Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be struggling managing someone I dislike

95 replies

mamagementpeopleyoudislike · 04/09/2023 22:13

NC. Before you say I'm a bad manager here me out...

I don't finding managing most people an issue or even difficult (testing at times but generally pretty ok).

I have someone at the moment who is capable, but rude and involved themselves in things they don't need to often which creates drama.

And when things are picked up with them all hell breaks loose and they get upset.

They are cheeky and rude but not to the point that warrant a warning for example - it's just their personality. I can tell they don't mean anything by it it maliciously but they tend to rub people up the wrong way.

I know it's not personal because I see it with others (it's not often it happens but it does).

It makes me dislike the person and completely unsure how to solve the issue.

Any supervisors or managers who have had this experience.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dramatico · 05/09/2023 10:28

determinedtomakethiswork · 04/09/2023 22:46

Oooh isn't that Godwin's law? I haven't seen it on here for a while.

I know right?! It was so funny, how quickly that went from A to Z lol

The funniest thing is that this isn't even something Hitler was guilty of with the people he managed, he was stuck with Goering and Guderian even though he loathed them and they were well past their level of competence lol

marymungoNminge · 05/09/2023 09:49

And always reach out to HR for help too. I'd probably do that after the second meeting if all else fails just to show you've tried and implemented a plan yourself first but the employee in question hasn't responded to it.

marymungoNminge · 05/09/2023 09:47

Christ there are some people here desperate to take a snipe at the OP.
Guessing all you lot coming at her have never looked up advice on the internet? Yes managers go through training and have resources and knowledge but sometimes, managers just want an outside opinion on something. Nothing wrong with that. Stop being so nasty.

I would much rather have the OP as a manager who wants to make sure they are doing the right thing than all you miserable, better than the rest posters on here. I feel sorry for you all if you're managing people underneath you.

OP I don't have much to suggest, apart from do you your employees have a monthly review / mid month catch up? We do at our company to go through KPIs from the month before and how we're looking for the month ahead. If you don't have those types of meetings perhaps you could go down the route of that, build a rapport with the employee and make some suggestions there for ways to improve. Tell them you'll meet again in a months time for a catch up to reassess so you put a time frame on it. If nothings improved / worse than you'll have to go down the more official route but I'd try to avoid that on the first meeting about this. Especially if they're causing drama and getting involved with things, my only real advice is to put a time stamp on it. Speak again in 4 weeks and see where you are.

Good luck!

lovemelongtime · 05/09/2023 08:59

ItWasAllFields · 04/09/2023 22:52

What kind of a manager asks internet forums for advice?............

One who is trying to improve and learn from other people's experiences

HeatherMoores · 05/09/2023 08:51

Do you have regular supervision with them once a month or every other month?
Sometimes it’s helpful to frame things in terms of how they make you feel, ie the impact their behaviour has on you (or others). Eg

When you said (rudeness) this is the impact it had on (specific situation) and it made me feel (x y z).
Can we review this? This is what you said (rudeness) and why it is considered inappropriate in the workplace.
When I give you feedback about (some of your language choices) or (your behaviour in recent situation) you don’t seem to be very open to considering what I have to say/ react by taking offence and this makes me feel that it’s difficult to give you constructive feedback and offer you support.

Ultimately I think it depends on how bad the behaviour is. If it’s really inappropriate enough to need highlighting and addressing? Or if it’s just a bit close to the wind and needs ‘pandering to’ or grey rocking, or ‘killing with kindness’.

Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 05/09/2023 08:19

Can you ask HR for help?

Orders76 · 05/09/2023 08:15

Cheeky and rude isn't a personality type, they've learned they get away with it.
All employees have a right to respect in the workplace and ongoing cheek and rudeness can contribute to a disrespectful environment.
You may need to tackle what they see as being a straight talker and what is actually making an uncomfortable work environment.

PollyPotato · 05/09/2023 07:43

I am a manager in a large global organisation. I manage one person in particular at the moment who is competent and can do good work, but can be rude to people, gets very frustrated at times and creates drama in the team the others complain to me about.
I think in a global organisation like mine, you have to leave some of your personality at the door and try to fit into the corporate culture. This is how I am trying to teach him. At times I could scream at him, he can be soooo ruuuude!

SummerInTheRain · 05/09/2023 06:04

@Shouldreallyknowbetter nope not only you. I felt half this thread could have been written by my manager about me.

LindaCrochet · 05/09/2023 05:26

I manage a large team, I've been a manager for a number of years and there been people who I probably wouldn't say I liked.
Currently there is one team member in particular who's personality and behaviours I can say I don't like.
The challenge is to still manage them to draw out the best of their abilities. My personal opinion of them is irrelevant. You need to remain objective.
Not everyone likes everyone else, we're human but for those employees you need to step back and put a little distance between your options and your management of them.
One is particularly difficult in terms of how they behave, they are unable to manage their reactions to situations when stressed.

I'm supporting her with that, various step's including identifying the causes of her stress and giving support.

It doesn't matter if I like her, it's my job to manage her performance and part of that is the support I'm giving her.
We wouldn't be friends if we met outside of work but I care about doing my job well and I have empathy for her, so I keep at it.

RantyAnty · 05/09/2023 05:18

How difficult would it be to sack him?

Difficult people are a risk and liability and bring down the morale of a team.

WhatAreYouOnAbout · 05/09/2023 05:05

No harm in asking.

HAF1119 · 05/09/2023 04:42

For me I would do - when you notice something happen, make a note (mentally or somewhere secure on your computer) and as soon as there is an opportunity speak to them.

I noticed earlier that X person asked you to complete X task and you said you'll do it when you are ready, I felt that the communication didn't flow very well in being mindful of your team and working together, why do you think you gave the answer you did? It's not a problem to be busy and unable to complete an additional task but if you speak openly with the team and say you are doing Y right now which should take around an hour, then you can begin X then your team mate will know that to expect and what you are working on at the moment. If defensive then open that discussion too, I feel like you are getting upset I have approached you about this, but I do need to approach issues - how would you like me to approach this differently in future and what style do you prefer me to use with you as I want you to feel happy and confident, but also need to manage my team and give feedback.

EyesEars · 05/09/2023 04:09

I can see your struggle - you too are not taking negative feedback well on here. Perhaps you both have work to do.

hoven · 05/09/2023 03:46

@Greengagesnfennel

I didn't say op must know everything and yes I am a senior manager and have qualifications in leadership.

I'm simply stating there are many ways to get guidance with this type of thing such as through courses funded by the workplace as I have done.

Also the op clearly states the issue is that they simply do not like the team member - begging the question that they should like everyone at work which is simply not the case.

Veracity23 · 05/09/2023 00:42

There's a great site called Ask a Manager that has tonnes of advice, it's American I think but has really good tips on there.

You have my sympathy I'm currently having issues with my manager although it isn't just me. Actually I'm having issues with the workplace and colleagues in general I never expected to encounter again after my bloody awful temping twenties were past....

When I was a manager I used to find the high maintenance aspects of some of my team very hard work and incredibly time consuming. You might also find it helpful to look up MBTI types, Insights, and also Belbin Team roles if you've not tried them with your team already. They all helped me immensely, good luck.

Gowlett · 05/09/2023 00:38

I know what you mean. Exactly the same is happening at my work. It’s really uncomfortable. Manager is a good person, decent manager. I have no problem doing as she asks, never have.

Young colleague simply doesn’t like being asked / told to do tasks. He’s casing drama & turning other staff against this manager. Who previously got on fine with folk. It’s horrible to watch, gotta say.

GarlicGrace · 05/09/2023 00:31

mamagementpeopleyoudislike · 04/09/2023 23:28

@midlifecrash yes they're the sort that if they don't like something in a team meeting (doesn't happen often) but they'll make it clear in front of everyone.

Not even I, as the manager do that. I'll take someone to one side as it's unprofessional to do otherwise.

See, team meetings to me are for debate & discussion. I would automatically raise potential issues at a meeting, and expect colleagues to do the same. If that's not what meetings are to you, then it's worth explaining - and clarifying your preferred method of raising issues / criticism / querying.

It's been interesting reading your replies to critics here. You seem very quick to defence and counter-attack. It's quite possible, I think, that you may be reacting this way to the perceived insubordination of this team member. Do you think so?

There's been some excellent input from PPs on improving your rapport with this person by finding out what makes her tick, putting yourself in her shoes, "killing her with kindness". You called this pandering, I call it effective relationship management.

All good management books highlight the importance of bringing out your team members' talents, and of fostering mutual respect.

Greengagesnfennel · 05/09/2023 00:10

TikTokCat · 04/09/2023 23:07

Any manager who thinks they know everything would probably not be a very good one.

We come across different people with different needs and motivations all the time. You don't need to pander to them but you need to try and understand them and be prepared for honest conversation.

This

I think a) hoven isn't a manager or b) is probably a bad one.

In terms of adapting to people. I am naturally a consultative person and consensus builder and in my early career I found people like the person you mention hard too. Till I realised some people like to hear a really clear 'order'. Have you perhaps been too soft in making it clear the decision is made and you have made it? Perhaps you need to be more direct in letting them know this. Have you ever tried that with them- you might find they take it really well and with their personality they like a clear line in the sand from you?

Shouldreallyknowbetter · 04/09/2023 23:55

I wonder if I am the only one who reads threads like this and wonders if it's me!! I think I may be regarded as difficult. Some of this I just live with as it matters (safeguarding element) but I know I need to ignore things or not say what I think - or think more carefully about my approach.

I, however, do appreciate direct feedback. Even if this person doesn't respond well I would have thought it needs to happen. As always be specific. X situation became more complicated because of your action (specific). Next time it might be better to... (eg come to me). Or re the rudeness/cheeky... can you please think how to say/write x message differently next time.

I have been called rude when communicating by email when I get a bit fed up (a culture of lots of people being copied in so you don't know who is actually doing xyz can be annoying) so perhaps worth exploring reasons even if you stay on message about what is unacceptable. Also find the team meeting comment unclear, might team members think open discussion is acceptable?

midlifecrash · 04/09/2023 23:53

Hmm, I think it can be better potentially if challenges come up in team meetings, depending on what they are of course. If it’s “reporting this way risks confusion over the results “ I think it’s good if someone has to explain exactly what they mean to the whole team. If they have misunderstood something that will become apparent, and this can clarify things for everyone. Or they might even be right!

if it’s “I don’t want to label my files this way it’s boring” then that is obviously not a team discussion, it’s something they just have to do.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 04/09/2023 23:51

I'm afraid seeing your responses to those that have been critical of you OP, I get the impression that you don't handle any form of criticism well yourself, and therefore faced with a member of staff who challenges you, or possibly your position, (which is effectively what this woman is doing when she argues with you), you struggle to deal with it effectively. Do you lack confidence in yourself as a manager OP, or maybe you suffer from 'imposter syndrome' so are reluctant to show any form of weakness to your own boss, (ie, asking them for advice), for fear you might be found out? It is good that you've reached out for advice, but like some others, I'm not sure that MN is the best place, perhaps for the future you might be better off if you don't have anyone else you feel comfortable asking, just looking on Google, who when I looked just now, pointed me to some very useful advice on the subject of handling difficult staff members. Maybe have a look at this:

https://www.betterup.com/blog/dealing-with-difficult-employees

two men talking - dealing with difficult employees

Dealing with Difficult Employees (8 Tips to Succeed)

Dealing with difficult employees is always a challenge. Learn the causes of bad employee behavior and how to move forward in your workplace.

https://www.betterup.com/blog/dealing-with-difficult-employees

BranchGold · 04/09/2023 23:45

mamagementpeopleyoudislike · 04/09/2023 23:28

@midlifecrash yes they're the sort that if they don't like something in a team meeting (doesn't happen often) but they'll make it clear in front of everyone.

Not even I, as the manager do that. I'll take someone to one side as it's unprofessional to do otherwise.

When you say ‘doesn’t happen often’ do you mean the employee raising an issue, or team meetings?

How do you communicate changes, feedback, tracking to the team? How do you receive that communication from your seniors? Meetings?

Sometimes it can appear to the team that managers do a lot of sitting around the table with others on their level and senior, then send an email reporting back a change, rather than having a dialogue with those who are actually responsible for the work.
Would you say you have good communication in general with your team?

Treesinmygarden · 04/09/2023 23:40

I'm on the other side of this. My team manager once told me I was "challenging and insubordinate". I'm not. I just wanted explanations for ridiculous and unreasonable decisions.

I am hugely more educated/professionally qualified than my line and team manager. I think this is an issue for them. I once asked team manager if her Assistant Director manager disagreed with her, would she challenge that? She said no... Yet we're always having training/guest speakers encouraging us to do just that!

I have watched other far less qualified/experienced people appointed and promoted, while I have been rejected (in my 50s at the time and I know that went against me too, going on the evidence of how other over 50s have been treated in my organisation!)

So, I have quietly quit. I am no longer going to give heart and soul, as I've done for over 30 years, to an organisation that has no regard for me.

Are you shutting down discussion about something that is actually relevant in a team meeting? My team manager was fucking furious in a team meeting because I and a colleague raised questions around the taking of annual leave and flexi that were relevant to all of us!

Maybe you need to look at your own behaviour too?

BranchGold · 04/09/2023 23:40

Have they been with the team/company for a long time?

in my team I have a colleague who the manager isn’t particularly fond of, her manner can be a bit abrasive and she knows the job inside out, often her points are valid but she can go about it in the wrong way. There’s quite a lot of favouritism though within the team, particularly towards the men, who know far less about the work but seem to be given preferential treatment because they don’t bring ‘drama’ to the manager.

How is the employee seen within the team by her peers? Do you think anyone on the team would say you have favourites/stronger working relationships with certain individuals?

Not every complaint she makes is legitimate, and I do feel like telling her that sometimes she needs to accept the ‘it’s always been done that way!’ Attitude needs to drop, the organisation can’t run on what’s happened in the past. But I also think her knowledge and understanding should be respected, and she’s quite often the one who ‘deals with the shit’ when it comes to changes that have been formulated in a senior meeting that doesn’t benefit the team or clients.