Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School have asked year 4 children to switch from Cursive

107 replies

Rp735 · 04/09/2023 21:38

This is causing me stress so worth getting the opinion of MN. DD went to first day of year 4 today and her teacher has told the class that they are not to use cursive or joined handwriting anymore and need to practice broken. I have checked with other children too who have confirmed. They have been in the school from reception and are quite competent in writing cursive by now. The class as a whole has been struggling due to lack of learning during covid and many teachers leaving in the years following that. I was really hoping this would be the year the would finally be able to catch up. However, this new change will set them back considerably, in my opinion. Also annoying that there was no communication regarding this. AIBU to be angry and to complain?

OP posts:
Changingmymind66 · 05/09/2023 20:14

Needmorelego · 05/09/2023 17:25

@TimeForTeaAndG I don't understand the "babyish" comment either.
This is cursive. Old fashioned and difficult to read if messy

I even find typed cursive difficult to read as an adult! I'm an avid reader, but letters from the school using typed cursive are not easy on the eye.

IsitChristmasyet23 · 05/09/2023 19:54

Smartiepants79 · 05/09/2023 19:01

I LOATHE the fact that printed handwriting can stop a child being deemed expected standard.
I’ve taught many exceptional writers with poor handwriting. Some well above expectations for all other areas. It makes me very cross that handwriting has such weight in this.
I also get cross with people who insist on sticking rigidly to silly rules like this. Good handwriting doesn’t make a good writer..

It’s not rules. It’s statutory in England.

IsitChristmasyet23 · 05/09/2023 19:53

Globules · 05/09/2023 19:12

I agree it's in the docs @IsitChristmasyet23 but here's some of the responses on this thread:

Not in my school they wouldn’t. We assess written work by the content, not by what it looks like.

They don’t have to join all the time, just prove they can by writing a paragraph or so in joined. Vs children got working towards standard even for a few unjoined words.

I have no doubt this is what is happening in 3 different schools. That's probably different LAs interpreting the printed words in different ways.

How many wpm does each LA consider "at speed"?

Does everything need to be joined across all subjects or does this vary from LA to LA?

What is the bottom line for "legible" across LAs? Readable to everyone, or readable to people tuned into the child's writing?

I agree it's in black and white, but the words are open to interpretation by LAs.

It does not vary - it is a statutory assessment. Moderators have statutory training. The issue is that many teachers get stale and don’t know outside of their key stage. This is poor practice. All teachers should know start and end points. It’s not negotiated by moderators either. They will need to see consistent, joined and legible writing. Not every piece but they will ask to see it.

Do schools push the boundaries if they are not being moderated. I’m sure they do but that is reportable and you risk losing your registration.

People have got confused by the stopping of the ‘lead in’ further down. Cursive is a required at the end of KS2 - no ifs or buts. I can’t explain poor knowledge of the UKS2 curriculum from some teachers.

AvengedQuince · 05/09/2023 19:37

I agree there must be variation between schools. DS arrived just before summer term of year 6 from overseas. Had only written joined up in school handwriting lessons, printing for all other work, which was barely legible as it was. He was told to write joined up for SATs, certainly wasn't demonstrating consistency but met the standard!

Callyem · 05/09/2023 19:16

IsitChristmasyet23 · 04/09/2023 22:25

Cursive is a requirement of the national curriculum. A Y6 child would be marked as not meeting expectations without using it. Therefore, it’s odd but necessary to a point. Then secondary don’t care.

Came to say exactly this. If they are not demonstrating consistency in cursive handwriting for Yr 6 writing assessment they cannot meet the expected standard and will be assessed as working towards.

Can only imagine the school have decided they need to backtrack to move forward with presentation.

Globules · 05/09/2023 19:12

I agree it's in the docs @IsitChristmasyet23 but here's some of the responses on this thread:

Not in my school they wouldn’t. We assess written work by the content, not by what it looks like.

They don’t have to join all the time, just prove they can by writing a paragraph or so in joined. Vs children got working towards standard even for a few unjoined words.

I have no doubt this is what is happening in 3 different schools. That's probably different LAs interpreting the printed words in different ways.

How many wpm does each LA consider "at speed"?

Does everything need to be joined across all subjects or does this vary from LA to LA?

What is the bottom line for "legible" across LAs? Readable to everyone, or readable to people tuned into the child's writing?

I agree it's in black and white, but the words are open to interpretation by LAs.

Noalcohol · 05/09/2023 19:05

My child had this as they were schooled abroad from 3 to 9 years. It was so hard adjusting. My child ended up with a hybrid type and just came out with A stars and A ‘s in A level so my advice let them develop their handwriting as much as they are comfortable but don’t worry too much as most examiners can read all types.

Smartiepants79 · 05/09/2023 19:01

I LOATHE the fact that printed handwriting can stop a child being deemed expected standard.
I’ve taught many exceptional writers with poor handwriting. Some well above expectations for all other areas. It makes me very cross that handwriting has such weight in this.
I also get cross with people who insist on sticking rigidly to silly rules like this. Good handwriting doesn’t make a good writer..

IsitChristmasyet23 · 05/09/2023 18:28

Globules · 05/09/2023 07:57

This thread is the perfect reason why teacher assessment can never be valid.

Professionals across the country can't agree if joined up writing is a y6 "expected" requirement. Yet they're all working from the same document.

LAs tell their schools something different to the next door LA. How can it be consistent?!

It is in England here - black and white. Absolute hard fact. Unless a child can write at speed, legibly and joined they have not met standard. Simple.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1119094/2018-19_teacher_assessment_frameworks_at_the_end_of_key_stage_2.pdf

Frankly, if they don’t know this they shouldn’t be teaching and should certainly be no where near KS2.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1119094/2018-19_teacher_assessment_frameworks_at_the_end_of_key_stage_2.pdf

JohnNolan · 05/09/2023 17:35

I wish they didnt have to do cursive at all! My oldest DCs cursive writing was horrific - so bad that when he was doing exams he was told that if he didnt improve it significantly there was a liklihood that his exams wouldnt get externally marked as it was so illegible. I spent so long trying to get him to stop doing it but it was so ingrained in junior school that he couldnt stop it at senior school. Im not sure why its so important to learn cursive for their SATS in year 6 when surely its better if there writing is clear - regardless of if its joined up or not.

Needmorelego · 05/09/2023 17:25

@TimeForTeaAndG I don't understand the "babyish" comment either.
This is cursive. Old fashioned and difficult to read if messy

School have asked year 4 children to switch from Cursive
TimeForTeaAndG · 05/09/2023 17:22

Is cursive different to regular joined up writing? I don't understand a PP comment about it being babyish.

itsmyp4rty · 05/09/2023 17:15

Cursive was a disaster for dyspraxic ds, I loathe formal cursive - who actually writes like that? It's just nonsense. Simple joined up writing is what they should be teaching. Print is obviously going to be slow, formal cursive is ridiculous - I don't understand why anyone would think otherwise. I don't understand why it has ever been taught, ds's school were really big on it in Yr 3/4 (over 10 years ago now).

However trying to 'make' kids stop using cursive and print instead, after they've taught them cursive for years is even worse! I understand teaching kids to print first, but why teach cursive and then tell them not to use it?

myladybelle · 05/09/2023 17:07

AvengedQuince · 04/09/2023 22:37

Being able to print is essential in day to day life, you can't only write in cursive

It's very easy as an adult to "print" on those few forms that require you to, and write cursive all of the time.

Sidslaw · 05/09/2023 16:57

cursive is a babyish habit, and causes the writers issues if they try to persist in secondary school - best dropped now.

I don't expect you know any adults that still write cursive

Confetto · 05/09/2023 16:55

Globules · 05/09/2023 07:57

This thread is the perfect reason why teacher assessment can never be valid.

Professionals across the country can't agree if joined up writing is a y6 "expected" requirement. Yet they're all working from the same document.

LAs tell their schools something different to the next door LA. How can it be consistent?!

Different professionals can argue as much as they like but it is very clearly stated in the Y5/6 English curriculum. It is shocking how much moderation differs, I agree, but in that case you'd no doubt have a similar issue with an exam model (which there was for writing pre-National Curriculum 2014).

Confetto · 05/09/2023 16:53

TruJay · 05/09/2023 09:24

Oh I hate this!

My son was taught to write using singular letters, no mention of cursive then all of a sudden, one year cursive was introduced. He had beautiful print handwriting and once he started cursive it became fairly illegible. It’s never recovered really and is something he is still pulled up on yearly (now in teens).

If you begin learning one way, that’s the way it should stay. If a school wants to change that, then begin implementing it at reception age and then it will slowly fill the school as the original print writers leave. You can’t change a child’s writing after years of learning one way and then berate them for poor handwriting later on as they did my son.

But that is like all learning. No one tells you when you're 5 that you'll have to deal with letters not numbers when you start learning algebra. How can you learn to join when you haven't learned to form single letters? You have to start somewhere. If letters are formed correctly and joining is taught it discrete handwriting lessons, most children can follow the national curriculum expectations (which in other areas are ridiculous compared to children's level of development) which is diagonal upstrokes at end of Y2 (eg joining t and i), joining most letters in Y3 and having a fluent, joined style in Y6.

TruJay · 05/09/2023 09:24

Oh I hate this!

My son was taught to write using singular letters, no mention of cursive then all of a sudden, one year cursive was introduced. He had beautiful print handwriting and once he started cursive it became fairly illegible. It’s never recovered really and is something he is still pulled up on yearly (now in teens).

If you begin learning one way, that’s the way it should stay. If a school wants to change that, then begin implementing it at reception age and then it will slowly fill the school as the original print writers leave. You can’t change a child’s writing after years of learning one way and then berate them for poor handwriting later on as they did my son.

ZadocPDederick · 05/09/2023 09:05

It might be worth suggesting a meeting with parents to talk about this and how they can support their children.

Rp735 · 05/09/2023 08:59

Thank you for the insights. I am not an insider to the education system,so they were very helpful. I will speak to the teacher at pick up time today to understand the reason. My concern is not whether they are taught one system or the other. But that they are being asked to switch when they are already good at writing cursive. The school has joined an academy so that may be it. I don't expect parents to be consultedbut definitely informed.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 05/09/2023 07:59

Why would you expect them to consult parents over something like this?

Smartiepants79 · 05/09/2023 07:59

All I can say is that 50% of my year 4 children's joined up handwriting is illegible, despite hours of lessons! I hate it. I’d much rather they didn’t use it.
However, I wouldn’t be stopping the other 50% from using it if I could read what they’d written.
Legibility is what matters to me!

Globules · 05/09/2023 07:57

This thread is the perfect reason why teacher assessment can never be valid.

Professionals across the country can't agree if joined up writing is a y6 "expected" requirement. Yet they're all working from the same document.

LAs tell their schools something different to the next door LA. How can it be consistent?!

baffledcoconut · 05/09/2023 07:55

Writing is such a fundamental skill. It utterly baffles me that a school exerts so much control and pressure over this. Let a child write how they are comfortable and capable. It’s absolute craziness.

NewName122 · 05/09/2023 07:52

Just crazy. Why can they not write how they like. My sons at college and they don't even have notebooks. Everything is done on a computer. If they need to take notes they take them on that or on their phones or simply just take a picture of the information they need.

Swipe left for the next trending thread