Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset over this

109 replies

pinkcandyj · 04/09/2023 19:30

My husband and I have been married for over 10 years.

In that time I had never even met his older brother as the family had been kind of estranged from him for 25 years.

My BIL moved down 2 years ago following his divorce, my in laws helped him buy one of the family Buy to Let's (which was supposed to be my husband's inheritance).

Anyway I have always had a good relationship with my in laws.
I have always helped them whenever I could and basically done the job of my BIL.

My husband is a wonderful son and helps them where he can.

I am now feeling a certain type of way.
My BIL is renovating his house and in laws have been helping him.

Bearing in mind both my in laws moan about him not ever helping them, seeing them, spending time with them etc.

It got me thinking.
In all these years I dont think my in laws have ever spent as much time helping me as they are doing with my BIL.
In fact I dont think they have ever helped me.

The only thing they do is buy me chips every now and then.

I have spent hours helping them with legal paperwork, gardening, shopping, chores, doctors, brought them presents to cheer them up.

My BIL couldnt care less about them.
He has never helped them, he is just selfish and all about himself.

He stayed away for 25 years and only came back because his ex left him with nothing.

Deep down I dont feel appreciated, I feel as if they take me for granted.
They claim to see me as a daughter, but I dont feel or see that.
They never help me.

Am I being unreasonable to be upset and to not want to help my in laws again?

OP posts:
pinkcandyj · 04/09/2023 22:45

Dotcheck · 04/09/2023 22:31

For heaven’s sake op.

Your posts are so whiney.

Their SON has been estranged for 25 years. They were facing never seeing him again so they are making up for lost time.
Can you not be happy that their son has come back?
You are coming across as unreasonably jealous and really petty.

They invited him back on the belief that their son would spend time with them, go for meals and help them.

Son has done nothing and only talks to them if he wants help.

They are the one's that come to my house moaning and whining about their son and Whats Apping me all the time slagging him off.

I am not stopping them building a relationship or whatever you can call it with their son.
I am just upset at how I have been treated.

My BIL is 60 and his parents are well into their late 70s but active for their age.

But when MIL does her knee in from doing his renovations, it wont be the son or my husband who is expected to look after her.
It will be me.

OP posts:
Scattery · 04/09/2023 22:45

pinkcandyj · 04/09/2023 20:52

Maybe I do feel a bit jealous and resentful.

My MIL had previously mentioned that she expected me and my husband to look after her and my FIL when it got to the stage where they were less mobile etc.

They also expect us both to manage the But to Lets when they get to the stage where they cant cope.

Me and my husband both work full time and I find it a bit selfish to expect so much from me when I have my own parents and elderly relatives to help.

Like a poster quite rightfully mentioned they claim to see me as a daughter.
But im not their daughter.

Yes I will stand back and gradually reduce my help to them and leave my husband to get on with it.

They expect you to look after them when they're less mobile? I'd run a mile. Be very careful of entertaining those expectations - the people who tend to pick up all the unpaid caring work are the women.

Sounds like it's time to back off and free up your time doing other things. I wouldn't feel resentful of your BIL - he's their son. But by all means be very careful about falling into an inadvertent caring role because you can get trapped there very easily.

Testina · 04/09/2023 22:36

“I think my husband says this just to keep the peace as we both know his parents have never helped me or treated me the same way they treat him and his two brothers.”

Nah, I don’t think your husband is keeping the peace with them. He’s just making sure you don’t drop the wifework and expect him do his own family stuff. Like I said upthread, funny how men so often have Big Jobs and Own Businesses, yet their wives are able to find the time to sort out a card for MIL’s birthday 🙄

Cowlover89 · 04/09/2023 22:33

Let them crack on. Concentrate on your own family.

Dotcheck · 04/09/2023 22:31

For heaven’s sake op.

Your posts are so whiney.

Their SON has been estranged for 25 years. They were facing never seeing him again so they are making up for lost time.
Can you not be happy that their son has come back?
You are coming across as unreasonably jealous and really petty.

pinkcandyj · 04/09/2023 22:24

billy1966 · 04/09/2023 22:06

OP, kindly meant but you really are a mug and don't they know it.

You have offered yourself up for this utterly thankless job to very selfish people.

They have of course accepted and demanded as much as you will give.

Of course you will never equal their son.
i bet you wouldn't anyway.

Of course they are going to impose on you and use you when you allow it.

They are the type that think a woman is to be used, hence they expect elder care from YOU and not their sons.

You have run yourself ragged and they have exploited it.

You have your own parents and yet you are running after your husbands.

Your husbands family must be delighted to have someone who will do so much with zero need to be appreciated.

Drop the rope.

Spend time with your parents, your children and hand over their care to their sons.

Stop being a mug.

Take that time that you spend being their unpaid PA to do something nice for yourself.

We teach people how to treat us.

You have taught them them that you have zero boundaries and are to be taken for granted.

Sorry if that sounds harsh but you are just another foolish woman being used by her husbands family.

This suits your husband perfectly too.

Thank you very much as you have just confirmed what I have felt and thought for a long time.

Every time I have relayed how I felt to my husband he will say " Oh but they see you like a daughter and have done such a lot for you ( getting me chips every now and then ).
I think my husband says this just to keep the peace as we both know his parents have never helped me or treated me the same way they treat him and his two brothers.

I do feel like a mug to be honest and I regret all the time I spent helping them.

From now on I will just step back and let my husband and BIL care and help them.

As you rightfully say I have my own parents and family to help and who are a lot more appreciative.

OP posts:
Offcom · 04/09/2023 22:12

Reminds me of a lil Bible story…

but that always made me feel sad for the unprodigal son who seemed to have a legit gripe.

billy1966 · 04/09/2023 22:06

OP, kindly meant but you really are a mug and don't they know it.

You have offered yourself up for this utterly thankless job to very selfish people.

They have of course accepted and demanded as much as you will give.

Of course you will never equal their son.
i bet you wouldn't anyway.

Of course they are going to impose on you and use you when you allow it.

They are the type that think a woman is to be used, hence they expect elder care from YOU and not their sons.

You have run yourself ragged and they have exploited it.

You have your own parents and yet you are running after your husbands.

Your husbands family must be delighted to have someone who will do so much with zero need to be appreciated.

Drop the rope.

Spend time with your parents, your children and hand over their care to their sons.

Stop being a mug.

Take that time that you spend being their unpaid PA to do something nice for yourself.

We teach people how to treat us.

You have taught them them that you have zero boundaries and are to be taken for granted.

Sorry if that sounds harsh but you are just another foolish woman being used by her husbands family.

This suits your husband perfectly too.

Testina · 04/09/2023 21:51

They just sound selfish and flaky.
And I bet they would be just the same towards you if you were their daughter.

DiscoBeat · 04/09/2023 21:39

They're trying to build bridges with him. Step back and give them time. Hopefully your BIL will realise that he needs to step up and help them in return.

Keyworks · 04/09/2023 21:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

pinkcandyj · 04/09/2023 21:36

Testina · 04/09/2023 20:56

“They always lead me to believe I was a daughter to them, it never felt like it to be honest.”

This doesn’t make any sense to me. How can you lead someone to believe it? And what does “like a daughter” mean ?
To them, treating you like family might simply mean they’re happy for you to know their business, helping with paperwork and medical appointments. It sounds like they just come out with meaningless niceties about it. The reality is - in laws almost never see anyone but their children, as their children.

Has something changed recently? Prodigal son has been back 2 years already. What drove you to post today?

Making a fuss of birthdays etc has got nothing do with being busy running a business. You’ve willingly - by the sounds of it - covered your husband’s slack picking up the wifework. You’re right it should be their children not you, but that includes him. Fair enough if you had more spare time (funny how the men are always too busy to make a fuss of mum’s birthday though…) for something like going through some paperwork. But the fuss of a birthday, showing you care about someone? That should be both sons, not you - sounds like you’re finally fed up of picking up the slack for both of them!

In laws would say to me "your the daughter we never had" and my husband would repeat this is what they would say to him about me.

But in all these years I do feel it was one sides, i.e me always helping them.
But when I wanted help, I never got it.

Its like when a stray kitten decided to adopt me in February.
I have 6 other animals and I didnt want another animal to look after.

But MIL didnt want me to give the kitten into Cats Protection.

"We will help you, we will split the cost of the vet fee's and help when the kitten gets spayed" MIL told me.

MIL did neither and I was left to pay all the vets bills and look after the kitten.
The kitten is now part of the family and very much loved.

But when MIL cat went missing she expected me to make posters, put posters up, list the cat on Facebook/ Cats Protection missing page.

It has very much been one sided.

What led me to post today was the fact they got up at 7am to help my BIL with knocking some walls down and helping him renovate his property.

They can do all that for him but could never spend time like that helping me.

I have been doing the work for all the children, i.e birthdays etc.

At least I know where I stand now and wont help in the future.

OP posts:
Testina · 04/09/2023 21:01

“Like a poster quite rightfully mentioned they claim to see me as a daughter.
But im not their daughter.”

I don’t know why you read so much into that. It’s just meaningless niceties. People come out with shite like that all the time! “Oh she’s like the daughter I never had” is just an easy compliment. It’s genuinely meant as a compliment - but they don’t actually mean it. It’s easy to say things like that… but say you cheated on their son. They wouldn’t be torn because they still love you despite your mistake, would they? They’re not thinking about what it means to truly feel someone is your child.

Just do whatever you have time for and feels right - and let them do the rest.

And don’t get stuck running their BTLs without a wage!

TheNightTrolll · 04/09/2023 20:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Testina · 04/09/2023 20:56

“They always lead me to believe I was a daughter to them, it never felt like it to be honest.”

This doesn’t make any sense to me. How can you lead someone to believe it? And what does “like a daughter” mean ?
To them, treating you like family might simply mean they’re happy for you to know their business, helping with paperwork and medical appointments. It sounds like they just come out with meaningless niceties about it. The reality is - in laws almost never see anyone but their children, as their children.

Has something changed recently? Prodigal son has been back 2 years already. What drove you to post today?

Making a fuss of birthdays etc has got nothing do with being busy running a business. You’ve willingly - by the sounds of it - covered your husband’s slack picking up the wifework. You’re right it should be their children not you, but that includes him. Fair enough if you had more spare time (funny how the men are always too busy to make a fuss of mum’s birthday though…) for something like going through some paperwork. But the fuss of a birthday, showing you care about someone? That should be both sons, not you - sounds like you’re finally fed up of picking up the slack for both of them!

pinkcandyj · 04/09/2023 20:52

Maybe I do feel a bit jealous and resentful.

My MIL had previously mentioned that she expected me and my husband to look after her and my FIL when it got to the stage where they were less mobile etc.

They also expect us both to manage the But to Lets when they get to the stage where they cant cope.

Me and my husband both work full time and I find it a bit selfish to expect so much from me when I have my own parents and elderly relatives to help.

Like a poster quite rightfully mentioned they claim to see me as a daughter.
But im not their daughter.

Yes I will stand back and gradually reduce my help to them and leave my husband to get on with it.

OP posts:
HeddaGarbled · 04/09/2023 20:34

Yes, I think you are being unreasonable. He’s their son, back in their lives after a long estrangement. Surely you can understand their motivation? Can’t you find it in yourself to feel sorry for them rather than angry with them?

Re the buy-to-let. Sounds like they have more than one so I don’t think your H’s “inheritance” as you put it, is at risk, though I really don’t like people thinking of their parents’ assets as their “inheritance” in that way.

If you feel like you aren’t appreciated for all the things you do for them, of course it’s OK to do less, though I’d reduce gently and gradually rather than stop immediately because you’re miffed about the BIL stuff.

gamerchick · 04/09/2023 20:22

Now resentment has set in, you have to pull back from them OP. Focus on your own parents and leave them to it.

Janieforever · 04/09/2023 20:19

Are you maybe jealous? This is their son. Of course they will help him. It isn’t a competition between you op. And as much as you maybe like a daughter, you are not their daughter. This doesn’t mean they don’t like or love you, but you need to be able to respect the fact he’s their son and not try to compete or compare.

supersonicginandtonic · 04/09/2023 20:18

They're probably making up for lost time. And let's be honest, as parents we'll always help our kids no matter what.

pinkcandyj · 04/09/2023 20:15

AnneLovesGilbert · 04/09/2023 20:13

How are you helping him when you’ve never met him?

He moved down two years ago - that is when I met him for the first time.

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 04/09/2023 20:13

How are you helping him when you’ve never met him?

pinkcandyj · 04/09/2023 20:05

Yes I will pull back and stop helping them.

They always lead me to believe I was a daughter to them, it never felt like it to be honest.

I have told my husband how I feel and he says he agrees with me to an extent.

I have told him I dont think it is fair for his parents to keep asking me for help and expect me to make a big effort and fuss for them on birthdays, Mother/Father Day's and Christmas when their own children should be doing that.

I have my own parents to help.

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 04/09/2023 19:59

You are not their child. It really is that simple. They will never love you the way they love their children, and I can imagine that they are desperate to rebuild a relationship with him, no matter how poorly he treats them.

Pull back at stop helping them if you believe you are being taken advantage of, (which you are). Your husband can deal with them.

DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 04/09/2023 19:53

Mums and sons, don’t try to fathom it, op. My parents are trying to gift my brother a place in Spain and don’t think I know.

you can’t change them so stop giving it any time, back off on the help

Swipe left for the next trending thread