just wanted to give this a little bump for the sheer absurdity of the outcome due to the assumptions made by the holiday companies!

blueshoes · 07/09/2023 10:50

Superfood · 07/09/2023 07:56

Unfortunately this is completely wrong. It's still over 90 percent, as per the link above, and we still live in an overwhelmingly patriarchal society which many women enthusiastically prop up, by taking their husband's name, giving their children their father's surname only, waiting for a proposal, being 'given away' etc etc.

90% in 2016 is not the vast VAST majority. I am prepared to accept that taking on a husband's name is less likely in my socio-economic circles than in the general population based on those quoted stats.

fairyfluf · 07/09/2023 10:39

I don't have the same last name as my husband. We got some stickers printed so we can stick them on the envelope with our names and return address on. My MIL has been told my name. She refuses.

fairyfluf · 07/09/2023 10:36

JSmithIloveyou · 05/09/2023 10:06

See below

That's outdated now. It pisses people off.

Mr A and Mrs B Smith is correct

Tessabelle74 · 07/09/2023 10:35

Superfood · 07/09/2023 10:31

You think that suggesting women challenge patriarchal traditions makes me "worse than a mysogynist [sic]"?

Odd.

No, I'm telling you that berating women for making their own choices is worse than misogyny so stop being deliberately obtuse, we both know you're more intelligent than that (and really? The sic? 🤣)

NoSaladThanks · 07/09/2023 10:34

To be fair, I wouldn't even notice that it was the opposite way round.