Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that I can't be content with a very very simple life unlike my DH?

208 replies

wendall456 · 04/09/2023 20:10

Contentment - Are you content and how do you define contentment?

Me and my DH keep arguing over this. He thinks he is very content - he has no desire to go out, spend money or do anything different. He is happy plodding and gets very angry if I want more from life and wishes I was content with my house and garden.

He would be really happy if I was a SAHP because sometimes I do get tired and I run the kids to activities etc. He doesn't understand why I need to work because if I didn't spend money I wouldn't need a job and the kids should be happy coming home from school and just chilling out. If I stayed home life would be much easier.

My kids are teenagers and are thinking about uni and their next steps and he gets annoyed about why they need to strive to be better than anyone else they leave school they get a job. End of....

He doesn't spend money on anything and is so content but unfortunately I cant be this content with nothing. Does this make me a bad person?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lul37 · 09/09/2023 19:23

*sorry typo I meant to stop being financially dependent on my DH'.

lul37 · 09/09/2023 19:12

Haven’t read the whole thread yet but just wanted to say I agree completely with other posters who say to keep your job. My DH sounds similar to yours (minus not wanting the kids to go to Uni), and has a different lifestyle preference to me. He also doesn’t like spending money on outings, activities, holidays or working towards getting a bigger nicer house for our growing kids. All he wants to do is just regularly go for dinner at my MIL 😳

Sadly I’ve been a SAHM for years prioritizing raising our kids myself while he worked full time and got promoted, so now he thinks he gets to call the shots over what we ‘can and cannot afford’ as well as making me feel bad for continuously asking him for ‘extra money’ that he doesn’t think I need, like to do my hair for example.

Eventually I got so fed up with his tight attitude about spending that I’ve decided to retrain and go back to Uni to do a course to make up for the time lost on my career 😞 and more importantly to hopefully stop being financially independent on a DH that doesn’t seem to want the same things you do in life.

Like you, I also just want to have some extra nice things, and I know how frustrating it is and how sad that the partner who you married and agreed to share your life with doesn’t want the same things as you.

ImustLearn2Cook · 09/09/2023 02:37

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 07/09/2023 09:31

I couldn’t live like this.

That said, though, I wonder if some of the criticisms of him on here would made of a woman. Money is what buys experiences and opportunities for children - we all know that. But adults decide to downsize their lives in order to work less and therefore earn less all the time. That is in effect clipping your kids’ wings - they’d have more opportunities and experiences if you earned more, that’s just a fact. I always see posts on here where women say ‘we live a small life so I can be a SAHM.’ I’ve seen women on here say their kids won’t get any help with driving lessons or university - they can earn the money themselves - so that they themselves can remain SAHMs. And that’s fine, that’s a decision they’ve made. I’m guilty of it - I work 4 days a week when I could work 5. My kids would have more opportunities and experiences if I worked 5 days but I work 4 for my quality of life.

I just wonder whether the reaction to this would be the same if it wasn’t a man, whom we traditionally view as required to provide, behaving in this way.

In none of your examples is the woman telling her husband to leave his job and become completely financially dependent on her.

Do you really think that people would respond differently if it was a woman who did that?

Scrumps81 · 08/09/2023 20:40

My partner went through a long phase of this before he was diagnosed with diabetes and depression, it was very tough for us all so i really do sympathise. I dont know if your DH has always been like this or if its new behaviour but could be an underlying health issue for him if its new or different

jolaylasofia · 07/09/2023 22:09

i’m just wondering what you need to sort out for the kids as you say they are teenagers and thinking about uni…what activities are you running them to? i mean i don’t agree with him about being a SAHP but are you running yourself ragged and not giving yourself any down time?

Heb1996 · 07/09/2023 16:23

@Annemaria I’m really sorry. What a miserable existence. Has he always been like this? It sounds intolerable and I wouldn’t live like it. You don’t have to either. I would see a solicitor for advice on divorcing him. You would get half or more of everything that he’s deprived you of to salt away in his bank account. Then you could be financially independent and live your life how you want and enjoy the rest of it without being controlled by him I’m sure your family would support you in this. Good luck and hope for the future.

Sarels · 07/09/2023 14:44

Im sorry but what screams to me about him he is tight , and boring tbh like an old man but then not all old men are like him . Personally being tight with money doesn’t sit well with me it’s a traight I don’t like in someone , whatever you do don’t give up your job . He needs to man up and pay more towards activities … and not store all his money like a tight ass … can’t do nothing with it when we gone so enjoy it whilst you’re alive .

girlfriend44 · 07/09/2023 14:30

Do he expect you to do the cooking?

Annemaria · 07/09/2023 14:25

Sounds just like my husband (now retired). We never have holidays or go out to eat; he never suggests any outings at all, even to see our grandchildren. I discovered that he had been salting money away in his account for years ( he would never allow a joint account) while I was buying all the household stuff, eg washing machines etc myself. He tries to get me to pay for all the food, even though I am on a small pension, sulks when I ask him to get me a newspaper even. His mother was the same, what my wise old mother would call small parcels. It’s not that I expect diamond necklaces for my birthday, but usually he reluctantly gives me some money. And I have to wring out of him contributions for birthday presents for or children & grandchildren. I often ask him if he cares how people will remember him - but he doesn’t care. Phew, got that off my chest.

Heb1996 · 07/09/2023 14:24

@Luckyduc separately.

Justneedagirlname · 07/09/2023 14:06

He can do whatever he wants but his crab in a bucket mentality I would find very off putting. If he is not interested in things outside the home, noone is allowed to be and he doesn’t want
the kids to do better than him - yuck.
re swimming lessons- unbelievable.
sorry he is just a stingy miser, and jealous one too - far from a happy content person

Luckyduc · 07/09/2023 14:05

This is my husband! We are so different....but I just crack on and don't ask him for advice or his opinion and I book holidays and days out without even asking if he wants to go....😂. He can plod away and I just life my life

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 07/09/2023 13:29

My DH and I both love a simple life. We can't manage on one salary, even though we both earn well: kids, mortgage, cost of living etc. But both of us would still do something work wise anyway because we like the independence and mental stimulation from it.

Aside from that, we like to cook, we like to garden, watch TV together, walk the dog, play with the DC etc. Neither of us is massively bothered about clothes and material stuff but we do have nice things, which we can afford because of the simple life.

So many people our age don't understand it. We still go out, take DC to the zoo, sealife, theatre etc but it's a few "big" things a year and the rest of the time is simple. Not everyone is happy like that. And that's fine, each to their own.

The issue you have is that you knew this when you met him. You knew it when you married him. You chose him and a life with him knowing this is how he wants to live. If that's not the life you wanted, you have to choose what to do now. Do you accept that this is how your life is, or do you make the changes you want? What do they look like?

user1497864954 · 07/09/2023 12:20

I think the OPs husband is getting a bit of a rough ride here. The OP stated in initial post or update that her husband has remained in the same line of work but had secured a number of promotions. So he's not just sat in the same job he did in his 20s.
He has seen burn out of a sibling through trying to do it all and it sounds as though the OP does a lot of facilitating the children doing things and then moans about how tired she is.
Less than 50 % of young people in UK got to Uni so her husband's view that leaving school and entering work can't be so out of the norm.
I do suspect that they have grown apart and now each want different things from life. The husband doesn't seem to have changed. The OP admits that it was the values her husband has that attracted her to him in the first place. I think the OP needs to decide if she wishes to remain in the relationship but the husband seems to have been very consistent in his view of life and the condemnation on here is pretty unpleasant.

chaosmaker · 07/09/2023 12:06

Money vs burnout though, doesn't make you a better parent IMO

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 07/09/2023 09:31

I couldn’t live like this.

That said, though, I wonder if some of the criticisms of him on here would made of a woman. Money is what buys experiences and opportunities for children - we all know that. But adults decide to downsize their lives in order to work less and therefore earn less all the time. That is in effect clipping your kids’ wings - they’d have more opportunities and experiences if you earned more, that’s just a fact. I always see posts on here where women say ‘we live a small life so I can be a SAHM.’ I’ve seen women on here say their kids won’t get any help with driving lessons or university - they can earn the money themselves - so that they themselves can remain SAHMs. And that’s fine, that’s a decision they’ve made. I’m guilty of it - I work 4 days a week when I could work 5. My kids would have more opportunities and experiences if I worked 5 days but I work 4 for my quality of life.

I just wonder whether the reaction to this would be the same if it wasn’t a man, whom we traditionally view as required to provide, behaving in this way.

Seaside3 · 07/09/2023 09:11

Isn't it funny, the things that once attracted us the most often become the things that we despise the most. He was probably attracted to your ambition to begin with too.

The older I get, the more I realise that a lot of relationships just have a 'use by date. It's not hatred, just a gentle growing apart. One day you have to decide of you want to try to come back together, but that requires work from both, or if the time has come to acknowledge things are different and graciously move on.

Life would be easier, in my opinion, if this was more accepted in every day life.

Scaredycatttt · 07/09/2023 09:02

There is a difference between living a simple life and being a hermit. I do a low paid, low stress job. I don't own fancy things or go on fancy holidays and I am happy that way. I do however go out for meals, take the kids out and do a cheap uk holiday etc. There's some big red flags here.

changeme4this · 07/09/2023 08:59

Slightly ott but I was reading an article today about a partner controlling the spending budget so the female OH was unable to leave the house as she had no access to period products…

this reminded me of our former neighbours. He was a total control freak and if I was talking to her, he would be there and tell her to ‘come on’ and leave the conversation. Later heard from one of her work buddies she was allowed x amount to top up her car, enough to get to work and back that day. Was frequently late getting to work because she had to ‘top up’ for the day…

do you want to go down this track?

Bunnycat101 · 07/09/2023 07:35

Is he into the FIRE movement? There are a lot of people who seem to take that to a bit of an extreme (ie spending as little as possible to retire early). In some ways though he isn’t wrong- if you can enjoy a simpler life, things are probably less stressful. I’m not that person and by the sounds of it you aren’t either.

Have you ever been on holiday as a family? It sounds like you’ve pushed to enable the kids to do activities but couldn’t tell from the posts whether you’ve had to push for days out etc all the time too.

The bit that intrigues me though is the fact that he must have some ambition if he’s working until 9 and out earns you.

Nina1013 · 07/09/2023 07:27

I just wanted to add something from a child’s perspective. Your husband sounds EXACTLY like my dad (my dad did take us on nice holidays but always controlled by him and with a very strict budget when there) but my dad is a lot older so my mum was a SAHM.

It meant she had no say. It meant she couldn’t contribute to things she wanted to, and he wouldn’t fork out for (activities etc).

He wanted me to do well but remain under his control. But now I’ve done really well, he doesn’t like it. He’s a bubbling, festering mess of resentment and barely concealed (sometimes/mostly just not concealed) anger that I’ve dared to better him. I don’t need him financially and my choices are my own. He’s got so, so, so much worse the better I have done in life and honestly he’s vile.

My advice is to get out because I have spent many years resenting my mum for not leaving him, and it’s only been the last year or so that I’ve been able to mentally make my peace with her and see she was/is trapped and a victim.

lking12 · 07/09/2023 07:07

If he’s so relaxed why is he getting angry about things like swimming lessons or the things you want to do?
how old are the children? Will they get more independent soon?

if you want to go on holiday is he happy to come? If not do you have friends you can holiday with? Would he be annoyed if you went away without him? I’m just seeing a lonely boring life as the kids get older and you get near and into retirement given you don’t seem to have a similar outlook.

I would challenge him when he gets annoyed saying these things are important to you and the kids and if you’re paying for it it’s not worth him getting upset about.
But do have a think how you’ll cope with this difference as you get older, having a fun circle of friends may save your sanity!

sandgrown · 07/09/2023 07:05

My ex got like this and I knew retirement with him would be sitting around watching TV . He didn’t even have any hobbies or friends of his own. I loved to go out , meet friends and go on holiday. He did these things if I paid and he quite enjoyed them but I became tired of arranging everything. The gap was too wide and we separated.

Tapasita · 07/09/2023 06:57

My advice to you is don’t give up your job. The children will ultimately resent him unfortunately for trying to stop them experiencing things - but that’s a problem of his own making I’m afraid. What on earth does he expect them to do? Stay home and tend house & garden like his good little wifey? FFS I’d not be hanging around

Tapasita · 07/09/2023 06:55

My dad is like this!! My poor mum has put up with his no-spending crap all her life. He’s a tight fisted git who hates putting his hand in his pocket. Never paid for the kids activities, never spent a dime unless it was on something of value to himself.

She’s still married to him. OP I hate to tell you this but it’s because he’s a penny pinching miser. Retirement with someone like that is going to be very tough on you