Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School have asked year 4 children to switch from Cursive

107 replies

Rp735 · 04/09/2023 21:38

This is causing me stress so worth getting the opinion of MN. DD went to first day of year 4 today and her teacher has told the class that they are not to use cursive or joined handwriting anymore and need to practice broken. I have checked with other children too who have confirmed. They have been in the school from reception and are quite competent in writing cursive by now. The class as a whole has been struggling due to lack of learning during covid and many teachers leaving in the years following that. I was really hoping this would be the year the would finally be able to catch up. However, this new change will set them back considerably, in my opinion. Also annoying that there was no communication regarding this. AIBU to be angry and to complain?

OP posts:
AccountantMum · 05/09/2023 07:48

You mention the class as a whole has struggled due to missing learning during covid - is it possible the Cursive writing is not working for most of the class and the teachers could not read their work and therefore they have decided to change to make sure they can cover the topics needed

BogRollBOGOF · 05/09/2023 07:47

I have dyslexic children. DS2's print was age appropriate legible when he started writing... then cursive was introduced...

I fail to see how a cramped, spidery, illegible mess can meet any form of standard better than a legible print. Especially in an era where beyond the classroom where any extended writing will be typed. Touch typing is a neglected skill in the education system
Handwriting still has a value for general fine motor control, but micro managing a generation into a particular style of writing can be very detrimental to some, and plain out of touch with reality for all of them.

ZadocPDederick · 05/09/2023 07:40

When my DD was taught cursive I too complained. However, when DS started school I could see the sense of it, because he was and is mildly dyslexic and writing cursive really helped him to learn to write the letters the right way round.

CoffeeCantata · 05/09/2023 07:30

I had a brief phased in primary teaching about 20 years ago when cursive writing was introduced, and I hated it and moaned about it a lot! I think it's a dreadful mistake.

I was never taught joined writing at school in the 60s and 70s. We just formed out own style, which worked well. Some people joined everything, others formed an italic style, others joined some letters and not others. No problem at all. I had a nice, italic style with some joined letters.

Then I had to teach cursive which has totally ruined my own handwriting to the point where nowadays I can hardly do it any more. I felt all the time I was teaching it that it was wrong, and I could see some children, who could barely cope with forming printed letters, getting more and more confused and bogged down. It was totally bonkers.

I was an English graduate and had been a secondary school teacher and the reason I left primary teaching was the craziness of the Literacy Strategy (in so many ways), which I felt was utterly wrong-headed. I'm so glad that the Victorian madness of cursive writing seems to be going out of fashion at last - is this the case? Let children develop their own writing style naturally - anything else is a hindrance. Handwriting should be as individual as a fingerprint.

IsitChristmasyet23 · 05/09/2023 07:29

What has stopped is the cursive lead in during earlier years in primary. Google teacher assessment framework - year 6 - writing. A child not joining in Y6 will not meet standard in England. It’s in the TAF in black and white and has not changed. Whether people agree or not - that’s the reality.

Needmorelego · 05/09/2023 07:25

@Confetto oh it was definitely American style cursive at my daughter's (English) primary. Totally different to the "joined up" handwriting I was taught back in the 80s.
Absolutely ridiculous and such a waste of time.

Pizzanight · 05/09/2023 07:22

My DS is going into year 2 and we were told last year they are not going to be taught joined up. My nephew is the same age and lives in the next town along and writes fully joined up.

Tarantella6 · 05/09/2023 07:16

DD2 was Y3 last year and they were told to stop with the joined up writing - they hadn't learned how to form the letters correctly first and it was unreadable. I'm assuming that after a year of that, they'll reintroduce cursive this year (Y4).

Honestly if the only impact of COVID is they can't do cursive (spoiler, it isn't the only impact!) then they'll have got off quite lightly.

skelter83 · 05/09/2023 07:12

Exactly this. It’s annoying but true and throughout the year groups there are formative assessment statements linked to handwriting and letter formation.

If may be that the children, as a whole, are still not forming letters correctly and they are stopping to re-teach.

MumblesParty · 05/09/2023 07:07

I find this interesting as I wonder if it’s a new thing. My kids were both made to start joining up their writing in year 1, when they’d barely learned how to form letters. Both are now teens with dreadful handwriting, and I’m sure that it’s partly due to forcing joining up too early. Maybe this has finally been acknowledged and the teaching pattern has changed. DS1 was actually told at age 13 to stop joining up, as his writing was illegible!

Confetto · 05/09/2023 06:42

Sugargliderwombat · 04/09/2023 22:46

OP is saying about cursive, not joined. OP have your school recently joined an academy chain? Maybe they have introduced a new handwriting policy.

Cursive just means joined if you look it up in a dictionary. Some people take it to mean the more American style of joining when letter all start on the line with lead ins, but that's just a style of joining. I've never seen a British primary school that actually teaches the American style if you look at how many of their letters are formed.

IsitChristmasyet23 · 05/09/2023 06:34

Sugargliderwombat · 04/09/2023 22:37

Not true anymore.

Why do people get annoyed before they've even spoken to an adult ? Check first.

Yes it is. It is in the teacher assessment framework for England. Go and have a look. WTS for non cursive at Y6. You are either not in England or you’re talking about pre cursive before stat assessment in Y6. Totally different.

IsitChristmasyet23 · 05/09/2023 06:32

Soontobe60 · 04/09/2023 22:30

Not in my school they wouldn’t. We assess written work by the content, not by what it looks like. That doesn’t mean we don’t care, it just means we don’t pressurise children who haven’t yet mastered a comfortable, legible form of writing.

You can’t be in England then. It is literally in the teacher assessment framework,

Snowneep · 04/09/2023 23:15

Unjoined writing is a skill they need to learn for labelling diagrams or data and form filling etc. It’s in the curriculum guidance for year 5/6. My daughters school taught unjoined writing in year 4 and it was helpful to have that skill before year 5 where they are expected to write at a much faster pace

Sugargliderwombat · 04/09/2023 22:46

CupOfCoffeePlease · 04/09/2023 22:34

Has that changed then?

I remember a few years ago being told they had to have joined up for Yr 6 to meet/exceed expectations!

Both my girls I reassured could un-join after Yr 6 and their writing is so much neater. But it was drilled as necessary for sats..

OP is saying about cursive, not joined. OP have your school recently joined an academy chain? Maybe they have introduced a new handwriting policy.

Heartfullofcheese · 04/09/2023 22:45

Indeed @Onelifeonly but there is such a huge discrepancy in what moderators want to see.
Definitely in line for moderation this year…sigh.

KingscoteStaff · 04/09/2023 22:41

Our Year 6 writing was moderated this year. One boy was about to be downgraded to 'Towards' for failing to join, when my brilliant TA remembered that for some bizarre reason he always joins in his Science conclusions and pulled that book out for them to see.

Confetto · 04/09/2023 22:39

Soontobe60 · 04/09/2023 22:30

Not in my school they wouldn’t. We assess written work by the content, not by what it looks like. That doesn’t mean we don’t care, it just means we don’t pressurise children who haven’t yet mastered a comfortable, legible form of writing.

It cannot meet Y6 standard if unjoined. Our writing was moderated and children got working towards standard even for a few unjoined words. Even by Y3, writing should only meet the expected standard if there is decent evidence of joining.

OP, I'd guess they're going back to print then reteaching joining. Maybe ask, rather than going in angry? Incidentally, this is not a subject I'd expect school to consult on if they have a plan to raise standards. Schools would get nothing done if they constantly consulted parents, nor do many parents know the expectations of the curriculum (understandably) so aren't in an ideal position to make decisions about teaching.

AvengedQuince · 04/09/2023 22:37

Being able to print is essential in day to day life, you can't only write in cursive

Sugargliderwombat · 04/09/2023 22:37

IsitChristmasyet23 · 04/09/2023 22:25

Cursive is a requirement of the national curriculum. A Y6 child would be marked as not meeting expectations without using it. Therefore, it’s odd but necessary to a point. Then secondary don’t care.

Not true anymore.

Why do people get annoyed before they've even spoken to an adult ? Check first.

Heartfullofcheese · 04/09/2023 22:37

If an external moderator came in they would say a non joining child does not meet the standard. You could have the odd child with a “specific weakness” such as dyspraxia but that’s it.
Not saying it’s right or fair but them’s the rules.
They don’t have to join all the time, just prove they can by writing a paragraph or so in joined.

Onelifeonly · 04/09/2023 22:35

In year 6 you only need to have evidence they can join, so not all their writing needs to be joined. So they can do some handwriting practice and that will count. But I've been through two moderations by LA moderators in recent years and none have ever mentioned the children's handwriting.

CupOfCoffeePlease · 04/09/2023 22:34

Has that changed then?

I remember a few years ago being told they had to have joined up for Yr 6 to meet/exceed expectations!

Both my girls I reassured could un-join after Yr 6 and their writing is so much neater. But it was drilled as necessary for sats..

Soontobe60 · 04/09/2023 22:30

IsitChristmasyet23 · 04/09/2023 22:25

Cursive is a requirement of the national curriculum. A Y6 child would be marked as not meeting expectations without using it. Therefore, it’s odd but necessary to a point. Then secondary don’t care.

Not in my school they wouldn’t. We assess written work by the content, not by what it looks like. That doesn’t mean we don’t care, it just means we don’t pressurise children who haven’t yet mastered a comfortable, legible form of writing.

IsitChristmasyet23 · 04/09/2023 22:25

Cursive is a requirement of the national curriculum. A Y6 child would be marked as not meeting expectations without using it. Therefore, it’s odd but necessary to a point. Then secondary don’t care.