Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that I can't be content with a very very simple life unlike my DH?

208 replies

wendall456 · 04/09/2023 20:10

Contentment - Are you content and how do you define contentment?

Me and my DH keep arguing over this. He thinks he is very content - he has no desire to go out, spend money or do anything different. He is happy plodding and gets very angry if I want more from life and wishes I was content with my house and garden.

He would be really happy if I was a SAHP because sometimes I do get tired and I run the kids to activities etc. He doesn't understand why I need to work because if I didn't spend money I wouldn't need a job and the kids should be happy coming home from school and just chilling out. If I stayed home life would be much easier.

My kids are teenagers and are thinking about uni and their next steps and he gets annoyed about why they need to strive to be better than anyone else they leave school they get a job. End of....

He doesn't spend money on anything and is so content but unfortunately I cant be this content with nothing. Does this make me a bad person?

OP posts:
FreeRider · 05/09/2023 01:57

My first husband was like this...we married when I was 21, he was 23...and like my mother said afterwards, he was the most middle-aged man of 23 she'd ever met!

He'd got really good A levels and his parents thought he was going to university...instead he worked as a labourer for 2 years and then joined an emergency service. He'd been working for about 6 months when we met when I was 17. After the stressful and chaotic childhood I had had he was like a breath of fresh air - steady and reliable. Sadly it was only when we'd married and started living together that I realised he was actually pretty boring - like your husband, he was happy just pottering around the house and garden...and his allotment (yes he had an allotment at just 22). Never wanted to go on holiday, never spent money, never wanted to go for meals out, etc. He was like a carbon copy of his father...but his father was 58 at the time!

Final straw for me was after 2 and a half years like this, when I'd had a big sobbing breakdown in front of him, complaining that we never spent quality time together, never went anywhere or did anything outside the house together...and his response was to start volunteering with the Scouts, meaning he was out of the house even more. 6 months later I left and we divorced. I've never regretting leaving for even a second.

Poivresel · 05/09/2023 01:44

If you gave up work would he give you access to his wages?
Stay at work and tell him to pull his finger out at home.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 05/09/2023 01:44

You know it's going to get worse when your DC leave home? When it's just the two of you how will you cope? You will be so lonely in your marriage....

OfficerChurlish · 05/09/2023 01:28

It sounds like the two of you have very different ideas about how to live well - but while you're content to let him do his stuff his way, he wants to control both his choices and yours. Unless he snaps out of it, I don't see a happy future.

He would be really happy if I was a SAHP because sometimes I do get tired and I run the kids to activities etc. He doesn't understand why I need to work because if I didn't spend money I wouldn't need a job and the kids should be happy coming home from school and just chilling out. If I stayed home life would be much easier. This part really confused me; I initially thought he was already a SAHP and was trying to convince you that if the family lived more simply you both could SAH. Maybe if you really wanted to SAH but thought you can't afford to, his trying to convince you you can could be benign/for your benefit (from his point of view). But otherwise it's weird/creepy. Why doesn't he SAH if it's so important?

Fine to keep working but I can't be moaning I am tired. Um, NO. I genuinely like my job and have no desire to leave it except for a more interesting, higher-paying position in the same field - but yeah, it's tiring at times. I think almost every job is, including SAHP. But he can't be making rules about what you can and can't say and about what you must do to be allowed to express your opinion. You're not his child, his employee, or his servant.

MintJulia · 05/09/2023 01:11

You have different tastes. Yanbu, and certainly not to want to offer your dcs more. I would find his preferences pretty dull too. It sounds like you have outgrown each other.

TooManyClouds · 05/09/2023 01:09

Right. So either he can just "potter" and you work and do everything for the kids (and presumably him?) or his solution is you give up all luxuries and financial security and effectively become a servant to him when the kids leave home soon as you'll be entirely dependent on him financially...

Clever trick to shrug his shoulders and sidestep the fact that it doesn't sound like he is pulling his weight in the household and is pushing the blame for that onto you as "your choice", the underlying assumption being the house and children are your responsibility to sort and then it's up to you whether you want to fit in a job around that to have income and work and a life outside the house. 🙄 How manipulative.

Tell him you will continue working and that he needs to do his share of household and child-related tasks or the marriage is over.

SouthLondonMum22 · 05/09/2023 01:03

wendall456 · 04/09/2023 22:59

He sees me get stressed and tired with the demands of working and ferrying kids around so his argument is he is giving me a way out of the stress of modern life as I don't need to work if I don't want to. Fine to keep working but I can't be moaning I am tired. It does sound like controlling behaviour which I suppose in a way it is but he hates how busy life is and by staying home he thinks my life would be far calmer which it would but I would be so BORED and he doesn't get bored just pottering about. He wants the kids to lead a stress free life but always striving for more results in stress and he wants them to be calm and happy - in his world you don't need money to be happy!!

If he truly felt like that, he'd be happy to become a SAHP. Money is a need, he knows that but he clearly means that life would be easier for him if you quit work because it would mean you wouldn't get stressed or tired, would probably not expect him to pull his weight much and he'd be able to push his agenda on to you and the kids more.

He isn't content. He's controlling.

Hambokki · 05/09/2023 01:02

Is DH a very introverted person? Does he have friends who he sees regularly? Or does he enjoy spending most of his time at home alone?

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 05/09/2023 01:00

He is controlling and trying to frame it as concern for you

If he really was concerned about how tired you are then he'd pull his finger out and do more

Yellowlegobrick · 05/09/2023 00:52

My bil is a bit like this.

There's an admirable side to it - he doesn't hanker after endless amounts of "stuff", doesn't waste money, is calm and happy as long as he can have a pint of cheap beer and bog standard food. He's a lovely bloke but not terribly imaginative, and honestly is fairly boring

Comtesse · 05/09/2023 00:05

What is stopping him ferrying the kids about exactly? How come it’s “your” responsibility?

RoadLess · 04/09/2023 23:53

Of course YANBU. He sounds unbelievably dull and/or so lazy that he regards people who do anything he considers unnecessary (like university, or leaving the house) as ‘striving’.

Lentilweaver · 04/09/2023 23:27

Maybe he should help more? He doesn't get to decide your boredom threshold.

wendall456 · 04/09/2023 22:59

He sees me get stressed and tired with the demands of working and ferrying kids around so his argument is he is giving me a way out of the stress of modern life as I don't need to work if I don't want to. Fine to keep working but I can't be moaning I am tired. It does sound like controlling behaviour which I suppose in a way it is but he hates how busy life is and by staying home he thinks my life would be far calmer which it would but I would be so BORED and he doesn't get bored just pottering about. He wants the kids to lead a stress free life but always striving for more results in stress and he wants them to be calm and happy - in his world you don't need money to be happy!!

OP posts:
SemperIdem · 04/09/2023 22:53

I like to have nice things. I like to be able to take my child to interesting places.

I like my job but if I won the lottery I’d quit immediately, probably from my nearest airport.

I work so I can live the life I enjoy having ultimately.

OhcantthInkofaname · 04/09/2023 22:49

Pointy things she Is not extreme.

determinedtomakethiswork · 04/09/2023 22:32

I can't imagine how miserable and boring this is going to be when you both retire. Why does he want you to be a stay at home mum at the moment when your children are teenagers?

pontipinemum · 04/09/2023 22:29

Nothing you have said it 'mad' or wanting to be very lavish, you want a few nice things in life, how bad. He doesn't want to spend money, it shouldn't stop you

Wexone · 04/09/2023 22:22

I am sorry but I think for a marriage to work you have to have the same goals in life and work together to get them goals. can be a simple life or can be the big house with bells and whistles on. you work together ti get there could be that one works and other stays at Home or both work. whatever it is it works for you yes there might have to be a few compromises or struggles in the way but thus is what makes you strong. this is not what you have here. both want different things and one is getting angry when it's not happening. tome at home is fine I like it sometimes and uts needed in a busy life. but me and my husband enjoy all same things like holidays and going out. we compromise so on hols is a mix of doing stuff or relaxing by pool. he doesn't drink but we still go out and I have a few glasses if wine. I think a serous discussion needed here for both of you and some serous changes needed or else resentment will build up and explode

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/09/2023 22:15

Being happy with a simple life is fine. Getting 'very angry' that you aren't is NOT fine. Neither is his attitude towards your dc's hopes and ambitions.

Codlingmoths · 04/09/2023 22:11

pointythings · 04/09/2023 20:14

You just want different things and you're both quite extreme about it. I'm pretty miuch bang in the middle between you - I want some nice things in life, I want my kids to have good lives, but I'm not competitive and forever climbing the ladder because I'm content with where I am. You could both do with learning from each other.

In what way is she extreme about it? She wants a job, to be able to buy some new clothes, to go out for dinner sometimes, and for her kids to go to some activities not just play footy and on the trampoline in the garden, and worst of all they want to go to university!! She didn’t say explicitly, but she might also dare to want such things as a holiday. Do your kids not do any activities or ever go on holiday? Do you ever buy new clothes or go out to dinner? There is nothing at all extreme in any of these. He is a joy sucker, and the op needs to say very sharply to him- you know what the simple life and being happy takes? It means accepting the life you have, and the people in it. You have a wife that enjoys eating out sometimes, you have kids that love their activities and want to go to university. None of this is weird or strange and millions and millions of other people like exactly the same thing. I am not going to become a hermit who never leaves the house, and they are not going to leave school and get a minimum wage job. You need to accept me for who I am, be proud of your amazing kids and find happiness in this, or you’ll be single and alone and your kids won’t bother coming back to visit. Will that make you happy?

NewCurtain · 04/09/2023 22:09

He's not content. He's a tight, miserable, small-minded man who wants to control his wife and children. Really awful.

Keep your job, go for promotions, eat out with your friends, book holidays for yourself and your children, enjoy your hobbies, encourage your children to fly high (he's jealous of them and their bright prospects)...and see a solicitor.

NewCurtain · 04/09/2023 22:03

Janieforever · 04/09/2023 20:30

He’s not content though is he. If he was he’d not be trying to stop his family soaring. Anyone who does that is far from contented. He doesn’t want to feel he’s left behind, he’s worried about his kids doing better than him, his wife doing better, so he’s trying to control you all.

that’s not contented, it’s a resentful unsuccessful little man.

This. Spot on.

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 04/09/2023 21:59

sometimes I do get tired and I run the kids to activities etc.

Bit of a tangent, but if your kids are of an age to be thinking about university, as you said, why are you running them to activities? Let them get themselves there and back while you put your feet up.

NeedMyDress · 04/09/2023 21:56

I don't think it's unreasonable between the two of you but when I got to the bit about your kids then I saw it totally differently.

Personally I think it's awful that he would actively discourage children from going to university if that's what they want to do.

I also think it's strange to encourage you into a SAHP role when your children are nearly adults.

You're not wanting loads from life - the vast majority of us require stimulation outside of our house and garden! He sounds desperately dull and suffocating.